Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

NGOs, elite capture and community-driven development: perspectives in rural Mozambique*

  • Alex Arnall (a1), David S.G. Thomas (a2), Chasca Twyman (a3) and Diana Liverman (a4)

Abstract

This article examines the problems of elite capture in community-driven development (CDD). Drawing on two case studies of non-governmental organisation (NGO) intervention in rural Mozambique, the authors consider two important variables – (1) the diverse and complex contributions of local elites to CDD in different locations and (2) the roles that non-elites play in monitoring and controlling leader activities – to argue that donors should be cautious about automatically assuming the prevalence of malevolent patrimonialism and its ill-effects in their projects. This is because the ‘checks and balances’ on elite behaviour that exist within locally defined and historically rooted forms of community-based governance are likely to be more effective than those introduced by the external intervener.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Footnotes

Hide All
*

This research was funded by an ESRC doctoral studentship. The authors express gratitude to Dr Gavin Hilson at the University of Reading whose comments helped strengthen draft versions of this paper. Special thanks are extended to Nelson Machava in Mozambique for his assistance during the fieldwork stage of the project, as well as the various NGOs and community members who participated in interviews.

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Adhikari, K.P. & Goldey, P.. 2010. ‘Social capital and its ‘downside’: the impact on sustainability of induced community-based organisations in Nepal’, World Development 38: 184–94.
Alexander, J. 1997. ‘The local state in post-war Mozambique: political practice and ideas about authority’, Africa 67: 126.
Araujo, M. C., Ferreira, F. H. G., Lanjouw, P. & Ozler, B.. 2008. ‘Local inequality and project choice: theory and evidence from Ecuador’, Journal of Public Economics 92: 1022–46.
Barnes, J. 2005. ‘Local government and development planning: towards decentralised planning and budgeting in Mozambique’. Conference paper. Dar-es-Salaam: UNDP.
Bayart, J. F. 1993. The State in Africa: The Politics of the Belly. London: Longman.
Bebbington, A. J., Dharmawan, L., Fahmi, E. & Guggenheim, S.. 2004. ‘Village politics, culture and community-driven development: insights from Indonesia’, Progress in Development Studies 4: 187205.
Berman, B. J. 1998. ‘Ethnicity, patronage and the African state: the politics of uncivil nationalism’, African Affairs 97: 305–41.
Bernard, T., Collion, M. H., De Janvry, A., Rondot, P. & Sadoulet, E.. 2008. ‘Do village organisations make a difference in African rural development? A study for Senegal and Burkino Faso’, World Development 36: 2188–204.
Berry, S. 1993. No Condition is Permanent: the social dynamics of agrarian change in sub-Saharan Africa. Madison, WI: The University of Wisconsin Press.
Bingen, J., Serrano, A. & Howard, J.. 2003. ‘Linking farmers to markets: different approaches to human capital development’, Food Policy 28: 405–19.
Bowen, M. L. 1989. ‘Peasant agriculture in Mozambique: the case of Chokwé, Gaza Province’, Canadian Journal of African Studies 23: 355–79.
Carbone, G. M. 2005. ‘Continuidade-na-renovação? Ten years of multiparty politics in Mozambique: roots, devolution and stabilisation of the Frelimo-Renamo party system’, Journal of Modern African Studies 43: 417–42.
CDG. 2005. Reassentamento dos Beneficiários: Fase 2. Maputo: Community Development Group.
Coelho, J. P. B. 1998. ‘State resettlement policies in post-colonial rural Mozambique: the impact of the communal village programme on Tete Province, 1977–1982’, Journal of Southern African Studies 24: 6191.
Coelho, V. S. P. & Favareto, A.. 2008. ‘Questioning the relationship between participation and development: a case study of the Vale do Ribeira, Brazil’, World Development 36: 2937–52.
Costy, A. 1996. ‘Who governs? NGOs in rural Mozambique’, Southern Africa Report 11.
Craig, D. & Porter, D.. 2006. Development beyond Neoliberalism? Governance, poverty reduction and political economy. Abingdon: Routledge.
Cunguara, B. & Hanlon, J.. 2010. Poverty is not being reduced in Mozambique. Development as state-making. Working Paper no. 74. London: Crisis States Research Centre.
Dasgupta, A. & Beard, V. A.. 2007. ‘Community-driven development, collective action and elite capture in Indonesia’, Development and Change 38: 229–49.
DeGrassi, A. 2008. ‘‘Neopatrimonialism’ and agricultural development in Africa: contributions and limitations of a contested concept’, African Studies Review 51: 107–33.
Denscombe, M. 2003. The good research guide for small-scale social research projects. Buckingham: Buckingham Open University Press.
Dinerman, A. 2001. ‘Peasant and state in Mozambique’, Journal of Peasant Studies 28: 143–54.
Fritzen, S. A. 2007. ‘Can the design of community-driven development reduce the risk of elite capture? Evidence from Indonesia’, World Development 35: 1359–75.
GlobalAid. 2006. Emergencies Impact Review. Johannesburg: GlobalAid Emergencies Unit.
Gow, D. D. & Vansant, J. 1983. ‘Beyond the rhetoric of rural development participation: how can it be done?’, World Development 11: 427–46.
Hanlon, J. & Mosse, M.. 2010. Mozambique's elite – finding its way in a globalised world and returning to old development models. Working Paper No. 2010/105. Helsinki: UNU-WIDER.
Harris, L. 1980. ‘Agricultural cooperatives and development policy in Mozambique’, Journal of Peasant Studies 7: 338–52.
Hedges, D. & Chilundo, A.. 1993. ‘A Contestação de Situação Colonial, 1945–1961’, in Rocha, A., ed. História de Moçambique, Vol. III, Moçambique no Auge do Colonialismo. Maputo: Universidade Eduardo Mondlane.
Hermele, K. 1992. ‘Land struggles and social differentiation in southern Mozambique: a case study of Chokwé, Limpopo 1950–1987’, International Journal of African Historical Studies 22: 729–31.
Hulme, D. 1994. ‘Social development research and the third sector: NGOs as users and subjects of social enquiry’, in Booth, D., ed. Rethinking Social Development: theory, research and practice. London: Longman.
Iverson, V., Chhetry, B., Francis, P., Gurung, M., Kafle, G., Pain, A. & Seeley, J.. 2005. ‘High value forests, hidden economies and elite capture: evidence from forest user groups in Nepal's Terai’, Ecological Economics 58: 93107.
Kyed, H. M. & Buur, L.. 2006. ‘New sites of citizenship: recognition of traditional authority and group-based citizenship in Mozambique’, Journal of Southern African Studies 32: 563–81.
Lange, A. 2010. ‘Elites in local development in the Philippines’, Development and Change 41: 5376.
Larson, A. M. & Ribot, J. C.. 2004. ‘Democratic decentralisation through a natural resource lens: an introduction’, European Journal of Development Research 16: 125.
Logan, C. 2009. ‘Selected chiefs, elected councillors and hybrid democracies: popular perspectives on the co-existence of democracy and traditional authority’, Journal of Modern African Studies 47: 101–28.
Long, N. & Long, A.. 1992. Battlefields of knowledge: the interlocking of theory and practice in social research and development. London: Routledge.
Maclean, L. 2010. Informal Institutions and Citizenship in Rural Africa: risk and reciprocity in Ghana and Cote d'Ivoire. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Mansuri, G. & Rao, V.. 2004. ‘Community-based and -driven development: a critical review’, World Bank Research Observer 19: 139.
Marriage, Z. 2006. ‘The comfort of denial: external assistance in southern Sudan’, Development and Change 37: 479500.
Matose, F. 2009. ‘Knowledge, power, livelihoods and commons practices in Dwesa-Cwebe, South Africa’, Development Southern Africa 26: 672–37.
Ministério Da Administração Estatal. 1995. Autoridade e Poder Tradicional, Vol. I e II. Maputo: CEGRAF.
Ministério Da Administração Estatal. 2005. Perfil do Distrito do Manhiça, Provincia de Maputo. Xai Xai, Mozambique: Ministério da Administração Estatal, República de Moçambique.
Ministério Da Agricultura. 1982. Contribução para o Programa da Cooperativização do Campo. Maputo: Bulletin of the Ministry of Agriculture.
Ostrom, E. 1999. Self-governance and forest resources. Occasional Paper No. 20. Bogor, Indonesia: Centre for International Forestry Research.
Pfeiffer, J. 2004. ‘Civil society, NGOs and the holy spirit in Mozambique’, Human Organisation 63: 359–72.
Pitcher, A., Moran, M. H. & Johnston, M.. 2009. ‘Rethinking patrimonialism and neopatrimonialism in Africa’, African Studies Review 52: 125–56.
Pitcher, M. A. 1998. ‘Disruption with transformation: agrarian relations and livelihoods in Nampula Province, Mozambique 1975–1995’, Journal of Southern African Studies 24: 115–40.
Platteau, J. P. & Abraham, A.. 2002. ‘Participatory development in the presence of endogenous community imperfections’, Journal of Development Studies 39: 104–36.
Rao, V. & Ibanez, A. M. 2005. ‘The social impact of social funds in Jamaica: a ‘participatory econometric’ analysis of targeting, collective action, and participation in community-driven development’, Journal of Development Studies 41: 788838.
Republic Popular De Moçambique. 1983. Primeiro Recenseamento Geral da População. Maputo: Conselho Coordenador de Recenseamento.
Ribot, J. C. & Oyono, P. R.. 2005. ‘The politics of decentralisation’, in Wisner, B., Toulmin, C. & Chitiga, R., eds. Towards a New Map of Africa. London: Earthscan.
Scott, J. C. 1985. Weapons of the Weak: everyday forms of peasant resistance. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Sumich, J. 2008. ‘Politics after the time of hunger in Mozambique: a critique of neo patrimonial interpretation of African elites’, Journal of Southern African Studies 34: 111–25.
Sumich, J. 2010. ‘The party and the state: Frelimo and social stratification in post-socialist Mozambique’, Development and Change 41: 679–98.
Tai, H. S. 2007. ‘Development through conservation: an institutional analysis of indigenous community-based conservation in Taiwan’, World Development 35: 1186–203.
Tendler, J. 1997. Good government in the tropics. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Thorp, R., Stewart, F. & Heyer, A.. 2005. ‘When and how far is group formation a route out of chronic poverty?’, World Development 33: 907–20.
Van den Berg, J. 1987. ‘A peasant form of production: wage-dependent agriculture in southern Mozambique’, Canadian Journal of African Studies 21: 375–89.
Veron, R., Williams, G., Corbridge, S. & Srivastava, M.. 2006. ‘Decentralised corruption or corrupt decentralisation? Community monitoring of poverty alleviation schemes in Eastern India’, World Development 34: 1922–41.
Wardman, A. 1985. ‘The co-operative movement in Chokwe, Mozambique’, Journal of Southern African Studies 11: 295304.
West, H. G. & Kloeck-Jenson, S.. 1999. ‘Betwixt and between: ‘traditional authority’ and democratic decentralisation in post-war Mozambique’, African Affairs 98: 455–84.
West, H. G. & Myers, G. W.. 1996. ‘A piece of land in a land of peace? State farm divesture in Mozambique’, Journal of Modern Africa Studies 34: 2751.
Wong, S. 2010. Elite capture or capture elites? Lessons from the counter-elite and co-opt elite approaches in Bangladesh and Ghana. Working Paper No. 2010/82. Helsinki: UNU-WIDER.

NGOs, elite capture and community-driven development: perspectives in rural Mozambique*

  • Alex Arnall (a1), David S.G. Thomas (a2), Chasca Twyman (a3) and Diana Liverman (a4)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed