Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Empedocles' Account of Breathing

  • N. B. Booth (a1)

Extract

Empedocles' Fragment 100 contains an account of ‘the way that all things breathe in and out’. It may conveniently be divided into three sections:

A. Lines 1–5, the apparatus of breathing.

B. Lines 6–8, the manner in which breathing takes place.

C. Lines 8–25, an illustration taken from the working of the klepsydra.

I shall discuss the fragment under thesethree headings.

A. The Apparatus of Breathing

These lines (1–5) are translated as follows by Diels-Kranz: ‘Also aber atmet alles ein und aus: Allen sind blutarme Fleischröhren über die Oberfläche des Körpers hin gespannt, und an ihren Mündungen ist mit vielen Ritzen durchweg durchbohrt der Haut äusserste Oberfläche, so dass zwar das Blut drinnen geborgen bleibt, der Luft aber freier Zutritt durch die Öffnungen gebahnt ist.’ Thus the picture which Diels gives us is of tubes running out to the skin all over the body, and at the ends of the tubes perforated flaps of skin which will allow the passage of air but not of blood. The tubes are, furthermore, only partly filled with blood.

This line of interpretation has been followed by most scholars since, and it appears to derive some reinforcement from Aristotle, who in his comment on the passage at de respiratione 7, p. 473, b 1 ff., says: ‘They have passages through to the outer air.’ The ‘outer air’ would appear to mean the outer air outside the body, and we might therefore be tempted to suppose that Aristotle meant to say that these tubes ended up at the surface of the skin.

Copyright

References

Hide All

1 The most recent example is Furley, D. J. in JHS lxxvii 1 (1957) 31–4. See also Burnet, J., Early Greek Philosophy (4th ed.) 219–20; Zafiropulo, , Empedocle D'Agrigente 142 n. 561, 158; Bignone, E., Empedocle 581, 621 n. 5. A notable exception is Traglia, Antonio, Studi sulla Lingua di Empedocle (Bari, n.d.) 25 n. 43, to which Mr Furley refers.

2 See ProfLast, in CQ. xviii (1924) 169–73; Regenbogen, O., ‘Eine Forschungsmethode antiken Naturwissenschaft’, Quell, u. Stud. z. Gesch. d. Mathematik i 180 ff.; Guthrie, W. K. C., Aristotle on the Heavens (Loeb) 228; D. J. Furley, loc. cit.

3 A major point at issue in this matter is the validity of Aristotle's evidence about the early philosophers. On this general subject, see Guthrie, W. K. C. in JHS lxxvii 1 (1957) 3541; for a particular application, see my article on Zeno, in JHS lxxvii 2 (1957) 187201.

I am indebted to Mr D. J. Furley for some generous help in private discussion.

I have only just seen, at the moment of going to press, Cardini, Maria Timpanaro's ‘Respirazione e Clessidra’, La Parola del Passato xii (1957) 250–70. This writer and I, working independently, have reached very much the same conclusions about the meaning of this fragment.

Empedocles' Account of Breathing

  • N. B. Booth (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed