Skip to main content Accessibility help

An Overview of the Scholarship in Law and Religion of Judge John T. Noonan, Jr.

  • Robert E. Rodes


I first met John Noonan at a Law Review dinner when I was a year or so out of law school and he was a third year student. Chance placed us at the same table, and the conversation—naturally—proved to be more interesting than the speeches. When I came home and reported on the occasion to my wife, it developed that she was already acquainted with John Noonan. When they were teenagers, he had been a particularly suave and glamorous summer inhabitant of a beach resort where one of her friends also spent summers.

Not long after the Law Review dinner, John graduated and went to Washington, and we left Boston, first for New Jersey and then for Notre Dame. I heard nothing more of John until one day when Joe O'Meara, the formidable dean of the Notre Dame Law School, showed me an article from the 1955 volume of the Journal of Legal Education called Value References in the Teaching of Negligence. The author had looked at all the Torts casebooks he could find, and earlier editions of many of them; at all the relevant case write-ups from the Harvard Law Review and the Yale Law Journal; at a number of law school examinations; and at all the issue sheets used by Harvard's Board of Student Advisors in supervising their moot court, the Ames Competition. He had found the value concerns in great disarray, and not much relied on anyhow. It was clear that teaching about negligence involved analysis of rules and not much else. The author (of course, it was John) admitted reluctantly that neither philosophy nor theology nor social science provided any principles that would be of much use in deciding negligence cases, but he expressed a rather wistful hope that more facts might lead to a more effective application of values to these cases. “More facts” was to be a major distinguishing quality in the rest of his work.



Hide All

1. Noonan, John T. Jr., Value References in the Teaching of Negligence, 8 J Legal Educ 150 (1955).

2. Noonan, John T. Jr., Contraception (The Belknap Press of Harvard U Press, 1986).

3. Dunne, John S., The City of the Gods (Macmillan, 1965).

4. Noonan, John I. Jr., Persons and Masks of the Law 65 (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1976).

5. Noonan, , Contraception at 4 (cited in note 2).

6. Noonan, , Contraception at 532–33 (cited in note 2).

7. Noonan, John T. Jr., Power to Dissolve 403–04 (The Belknap Press of Harvard U Press, 1972).

8. Noonan, John T. Jr., Bribes 702 (U of California Press, 1984).

9. Noonan, , Persons and Masks at 167–68 (cited in note 4).

10. Noonan, John T. Jr., The Antelope 159 (U of California Press, 1977).

11. Noonan, , Bribes at 239–48 (cited in note 8).

12. Id at 334.

13. Noonan, , Power to Dissolve at 6072 (cited in note 7).

14. Id at 302.

15. Missouri v Holland, 252 US 416, 433-34 (1920).

16. Quoted in Rodes, Robert E. Jr., The Legal Enterprise 37 (Kennikat Press, 1976). Noonan, John T. Jr., Review of The Legal Enterprise, 22 Amer J Jurisprudence 190–95 (1977).

17. Noonan, , Persons and Masks at 164–65 (cited in note 4).

18. Noonan, John T. Jr., A Private Choice (The Free Press, 1979).

19. Id at 192.

* Professor of Law, Notre Dame Law School. Remarks in recognition of the Honorable John T. Noonan, Jr., recipient of the Journal of Law and Religion award for his contributions to the field of law and religion, October 11, 1996.


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed