Skip to main content Accessibility help

Ontogeny and shape change of the phacopid trilobite Calyptaulax

  • Gabriel S. Jacobs (a1) and Jesse R. Carlucci (a2)


Major transitions in trilobite ontogeny have historically been defined based on the number and distribution of trunk segments, and articulation between the trunk and cephalon. This study documents additional morphological change across the meraspid-holaspid transition on the Ordovician phacopid trilobite Calyptaulax strasburgensis. An extensive dataset of silicified cranidia and pygidia collected from the mid-Ordovician Edinburg Formation of Virginia was subjected to a series of multivariate analyses, with a primary focus on the intersections and termini of furrows. Multivariate regression of partial warp scores demonstrates statistically significant change in allometric growth patterns over the course of development. These changes are concentrated in earlier instars, but are coincident in cranidia and pygidia. This sharp decrease in the rate of allometry, present in both tagmata, is expressed as significant breakpoints derived from a segmented regression, with the largest portion of allometric change found in the pre-breakpoint individuals. The term holeidos is proposed to describe the completion of form during trilobite development, independent of the completion of the thorax. The most dramatic change in shape during this period of ontogeny includes lateral glabellar expansion through deflection of the axial and palpebral furrows, possibly reflecting a change in the feeding habit during later development. Other morphological changes include the development of a more angular appearance to the anterior portion of the glabella, and anterior migration of the pygidial anterior margin. The appearance of these growth patterns in Calyptaulax extends the temporal range of these changes, some of which have only been documented in Devonian phacopids.



Hide All
Adams, D.C., Rohlf, F.J., and Slice, D.E., 2004, Geometric morphometrics: ten years of progress following the ‘revolution’: Italian Journal of Zoology, v. 71, p. 516, doi:10.1080/11250000409356545.
Akaike, H., 1974, A new look at the statistical model identification: IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control, v. 19, 716723.
Akam, M., Averof, M., Castelli-Gair, J., Dawes, R., Falciani, F., and Ferrier, D., 1994, The evolving role of Hox genes in arthropods: Development, v. 1994, Supplement, p. 209215.
Amati, L., 2004, Systematics and Paleoecology of Trilobites from the Late Ordovician Viola Group, South-Central Oklahoma: Oklahoma City, University of Oklahoma, 527 p.
Barrande, J., 1846, Notice préliminaire sur le systême Silurien et les trilobites de Bohême: Leipzig, C.L. Hirschfeld, 97 p.
Beecher, C.E., 1895, The larval stages of trilobites: The American Geologist, v. 16, p. 166196.
Bookstein, F.L., 1991, Morphometric Tools for Landmark Data: Geometry and Biology: Cambridge/New York, Cambridge University Press, 456 p.
Brett, C.E., Goodman, W.M., and LoDuca, S.T., 1990, Sequences, cycles, and basin dynamics in the Silurian of the Appalachian Foreland Basin: Sedimentary Geology, v. 69, p. 191244, doi:10.1016/0037-0738(90)90051-T.
Butts, C., 1941, Geology of the Appalachian Valley in Virginia, part 2, fossil plates and explanations: Virginia Geological Survey Bulletin 52, pt. 2, 271 p.
Campbell, H.D., 1905, The Cambro-Ordovician limestones of the middle portion of the Valley of Virginia: American Journal of Science, ser. 4, v. 20, p. 445447.
Carlucci, J.R., and Westrop, S.R., 2012, Trilobite biofacies along an Ordovician (Sandbian) carbonate buildup to basin gradient, southwestern Virginia: Palaios, v. 27, p. 1934, doi:10.2110/palo.2011.p11–069r.
Carlucci, J.R., and Westrop, S.R., 2015, Trilobite biofacies and sequence stratigraphy: an example from the Upper Ordovician of Oklahoma: Lethaia v. 48, p. 309325.
