Skip to main content Accessibility help

Effect of CSN1S1 genotype and its interaction with diet energy level on milk production and quality in Girgentana goats fed ad libitum

  • Renato Italo Pagano (a1), Pietro Pennisi (a1), Bernardo Valenti (a2), Massimiliano Lanza (a1), Adriana Di Trana (a3), Paola Di Gregorio (a3), Anna De Angelis (a1) and Marcella Avondo (a1)...


A study was carried out to evaluate how the energy level of the diet can affect milk production and quality in Girgentana lactating goats in relation to polymorphism at the αs1-casein (CSN1S1) genotype locus. Twenty-seven goats, homogeneous for milk production (1·5±0·3 kg/d), days of lactation (90±10 d) and body weight (35·8±5·5 kg) were selected on the basis of their CSN1S1 genotype, as follows: nine goats homozygous for strong (AA) alleles, nine goats homozygous for weak alleles (FF) and nine goats heterozygous (AF). The goats were used in a 3×3 factorial arrangement of treatments, with three genotypes (AA, FF, AF) and three diets at different energy levels (100%, 65% and 30% of hay inclusion). The experiment consisted of three simultaneous 3×3 Latin squares for the three genotypes, with one square for each level of hay inclusion in the diet. All the animals were housed in individual pens. Each experimental period lasted 23 d and consisted of 15 d for adaptation and 8 d for data and sample collection, during which the goats received the scheduled diet ad libitum. The animals were fed three different diets designed to have the same crude protein content (about 15%) but different energy levels: a pelleted alfalfa hay (H100) and two feeds including 65% (H65) and 30% (H30) of alfalfa hay (respectively 1099, 1386 and 1590 kcal NE for lactation/kg DM). All the diets were ground and pelleted (6 mm diameter). AA goats were more productive than AF and FF goats (respectively: 1419 v. 1145 and 1014 g/d; P=0·002). Indeed the interaction energy level×genotype was significant (P=0·018): in fact AA goats showed their milk increase only when fed with concentrates. Differences in protein and in casein levels between the three genotypes were in line with results expected from the different allele contribution to αs1-casein synthesis. Milk urea levels were significantly lower in AA goats compared with AF and FF genotypes (respectively 32·7 v. 40·4 and 40·4 mg/dl; P=0·049) and significantly lower when goats were fed with 65H and 30H diets than with 100H diet (respectively 37·4 and 34·3 v. 41·7 mg/dl; P<0·001). Indeed, a significant interaction genotype×diet (P=0·043) occurred for milk urea, which was significantly lower in AA goats but only when fed with concentrates (65H and 30H). Blood concentrations of energy indicators (glucose, non-esterified fatty acids and beta-hydroxybutyric acid) were not influenced by genotype. The results confirm that strong alleles are associated with a greater efficiency of feed utilization and seem to show that a high energy level of the diet can further improve this efficiency.


Corresponding author

*For correspondence; e-mail:


Hide All
Association of Official Analytical Chemists 1990 Official Methods of Analysis 15th Edn. Arlington VA, USA: AOAC
Auldist, MJ, Thomson, NA, Mackle, TR, Hill, JP & Prosser, CG 2000 Effects of pasture allowance on the yield and composition of milk from cows of different beta-lactoglobulin phenotypes. Journal of Dairy Science 83 20692074
Avondo, M, Bonanno, A, Pagano, RI, Valenti, B, Di Grigoli, A, Alicata, ML, Galofaro, V & Pennisi, P 2008 Milk quality as affected by grazing time of day in Mediterranean goats. Journal of Dairy Research 75 4854
Avondo, M, Pagano, RI, Guastella, AM, Criscione, A, Di Gloria, M, Valenti, B, Piccione, G & Pennisi, P 2009 Diet selection and milk production and composition in Girgentana goats with different αs1-casein genotype. Journal of Dairy Research 76 202209
Bonanno, A, Finocchiaro, R, Di Grigoli, A, Sardina, MT, Tornambè, D & Gigli, I 2007 Energy intake effects at pasture on milk production and coagulation properties in Girgentana goats with different as1-casein genotypes. Proceedings Symposium of the International Goat Association (IGA) The quality of goats products, CRA-Uze, Bella (PZ), Italy, p. 70
Bowling, AT, Stott, ML & Bickel, L 1993 Silent blood chimerism in a mare confirmed by DNA marker analysis of hair bulbs. Animal Genetics 24 323324
Broderick, GA 2003 Effects of varying dietary protein and energy levels on the production of lactating dairy cows. Journal of Dairy Science 86 13701381
Caravaca, F, Carrizosa, J, Urrutia, B, Baena, F, Jordana, J, Amills, M, Badaoui, B, Sanchez, A, Angiolillo, A & Serradilla, JM 2009 Short communication: Effect of αs1-casein (CSN1S1) and k-casein (CSN3) genotypes on milk composition in Murciano-Granadina goats. Journal of Dairy Science 92 29602964
Chilliard, Y, Rouel, J & Leroux, C 2006 Goats alpha-s1-casein genotype influences its milk fatty acid composition and delta-9 desaturation ratios. Animal Feed Science and Technology 131 474487
Cosenza, G, Illario, R, Rando, A, Di Gregorio, P, Masina, P & Ramunno, L 2003 Molecular characterization of the goat CSN1S1(01) allele. Journal of Dairy Research 70 237240
De la Torre, G, Serradilla, JM, Gil Extremera, F & Sanz Sampelayo, MR 2008 Nutritional utilization in Malagueña dairy goats differing in genotypes for the content of αs1-casein in milk. Journal of Dairy Science 91 24432448
De la Torre, G, Ramos Morales, E, Serradilla, JM, Gil Extremera, F & Sanz Sampelayo, MR 2009 Milk production and composition in Malagueña dairy goats. Effect of genotype for synthesis of αs1-casein on milk production and its interaction with dietary protein content. Journal of Dairy Research 76 137143
Deriaz, RE 1961 Routine analysis of carbohydrates and lignin in herbage. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 12 152160
Di Trana, A, Celi, R, Fedele, V & Cogliandro, E 1994 [Effect of different feeding systems on metabolic profile of lactating goats]. In: [Improvement of Productive Efficiency in Sheep and Goats] (Ed. Rubino, R) pp. 3.13.11. Bella (PZ), Italy: ISZ
Dunshea, FR & Bell, AW 1989 Relations between plasma non-esterified fatty acid metabolism and body fat mobilization in primiparous lactating goats. British Journal of Nutrition 62 5161
Forbes, JM 1995 Voluntary Food Intake and Diet Selection in Farm Animals. Wallingford, UK: CAB International
Grosclaude, F, Ricordeau, G, Martin, P, Remeuf, F, Vassal, L & Bouillon, J 1994 From gene to cheese: caprine alpha s1 casein polymorphism, its effects and its evolution. INRA Productions Animales 7 3–19
Havrevoll, Ø, Rajbhandari, SP, Eik, LO & Nedkvitne, JJ 1995 Effects of different energy levels during indoor rearing on performance of Norwegian dairy goats. Small Ruminant Research 15 231237
International Dairy Federation 1964 Determination of the casein content of milk. FIL-IDF Standard No. 29, Brussels, Belgium
Jansà, Pérez M, Leroux, C, Sànchez, Bonastre A & Martin, P 1994 Occurrence of a LINE sequence in the 3'UTR of the goat as1-casein E-encoding allele associated with a reduced protein synthesis level. Gene 147 179187
Kaneko, JJ, Harvey, JW & Bruss, ML 1997 Clinical Biochemistry of Domestic Animals. New York, USA: Academic Press
