Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Pooled analysis of the evidence for open cavity, combined approach and reconstruction of the mastoid cavity in primary cholesteatoma surgery

  • A T Harris (a1), B Mettias (a1) and T H J Lesser (a1)

Abstract

Background:

Cholesteatoma is keratinising epithelium within the middle-ear cleft or mastoid. This disease destroys the peripheral organs of balance and hearing, with possible intracranial sequelae. The management of cholesteatoma is surgical and the primary aim is to remove the disease and prevent recurrence. Secondary aims are to obtain a non-discharging, hearing ear. Cholesteatoma surgery falls into two broad categories: open cavity surgery and combined approach surgery. A third surgical category is reconstruction of an open mastoid cavity after open surgery. This study performed a pooled analysis of the worldwide literature to compare the rates of cholesteatoma not being cured (i.e. recidivism), ear discharge and hearing change among open cavity, combined approach and reconstruction mastoid surgery for primary cholesteatoma.

Methods:

A literature search for all types of cholesteatoma surgery in the PubMed, Google Scholar and Medline databases and in published conference proceedings was undertaken.

Results:

There was no level 1 evidence for the best method of primary cholesteatoma surgery. The highest evidence level found (level 2; 5366 patients) shows no difference in hearing change or discharge rate between open and combined approach surgery; however, these methods fail to cure the cholesteatomas in 16.0 per cent and 29.4 per cent of cases, respectively. In a total of 640 patients, reconstruction and/or repair mastoid surgery using a variety of non-comparable techniques had a failure rate of between 5.3 per cent and 20 per cent.

Conclusion:

The available evidence suggests that reconstruction of the posterior canal wall and/or obliteration of the mastoid may be the best surgical treatment alternative. This technique appears to provide the lowest recidivism rate combined with a low post-operative ear discharge rate.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Address for correspondence: Mr T H J Lesser, ENT Department, Aintree University Hospital, Lower Lane, Liverpool L9 7AL, UK E-mail: tristram.lesser@aintree.nhs.uk

References

Hide All
1Ojala, K, Palva, A.Late results of obliterative cholesteatoma surgery. Arch Otolaryngol 1982;108:13
2Patient: trusted medical information and support, 2011 Different levels of evidence. In: http://www.patient.co.uk/doctor/different-levels-of-evidence [24 July 2015]
3Lau, T, Tos, M.Tensa retraction cholesteatoma: treatment and long-term results. J Laryngol Otol 1989;103:149–57
4Zorita, C, Villar, J, Bosch, J.Long-term results of cholesteatoma surgery in children. Acta Otorrinolaringol Esp 1994;45:233–6
5Stangerup, SE, Drozdziewicz, D, Tos, M, Trabalzini, F.Surgery for acquired cholesteatoma in children: long-term results and recurrence of cholesteatoma. J Laryngol Otol 1998;112:742–9
6Godinho, RA, Kamil, SH, Lubianca, JN, Keogh, IJ, Eavey, RD.Pediatric cholesteatoma: canal wall window alternative to canal wall down mastoidectomy. Otol Neurotol 2005;26:466–71
7Derlacki, EL, Baron, HS, Beales, PH, Bellucci, RJ, Guilford, FR, Plester, D et al. Selection of closed vs open technique for cholesteatomas. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1969;89:211–19
8Deguine, C.Longterm results in cholesteatoma surgery. Clin Otolaryngol Allied Sci 1978;3:301–10
9Brown, JS.A ten year statistical follow-up of 1142 consecutive cases of cholesteatoma: the closed vs. the open technique. Laryngoscope 1982;92:390–6
10Charachon, R.Surgery of cholesteatoma in children. J Laryngol Otol 1988;102:680–4
11Quaranta, A, Cassano, P, Carbonara, G.Cholesteatoma surgery: open vs closed tympanoplasty. Am J Otol 1988;9:229–31
12Marco-Algarra, J, Gimenez, F, Mallea, I, Armengot, M, de la Fuente, L.Cholesteatoma in children: results in open versus closed techniques. J Laryngol Otol 1991;105:820–4
13Schmid, H, Dort, JC, Fisch, U.Long-term results of treatment for children's cholesteatoma. Am J Otol 1991;12:83–7
14Vartiainen, E, Nuutinen, J.Long-term results of surgical treatment in different cholesteatoma types. Am J Otol 1993;14:507–11
15Karmarkar, S, Bhatia, S, Saleh, E, DeDonato, G, Taibah, A, Russo, A et al. Cholesteatoma surgery: the individualized technique. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 1995;104:591–5
16Parisier, SC, Hanson, MB, Han, JC, Cohen, AJ, Selkin, BA.Pediatric cholesteatoma: an individualized, single-stage approach. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1996;115:107–14
17Roden, D, Honrubia, VF, Wiet, R.Outcome of residual cholesteatoma and hearing in mastoid surgery. J Otolaryngol 1996;25:178–81
18Dodson, EE, Hashisaki, GT, Hobgood, TC, Lambert, PR.Intact canal wall mastoidectomy with tympanoplasty for cholesteatoma in children. Laryngoscope 1998;108:977–83
19Darrouzet, V, Duclos, JY, Portmann, D, Bebear, JP.Preference for the closed technique in the management of cholesteatoma of the middle ear in children: a retrospective study of 215 consecutive patients treated over 10 years. Am J Otol 2000;21:474–81
20Rondini-Gilli, E, Mosnier, I, Julien, N, Gouin, JM, Aïdan, P, Rufat, P, Sterkers, O.One-stage surgery of middle ear cholesteatoma in adults: apropos of 180 cases. Rev Laryngol Otol Rhinol (Bord) 2001;122:75–9
21Göçmen, H, Kiliç, R, Ozdek, A, Kizilkaya, Z, Safak, MA, Samim, E.Surgical treatment of cholesteatoma in children. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol 2003;67:867–72
22Siddiqui, R.Surgery for otitis media with cholesteatoma: canal up versus canal down procedures. Liaquat J Uni Med Health Sci 2005;44:64–7
23Shirazi, MA, Muzaffar, K, Leonetti, JP, Marzo, S.Surgical treatment of pediatric cholesteatomas. Laryngoscope 2006;116:1603–7
24Tos, M.Modification of combined-approach tympanoplasty in attic cholesteatoma. Arch Otolaryngol 1982;108:772–8
25Lesinskas, E, Vainutiene, V.Closed tympanoplasty in middle ear cholesteatoma surgery. Medicina (Kaunas) 2004;40:856–9
26Sanna, M, Zini, C, Gamoletti, R, Delogu, P, Russo, A, Scandellari, R, Taibah, A.The surgical management of childhood cholesteatoma. J Laryngol Otol 1987;101:1221–6
27Ojala, K, Palva, A.Late results of obliterative cholesteatoma surgery. Arch Otolaryngol 1982;108:13
28Barakate, M, Bottrill, I.Combined approach tympanoplasty for cholesteatoma: impact of middle-ear endoscopy. J Laryngol Otol 2008;122:120–4
29He, Y, Liang, Y, Liu, X, Li, G, Hu, Y.Intact canal wall mastoidectomy and tympanoplasty in treating patients with cholesteatoma of the middle ear and mastoid [in Chinese]. Lin Chung Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi 2008;22:740–1
30Hinohira, Y, Yanagihara, N, Gyo, K.Improvements to staged canal wall up tympanoplasty for middle ear cholesteatoma. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2007;137:913–17
31Ho, SY, Kveton, JF.Efficacy of the 2-staged procedure in the management of cholesteatoma. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2003;129:541–5
32Quaranta, N, Fernandez-Vega Feijoo, S, Piazza, F, Zini, C.Closed tympanoplasty in cholesteatoma surgery: long-term (10 years) hearing results using cartilage ossiculoplasty. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2001;258:20–4
33Mutlu, C, Khashaba, A, Saleh, E, Karmarkar, S, Bhatia, S, DeDonato, G et al. Surgical treatment of cholesteatoma in children. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1995;113:5660
34Schwaber, MK.Intact canal wall mastoidectomy. Am J Otol 1979;1:45–8
35Sun, J, Sun, J, Hu, Y, Lv, Q, Wang, Y, Li, X, et al. Canal wall-down mastoidectomy with mastoid obliteration for pediatric cholesteatoma. Acta Otolaryngol 2010;130:259–62
36Redaelli de Zinis, LO.Titanium vs hydroxyapatite ossiculoplasty in canal wall down mastoidectomy. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2008;134:1283–7
37Ajalloueyan, M.Experience with surgical management of cholesteatomas. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006;132:931–3
38Mukherjee, P, Saunders, N, Liu, R, Fagan, P.Long-term outcome of modified radical mastoidectomy. J Laryngol Otol 2004;118:612–16
39Berrettini, S, Ravecca, F, de Vito, A, Forli, F, Valori, S, Franceschini, SS.Modified Bondy radical mastoidectomy: long-term personal experience. J Laryngol Otol 2004;118:333–7
40Kos, MI, Castrillon, R, Montandon, P, Guyot, JP.Anatomic and functional long-term results of canal wall-down mastoidectomy. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2004;113:872–6
41Ramsey, MJ, Merchant, SN, McKenna, MJ.Postauricular periosteal-pericranial flap for mastoid obliteration and canal wall down tympanomastoidectomy. Otol Neurotol 2004;25:873–8
42Vartiainen, E.Ten-year results of canal wall down mastoidectomy for acquired cholesteatoma. Auris Nasus Larynx 2000;27:227–9
43Castrillon, R, Kos, I, Montandon, P, Guyot, JP.Long-term results of canal wall down mastoidectomy [in French]. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 2000;125:58S61S
44Mills, RP, Padgham, ND.Management of childhood cholesteatoma. J Laryngol Otol 1991;105:343–5
45Kronenberg, J, Shapira, Y, Migirov, L.Mastoidectomy reconstruction of the posterior wall and obliteration (MAPRO): preliminary results. Acta Otolaryngol 2012;132:400–3
46Dornhoffer, JL.Retrograde mastoidectomy. Otolaryngol Clin North Am 2006;39:1115–27
47El Sharkawy, A, Mekbel, K, Emam, H, Abdel Razek, M.The use of cartilage and pedicles perichondrial flap for primary reconstruction of posterior canal wall. EJENTAS 2010;10:75–8
48Zhang, ZG, Liu, X, Chen, SJ, Chen, B, Zheng, YQ.Modification of closed tympanoplasty in middle ear cholesteatoma. Chin Med J (Engl) 2010;123:447–51
49Kang, MK, Ahn, JK, Gu, TW, Han, CS.Epitympanoplasty with mastoid obliteration technique: a long-term study of results. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2009;140:687–91
50Abramovich, S, Hannan, SA, Huins, CT, Georgalas, C, McGuinness, J, Vats, A, Thompson, I.Prospective cohort comparison of bioactive glass implants and conchal cartilage in reconstruction of the posterior canal wall during tympanomastoidectomy. Clin Otolaryngol 2008;33:553–9
51Uzun, C, Yagiz, R, Tas, A, Adali, MK, Koten, M, Karasalihoglu, AR.Combined Heermann and Tos (CHAT) technique in cholesteatoma surgery: surgical technique and preliminary results. J Laryngol Otol 2005;119:429–35
52Ikeda, M, Yoshida, S, Ikui, A, Shigihara, S.Canal wall down tympanoplasty with canal reconstruction for middle-ear cholesteatoma: post-operative hearing, cholesteatoma recurrence, and status of re-aeration of reconstructed middle-ear cavity. J Laryngol Otol 2003;117:249–55
53Paparella, MM, Jung, TT.Intact bridge tympanomastoidectomy (I.B.M.) – combining essential features of open vs closed procedures. J Laryngol Otol 1983;97:579–85
54Hatano, M, Ito, M, Yoshizaki, T.Retrograde mastoidectomy on demand with soft-wall reconstruction in pediatric cholesteatoma. Acta Otolaryngol 2010;130:1113–18
55Haginomori, S, Takamaki, A, Nonaka, R, Takenaka, H.Residual cholesteatoma: incidence and localization in canal wall down tympanoplasty with soft-wall reconstruction. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2008;134:652–7
56Della Santina, CC, Lee, SC.Ceravital reconstruction of canal wall down mastoidectomy: long-term results. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006;132:617–23
57Cho, SW, Cho, YB, Cho, HH.Mastoid obliteration with silicone blocks after canal wall down mastoidectomy. Clin Exp Otorhinolaryngol 2012;5:23–7
58Lee, WS, Kim, SH, Lee, WS, Kim, SH, Moon, IS, Byeon, HK.Canal wall reconstruction and mastoid obliteration in canal wall down tympanomastoidectomized patients. Acta Otolaryngol 2009 Sep;129:955–61
59Takahashi, H, Iwanaga, T, Kaieda, S, Fukuda, T, Kumagami, H, Takasaki, K et al. Mastoid obliteration combined with soft-wall reconstruction of posterior ear canal. Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 2007;264:867–71
60Leonetti, JP, Marzo, SJ, Beauchamp, MM, Jellish, WS.Long-term results with operated sinus tympani retraction cholesteatoma. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2006;135:152–4
61Gantz, BJ, Wilkinson, EP, Hansen, MR.Canal wall reconstruction tympanomastoidectomy with mastoid obliteration. Laryngoscope 2005;115:1734–40
62Lee, WS, Choi, JY, Song, MH, Son, EJ, Jung, SH, Kim, SH.Mastoid and epitympanic obliteration in canal wall up mastoidectomy for prevention of retraction pocket. Otol Neurotol 2005;26:1107–11
63Dornhoffer, JL.Retrograde mastoidectomy with canal wall reconstruction: a single-stage technique for cholesteatoma removal. Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol 2000;109:1033–9
64Tomlin, J, Chang, D, McCutcheon, B, Harris, J.Surgical technique and recurrence in cholesteatoma: a meta-analysis. Audiol Neurootol 2013;18:135–42

Keywords

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Pooled analysis of the evidence for open cavity, combined approach and reconstruction of the mastoid cavity in primary cholesteatoma surgery

  • A T Harris (a1), B Mettias (a1) and T H J Lesser (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.