Carlucci, J.R., Westrop, S.R., Brett, C.E. and Burkhalter, R., 2014, Facies architecture and sequence stratigraphy of the Ordovician Bromide Formation (Oklahoma): a new perspective on a mixed carbonate-siliciclastic ramp: Facies, v. 60, p. 9871012, doi:10.1007/s10347-014-0412-6.
Chatterton, B.D., 1971, Taxonomy and ontogeny of Siluro-Devonian trilobites from near Yass, New South Wales: Palaeontographica abteilung A, v. 137, p. 1108.
Chatterton, B.D., 1994, Ordovician proetide trilobite Dimeropyge, with a new species from northwestern Canada: Journal of Paleontology, v. 68, p. 541556.
Chatterton, B.D., and Speyer, S.E., 1997, Ontogeny, in Kaesler, R.L., ed., Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Pt. O, Arthropoda I: Trilobita (Revised): Lawrence, Kansas, Geological Society of America and University of Kansas, p. O173O247.
Chatterton, B.D., Edgecombe, G.D., Speyer, S.E., Hunt, A.S., and Fortey, R.A., 1994, Ontogeny and relationships of Trinucleoidea (Trilobita): Journal of Paleontology, v. 68, p. 523540, doi:10.1017/S0022336000025907.
Clarkson, E.N., and Ahlberg, P., 2002, Ontogeny and structure of a new, miniaturised and spiny olenid trilobite from southern Sweden: Palaeontology, v. 45, p. 122, doi:10.1111/1475-4983.00224.
Clarkson, E.N., Ahlgren, J., and Taylor, C.M., 2003, Structure, ontogeny, and moulting of the olenid trilobite Ctenopyge (Eoctenopyge) angusta Westergård, 1922 from the Upper Cambrian of Västergötland, Sweden: Palaeontology, v. 46, p. 127, doi:10.1111/1475-4983.00284.
Cooper, B.N., 1953, Trilobites from the lower Champlainian formations of the Appalachian Valley: Geological Society of America Memoir 55, 69 p.
Cooper, B.N., and Cooper, G.A., 1946, Lower Middle Ordovician stratigraphy of the Shenandoah Valley, Virginia: Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 57, p. 35114.
Cooper, G.A., 1930, Upper Ordovician and Lower Devonian stratigraphy and paleontology of Percé, Quebec, Part II, New species from the Upper Ordovician of Percé: American Journal of Science, v. 20, p. 365392, doi:10.2475/ajs.s5-20.119.365.
Crônier, C., 2007, Larval morphology and ontogeny of an Upper Devonian phacopid: Nephranops from Thuringia, Germany: Journal of Paleontology, v. 81, p. 684700, doi:10.1666/pleo0022-3360(2007)081[0684:LMAOOA]2.0.CO;2.
Crônier, C., 2013, Morphological disparity and developmental patterning: contribution of phacopid trilobites: Palaeontology, v. 56, p. 12631271, doi:10.1111/pala.12024.
Crônier, C., and Feist, R., 1997, Morphologie et évolution ontogénétique de Trimerocephalus lelievrei nov. sp., premier trilobite phacopidé aveugle du Famennien nord-africain: Geobios, v. 30, p. 161170.
Crônier, C., and Fortey, R.A., 2006, Morphology and ontogeny of an Early Devonian phacopid trilobite with reduced sight from southern Thailand: Journal of Paleontology, v. 80, p. 529536, doi: 10.1666/0022–3360(2006)80[529:MAOOAE]2.0.CO;2.
Crônier, C., Renaud, S., Feist, R., and Auffray, J.C., 1998, Ontogeny of Trimerocephalus lelievrei (Trilobita, Phacopida), a representative of the Late Devonian phacopine paedomorphocline: a morphometric approach: Paleobiology, v. 24, p. 359370, doi:10.1666/0094-8373(1998)024[0359:OOTLPA]2.3.CO;2.
Crônier, C., Auffray, J.C., and Courville, P., 2005, A quantitative comparison of the ontogeny of two closely related Upper Devonian phacopid trilobites: Lethaia, v. 38, p. 123135, doi:10.1080/00241160510013240.
Delabroye, A., and Crônier, C., 2008, Ontogeny of an Ordovician trinucleid (Trilobita) from Armorica, France: a morphometric approach: Journal of Paleontology, v. 82, p. 800810, doi:10.1666/07-084.1.
Dempster, A.P., Laird, N.M. and Rubin, D.B., 1977, Maximum likelihood from incomplete data via the EM algorithm: Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, v. 39, p. 138.
Dyar, H.G., 1890, The number of molts of lepidopterous larvae: Psyche: A Journal of Entomology, v. 5, p. 420422.
Edgecombe, G.D., Chatterton, B.D., Vaccari, N.E., and Waisfeld, B.G., 1997, Ontogeny of the proetoid trilobite Stenoblepharum, and relationships of a new species from the Upper Ordovician of Argentina: Journal of Paleontology, v. 71, p. 419433, doi:10.1017/S0022336000039445.
Ettensohn, F.R., 2008, The Appalachian foreland basin in eastern United States, in Miall, A., ed., Sedimentary Basins of the World, Volume 5. The Sedimentary Basins of the United States and Canada: Oxford/Boston, Elsevier Science, p. 105179.
Feist, R., McNamara, K.J., Crônier, C., Lerosey-Aubril, R., 2009, Patterns of extinction and recovery of phacopid trilobites during the Frasnian-Famennian (Late Devonian) mass extinction event, Canning Basin Western Australia: Geological Magazine, v. 146, p. 1233.
Fortey, R.A., and Morris, S.F., 1978, Discovery of nauplius-like trilobite larvae: Palaeontology, v. 21, p. 823833.
Forty, R.A., and Owens, R.M., 1999, Feeding habits in trilobites: Palaeontology, v. 42, p. 429465.
Fusco, G., Hughes, N.C., Webster, M., and Minelli, A., 2003, Exploring developmental modes in a fossil arthropod: growth and trunk segmentation of the trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii: The American Naturalist, v. 163, p. 167183, doi:10.1086/381042.
Fusco, G., Garland, T., Hunt, G. and Hughes, N.C., 2012, Developmental trait evolution in trilobites: Evolution, v. 66, p. 314329.
Gellon, G., and McGinnis, W., 1998, Shaping animal body plans in development and evolution by modulation of Hox expression patterns: BioEssays, v. 20, p. 116125, doi:10.1002/(SICI)1521-1878(199802)20:2<116::AID-BIES4>3.0.CO;2-R.
Goodall, C., 1991, Procrustes methods in the statistical analysis of shape: Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, ser. B, v. 53, p. 285339.
Green, J., 1832, A Monograph of the Trilobites of North America with coloured models of the species: Philadelphia, J. Brano, 93 p.
Hall, J., 1847, The Paleontology of New York: Albany, C. Van Benthuysen, v. 1, 247 p.
Hammer, O., Harper, D.A.T, and Ryan, P. 2001: PAST: Paleontological statistics software for education and data analysis: Palaeontologia Electronica 4, 9,
Hartnoll, R.G., 1983, Strategies of crustacean growth: Memoirs of the Australian Museum, no. 18, p. 121131.
Holland, S.M., and Patzkowsky, M.E., 1996, Sequence stratigraphy and long-term paleoceanographic change in the Middle and Upper Ordovician of the eastern United States, in Witzke, B.J., Ludvigson, G.A., and Day, J., eds., Paleozoic Sequence Stratigraphy; Views from the North American Craton: Geological Society of America, Special Paper 306, p. 117–130, doi:10.1130/SPE306.
Hopkins, M.J., and Pearson, J.K., 2016, Non-linear ontogenetic shape change in Cryptolithus tesselatus (Trilobita) using three-dimensional geometric morphometrics: Palaeontologia Electronica, v. 19, art. 42A, p. 154, doi:10.26879/665.
Hopkins, M.J., and Webster, M., 2009, Ontogeny and geographic variation of a new species of the corynexochine trilobite Zacanthopsis (Dyeran, Cambrian): Journal of Paleontology, v. 83, p. 524547, doi:10.1666/08-102R.1.
Hughes, N.C., 2007, The evolution of trilobite body patterning: Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, v. 35, p. 401434, doi:10.1146/
Hughes, N.C., and Chapman, R.E., 1995, Growth and variation in the Silurian proetid trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii and its implications for trilobite palaeobiology: Lethaia, v. 28, p. 333353, doi:10.1111/j.1502-3931.1995.tb01824.x.
Hughes, N.C., Minelli, A., and Fusco, G., 2006, The ontogeny of trilobite segmentation: a comparative approach: Paleobiology, v. 32, p. 602627, doi:10.1666/06017.1.
Hunt, G., and Chapman, R.E., 2001, Evaluating hypotheses of instar-grouping in arthropods: a maximum likelihood approach: Paleobiology, v. 27, p. 466484.
Kim, K., Sheets, H.D., Haney, R.A., and Mitchell, C.E., 2002, Morphometric analysis of ontogeny and allometry of the Middle Ordovician trilobite Triarthrus becki: Paleobiology, v. 28, p. 364377, doi:10.1666/0094-8373(2002)028<0364:MAOOAA>2.0.CO;2.
Klingenberg, C.P., and Zimmermann, M., 1992. Dyar's rule and multivariate allometric growth in nine species of waterstriders (Heteroptera:Gerridae): Journal of Zoology, v. 227, p. 453464.
Kobayashi, T., 1933, Upper Cambrian of the Wuhutsui Basin, Liaotung, with special reference to the limit of the Chaumitian (or Upper Cambrian) of eastern Asia, and its subdivision: Japanese Journal of Geology and Geography, v. 11, p. 55155.
Kobayashi, T., and Hamada, T., 1968, A Devonian phacopid recently discovered by Mr. Charan Poothai in peninsular Thailand: Geology and Palaeontology of Southeast Asia, v. 4, p. 2228.
Kozub, D., Khmelik, V., Shapoval, Y., Chentsov, S., Yatsenko, B., Litovchenko, B., and Starykh, V., 2008, Helicon Focus v.5.3x64: HeliconSoft,
McLaughlin, P.I., and Brett, C.E., 2007, Signatures of sea-level rise on the carbonate margin of a Late Ordovician foreland basin: a case study from the Cincinnati Arch, USA: Palaios, v. 22, p. 245267, doi:10.2110/palo.2006.p06-106.
McNamara, K.J., 1986, The role of heterochrony in the evolution of Cambrian trilobites: Biological Reviews, v. 61, p. 121156, doi:10.1111/j.1469-185X.1986.tb00464.x.
Meek, F.B., 1870, Descriptions of fossils collected by the US Geological Survey under the charge of Clerence King, Esq.: Proceedings of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia, v. 22, p. 5664.
Mitchell, C., Adhya, S., Bergstrom, S., Joy, M., and Delano, J., 2004, Discovery of the Ordovician Millbrig K-bentonite bed in the Trenton Group of New York State: implications for regional correlation and sequence stratigraphy in eastern North America: Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeocology, v. 210, p. 331346, doi:10.1016/j.palaeo.2004.02.037.
Muggeo, V.M.R., 2008, Segmented: an R package to fit regression models with broken-line relationships: R News, v. 8/1, p. 2025.
Oehlert, D.P., 1895, Sur les Trinucleus de l'Ouest de la France: Bulletins de la Société Géologique de France, v. 23, p. 299335.
Oosterbaan, R.J., 2011, SegReg: segmented linear regression with breakpoint and confidence intervals:
Oosterbann, R., Sharma, D.P., Singh, K.N., and Rao, K.V.G.K, 1990, Crop production and soil salinity: evaluation of field data from India by segmented linear regression with breakpoint: Proceedings for the Symposium on Land Drainage for Salinity Control in Arid and Semi-Arid Regions, v. 3, p. 373383.
Palmer, A.R., 1957, Ontogenetic development of two olenellid trilobites: Journal of Paleontology, v. 31, p. 105128.
Palmer, A.R., 1962, Comparative ontogeny of some opisthoparian, gonatoparian and proparian Upper Cambrian trilobites: Journal of Paleontology, v. 36, p. 8796.
Park, T.Y., and Choi, D.K., 2010, Ontogeny of the Furongian (late Cambrian) remopleuridioid trilobite Haniwa quadrata Kobayashi, 1933 from Korea: implications for trilobite taxonomy: Geological Magazine, v. 148, p. 288303, doi:10.1017/S0016756810000701.
Raw, F., 1925, The Development of Leptoplastus salteri (Callaway), and of other Trilobites (Olenidae, Ptychoparidae, Conocoryphidae, Paradoxidae, Phacopidae, and Mesonacidae): Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 81, p. 223324.
Raymond, P.E., 1905, Trilobites of the Chazy Limestone: Annals of the Carnegie Museum, v. 3, p. 328396.
Read, J.F., 1980, Carbonate ramp-to-basin transitions and foreland basin evolution, Middle Ordovician, Virginia Appalachians: AAPG Bulletin, v. 64, p. 15751612.
Read, J.F., 1982, Geometry, facies, and development of Middle Ordovician carbonate buildups, Virginia Appalachians: AAPG Bulletin, v. 66, p. 189209.
Reed, F.R.C., 1905, The classification of the Phacopidae: Geological Magazine, v. 2, p. 172178.
Richter, R., and Richter, E., 1926, Die Trilobiten des Oberdevons, Beiträge Kenntnis devonischer Trilobiten IV: Abhandlungen der preussischen geologischen Landesanstalt, v. 99, p. 1314.
Robison, R.A., 1964, Late middle Cambrian faunas from western Utah: Journal of Paleontology, v. 38, p. 510566.
Robison, R.A., 1967, Ontogeny of Bathyuriscus fimbriatus and its bearing on affinities of corynexochid trilobites: Journal of Paleontology, v. 41, p. 213221.
Rohlf, F.J., 1993, Relative warp analysis and an example of its application to mosquito wings, in Marcus, L.F., Bello, E., and García-Valdecasas, E., eds., Contributions to Morphometrics: Museo Nacional de Ciencias Naturales, Madrid, Monografias, p. 131159.
Rohlf, F.J., 2013, tpsDig: Digitize coordinates of landmarks and capture outlines: Stony Brook, N.Y., Department of Ecology and Evolution, Stony Brook University,
Rohlf, F.J., and Marcus, L.F., 1993, A revolution in morphometrics: Trends in Ecology & Evolution, v. 8, p. 129132, doi:10.1016/0169-5347(93)90024-J.
Salter, J.W., 1864, On some new fossils from the Lingula-flags of Wales: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 20, p. 233241.
Sebens, K.P., 1987, The ecology of indeterminate growth in animals: Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics, v. 18, p. 371407, doi:10.1146/
Shaw, A.B., 1957, Quantitative trilobite studies II. Measurement of the dorsal shell of non-agnostidean trilobites: Journal of Paleontology, v. 31, p. 193207.
Shaw, F.C., 1974, Simpson Group (Middle Ordovician) trilobites of Oklahoma: The Paleontological Society Memoir 6, 54 p.