Koenig, KM, Beauchemin, KA & Rode, LM 2003 Effect of grain processing and silage on microbial protein synthesis and nutrient digestibility in beef cattle fed barley-based diets. Journal of Animal Science 81 10571067
Mackle, TR, Bryant, AM, Petch, SF, Hill, JP & Auldist, MJ 1999 Nutritional influences on the composition of milk from cows of different protein phenotypes in New Zealand. Journal of Dairy Science 82 172180
Mahé, MF, Manfredi, E, Ricordeau, G, Piacère, A & Grosclaude, F 1993 Effects of the αs1-casein polymorphism on goat dairy performance: a within-sire analysis of alpine bucks. Genetics Selection Evolution 26 151157
Marletta, D, Criscione, A, Bordonaro, S, Guastella, AM & D'Urso, G 2007 Casein polymorphism in goat milk. Le Lait 87 491504
Martin, P, Ollivier-Bousquet, M & Grosclaude, F 1999 Genetic polymorphism of caseins: a tool to investigate casein micelle organization. International Dairy Journal 9 163171
McNamara, JP 1991 Regulation of adipose tissue metabolism in support of lactation. Journal of Dairy Science 74 706719
Morand-Fehr, P & Sauvant, D 1988 Feeding goats. In: Feeding of Cattle, Sheep and Goats (Ed. Jarrige, R) pp. 281304. Paris, France: INRA
Morand-Fehr, P, Sanz Sampelayo, MR, Fedele, V, Le Frileux, Y, Eknaes, M, Schmidely, Ph, Giger-Reverdin, S, Bas, P, Rubino, R, Havrevall, Ø & Sauvant, D 2000 Effect of feeding on the quality of goat milk and cheese. Pages 5365 in Proceedings of 7 International Conference on Goats Vol. 1. Tours, France: International Goat Association
Ollier, S, Robert-Granie, C, Bernard, L, Chilliard, Y & Leroux, C 2007 Mammary transcriptome analysis of food-deprived lactating goats highlights genes involved in milk secretion and programmed cell death. Journal of Nutrition 137 560567
Petit, HV & Tremblay, GF 1995 Ruminal fermentation and digestion in lactating cows fed grass silage with protein and energy supplements. Journal of Dairy Science 78 342352
Ramunno, L, Mariani, P, Pappalardo, M, Rando, A, Capuano, M, Di Gregorio, P & Cosenza, G 1995 [A major gene on the β-casein content of goat milk]. In: Proceedings of the XI Congress of Animal Science and Production Association (ASPA), Grado, Italy: ASPA pp. 185186
Ramunno, L, Cosenza, G, Pappalardo, M, Pastore, N, Gallo, D, Di Gregorio, P & Masina, P 2000 Identification of the goat CSN1S1 F allele by means of PCR-RFLP method. Animal Genetics 31 333346
Ramunno, L, Cosenza, G, Pappalardo, M, Longobardi, E, Gallo, D, Pastore, N, Di Gregorio, P & Rando, A 2001 Characterization of two new alleles at the goat CSN1S2 locus. Animal Genetics 32 264268
Ramunno, L, Cosenza, G, Gallo, D, Illario, R, Rando, A & Masina, P 2002 [A new allele at the goat CSN1S1 locus, CSN1S1 N]. In Proceedings. XV Congress SIPAOC, Cagliari, Italy: SIPAOC, p. 220
Sacchi, P, Chessa, S, Budelli, E, Bolla, P, Cerotti, G, Soglia, D, Rasero, R, Cauvin, E & Caroli, A 2005 Casein haplotypes in five Italian goat breeds. Journal of Dairy Science 88 15611568
Santucci, PM & Maestrini, O 1985 Body condition of dairy goats in extensive systems of production: method of estimation. Annales de Zootechnie 34 471490
Schmidely, Ph, Meschy, F, Tessier, J & Sauvant, D 2002 Lactation response and nitrogen, calcium, and phosphorus utilization of dairy goats differing by the genotype for αs1-casein in milk, and feed diets varying in crude protein concentration. Journal of Dairy Science 85 22992307
Sloan, BK & Rowlinson, P 1987 A note on concentrate energy source for dairy cows in mid lactation. Animal Production 45 321323
Van Soest, PJ, Robertson, JB & Lewis, BA 1991 Methods for dietary fiber, neutral detergent fiber and non-starch polysaccharides in relation to animal nutrition. Journal of Dairy Science 74 35833597


Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Effect of CSN1S1 genotype and its interaction with diet energy level on milk production and quality in Girgentana goats fed ad libitum

  • Renato Italo Pagano (a1), Pietro Pennisi (a1), Bernardo Valenti (a2), Massimiliano Lanza (a1), Adriana Di Trana (a3), Paola Di Gregorio (a3), Anna De Angelis (a1) and Marcella Avondo (a1)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.