Skip to main content Accessibility help

Sizing up mechanical testing: Comparison of microscale and mesoscale mechanical testing techniques on a FeCrAl welded tube

  • Jonathan G. Gigax (a1), Avery J. Torrez (a2), Quinn McCulloch (a1), Hyosim Kim (a2), Stuart A. Maloy (a2) and Nan Li (a1)...


FeCrAl alloys are among the best and most mature accident tolerant fuel cladding candidates produced to date, due to their superior combination of mechanical properties and stability at elevated temperatures. For fuel cladding applications, these materials are drawn into tubes with plugs welded to the ends. The mechanical properties of such welds and the impact on cladding performance have not been fully investigated. A novel mesoscale mechanical test and a variety of microscale tests were performed to evaluate a range of properties including nanoindentation hardness, compression and shear yield strengths, and tensile strengths and elongations. Micromechanical testing generally matched the trends of the larger mesoscale testing, with nanoindentation reproducing the trend the best, although some discrepancies existed in regions with low dislocation content. Mesoscale tensile testing showed good correlation with macroscale tests and revealed that the plug heat-affected zone possessed the lowest strength and ductility. This indicated that failure would occur first in or near this region.


Corresponding author

a)Address all correspondence to this author. e-mail:


Hide All
1.Rebak, R.B., Terrani, K.A., Gassmann, W.P., Williams, J.B., and Ledford, K.L.: Improving nuclear power plant safety with FeCrAl alloy fuel cladding. MRS Adv. 2(21–22), 1 (2017).
2.Yamamoto, Y., Pint, B.A., Terrani, K.A., Field, K.G., Yang, Y., and Snead, L.L.: Development and property evaluation of nuclear grade wrought FeCrAl fuel cladding for light water reactors. J. Nucl. Mater. 467(Pt 2), 703716 (2015).
3.Field, K.G., Gussev, M.N., Yamamoto, Y., and Snead, L.L.: Deformation behavior of laser welds in high temperature oxidation resistant Fe–Cr–Al alloys for fuel cladding applications. J. Nucl. Mater. 454, 352 (2014).
4.Zinkle, S.J., Terrani, K.A., and Snead, L.L.: Motivation for utilizing new high-performance advanced materials in nuclear energy systems. Curr. Opin. Solid State Mater. Sci. 20, 401 (2016).
5.Yamamoto, Y., Sun, Z., Pint, B.A., and Terrani, K.A.: Optimized Gen-II FeCrAl Cladding Production in Large Quantity for Campaign Testing (Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, 2016).
6.Field, K.G., Snead, M., Yamamoto, Y., Pint, B.A., and Terrani, K.A.: Handbookonthe Material Properties of FeCrAl Alloys for Nuclear Power Production Applications, ORNL/TM-2017/186, 2017.
7.Wei, C., Zhang, J., Yang, S., Tao, W., Wu, F., and Xia, W.: Experiment-based regional characterization of HAZ mechanical properties for laser welding. Int. J. Adv. Manuf. Technol. 78, 1629 (2015).
8.Wang, X., Mao, S., Chen, P., Liu, Y., Ning, J., Li, H., Zang, K., Zhang, Z., and Han, X.: Evolution of microstructure and mechanical properties of a dissimilar aluminium alloy weldment. Mater. Des. 90, 230 (2016).
9.Gussev, M.N., Field, K.G., and Yamamoto, Y.: Design, properties, and weldability of advanced oxidation-resistant FeCrAl alloys. Mater. Des. 129, 227 (2017).
10.Barabash, O.M., Horton, J.A., Babu, S.S., Vitek, J.M., David, S.A., Park, J.W., Ice, G.E., and Barabash, R.I.: Evolution of dislocation structure in the heat affected zone of a nickel-based single crystal. J. Appl. Physiol. 96, 3673 (2004).
11.McCulloch, Q., Gigax, J., and Hosemann, P.: Femtosecond laser ablation for mesoscale specimen evaluation. JOM 72(4), 1694 (2020).
12.Smith, N.S., Skoczylas, W.P., Kellogg, S.M., Kinion, D.E., Tesch, P.P., Sutherland, O., Aanesland, A., and Boswell, R.W.: High brightness inductively coupled plasma source for high current focused ion beam applications. J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B 24, 2902 (2006).
13.Uchic, M.D. and Dimiduk, D.M.: A methodology to investigate size scale effects in crystalline plasticity using uniaxial compression testing. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 400–401, 268 (2005).
14.Kawakami, T. and Kunieda, M.: Study on factors determining limits of minimum machinable size in micro EDM. CIRP Ann. Manuf. Technol. 54(1), 167 (2005).
15.Pfeifenberger, M.J., Mangang, M., Wurster, S., Reiser, J., Hohenwarter, A., Pfleging, W., Kiener, D., and Pippan, R.: The use of femtosecond laser ablation as a novel tool for rapid micro-mechanical sample preparation. Mater. Des. 121, 109 (2017).
16.Echlin, M.P., Titus, M.S., Straw, M., Gumbsch, P., and Pollock, T.M.: Materials response to glancing incidence femtosecond laser ablation. Acta Mater. 124, 37 (2017).
17.Gigax, J.G., Vo, H., McCulloch, Q., Chancey, M., Wang, Y., Maloy, S.A., Li, N., and Hosemann, P.: Micropillar compression response of femtosecond laser-cut single crystal Cu and proton irradiated Cu. Scr. Mater. 170, 145 (2019).
18.Gigax, J., El-Atwani, O., McCulloch, Q., Aytuna, B., Efe, M., Fensin, S., Maloy, S.A., and Li, N.: Micro- and mesoscale mechanical properties of an ultra-fine grained CrFeMnNi high entropy alloy produced by large strain machining. Scr. Mater. 178, 508 (2020).
19.Gigax, J., Torrez, A., and Li, N.: Microstructural and Micromechanical Characterization of FeCrAl C26M tubes (Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM, 2019).
20.Maier, P., Richter, A., Faulkner, R.G., and Ries, R.: Application of nanoindentation technique for structural characterisation of weld materials. Mater. Charact. 48(4), 329 (2002).
21.Baltazar Hernandez, V.H., Panda, S.K., Kuntz, M.L., and Zhou, Y.: Nanoindentation and microstructure analysis of resistance spot welded dual phase steel. Mater. Lett. 65(2), 207 (2010).
22.Charitidis, C.A., Dragatogiannis, D.A., Koumoulos, E.P., and Kartsonakis, I.A.: Residual stress and deformation mechanism of friction stir welded aluminum alloys by nanoindentation. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 540, 226 (2012).
23.Legendre, F., Poissonnet, S., Bonnaillie, P., Boulanger, L., and Forest, L.: Some microstructural characterisations in a friction stir welded oxide dispersion strengthened ferritic steel alloy. J. Nucl. Mater. 386–388, 537 (2009).
24.Cabibbo, M., Forcellese, A., El Mehtedi, M., and Simoncini, M.: Double side friction stir welding of AA6082 sheets: Microstructure and nanoindentation characterization. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 590, 209 (2014).
25.Nix, W.D. and Gao, H.: Indentation size effects in crystalline materials: A law for strain gradient plasticity. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 46, 411 (1998).
26.Gao, H., Huang, Y., Nix, W.D., and Hutchinson, J.W.: Mechanism-based strain gradient plasticity – I. Theory. J. Mech. Phys. Solids 47, 1239 (1999).
27.Huang, Y., Xue, Z., Gao, H., Nix, W.D., and Xia, Z.C.: A study of microindentation hardness tests by mechanism-based strain gradient plasticity. J. Mater. Res. 15(8), 1786 (2000).
28.Durst, K., Backes, B., Franke, O., and Goken, M.: Indentation size effect in metallic materials: Modelling strength from pop-in to macroscopic hardness using geometrically necessary dislocations. Acta Mater. 54, 2547 (2006).
29.Stelmashenko, N.A., Walls, M.G., Brown, L.M., and Milman, Y.V.: Microindentations on W and Mo oriented single crystals: An STM study. Acta Metall. Mater. 41(10), 2855 (1993).
30.Liu, Y., Varghese, S., Ma, J., Yoshino, M., Lu, H., and Komanduri, R.: Orientation effects in nanoindentation of single crystal copper. Int. J. Plast. 24(11), 1990 (2008).
31.Pathak, S. and Kalidindi, S.R.: Spherical nanoindentation stress-strain curves. Mater. Sci. Eng. R 91, 1 (2015).
32.Patel, D.K. and Kalidindi, S.R.: Correlation of spherical nanoindentation stress-strain curves to simple compression stress-strain curves for elastic-plastic isotropic materials using finite element models. Acta Mater. 112, 295 (2016).
33.Wang, Z., Bei, H., George, E.P., and Pharr, G.M.: Influences of surface preparation on nanoindentation pop-in in single-crystal Mo. Scr. Mater. 65, 469 (2011).
34.Weaver, J.S., Priddy, M.W., McDowell, D.L., and Kalidindi, S.R.: On capturing the grain-scale elastic and plastic anisotropy of alpha-Ti with spherical nanoindentation and electron back-scattered diffraction. Acta Mater. 117, 23 (2016).
35.Kiener, D., Motz, C., and Dehm, G.: Micro-compression testing: A critical discussion of experimental constraints. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 505, 79 (2009).
36.Kim, J.Y. and Greer, J.: Size-dependent mechanical properties of molybdenum nanopillars. Appl. Phys. Lett. 93, 101916 (2008).
37.Frick, C.P., Clark, B.G., Orso, S., Schneider, A.S., and Arzt, E.: Size effect on strength and strain hardening small-scale [1 1 1] nickel compression pillars. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 489(1–2), 319 (2008).
38.Budiman, A.S., Han, S.M., Greer, J.R., Tamura, N., Patel, J.R., and Nix, W.D.: A search for evidence of strain gradient hardening in Au submicron pillars under uniaxial compression using synchrotron X-ray microdiffraction. Acta Mater. 56, 602 (2008).
39.Kim, J.Y., Jang, D., and Greer, J.R.: Tensile and compressive behavior of tungsten, molybdenum, tantalum and niobium at the nanoscale. Acta Mater. 58, 2355 (2010).
40.Uchic, M.D., Dimiduk, D.M., Florando, J.N., and Nix, W.D.: Sample dimensions influence strength and crystal plasticity. Science 305, 986 (2004).
41.Greer, J.R., Oliver, W.C., and Nix, W.D.: Size dependence of mechanical properties of gold at the micron scale in the absence of strain gradients. Acta Mater. 53, 1821 (2005).
42.Korunsky, A.M., Sebastini, M., and Bemporad, E.: Focused ion beam ring drilling for residual stress evaluation. Mater. Lett. 63(22), 1961 (2009).
43.Gigax, J.G., Baldwin, J.K., Sheehan, C.J., Maloy, S.A., and Li, N.: Microscale shear specimens for evaluating the shear deformation in single-crystal and nanocrystalline Cu and at Cu-Si interfaces. J. Mater. Res. 34(9), 1574 (2019).
44.Heyer, J.K., Brinckmann, S., Pfetzing-Micklich, J., and Eggeler, G.: Microshear deformation of gold single crystals. Acta Mater. 62, 225 (2014).
45.Wierczorek, N., Laplanche, G., Heyer, J.-K., Parsa, A.B., Pfetzing-Micklich, J., and Eggeler, G.: Assessment of strain hardening in copper single crystals using in situ SEM microshear experiments. Acta Mater. 113, 320 (2016).
46.Milot, T.S.: Establishing Correlations for Predicting Tensile Properties Based on the Shear Punch Test and Vickers Microhardness Data (University of California, Santa Barbara, 2012).
47.Zhang, P., Li, S.X., and Zhang, Z.F.: General relationship between strength and hardness. Mater. Sci. Eng. A 529, 62 (2011).
48.El-Awady, J.A.: Unravelling the physics of size-dependent dislocation-mediated plasticity. Nat. Commun. 6, 5926 (2015).
49.Kunz, A., Pathak, S., and Greer, J.R.: Size effects in Al nanopillars: Single crystalline vs. bicrystalline. Acta Mater. 59, 4416 (2011).
50.Imrich, P.J., Kirchlechner, C., Motz, C., and Dehm, G.: Differences in deformation behavior of bicrystalline Cu micropillars containing a twin boundary or a large-angle grain boundary. Acta Mater. 73, 240 (2014).
51.Was, G.: Irradiation hardening and deformation. In Fundamentals of Radiation Materials Science – Metals and Alloys (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2007), pp. 669733.
52.Hosemann, P.: Small-scale mechanical testing on nuclear materials: Bridging the experimental length-scale gap. Scr. Mater. 143, 161 (2018).
53.Vo, H.T., Reichardt, A., Frazer, D., Bailey, N., Chou, P., and Hosemann, P.: In situ micro-tensile testing on proton beam-irradiated stainless steel. J. Nucl. Mater. 493, 336 (2017).
54.Weaver, J.S., Pathak, S., Reichardt, A., Vo, H.T., Maloy, S.A., Hosemann, P., and Mara, N.A.: Spherical nanoindentation of proton irradiated 304 stainless steel: A comparison of small scale mechanical test techniques for measuring irradiation hardening. J. Nucl. Mater. 493, 368 (2017).
55.Krumwiede, D.L., Yamamoto, T., Saleh, T.A., Maloy, S.A., Odette, G.R., and Hosemann, P.: Direct comparison of nanoindentation and tensile test results on reactor-irradiated materials. J. Nucl. Mater. 504, 135 (2018).
56.Aydogan, E., Weaver, J.S., Maloy, S.A., El-Atwani, O., Wang, Y.Q., and Mara, N.A.: Microstructure and mechanical properties of FeCrAl alloys under heavy ion irradiations. J. Nucl. Mater. 503, 250 (2018).
57.Chen, T., Gigax, J.G., Price, L., Chen, D., Ukai, S., Aydogan, E., Maloy, S.A., Garner, F.A., and Shao, L.: Temperature dependent dispersoid stability in ion-irradiated ferritic-martensitic dual-phase oxide-dispersion-strengthened alloy: Coherent interfaces vs. incoherent interfaces. Acta Mater. 116, 29 (2016).
58.Gigax, J.G., Chen, T., Kim, H., Wang, J., Price, L.M., Aydogan, E., Maloy, S.A., Schreiber, D.K., Toloczko, M.B., Garner, F.A., and Shao, L.: Radiation response of alloy T91 at damage levels up to 1000 peak dpa. J. Nucl. Mater. 482, 257 (2016).
59.Gigax, J.G., Kim, H., Chen, T., Garner, F.A., and Shao, L.: Radiation instability of equal channel angular extruded T91 at ultra-high damage levels. Acta Mater. 132, 10 (2017).
60.Aydogan, E., Maloy, S.A., Anderoglu, O., Sun, C., Gigax, J.G., Shao, L., Garner, F.A., Anderson, I.E., and Lewandowski, J.J.: Effect of tube processing methods on microstructure, mechanical properties and irradiation response of 14YWT nanostructured ferritic alloys. Acta Mater. 134, 116 (2017).
61.Kim, H., Gigax, J.G., Chen, T., Ukai, S., Garner, F.A., and Shao, L.: Dispersoid stability in ion irradiated oxide-dispersion-strengthened alloy. J. Nucl. Mater. 509, 504 (2018).
62.Oliver, W.C. and Pharr, G.M.: Measurement of hardness and elastic modulus by instrumented indentation: Advances in understanding and refinements to methodology. J. Mater. Res. 19(1), 3 (2004).


Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Gigax et al. supplementary material
Gigax et al. supplementary material

 Unknown (2.9 MB)
2.9 MB

Sizing up mechanical testing: Comparison of microscale and mesoscale mechanical testing techniques on a FeCrAl welded tube

  • Jonathan G. Gigax (a1), Avery J. Torrez (a2), Quinn McCulloch (a1), Hyosim Kim (a2), Stuart A. Maloy (a2) and Nan Li (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.