Sheets, H.D., 2001, Standard6beta: Buffalo, New York, Department of Physics, Canisius College,
Sheets, H.D., 2010, TwoGroup for integrated morphometrics package, Version 7: Buffalo, N.Y., Department of Physics, Canisius College,
Sheets, H.D., 2011a, CoordGen v.7a: Coordinate generating utility: Buffalo, N.Y., Department of Physics, Canisius College,
Sheets, H.D., 2011b, PCAGen v.7a: PCA of shape data: Buffalo, N.Y., Department of Physics, Canisius College,
Sheets, H.D., 2011c, Regress v.7a: Thin plate spline and regression utility: Buffalo, N.Y., Department of Physics, Canisius College,
Sheets, H.D., Kim, K., and Mitchell, C.E., 2004, A combined landmark and outline-based approach to ontogenetic shape change in the Ordovician trilobite Triarthrus becki, in Elewa, A.M.T., ed., Morphometrics: Berlin, Heidelberg, Springer-Verlag, p. 6782, doi:10.1007/978-3-662-08865-4_6.
Simpson, A.G., Hughes, N.C., Kopaska-Merkel, D.C., and Ludvigsen, R., 2005, Development of the caudal exoskeleton of the pliomerid trilobite Hintzeia plicamarginis new species: Evolution & Development, v. 7, p. 528541.
Struve, W., 1959, Suborder Phacopina, in Moore, R.C., ed., Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Pt. O, Arthropoda 1: Lawrence, KS, University of Kansas, p. O461O462.
Ulrich, E.O., and Delo, D.M., 1940, Phacopid trilobites of North America: Geological Society of America Special Paper 29, p. 1135.
Wagner, A.K., Soumerai, S.B., Zhang, F., and Rose-Degnan, D., 2002, Segmented regression analysis of interrupted time series studies in medication use research: Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics, v. 27, p. 299309, doi:10.1046/j.1365-2710.2002.00430.x.
Walcott, C.D., 1879, Fossils of the Utica slate and metamorphoses of Triarthrus becki: Transactions of the Albany Institute, no. 10, p. 18–38.
Webster, M., 2011, The structure of cranidial shape variation in three early ptychoparioid trilobite species from the Dyeran-Delamaran (traditional “lower-middle” Cambrian) boundary interval of Nevada, USA: Journal of Paleontology, v. 85, p. 179225, doi:10.1666/10-075.1.
Webster, M., 2015, Ontogeny and intraspecific variation of the early Cambrian trilobite Olenellus gilberti, with implications for olenelline phylogeny and macroevolutionary trends in phenotypic canalization: Journal of Systematic Palaentology, v. 13, p. 174, doi:10.1080/14772019.2013.852903.
Webster, M., 2019, Morphological homeostasis in the fossil record: Seminars in Cell & Developmental Biology, v. 88, p. 91104, doi:10.1016/j.semcdb.2018.05.016
Webster, M., and Sheets, H.D., 2010, A practical introduction to landmark-based geometric morphometrics, in Alroy, J., and Hunt, G., eds., Quantitative Methods in Paleobiology: The Paleontological Society Papers, v. 16, p. 168188.
Webster, M., and Zelditch, M.L., 2005, Evolutionary modifications of ontogeny: heterochrony and beyond: Paleobiology, v. 31, p. 354372, doi:10.1666/0094-8373(2005)031[0354:EMOOHA]2.0.CO;2.
Westergård, A.H., 1922, Sveriges olenidskiffer: Sveriges Geologiska Undersökning Avhandlingar och uppsatser series Ca, v. 18, 269 p.
Whittington, H.B., 1957, The ontogeny of trilobites: Biological Reviews, v. 32, p. 421467, doi:10.1111/j.1469-185X.1957.tb00779.x.
Whittington, H.B., and Evitt, W.R., 1954, Silicified Middle Ordovician trilobites (Virginia): Geological Society of America Memoir 59, 137 p.
Zelditch, M.L., Swiderski, D.L., and Sheets, H.D., 2012a, Geometric Morphometrics for Biologists: A Primer: New York and London, Elsevier Academic Press, 437 p.
Zelditch, M.L., Swiderski, D.L., Sheets, H.D., 2012b, A Practical Companion to Geometric Morphometrics for Biologists: Running analyses in freely-available software:

Ontogeny and shape change of the phacopid trilobite Calyptaulax

  • Gabriel S. Jacobs (a1) and Jesse R. Carlucci (a2)


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed