Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery: fact or fantasy?

  • Mario Sanna (a1), Sandeep Karmarkar (a2) and Mauro Landolfi (a1)

Abstract

This study reviews 57 papers dealing with the issue of hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery published in otolaryngologic and neurosurgical literature between theyears 1977 and 1994. The authors', in this review, have made an attempt to verify whether the claims of hearing preservation are real, whether there is a price to be paid in terms of morbidity and whether there are univocal criteria for reporting results. The review shows that there is a wide disarray in reporting hearing results and the claims of hearing preservation are often unreal and misleading. On retabulating the results of a few series according to the minimal prerequisites for normal hearing (PTA ≤3O dB and SDS ≥70 per cent) and according to other various commonly reported criteria, it became evident that rates of hearing preservation differeda lot depending upon criteria. While any measurable hearing could be preserved in many cases, only a few had normal hearing preserved.

Copyright

Corresponding author

Address for correspondence: Mario Sanna, M. D., Gruppo Otologico, Via Emmanueli 42. 29100 Piacenza, Italy, Fax: 0039 523 453708

Footnotes

Hide All

This work has been supplied by a grant from the Associazione Italiana Neurotologica (A.I.N.O.T.).

Footnotes

References

Hide All
Abramson, M., Stein, B. M., Pedley, T. A., Emerson, R. G., Wazen, J. J. (1985) Intraoperative BAER monitoring and hearing preservation in the treatment of acoustic neuromas. Laryngoscope 95: 13181322.
Atlas, M. A.Harvey, C., Fagan, P. A. (1992) Hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery: a continuing study. Laryngoscope 102: 779783.
Baldwin, D. L., King, T. T., Morrison, A. W. (1990) Hearing conservation in acoustic neuroma surgery via the posterior fossa. The Journal of Laryngology and Otology 104: 463467.
Bauch, C. D., Olsen, W. O., Harner, S. G. (1990) Preoperative and postoperative auditory brainstem response results for patients with eighth nerve tumours. Archives of Otolaryngology 116: 10261029.
Brackmann, D. E., House, J. R. III, Hitselberger, W. E. (1994) Technical modifications to the middle fossa craniotomy approach in removal of acoustic neuromas. The American Journal of Otology 15: 614619.
Charabi, S.Tos, M., Thomsen, J., Borgesen, S. V. (1992) Suboccipital acoustic neuroma surgery: results of decentralized tumor removal in Denmark. Acta Otolaryngologica (Stockholm) 112: 810815.
Chen, T. C., Macen, D. R., Giannotta, S. L., Shih, L., McComb Gordon, J. (1992) Unilateral acoustic neuromas in childhood without evidence of neurofibromatosis: case report and review of the literature. The American Journal of Otology 13: 318322.
Cohen, M. L., Hammerschlag, P.Berg, H., Ransohoff, J. (1986) Acoustic neuroma surgery: an eclectic approach with emphasis on preservation of hearing. Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology 95: 2127.
Cohen, N. L., Lewis, W. S.Ransohoff, J. (1993) Hearing preservation in cerebellopontine angle tumor surgery: the NYU experience. The American Journal of Otology 14: 423433.
Ditullio, M. V., Malkasian, D., Rand, R. W. (1978) A critical comparison of neurosurgical and otolaryngological approaches to acoustic tumours Journal of Neurosurgery 48: 112.
Doyle, K. J., Shelton, C. (1993) Hearing preservation in bilateral acoustic neuroma surgery. The American Journal of Otology 14: 562565.
Fischer, G., Fischer, C., Remond, J. (1992) Hearing preservation in acoustic neurinoma surgery. Journal of Neurosurgery 76: 910917.
Gantz, B. J., Parnes, L. S., Hanker, L. A.. McCabe, B. E (1986) Middle cranial fossa acoustic neuroma excision: results and complications Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngotogy 95: 454459.
Gardner, G., Robertson, J. H. (1988) Hearing preservation in unilateral acoustic neunoma surgery. Annals of Otology, Rhinology and Laryngology 97: 5565.
Glasscock, M. E. III, Hays, J. W., Minor, L. B., Haynes, D. S., Carrasco, V. N. (1993) Preservation of hearing in surgery for acoustic neuromas. Journal of Neurosurgery 78: 864870.
Harker, L. A., McCabe, B. F. (1978) Iowa results of acoustic neuroma operations Laryngoscope 88: 19041911.
Harnen, S. G., Beatty, C. W., Ebersold, M. J. (1990) Retnosigmoid removal of acoustic neuroma: experience 1978–1988. Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery 103: 4045.
Hpen, C. M., Harner, S. G., Slavit, D. H., Litchy, W. J., Daube, J. R., Beatty, C. W., Ebersold, M. J. (1992) Effect of BAEP monitoring on hearing preservation during acoustic neuroma resection. Neurology 42: 15511553.
Hinton, A. E., Ramsden, R. T., Dutton, J. E. (1992) Criteria for hearing preservation in acoustic schwannoma surgery: the concept of useful hearing. The Journal of Laryngology and Otology 106: 500503.
Hoehmann, D. (1991) Pre and post-operative hearing thresholds and brainstem responses in patients with acoustic neuroma: follow-up study using the middle fossa approach. The American Journal of Otology 12: 172178.
Janetta, P. J., Moller, A. R., Mollen, A. B. (1984) Technique of hearing preservation in small acoustic neuromas. Annals of Surgery 200: 513523.
Jenkins, H. A. (1992) Hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery. Laryngoscope 102: 125128.
Kemink, J. L., La Rouere, M. J., Kileny, P. R., Teluan, S. A., Hoff, J. T. (1990) Hearing preservation following suboccipital removal of acoustic neuromas Laryngoscope 100: 597602.
Mangham, C. A., Skalabnin, T. A. (1992) Indications for hearing preservation in acoustic tumor surgery. The American Jourrnal of Otology 13: 137140.
Mazzoni, A., Calabrese, V., Danesi, G., DcNignis, M. (1993) La via sub-occipitale nella chirurgia funzionale del neurinoma dell'VIII nervo cranico. Acta Otorhinolaryngologica italica 13: 311.
McElveen, J. T. Jr, Wilkins, R. H., Erwin, A. C., Wolford, R. D. (1991) Modifying the translabyninthine approach to preserve hearing during acoustic tumour surgery. The Journal of Laryngology and Otology 105: 3437.
McKenna, M. J., Halpin, C., Ojemann, R. G., Nadol, J. B. Jr, Montgomery, W. W., Levine, R. A., Carlisle, E., Mantuza, R.(1992) Long-term hearing results in patients after surgical removal of acoustic tumors with hearing preservation. 0The American Journal of Otology 13: 134136.
Molony, T. B., Kwartler, J. A., House, W. F., Hitselberger, W. E. (1992) Extended middle fossa and retrolabyninthine approaches in acoustic neuroma surgery: case reports. The American Journal of Ototogy 13: 360363.
Nadol, J., Levine, R., Ojemann, R., Martuza, R., Montgomery, W. W., Dc Sandoval, P. K. (1987) Preservation of hearing in surgical removal of acoustic neuromas of the internal auditory canal and cerebellar pontine angle. Laryngoscope 97: 12871294.
Nadol, J. B. Jr, Chiong, C. M., Ojemann, R. G., McKenna, M. J., Martuza, R. L., Montgomery, W. W., Levine, R. A., Ronner, S. FGlynn, R. J. (1992) Preservation of hearing and facial nerve function in resection of acoustic neuroma. Laryngoscope 102: 11531158.
Ogawa, K., Kanzaki, J., O-Uchi, T., Inoue, Y. (1991) Preoperative findings and hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery. Acta Otolaryngologica (Stockholm) Suppl. 487: 3035.
Ojemann, R. G., Levine, R. A., Montgomery, W. M., McGaffigan, P. (1984) Use of intraopenative auditory evoked potentials to preserve hearing in unilateral acoustic neuroma removal. Journal of Neurosurgery 61 938948.
Palva, T., Troupp, H., Jauhiainen, T. (1981) Team surgery foracoustic neurinomas and the preservation of hearing. Acta Otolaryngologica (Stockholm) 91: 3745.
Palva, T., Troupp, H., Jauhiainen, T. (1985) Hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery. Acta Otolaryngologica (Stockholm) 99: 17.
Pifko, P., Pasztor, E. (1981) Operated bilateral acoustic neurinoma with preservation of hearing and facial nerve function. ORL 43: 255261.
Rand, R. W. (1982) Postoperative edema and preservation of hearing in acoustic tumour surgery. In: Neurological surgery of the ear and skull base. (Brackmann, D. E. ed). Raven Press, New York, pp 247256.
Samii, M., Turel, K. E., Penkert, G. (1985) Management of seventh and eighth nerve involvement by cerebellopontine angle tumours Clinical neurosurgery 32: 242271.
Samii, M. (1991) Personal communication.
Sanna, M., Zini, C., Mazzoni, A., Gandolfi, A., Pareschi, R., Pasanisi, E., Gamoletti, R. (1987) Hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery. The American Journal of Otology 8: 500506.
Sanna, M., Gamoletti, R., Tos, M., Thomsen, J. (1991 a) Synopsis on: hearing preservation following acoustic neuroma surgery. In: Acoustic neuroma. (Tos, M., Thomsen, J., eds). Kugler Publications Amsterdam/New York, pp 985987.
Sanna, M., Zini, C., Gamoletti, R., Landolfi, M., Shaan, M., Piazza, E. (1991 b) Hearing preservation: A critical review of literature. In: Acoustic neuroma. (Tos, M., Thomsen, J. eds). Kugler Pub1ications Amsterdam/New York, pp 631638.
Shelton, C., Brackmann, D. E., House, W. E.Hitselberger, W. E. (1989) Middle fossa acoustic tumour surgery: results in 106 cases. Laryngoscope 99: 405408.
Shelton, C., Hitselberger, W. E., House, W. F.Brackmann, D. E. (1990) Hearing preservation after acoustic neuroma removal. Laryngoscope 100: 115119.
Shelton, C., Hitselberger, W. E. (1991) The treatment of small acoustic tumors: Now or later? Laryngoscope 101: 925928.
Silverstein, H., McDaniel, A. B., Norrel, H. (1985) Hearing preservation after acoustic neuroma surgery using inatraoperative direct eighth cranial nerve monitoring. The American Journal of Otology (Suppl.) 99106.
Silverstein, H., McDaniel, A., Norrel, H., Haberkamp, T. (1986) Hearing preservation after acoustic neuroma surgery with intraoperative direct eighth cranial nerve monitoring: Part 2. A classification of results Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery 95: 285290.
Smith, M. F., Clancy, T. P., Lang, J. S. (1977) Conservation of hearing in acoustic neurilemmoma excision. ORL 84: 704709.
Smith, P. G., Bigelow, D. C., Kletzker Robert, G., Leonetti, J. P., Pugh, B. K., Mishler Tracy, E. (1993) Hearing preservation following a transtemporal resection of an acoustic schwannoma: a case report. The American Journal of Otology 14: 434436.
Sterkers, J. M., Sterkers, O.Maudelonde, C.. Corlieu, P. (1984) Preservation of hearing by the retrosigmoid approach in acoustic neuroma surgery. Advances in Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 34: 187192.
Sterkers, J. M., Morrison, G. A., Sterkers, O., Badr El-Dine, M. M. (1994) Preservation of facial. cochlear, and other nerve functions in acoustic neuroma treatment. Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery 110: 146155.
Tatagiba, M., Samii, M., Matthies, M., Azm, M. E., Schonmayr, R. (1992) The significance for post-operative hearing of preserving the labyrinth in acoustic neurinoma surgery. Journal of Neurosurgery 77: 677684.
Tator, C. H., Nedzelski, J. M. (1985) Preservation of hearing in patients undergoing excision of acoustic neuromas and other cerebellopontine angle tumours Journal of Neurosurgery 63: 168174.
Tucci, D. L., Telian, S. A., Kileny, P. R.. Hoff, J. T.Kemink, J. L. (1994) Stability of hearing preservation following acoustic neuroma surgery. The American Journal of Otology 15: 183188.
Umezu, H., Aiba, T. (1994) Preservation of hearing after surgery for acoustic schwannomas:correlation between cochlear nerve function and operative findings Journal of Neurosurgery 80: 844848.
Wade, P. J., House, W. F. (1984) Hearing preservation in patients with acoustic neuromas via the middle fossa approach. Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery 92: 184193.
Wanxing, C. (1981) Preservation of facial and acoustic nerves in the total removal of large and small acoustic tumours Journal of Neurosurgery 54: 268272.
Wigand, M. E., Haid, T., Berg, M., Schuster, B., Goertzen, W. (1991) The extended middle cranial fossa approach for acoustic tumour. Skull Base Surgery 1: 183187.

Keywords

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery: fact or fantasy?

  • Mario Sanna (a1), Sandeep Karmarkar (a2) and Mauro Landolfi (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.