Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-dk4vv Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-22T11:39:29.478Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Private Health Care for Canada: North of the Border, an Idea Whose Time Shouldn't Come?

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  01 January 2021

Ted Schrecker
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Toronto physician Brian Goldman had thought about “joining the camp that favours private health care for Canada.” Writing in the Canadian Medical Association Journal, he tells us that he changed his mind after one of his cats experienced a series of illnesses and misadventures that resulted in a Can$3,101 medical bill. “I’m just glad,” he says, “that the cost of health care never entered my deliberations.”’

Canadian citizens and permanent residents are similarly free from most worries about the direct costs of their own medical care, and have been for more than a generation. This reflects a fundamental difference between the Canadian and United States contexts for health policy. Since the failure of President Clinton's first-term efforts to provide something approximating universal health insurance, reforms to the existing regime of providing and financing health care in the United States have been incremental, and primarily responsive to the changing nature of the health care marketplace. In Canada, universal publicly funded first-dollar coverage for most physicians’ and hospitals’ services has been a reality since the early 1970s.

Type
Article
Information
Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics , Volume 26 , Issue 2 , Summer 1998 , pp. 138 - 148
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Law, Medicine and Ethics 1998

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Goldman, B., “Lessons My $3101 Cat Taught Me About Universal Health Care,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 153 (1995): At 621–22. At this writing, Can$1.00 is worth approximately US$0.65.Google Scholar
See, for example, Dirnfeld, V., “The Benefits of Privatization,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 155 (1996): 407–10 (Victor Dirnfeld, M.D., is the current president of the Canadian Medical Association); Gunton, R., Editorial, “It's Time to Re-Introduce a Private Component to the Funding of Health Care,” Annals of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, 30 (1997): 9–11; and Hill, G., “What Canada's Health System Needs Is More Choice,” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Aug. 21, 1995, at A11 (Grant Hill, M.D., a Member of Parliament for the province of Alberta, is the health spokesman for the Reform Party of Canada).Google Scholar
Dirnfeld, , id. at 408.Google Scholar
See Berger, P., “Medicare Works Best If the Affluent Are Forced to Defend It,” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Aug. 21, 1995, at A11; Carver, C., “It's Time for CMA to Put the Lid on Privatization,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 155 (1996): 1156–57; Gordon, M., “A System Worth Saving,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 154 (1996): 1395–96; Gordon, M. Berger, P., “The Alluring Myth of Private Medicine,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 155 (1996): 404–06; Gordon, M. Turner, T., “Healing Medicare: Options to Save the Single-Payer System,” Annals of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, 30 (1997): 275–78; and Turner, T. Gordon, M., “The Privatization of Medicare: Should We Consider It?,” Ontario Medical Review, Apr. (1996): 52–56.Google Scholar
See Somerville, M.A., “Weaving ‘Birth’ Technology into the ‘Value and Policy Web’ of Medicine, Ethics and Law: Should Policies on ‘Conception’ be Consistent,” Nova Law Review, 13 (1989): At 539; Somerville, M.A., “The Song of Death: The Lyrics of Euthanasia,” Journal of Contemporary Health Law and Policy, 9 (1993): At 64–68; and Moskowitz, E., “The Ethics of Government Bioethics,” Politics and the Life Sciences, 13 (1994): At 96.Google Scholar
Hoffmaster, C.B., “Challenges to Health Care Ethics in Canada,” Westminster Affairs, 8, no. 1 (1995): At 7 (on file with author).Google Scholar
Canada Health Act of 1984, R.S.C., ch. C-6, §§ 7–12 (1985) (Can.).Google Scholar
For more detail on Canadian arrangements for health care provision and financing, see Burke, M. Stevenson, H.M., “Fiscal Crisis and the Restructuring of Medicare: The Politics and Political Science of Health in Canada,” Health and Canadian Society, 1, no. 1 (1995): 51–80; and Deber, R., “Canadian Medicare: Can it Work in the United States? Will it Survive in Canada?,” American Journal of Law & Medicine, XIX (1993): 75–93.Google Scholar
See National Forum on Health, The Public and Private Financing of Canada's Health System (Ottawa: Health Canada, Sept. 1995): At 9.Google Scholar
See Barer, M., “Re-Minding Our Ps and Qs: Medical Cost Controls in Canada,” Health Affairs, 15, no. 2 (1996): 216–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Lomas, J. Woods, J. Veenstra, G., “Devolving Authority for Health Care in Canada's Provinces: 1. An Introduction,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 156 (1997): 371–77.Google Scholar
R.S.C., ch. C-6, § 2 (1985) (Can.).Google Scholar
Id.Google Scholar
See id.Google Scholar
See id. § 12.Google Scholar
See id. § 2.Google Scholar
See Annual Report on the Administration and Operation of the Canada Health Act, 1995–96 (Ottawa: Health Canada, 1997). This document, and more recent annual reports as they are produced, are available at <http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/medicare/chaover.htm>. The report provides a province-by-province breakdown of insured and uninsured services..+The+report+provides+a+province-by-province+breakdown+of+insured+and+uninsured+services.>Google Scholar
As provided for in R.S.C., ch. C-6, §§ 5, 7.Google Scholar
The principles of the Canada Health Act do not have constitutional status. Unlike the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which has been part of Canada's Constitution Act since 1982, the Canada Health Act contains no provisions giving individuals standing to enforce its provisions. Reflecting the convention of parliamentary supremacy, Canadian courts have generally been inhospitable to citizens' efforts to litigate issues of policy implementation with the exception of Charter-related cases. It is conceivable that health care resource constraints could eventually be the subject of a successful action under the Charter, perhaps as age-based rationing becomes more conspicuous. However, exploring this possibility would require a separate article.Google Scholar
See Tholl, W.G., “Health Care Spending in Canada: Skating Faster on Thinner Ice,” in Blomqvist, Å. Brown, D., eds., Limits to Care: Reforming Canada's Health System in an Age of Restraint (Toronto: C.D. Howe Institute, 1994): At 62–63.Google Scholar
See Gray, C., “The Face of Canadian Medicare is Going to Look Much Different Following this Federal Budget,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 152 (1995): 1281–83.Google Scholar
Banting, K., “Who R Us?,” Address to the Canadian Association of Business Economists, Ottawa, Ontario (May 2, 1995), at 9 (Keith Banting is Director of the School of Policy Studies at Queen's University, in Kingston, Ontario) (on file with author); see also Evans, R., “Health Care Reform: ‘The Issue From Hell’,” Policy Options, July-Aug. (1993): At 40.Google Scholar
See Harrison, M., “Discharging Patients Earlier from Winnipeg Hospitals: Does it Adversely Affect Quality of Care?,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 153 (1995): 745–51 (study covering lengths of stay between 1989 and 1993).Google Scholar
See Vingilis, E. Burkell, J., “A Critique of an Evaluation of the Impact of Hospital Bed Closures in Winnipeg, Canada: Lessons to be Learned from Evaluation Research Methods,” Journal of Public Health Policy, 17 (1996): 409–25.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Region Ten Medical Staff, Report of the Critical Assessment Committee (Edmonton: Capital Health Authority, Oct. 18, 1996) <http://www.cha.ab.ca/reports.htm>..>Google Scholar
See Hardy, K., Leading the Management of Change: A Study of 12 Ontario Hospitals (London: Richard Ivey School of Business, Sept. 22, 1997).Google Scholar
See Armstrong, P. Armstrong, H., Wasting Away: The Undermining of Canadian Health Care (Toronto: Oxford University Press, 1996): At 66–137, 170–88. It could be argued that Wasting Away is compromised by its reliance on the accounts of patients who called a hot-line set up by a coalition of public sector unions representing workers in hospitals and other health care institutions to solicit complaints about quality and access to care—in other words, that the sample is self-selected and the researchers arguably self-interested. On the other hand, the accounts of patients are eloquent, and so far as I know no one has questioned their veracity. Some of the most recent media reports on the topic include: Egan, M., “Intensive Care Bed Shortage a Crisis,” London Free Press (Ontario), Sept. 20, 1997, at A1–A2; Laghi, B., “Edmonton Hospitals Cancel Most Elective Surgery,” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Feb. 27, 1998, at A4; and “Hospital Team to Tackle Crisis,” Toronto Star, Feb. 3, 1998 (Internet ed.).Google Scholar
See Capen, K., “Findings of Negligence Followed Communication Lapses in B.C. Aneurysm Case,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 156 (1997): 49–51 (commenting on Law Estate v. Simice [1994] 21 C.C.L.T.2d 228 (B.C.) (Can.)); Capen, K., “Resource Allocation and Physician Liability,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 156 (1997): 393–95; and Kryworuk, P. Butler, B. Otten, A., “Potential Legal Liability in the Allocation of Scarce Health Care Resources,” Annals of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, 28 (1995): 153–60.Google Scholar
See Gray, C., “Visions of Our Health Care Future: Is a Parallel Private System the Answer?,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 154 (1996): 1084–87; and “Two-Thirds of Canadians Have Extended Coverage,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 154 (1996): 1070.Google Scholar
See Health Canada, National Health Expenditures in Canada, 1975–1996 (Ottawa: Policy and Consultation Branch, Health Canada, 1997) <http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/datapcb/datahesa/hex.htm>..>Google Scholar
Total Canadian health care spending amounted to 9.5 percent of GDP in 1996, down from a peak of 10.2 percent in 1992. This is close to the figure for a number of other high-income countries that are members of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, but dramatically lower than the U.S. figure of 14.2 percent of GDP. However, public sector health care spending as a percentage of GDP declined by 12 percent between 1992 and 1996, from 7.5 percent of GDP to 6.6 percent. See id. at 5.Google Scholar
The increase in self-employment accounted for all the net job creation between 1990 and 1997. See Advisory Committee on the Changing Workplace, Collective Reflection on the Changing Workplace (Ottawa: Labour Canada, 1997): At 9.Google Scholar
See Armstrong, Armstrong, , supra note 27, at 135–44; and Cochrane, J. Goering, P. Rogers, J., “The Mental Health of Informal Caregivers in Ontario: An Epidemiological Survey,” American Journal of Public Health, 87 (1997): 2002–07.Google Scholar
See Brooks, J., “Canada's First Private MRI Clinic: Does it Signal a Shift to Two-Tiered Medicine?,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 149 (1993): 1155–58; and DeCoster, C. Brownell, M., “Private Health Care in Canada: Saviour or Siren?,” Public Health Reports, 112 (1997): 298–305.Google Scholar
See Cohen, M., “Women, Democracy and the Future of Nations,” in Boyer, R. Drache, D., eds., States Against Markets: The Limits of Globalization (London: Routledge, 1996): At 402–06.Google Scholar
See Coutts, J., “Support for Health-Care Principles Weaker Among Well-Off,” Globe and Mail (Toronto), Oct. 26, 1995, at A21.Google Scholar
National Forum on Health, supra note 9, at 4–5.Google Scholar
Id. at 12.Google Scholar
National Forum on Health, Canada Health Action: Building on the Legacy, Final Report (Ottawa: Health Canada, Vol. I, 1996): Ch. I.1.Google Scholar
In an extensive literature, the clearest critical analyses of this change include Ferge, Z., “The Changed Welfare Paradigm: The Individualization of the Social,” Social Policy and Administration, 31 (1997): 20–44; Hoover, K. Plant, R., Conservative Capitalism in Britain and the United States: A Critical Appraisal (London: Routledge, 1989): At 15–75, 205–35; and Ignatieff, M., “The Myth of Citizenship,” in Beiner, R., ed., Theorizing Citizenship (Albany: State University of New York Press, 1993): 53–78.Google Scholar
Murray, C., Losing Ground: American Social Policy, 1950–1980 (New York: Basic Books, 1984): At 233–34.Google Scholar
Id. at 227–28.Google Scholar
Daniels, N. Light, D. Caplan, R., Benchmarks of Fairness for Health Care Reform (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996): At 37, see generally 37–44.Google Scholar
Id. at 21–22.Google Scholar
Id. at 18.Google Scholar
Id. at 25.Google Scholar
See id. at 71–134.Google Scholar
See id. at 73, 129–34.Google Scholar
Id. at 74.Google Scholar
See Chapman, A.R., Exploring a Human Rights Approach to Health Care Reform (Washington, D.C.: Science and Human Rights Program, American Association for the Advancement of Science, 1993): At 21.Google Scholar
Id. at 17.Google Scholar
Id. at 22.Google Scholar
Id. at 17.Google Scholar
Id. at 23, 25.Google Scholar
See id. at 26–27.Google Scholar
See Daniels, Light, Caplan, , supra note 43, at 44–53.Google Scholar
See Gordon, Turner, , supra note 4, at 275.Google Scholar
See Dirnfeld, , supra note 2, at 409.Google Scholar
Keon, Wilbert, Director, University of Ottawa Heart Institute, as quoted in Gray, , supra note 29, at 1085–86.Google Scholar
See Evans, R., “Finding the Levers, Finding the Courage: Lessons from Cost Containment in North America,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 11 (1986): At 598; and Evans, R., “Hang Together, or Hang Separately: The Viability of a Universal Health Care System in an Aging Society,” Canadian Public Policy, 13 (1987): At 173–74.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Cornwell, E., “Health Care Crisis from a Trauma Center Perspective: The L.A. Story,” JAMA, 276 (1996): 940-44; Drake, D., “Managed Care: A Product of Market Dynamics,” JAMA, 277 (1997): 560-63; Feder, J. Hadley, J., “The Economically Unattractive Patient: Who Cares?,” Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 61 (Jan.–Feb. 1985): 68–80; Light, D., “The Practice and Ethics of Risk-Rated Health Insurance,” JAMA, 267 (1992): 2503–08; Morgan, R., “The Medicare-HMO Revolving Door—The Healthy Go In and the Sick Go Out,” N. Engl. J. Med., 337 (1997): 169-75; and Sack, K., “Public Hospitals Around Country Cut Basic Service,” New York Times, Aug. 20, 1995, at A1, A13.Google Scholar
See Gladwell, M., “Failing Health,” Saturday Night, Oct. 1993, at 26–30, 66–69.Google Scholar
Kinney, E., “Serious Illness and Private Health Coverage: A Unique Problem Calling for Unique Solutions,” Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 25 (1997): At 187.Google Scholar
See id. at 184.Google Scholar
Id. at 186.Google Scholar
Evans, R., Who Are the Zombie Masters, and What Do They Want? (Toronto: Premier's Council on Health, Well-Being and Social Justice, June 1994): At 7. The intriguing title refers specifically to the idea of user charges in a publicly financed health care system, which the authors regard as thoroughly discredited. “Like zombies in the night, these ideas may be intellectually dead but are never buried.” Id. at 3.Google Scholar
See id. For more extensive discussions of the same theme, see Evans, R., “Going for the Gold: The Redistributive Agenda Behind Market-Based Health Care Reform,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 22 (1997): 427–65; and Evans, R., “Health Care Reform: Who's Selling the Market, and Why?,” Journal of Public Health Medicine, 19 (1997): 45-49.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Reich, R., “Secession of the Successful,” New York Times Magazine, Jan. 20, 1991, at 16–17, 42-45; and Reich, R., The Work of Nations (New York: Knopf, 1991): At 243–300.Google Scholar
See New York Times Special Report, The Downsizing of America (New York: Times Books, 1996); Economic Council of Canada, Good Jobs, Bad Jobs: Employment in the Service Economy (Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada, 1990); Economic Council of Canada, Legacies: Twenty-Sixth Annual Review, 1989 (Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada, 1990): At 33–47; Mishel, L. Bernstein, J. Schmitt, J., The State of Working America, 1996–97 (Washington, D.C.: Economic Policy Institute, 1997); and Wolff, E., Top Heavy: A Study of the Increasing Inequality of Wealth in America (New York: Twentieth Century Fund Press, 1995).Google Scholar
See Light, D., “The Real Ethics of Rationing,” British Medical Journal, 315 (1997): At 114; and Dickson, N., “Blood, Sweat and Tiers,” The Guardian, Sept. 11, 1996, at 2.Google Scholar
See Aaron, H. Schwartz, W., The Painful Prescription: Rationing Hospital Care (Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution, 1984), at 33, 48–50, 54–56, 65–67; Schwartz, W. Aaron, H., Special Report, “Rationing Hospital Care: Lessons from Britain,” N. Engl. J. Med., 310 (1984): 53-56; and Simmons, R. Marine, S., “The Regulation of High Cost Technology Medicine: The Case of Dialysis and Transplantation in the United Kingdom,” Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 25 (1984): At 322–24.Google Scholar
See “Cash Crisis Cripples the NHS,” The Times, Nov. 3, 1996, at 1; “An Unhealthy Silence,” The Economist, Mar. 15, 1997 (Internet ed.); and Rogers, L., “Cuts Threaten 10 Hospitals with Closure,” The Times, Jan. 11, 1998 (Internet ed.).Google Scholar
Rees-Mogg, W., “Closing the Health and Education Gaps,” The Times, Jan. 13, 1997, at 18; see also Rees-Mogg, W., “Why the NHS is the Sick Man of Europe,” The Times, Oct. 6, 1997, at 20; and Smith, D., “Quick Nurse, More Private Cash,” The Times, Nov. 10, 1996, at 9.Google Scholar
Deber, R. Swan, B., “Puzzling Issues in Health Care Financing,” in National Forum on Health, ed., Canada Health Action: Building on the Legacy, Health Care Systems in Canada and Elsewhere (Sainte-Foy: Editions MultiMondes, 1998): At 331–32.Google Scholar
See “Focus: Private Healthcare,” The Times, Jan. 24, 1997, at 35–39.Google Scholar
“An Unhealthy Silence,” supra note 72.Google Scholar
Berger, , supra note 4, at A11.Google Scholar
Interestingly, the authors of one recent article on the National Health Service (NHS) funding did not; they concluded that “the ultimate test of NHS funding will be the expression of satisfaction in opinion surveys, and by continued use of NHS funded care by the majority of the population.” Dixon, J. Harrison, A. New, B., “Is the NHS Underfunded?,” British Medical Journal, 314 (1997): At 61. Can the majority of the British population really afford this expression of “choice”?Google Scholar
See Naylor, C.D., “Building a Sustainable Health Care System,” Canadian Speeches, 11, no. 3 (June 1997): 25–31.Google Scholar
See Woolhandler, S. Himmelstein, D., “The Deteriorating Administrative Efficiency of the U.S. Health Care System,” N. Engl. J. Med., 324 (1991): 1253-58; Woolhandler, S. Himmelstein, D. Lewontin, J., “Administrative Costs in U.S. Hospitals,” N. Engl. J. Med., 329 (1993): 400-03; and Himmelstein, D. Lewontin, J. Woolhandler, S., “Who Administers? Who Cares? Medical Administrative and Clinical Employment in the United States and Canada,” American Journal of Public Health, 86 (1996): 172–78.Google Scholar
Evans, (1986), supra note 60, at 602–03.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
On this phenomenon in the NHS, see Schwartz, Aaron, , supra note 71; and Simmons, Marine, , supra note 71.Google Scholar
See, for example, Annas, G.J., “Patients' Rights in Managed Care—Exit, Voice and Choice,” N. Engl. J. Med., 337 (1997): 210-15; Howe, E.G., “Managed Care: ‘New Moves,’ Moral Uncertainty, and a Radical Attitude,” Journal of Clinical Ethics, 6 (1995): 290-305; Mariner, W.K., “Business vs. Medical Ethics: Conflicting Standards for Managed Care,” Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 23 (1995): 236-46; Morgan, , supra note 61; Pear, R., “HMOs Refusing Emergency Claims, Doctors Assert,” New York Times, July 9, 1995, at 1, 12; and Zoloth-Dorfman, L. Rubin, S., “The Patient as Commodity: Managed Care and the Question of Ethics,” Journal of Clinical Ethics, 6 (1995): 339–57.Google Scholar
See Eisenberg, L., “The Case Against For-Profit Hospitals,” Hospital and Community Psychiatry, 35 (1984): 1009–13.Google Scholar
See Latham, S.R., “Regulation of Managed Care Incentive Payments to Physicians,” American Journal of Law & Medicine, XXII (1996): 399–432; Mariner, , supra note 83; and Zoloth-Dorfman, Rubin, , supra note 83.Google Scholar
Ignatieff, , supra note 40, at 70.Google Scholar
On this approach to the future of the NHS, see New, B., “Defining a Package of Healthcare Services the NHS is Responsible For: The Case For,” British Medical Journal, 314 (1997): 503–06; and Klein, R., “Defining a Package of Healthcare Services the NHS is Responsible For: The Case Against,” British Medical Journal, 314 (1997): 506-09.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Gray, C., “NHS Reforms Reduce Length of Waiting Lists but Create Widespread Unease,” Canadian Medical Association Journal, 155 (1996): At 1488.Google Scholar
See Mays, N. Keen, J., “Will the Fudge on Equity Sustain the NHS into the Next Millennium?,” British Medical Journal, 317 (1998): 66–69; Portillo, M., “The Bevan Legacy,” British Medical Journal, 317 (1998): 37–40; and Rees-Mogg, , “Closing the Health and Education Gaps,” supra note 73.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, , “Going for the Gold,” supra note 67, at 447.Google Scholar
Id. at 445, see generally 445–49. See also Evans, (1987), supra note 60, at 170–71.Google Scholar
See supra notes 43–56 and accompanying text.Google Scholar
See Evans, R. Stoddart, G., “Producing Health, Consuming Health Care,” Social Science and Medicine, 31 (1990): 1347–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See Culyer, A.J., “Maximizing the Health of the Whole Community: The Case For,” British Medical Journal, 314 (1997): 667-69; and Harris, J., “Maximizing the Health of the Whole Community: The Case Against: What the Principal Objective of the NHS Should Really Be,” British Medical Journal, 314 (1997): 669–72.Google Scholar
See Corrigan, P., “A Dose of Realism? The Social Grammar of Globalism,” in Schrecker, T., ed., Surviving Globalism: The Social and Environmental Challenges (London: Macmillan, 1997): 239–52.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
See, for example, Zoloth-Dorfman, Rubin, , supra note 83, at 342–43.Google Scholar
See Feder, Hadley, , supra note 61; and Sack, , supra note 61.Google Scholar
Mays, Keen, , supra note 89, at 66.Google Scholar
Hoffmaster, , supra note 6, at 4.Google Scholar