Skip to main content Accessibility help

Milking efficiency of swingover herringbone parlours in pasture-based dairy systems

  • J Paul Edwards (a1) (a2), Bernadette O'Brien (a3), Nicolas Lopez-Villalobos (a2) and Jenny G Jago (a1)


The objective of this study was to collect and analyse milking data from a sample of commercial farms with swingover herringbone parlours to evaluate milking efficiency over a range of parlour sizes (12–32 milking units). Data were collected from 19 farms around the Republic of Ireland equipped with electronic milk metres and herd management software that recorded data at individual milking sessions. The herd management software on each farm was programmed to record similar data for each milking plant type. Variables recorded included cow identification, milking date, identification time, cluster-attachment time, cluster/unit number, milk yield, milking duration, and average milk flow rate. Calculations were performed to identify efficiency benchmarks such as cow throughput (cows milked per h), milk harvesting efficiency (kg of milk harvested per h) and operator efficiency (cows milked per operator per h). Additionally, the work routine was investigated and used to explain differences in the benchmark values. Data were analysed using a linear mixed model that included the fixed effects of season-session (e.g. spring-AM), parlour size and their interaction, and the random effect of farm. Additionally, a mathematical model was developed to illustrate the potential efficiency gains that could be achieved by implementing a maximum milking time (i.e. removing the clusters at a pre-set time regardless of whether the cow had finished milking or not). Cow throughput and milk harvesting efficiency increased with increasing parlour size (12 to 32 units), with throughput ranging from 42 to 129 cows/h and milk harvesting efficiency from 497 to 1430 kg/h (1–2 operators). Greater throughput in larger parlours was associated with a decrease in operator idle time. Operator efficiency was variable across farms and probably dependent on milking routines in use. Both of these require consideration when sizing parlours so high levels of operator efficiency as well as cow throughput can be achieved simultaneously. The mathematical model indicated that application of a maximum milking time within the milking process could improve cow throughput (66% increase in an 18-unit parlour when truncating the milking time of 20% of cows). This could allow current herd milking durations to be maintained as herd size increases.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Clarke, T, Cuthbertson, EM, Greenall, RK, Hannah, MC, Jongman, E & Shoesmith, D 2004 Milking regimes to shorten milking duration. Journal of Dairy Research 71 419426. doi: 10.1017/s0022029904000421
Clarke, T, Cuthbertson, EM, Greenall, RK, Hannah, MC & Shoesmith, D 2008 Incomplete milking has no detectable effect on somatic cell count but increased cell count appears to increase strip yield. Australian Journal of Experimental Agriculture 48 11611167. doi: 10.1071/EA07259
Cuthbert, S 2008 DairyNZ Milking Practices and Technology use Survey. Hamilton, New Zealand: LIC
DairyNZ & LIC 2011 New Zealand dairy statistics 2010–11.
DairyNZ MilkSmart 2013a Applying MaxT info sheet.
Edwards, JP, Lopez-Villalobos, N & Jago, JG 2012 Increasing platform speed and the percentage of cows completing a second rotation improves throughput in rotary dairies. Animal Production Science 52 969973. doi: 10.1071/AN12071
Edwards, JP, Jago, JG & Lopez-Villalobos, N 2013a Large rotary dairies achieve high cow throughput but are not more labour efficient than medium sized rotaries. Animal Production Science 53 573579. doi: 10.1071/AN12312
Edwards, JP, Jago, JG & Lopez-Villalobos, N 2013b Milking efficiency can be improved by increasing automatic cluster remover thresholds to grazing dairy cows without applying pre-milking stimulation. Journal of Dairy Science 96 37663773. doi: 10.3168/jds.2012-6394
Edwards, JP, O'Brien, B, Lopez-Villalobos, N & Jago, JG 2013c Overmilking causes deterioration in teat-end condition of dairy cows in late lactation. Journal of Dairy Research 80 344348
Edwards, JP, Jago, JG & Lopez-Villalobos, N 2013d Short-term application of pre-stimulation and increased automatic cluster remover threshold affect milking characteristics of grazing dairy cows in late lactation. Journal of Dairy Science 96 18861893. doi: 10.3168/jds.2012-6191
EU 2004 Annex III, Section IX, Chapter I, Part II, Subpart B, Point 1(b) of Regulation (EC) No 853/2004. Official Journal of the European Commission L 226 2282
Gleeson, DE, O'Callaghan, EJ & Rath, MV 2003 The effects of genotype, milking time and teat-end vacuum pattern on the severity of teat-end hyperkeratosis. Irish Journal of Agricultural and Food Research 42 195203
ICBF 2011 ICBF Dairy Cattle Statistics. Bandon, Co. Cork: Irish Cattle Breeding Federation Society Limited
Jago, JG, Burke, JK & Williamson, JH 2010a Effect of automatic cluster remover settings on production, udder health, and milking duration. Journal of Dairy Science 93 25412549. doi: 10.3168/jds.2009-2949
Jago, JG, McGowan, JE & Williamson, JH 2010b Effect of setting a maximum milking time, from peak lactation, on production, milking time and udder health. New Zealand Veterinary Journal 58 246252. doi: 10.1080/00480169.2010.69298
Kelly, PT 2009 A study of the somatic cell count (SCC) of Irish milk from herd management and environmental perspectives. PhD Thesis. Dublin, Ireland: National University of Ireland
Neijenhuis, F, Barkema, HW, Hogeveen, H & Noordhuizen, J 2001 Relationship between teat-end callosity and occurrence of clinical mastitis. Journal of Dairy Science 84 26642672. doi: 10.3168/jds.S0022-0302(01)74720-0
O'Brien, B, Jago, JG, Edwards, JP, Lopez-Villalobos, N & McCoy, F 2012 Milking parlour size, pre-milking routine and stage of lactation affect efficiency of milking in single-operator herringbone parlours. Journal of Dairy Research 79 216223. doi: 10.1017/S0022029912000088
O'Donnell, S, Horan, B, Butler, AM & Shalloo, L 2011 A survey of the factors affecting the future intentions of Irish dairy farmers. Journal of Agricultural Science 149 647654. doi: 10.1017/S0021859611000037
O'Donovan, K, O'Brien, B, Ruane, DJ, Kinsella, J & Gleeson, D 2008 Labour input on Irish dairy farms and the effect of scale and seasonality. Journal of Farm Management 13 327342
Taylor, G, van der Sande, L & Douglas, R 2009 Smarter not Harder: Improving Labour Productivity in the Primary Sector. Hamilton, New Zealand: DairyNZ
Thiel, CC & Dodd, FH 1979 Machine Milking. Technical Bulletin No. 1. Reading, England: NIRD


Milking efficiency of swingover herringbone parlours in pasture-based dairy systems

  • J Paul Edwards (a1) (a2), Bernadette O'Brien (a3), Nicolas Lopez-Villalobos (a2) and Jenny G Jago (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed