Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
×
Home

Speaking truth to power: political advisers’ and civil servants’ responses to perceived harmful policy proposals

  • Birgitta Niklasson (a1), Peter Munk Christiansen (a2) and Patrik Öhberg (a1)

Abstract

How are civil servants and politically appointed advisers likely to respond to policy proposals that they believe will harm their countries severely even if they are legal? Based on the different loyalties and roles of political advisors (PA) and civil servants (CS), we hypothesise that (1) PAs are more likely to voice internally, (2) CSs are more likely to voice externally and (3) CSs in functionally politicised systems are more likely to stay silent. These hypotheses are tested on – and partially supported by – data collected through two surveys directed to the ministerial staffs in Denmark and Sweden. PAs are more likely to voice internally, but none of the two groups is particularly keen to voice externally. The propensity to voice concerns in case of perceived harmful policy proposals depends on the kind as well as the level of politicisation.

Copyright

Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. Email: pmc@ps.au.dk

Footnotes

Hide All

Cite this article: Niklasson B, Christiansen PM, Öhberg P. 2019. Speaking truth to power: political advisers’ and civil servants’ responses to perceived harmful policy proposals. Journal of Public Policy X: 1–21, doi:10.1017/S0143814X18000508

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Aberbach, J Rockman, BD (1994) Civil Servants and Policymakers: Neutral or Responsive Competence? Governance 7, 461469.
Arendt, H (1994) Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. New York: Penguin Group.
Aucoin, P (2010) Canada. In Eichbaum C and Shaw R (eds.), Partisan Appointees and Public Servants. An International Analysis of the Role of the Political Adviser. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 6493.
Bertelli, AM Lewis, DE (2013) Policy Influence, Agency-Specific Expertise, and Exit in the Federal Service. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 23, 223245.
Bovens, M (2007) Conflicting Loyalties: Ethical Pluralism in Administrative Life. International Journal of Public Administration 19(11-12): 21952211.
Bovens, M, Geveke, HG Vries, J de (1995) Open Public Administration in the Netherlands: The Politics of Leaking. International Review of Administrative Sciences 61, 1740.
Christiansen, PM, Niklasson, B Öhberg, P (2016) Does Politics Crowd out Professional Competence? The Organisation of Ministerial Advice in Denmark and Sweden. West European Politics 39(6): 12301250.
Christensen, JG (2006) Ministers and Mandarins under Danish Parliamentarism. International Journal of Public Administration 29(12): 9971019.
Christensen, JG (2011) Weber’s Modern Form. The Persistence of Merit Bureaucracy in Danish Central Government. In Schimanke D, Veit S and Bull H.P eds, Bürokratie im Irrgarten der Politik: Gedächtnisband für Hans-Ulrich Derlien. Baden-Baden: Monos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG, 125149.
Cook, B (1988) Bureaucratic Politics and Regulatory Reform. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
Dahl, R (1989) Democracy and Its Critics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Dahlström, C (2009) Political Appointments in 18 Democracies, 1975-2007. QoG Working Paper Series 2009:18 . Gothenburg: The Quality of Government Institute.
Dahlström, C Lapuente, V (2017) Organizing Leviathan. Politicians, Bureaucrats and the Making of Good Government. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dahlström, C, Lapuente, V Teorell, J (2012) The Merit of Meritocratization: Politics, Bureaucracy, and the Institutional Deterrents of Corruption. Political Research Quarterly 65, 656668.
de Graaf, G (2010) The Loyalties of Top Public Administrators. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 2, 285306.
Denhardt, RB Denhardt, JV (2000) The New Public Service: Serving Rather Than Steering. Public Administration Review 60, 549559.
Dickinson, MJ Rudalevige, A (2005) Presidents, Responsiveness, and Competence: Revisiting the ‘Golden Age’ at the Bureau of the Budget. Political Science Quarterly 119(4): 633654.
DJØF (1993) Fagligt etiske principper i offentlig adminsitration: DJØF Publishing.
Dowding, KPJ John, P (2012) Exits, Voices and Social Investment. Citizens’ Reaction to Public Services. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dowding, KPJ, Mergoupis, T van Vugt, M (2000) Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Analytic and Empirical Developments. European Journal of Political Research 37, 469495.
Ehn, P (1998) Maktens administratörer. Ledande svenska statstjänstemäns och politikers syn på tjänstemannarollen i ett förändringsperspektiv. Stockholm: Dept. of Political Science, Stockholm University.
Eichbaum, C Shaw, R (2007) Ministerial Advisers and the Politics of Policy-Making: Bureaucratic Permanence and Popular Control. The Australian Journal of Public Administration 66, 453467.
Eichbaum, C Shaw, R (2008) Revisiting Politicization: Political Advisers and Public Servants in Westminster Systems. Governance: An International Journal of Policy, Administration, and Institutions 21(3): 337363.
Eichbaum, C Shaw, R (2010) New Zeeland. In Eichbaum C and Shaw R eds, Partisan Appointees and Public Servants. An International Analysis of the Role of the Political Adviser. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar, 114150.
Farrell, D (1983) Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect as Responses do Job Dissatisfaction: A Multidimensional Scaling Study. The Academy of Management Journal 26(4): 596607.
Flynn, K (2006) Covert Disclosures. Journalism Studies 7(2): 256273.
Frederiksen, T Nielsen, SW (2010) Projekt Løkke. Copenhagen: Gyldendal.
Goetz, KH (1997) Acquiring Political Craft: Training Grounds for Top Officials in the German Core Executive. Public Administration 74, 753775.
Golden, MM (1992) Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect: Bureaucratic Responses to Presidential Control During the Reagan Administration. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 2(1): 2962.
Government of Denmark (2013) Ministrenes Særlige Rådgivere: Serviceeftersyn. Government white paper on special advisers. White Paper 1537/2013. English summary, pp. 179-209. http://www.fm.dk/publikationer/2013/betaenkning-1537-ministrenes-saerlige-raadgivere/.
Government Investigation (1990) Demokrati och makt i Sverige. Maktutredningens huvudrapport. SOU 1990:44. Stockholm: Fritzes förlag.
Hirschman, AO (1970) Exit, Voice, and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organizations, and States. Massachusetts and London: Harvard University Press.
Hooghiemstra, R van Manen, J (2002) Supervisory Directors and Ethical Dilemmas: Exit or Voice? European Management Journal 20(1): 19.
Hsiung, H Yang, K (2012) Employee Behavioral Options in Problematic Working Conditions: Response Pattern Analysis. International Journal of Human Resource Management 23, 18881907.
Hustedt, T Salomonsen, H (2014) Ensuring Political Responsiveness: Politicisation Mechanisms in Ministerial Bureaucracies. International Review of Administrative Sciences 80(4): 746765.
Ingraham, PW Colby, PW (1982) Political Reform and Government Management: The Case of the Senior Executive Service. Policy Studies Journal 11, 304317.
Jensen, T (2000) Party Cohesion. In Esaiasson P. and Heidar K eds, Beyond Westminster and Congress: The Nordic Experience. Columbus: Ohio State University Press, 210236.
John, P (2017) Finding Exits and Voices: Albert Hirschman’s Contribution to the Study of Public Services. International Public Management Journal 20(3): 512529.
Kaufman, H (1960) The Forest Ranger: A Study of Administrative Behavior. London: Earthscan.
Kellough, JE Osuna, W (1995) Cross-Agency Comparisons of Quit Rates in the Federal Service: Another Look at the Evidence. Review of Public Personnel Administration 15(4): 5868.
Kingston, W (2002) A Running Repair for the Civil Service. The Political Quarterly 73(2): 198207.
Lee, J Varon, AL (2016) Employee Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect in Response to Dissatifying Organizational Situations: It Depends on Supervisory Relationship Quality. International Journal of Business Communication October 2016, 122.
Levin, B (1983) En skog av röda nålar: om politiseringen av departement och förvaltning. In Rydén B ed, Makt och vanmakt. Stockholm: SNS Förlag, 91100.
Lewin, L (2007) Democratic Accountability. Why Choice in Politics Is Both Possible and Necessary. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Lewis, DE (2008) The Politics of Presidential Appointments: Political Control and Bureaucratic Performance. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Lewis, G Park, K (1989) Turnover Rates in Federal White-Collar Employment: Are Women More Likely to Quit than Men? The American Review of Public Administration 19(1): 1328.
Liljegren, M, Nordlund, A Ekberg, K (2008) Psychometric Evaluation and Further Validation of the Hagedoorn et al. Modified EVLN Measure. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 49, 169177.
Long, JS (1997) Regression Models for Categorical and Limited Dependent variables . Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Moynihan, DP Landuyt, N (2008) Explaining Turnover Intention in State Government: Examining the Roles of Gender, Life Cycle, and Loyalty. Review of Public Personnel Administration 28, 120143.
Mulgan, R (2007) Truth in Government and the Politicisation of Public Service Advice. Public Administration 85, 569586.
Niemann, C (2013) Villkorat förtroende. Normer och rollförväntningar i relationen mellan politiker och tjänstemän i Regeringskansliet. Dissertation defended at the Department of Political Science, Stockholm University, November 29.
Niklasson, B (2007) Förvaltningseliten. In Göransson A ed, Maktens kön. Kvinnor och män i den svenska makteliten på 2000-talet. Nora: Bokförlaget Nya Doxa, 365384.
Niskanen, WA (1971) Bureaucracy and Representative Government. New York: Aldine-Alderton.
Overeem, P (2005) The Value of the Dichotomy: Politics, Administration, and the Political Neutrality of Administrators. Administrative Theory Praxis 27(2): 311329.
Peters, BG Pierre, J (eds.) (2004) Politicisation of the Civil Service in Comparative Perspective. London: Routledge.
Peters, BG (1987) Politicians and Bureaucrats in the Politics of Policy-making. In Lane J-E ed, Bureaucracy and Public Choice. London: Sage, 256282.
Pfiffner, JP (1985) Political Public Administration. Public Administration Review 45(2): 352356.
Rouban, L (2012) Politicisation of the Civil Service. In Peters B. G and Pierre J eds, The SAGE Handbook of Public Administration. London: Sage, 380391.
Rourke, FE. (1992) Responsiveness and Neutral Competence in American Bureaucracy. Public Administration Review 52, 539546.
Rusbult, C Lowery, D (1985) When Bureaucrats Get the Blues: Responses to Dissatisfaction Among Federal Employees. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 15(1): 80103.
Transparency International (2015) Corruption Perception Index 2015. Berlin: Transparency International.
Ullström, A (2011) Styrning Bakom Kulisserna. Regeringskansliets Politiska Staber och Regeringens Styrningskapacitet. Dissertation defended at the Department of Political Science, Stockholm University, May 20.
Vantilborgh, T (2015) Volunteers’ Reactions to Psychological Contract Fulfillment in Terms of Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect Behavior. Voluntas: International Journal of Voluntary & Nonprofit Organizations 54, 14831518.
Värdegrundsdelegationen (2014) Introduktion till den Gemensamma Värdegrunden för de Statsanställda. Stockholm: Regeringskansliet.
Weber, M (1946) Politics as a Vocation. In Gerth H. H and Wright Mills C eds, From Max Weber: Essays in Sociology. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 196244.
Whitford, AB Lee, S-Y (2014) Exit, Voice, and Loyalty with Multiple Exit Options: Evidence from the US Federal Workforce. Journal of Public Administration Research 25, 373398.
Williams, R (2006) Generalized Ordered Logit/Partial Proportional Odds Models for Ordinal Dependent Variables. Stata Journal 6(1): 58.
Wilson, W (1887) The Study of Administration. Political Science Quarterly 2, 197222.
Öhberg, P Naurin, E (2015) Party-Constrained Policy Responsiveness: A Survey Experiment on Politicians’ Response to Citizen-Initiated Contacts. British Journal of Political Science 46(4): 785797.
Recommend this journal

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this journal to your organisation's collection.

Journal of Public Policy
  • ISSN: 0143-814X
  • EISSN: 1469-7815
  • URL: /core/journals/journal-of-public-policy
Please enter your name
Please enter a valid email address
Who would you like to send this to? *
×

Keywords

Type Description Title
WORD
Supplementary materials

Niklasson et al. supplementary material
Appendix

 Word (25 KB)
25 KB

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed