Skip to main content Accessibility help

Ovarian activity in Fleckvieh, Brown Swiss and two strains of Holstein-Friesian cows in pasture-based, seasonal calving dairy systems

  • Valérie Piccand (a1), Susanne Meier (a2), Erwan Cutullic (a1), Sara Weilenmann (a3), Peter Thomet (a1), Fredy Schori (a4), Chris R Burke (a2), Daniel Weiss (a5), John R Roche (a2) and Peter L Kunz (a1)...


The objectives of the study were to compare the ovarian activity of Holstein-Friesian (CH HF), Fleckvieh (CH FV) and Brown Swiss (CH BS) dairy cows of Swiss origin with that of Holstein-Friesian (NZ HF) dairy cows of New Zealand origin, the latter being used as a reference for reproductive performance in pasture-based seasonal calving systems. Fifty, second-lactation NZ HF cows were each paired with a second-lactation Swiss cow (17, 15 and 18 CH HF, CH FV and CH BS respectively) in 13 pasture-based, seasonal-calving commercial dairy farms in Switzerland. Ovarian activity was monitored by progesterone profiling from calving to first breeding service. CH BS cows produced less energy-corrected milk (mean 22·8 kg/d) than the other breeds (26·0–26·5 kg/d) during the first 100 d of lactation. CH HF cows had the lowest body condition score (BCS) at calving and the greatest BCS loss from calving to 30 d post partum. Commencement of luteal activity (CLA) was later for NZ HF than for CH FV (51·5 v. 29·2 d; P <0·01), with CH HF and CH BS intermediate (43 d). On average, NZ HF and CH HF cows had one oestrous cycle before the onset of the seasonal breeding period; this was less (P<0·01) than either CH FV (1·7) or CH BS (1·6). There was a low prevalence of luteal persistency (3%) among the studied cows. First and second oestrous cycle inter-ovulatory intervals did not differ between breeds (20·5–22·6 d). The luteal phase length of CH BS during the second cycle was shorter (10·6 d) than that of the other breeds (13·8–16·0 d), but the inter-luteal interval was longer (9·8 d v. 7·0–8·0 d). The results suggest that the Swiss breeds investigated have a shorter interval from calving to CLA than NZ HF cows.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Bates, D & Maechler, M 2010 lme4: Linear mixed-effects models using S4 classes R package version 0.999375–35
Blättler, T, Durgai, B, Kohler, S, Kunz, P, Leuenberger, S, Müller, R, Schäublin, H, Spring, P, Stähli, R, Thomet, P, Wanner, K, Weber, A & Menzi, A 2004 [Opti-Milk Project: Objectives and Basic Information.] Agrarforschung 11 8085
Bleach, ECL, Glencross, RG & Knight, PG 2004 Association between ovarian follicle development and pregnancy rates in dairy cows undergoing spontaneous oestrous cycles. Reproduction 127 621629
Böbner, C 1994 [Estimation of economic weighting for secondary production trait by Swiss dual purpose cows with the use of dynamic optimisation.] PhD Thesis, ETHZ, Switzerland
Butler, WR, Everett, R & Coppock, CE 1981 The relationships between energy balance, milk production and ovulation in post-partum Holstein cows. Journal of Animal Science 53 742748
Burke, CR, Kay, JK, Phyn, CVC, Meier, S, Lee, JM & Roche, JR 2010 Short communication: Effects of dietary nonstructural carbohydrates pre- and postpartum on reproduction of grazing dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 93 42924296
Burke, CR & Roche, JR 2007 Effects of pasture feeding during the periparturient period on postpartum anovulation in grazed dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 90 43044312
Chagas, LM, Gore, P, Sheahan, JA, Lee, JM, Watkins, PW, Aspin, PW & Roche, JR 2006 Diet or strain: effects on postpartum anovulatory interval in dairy cows. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 66 339343
Cutullic, E 2010 Competition between lactation and reproduction in the dairy cow PhD Thesis, University Caen Basse-Normandie, France
Cutullic, E, Delaby, L, Gallard, Y & Disenhaus, C 2011 Dairy cows reproductive response to feeding level differs according to the reproductive stage and the breed. Animal 5 731740
Edmonson, AJ, Lean, IJ, Weaver, LD, Farver, T & Webster, G 1989 A body condition scoring chart for Holstein dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 72 6878
Flückiger, N 1990 100 [100 years of the Swiss Red and White dairy cow Breeding Federation.] In: Fédération suisse d'élevage de la race tachetée rouge, Zollikofen
Friggens, NC, Disenhaus, C & Petit, HV 2010 Nutritional sub-fertility in the dairy cow: towards improved reproductive management through a better biological understanding. Animal 4 11971213
Fulkerson, WJ, Davison, TM, Garcia, SC, Hough, G, Goddard, ME, Dobos, R & Blockey, M 2008 Holstein-Friesian dairy cows under a predominantly grazing system: Interaction between genotype and environment. Journal of Dairy Science 91 826839
Gong, JG, Lee, WJ, Garnsworthy, PC & Webb, R 2002 Effect of dietary-induced increases in circulating insulin concentrations during the early postpartum period on reproductive function in dairy cows. Reproduction 123 419427
Hagger, C 2005 Estimates of genetic diversity in the brown cattle population of Switzerland obtained from pedigree information. Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics 122 405413
Holmes, CW, Brookes, IM, Garrick, DJ, Mackenzie, DDS, Parkinson, TJ & Wilson, GF 2007 Milk Production from Pasture. Principles and Practices. Massey University, Palmerston North, New Zealand
Horan, B, Mee, JF, O'Connor, P, Rath, M & Dillon, P 2005 The effect of strain of Holstein-Friesian cow and feeding system on postpartum ovarian function, animal production and conception rate to first service. Theriogenology 63 950971
Jeanneret, F & Vautier, P 1977 [Mapping of the climatic suitability for agriculture in Switzerland.] Geographisches Institut der Universität Bern, Bern, Switzerland
Kolver, ES, Roche, JR, Veth, MJ de, Thorne, PL & Napper, AR 2002 Total mixed rations versus pasture diets: Evidence for a genotype×diet interaction in dairy cow performance. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 62 246251
Macdonald, KA, Verkerk, GA, Thorrold, BS, Pryce, JE, Penno, JW, McNaughton, LR, Burton, LJ, Lancaster, JAS, Williamson, JH & Holmes, CW 2008 A comparison of three strains of Holstein-Friesian grazed on pasture and managed under different feed allowances. Journal of Dairy Science 91 16931707
Macmillan, KL 2002 Advances in bovine theriogenology in New Zealand. 1. Pregnancy, parturition and the postpartum period. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 50 6773
McNaughton, LR, Sanders, KM, Pryce, JE, Bracefield, GE, Harcourt, SJ & Spelman, RJ 2007 Phenotypic relationships between the interval from calving to first luteal activity and fertility in a seasonal dairy production system. Animal Reproduction Science 102 98110
McNaughton, LR, Verkerk, GA, Parkinson, TJ, Macdonald, KA & Holmes, CW 2003 Postpartum anoestrous intervals and reproductive performance of three genotypes of Holstein-Friesian dairy cattle managed in a seasonal pasture-based dairy system. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 63 7781
Meier, S, Roche, JR, Kolver, ES, Verkerk, GA & Boston, RC 2009 Comparing subpopulations of plasma progesterone using cluster analyses. Journal of Dairy Science 92 14601468
Meyer, HHD, Gueven, B & Karg, H 1986 [Enzyme-immuno assay (EIA) on microtitration plate for progesterone determination in skim milk.] Wiener Tierärztliche Monatsschrift 73 8692
Petersson, K, Gustafsson, H, Strandberg, E & Berglund, B 2006 Atypical progesterone profiles and fertility in Swedish dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 89 25292538
Piccand, V, Cutullic, E, Schori, F, Weilenmann, S & Thomet, P 2011 [Which cow for pasture-based production systems? Production, reproduction and health.] Recherche Agronomique Suisse 2 252257
Pollott, GE & Coffey, MP 2008 The effect of genetic merit and production system on dairy cow fertility, measured using progesterone profiles and on-farm recording. Journal of Dairy Science 91 36493660
R Development Core Team 2009 R: A language and environment for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria
Roche, JR, Friggens, NC, Kay, JK, Fisher, MW, Stafford, KJ & Berry, DP 2009 Invited review: Body condition score and its association with dairy cow productivity, health, and welfare. Journal of Dairy Science 92 57695801
Royal, MD, Darwash, AO, Flint, AP, Webb, R, Woolliams, JA & Lamming, GE 2000 Declining fertility in dairy cattle: changes in traditional and endocrine parameters of fertility. Animal Science 70 487501
Royal, MD, Flint, APF & Woolliams, JA 2002 Genetic and phenotypic relationships among endocrine and traditional fertility traits and production traits in Holstein-Friesian dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 85 958967
Veerkamp, RF, Oldenbroek, JK, van der Gaast, HJ & van der Werf, JHJ 2000 Genetic correlation between days until start of luteal activity and milk yield, energy balance, and live weights. Journal of Dairy Science 83 577583
Verkerk, GA, Morgan, SR & Kolver, ES 2000 Comparison of selected reproductive characteristics in Overseas and New Zealand Holstein-Friesian cows grazing pasture or fed a total mixed ration. Proceedings of the New Zealand Society of Animal Production 60 270274
Wegmann, S, Chavaz, J, Hitz, M, Roulin, A & Savary, D 1999 100 Years in black and white. Holstein Association of Switzerland, Posieux, Switzerland
Weiss, D, Reist, M & Bruckmaier, RM 2004 The acyclic period postpartum in automatic and conventional milking. Journal of Veterinary Medicine 268272
Yenikoyé, A, Mariana, JC, Ley, JP, Jolivet, E, Terqui, M & Lemon-Resplandy, M 1981 [A mathematical model of the cow progesterone pattern : application and proof of breed differences.] Reproduction Nutrition Development 21 561575


Ovarian activity in Fleckvieh, Brown Swiss and two strains of Holstein-Friesian cows in pasture-based, seasonal calving dairy systems

  • Valérie Piccand (a1), Susanne Meier (a2), Erwan Cutullic (a1), Sara Weilenmann (a3), Peter Thomet (a1), Fredy Schori (a4), Chris R Burke (a2), Daniel Weiss (a5), John R Roche (a2) and Peter L Kunz (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed