Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Comparing the performance of 11 crop simulation models in predicting yield response to nitrogen fertilization

  • T. J. SALO (a1), T. PALOSUO (a2), K. C. KERSEBAUM (a3), C. NENDEL (a3), C. ANGULO (a4), F. EWERT (a4), M. BINDI (a5), P. CALANCA (a6), T. KLEIN (a6), M. MORIONDO (a7), R. FERRISE (a5), J. E. OLESEN (a8), R. H. PATIL (a8) (a9), F. RUGET (a10), J. TAKÁČ (a11), P. HLAVINKA (a12) (a13), M. TRNKA (a12) (a13) and R. P. RÖTTER (a2)...

Summary

Eleven widely used crop simulation models (APSIM, CERES, CROPSYST, COUP, DAISY, EPIC, FASSET, HERMES, MONICA, STICS and WOFOST) were tested using spring barley (Hordeum vulgare L.) data set under varying nitrogen (N) fertilizer rates from three experimental years in the boreal climate of Jokioinen, Finland. This is the largest standardized crop model inter-comparison under different levels of N supply to date. The models were calibrated using data from 2002 and 2008, of which 2008 included six N rates ranging from 0 to 150 kg N/ha. Calibration data consisted of weather, soil, phenology, leaf area index (LAI) and yield observations. The models were then tested against new data for 2009 and their performance was assessed and compared with both the two calibration years and the test year. For the calibration period, root mean square error between measurements and simulated grain dry matter yields ranged from 170 to 870 kg/ha. During the test year 2009, most models failed to accurately reproduce the observed low yield without N fertilizer as well as the steep yield response to N applications. The multi-model predictions were closer to observations than most single-model predictions, but multi-model mean could not correct systematic errors in model simulations. Variation in soil N mineralization and LAI development due to differences in weather not captured by the models most likely was the main reason for their unsatisfactory performance. This suggests the need for model improvement in soil N mineralization as a function of soil temperature and moisture. Furthermore, specific weather event impacts such as low temperatures after emergence in 2009, tending to enhance tillering, and a high precipitation event just before harvest in 2008, causing possible yield penalties, were not captured by any of the models compared in the current study.

Copyright

Corresponding author

* To whom all correspondence should be addressed. Email: tapio.salo@luke.fi

References

Hide All
Abrahamsen, P. & Hansen, S. (2000). Daisy: an open soil-crop-atmosphere system model. Environmental Modelling & Software 15, 313330.
Addiscott, T. M. & Whitmore, A. P. (1991). Simulation of solute leaching in soils of differing permeabilities. Soil Use and Management 7, 94102.
Anwar, M. R., O'Leary, G. J., Rab, M. A., Fisher, P. D. & Armstrong, R. D. (2009). Advances in precision agriculture in south-eastern Australia. V. management zones. Crop and Pasture Science 60, 901911.
Asseng, S., Ewert, F., Rosenzweig, C., Jones, J. W., Hatfield, J. L., Ruane, A. C., Boote, K. J., Thorburn, P. J., Rötter, R. P., Cammarano, D., Brisson, N., Basso, B., Martre, P., Aggarwal, P. K., Angulo, C., Bertuzzi, P., Biernath, C., Challinor, A. J., Doltra, J., Gayler, S., Goldberg, R., Grant, R., Heng, L., Hooker, J., Hunt, L. A., Ingwersen, J., Izaurralde, R. C., Kersebaum, K. C., Mueller, C., Naresh Kumar, S., Nendel, C., O'Leary, G., Olesen, J. E., Osborne, T. M., Palosuo, T., Priesack, E., Ripoche, D., Semenov, M. A., Shcherbak, I., Steduto, P., Stöckle, C., Stratonovitch, P., Streck, T., Supit, I., Tao, F., Travasso, M., Waha, K., Wallach, D., White, J. W., Williams, J. R. & Wolf, J. (2013). Uncertainty in simulating wheat yields under climate change. Nature Climate Change 3, 827832.
Baxter, S. J., Oliver, M. A. & Gaunt, J. (2003). A geostatistical analysis of the spatial variation of soil mineral nitrogen and potentially available nitrogen within an arable field. Precision Agriculture 4, 213226.
BBCH (Biologische Bundesanstallt Für Land-Und Forstwirtschaft) (1997). Growth Stages of Mono-and Dicotyledonous Plants: BBCH Monograph. Berlin: Blackwell Wissenschafts-Verlag.
Berntsen, J., Hauggard-Nielsen, H., Olesen, J. E., Petersen, B. M., Jensen, E. S. & Thomsen, A. (2004). Modelling dry matter production and resource use in intercrops of pea and barley. Field Crops Research 88, 6983.
Borg, G. C., Jansson, P. E. & Linden, B. (1990). Simulated and measured nitrogen conditions in a manured and fertilised soil. Plant and Soil 121, 251267.
Burns, I. G. (1974). A model for predicting the redistribution of salts applied to fallow soils after excess rainfall or evaporation. Journal of Soil Science 25, 165178.
Cannavo, P., Recous, S., Parnaudeau, V. & Reau, R. (2008). Modeling N dynamics to assess environmental impacts of cropped soils. Advances in Agronomy 97, 131174.
Carter, T. R. (2013). Multi-model yield projections. Nature Climate Change 3, 784786.
Cassman, K. G., Dobermann, A., Walters, D. T. & Yang, H. (2003). Meeting cereal demand while protecting natural resources and improving environmental quality. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 28, 315358.
Corre-Hellou, G., Faure, M., Launay, M., Brisson, N. & Crozat, Y. (2009). Adaptation of the STICS intercrop model to simulate crop growth and N accumulation in pea-barley intercrops. Field Crops Research 113, 7281.
de Wit, C. T. (1965). Photosynthesis of Leaf Canopies. Verslagen Landbouwkundige Onderzoekingen (Agricultural Research Reports) 663. Wageningen, The Netherlands: Pudoc.
Dessureault-Rompré, J., Zebarth, B. J., Burton, D. L., Gregorich, E. G., Goyer, C., Georgallas, A. & Grant, C. A. (2013). Are soil mineralizable nitrogen pools replenished during the growing season in agricultural soils? Soil Science Society of America Journal 77, 512524.
Diekkrüger, B., Söndgerath, D., Kersebaum, K. C. & McVoy, C. W. (1995). Validity of agroecosystem models a comparison of results of different models applied to the same data set. Ecological Modelling 81, 329.
Dobermann, A., Dawe, D., Roetter, R. P. & Cassman, K. G. (2000). Reversal of rice yield decline in a long-term continuous cropping experiment. Agronomy Journal 92, 633643.
Donatelli, M., Stöckle, C., Ceotto, E. & Rinaldi, M. (1997). Evaluation of CropSyst for cropping systems at two locations of northern and southern Italy. European Journal of Agronomy 6, 3545.
Doltra, J., Lægdsmand, M. & Olesen, J. E. (2011). Cereal yield and quality as affected by nitrogen availability in organic and conventional arable crop rotations: a combined modeling and experimental approach. European Journal of Agronomy 34, 8395.
Doltra, J., Laegsmand, M. & Olesen, P. (2014). Impacts of projected climate change on productivity and nitrogen leaching of crop rotations in arable and pig farming systems in Denmark. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 152, 7592.
Eitzinger, J., Trnka, M., Hösch, J., Žalud, Z. & Dubrovsky, M. (2004). Comparison of CERES, WOFOST and SWAP models in simulating soil water content during growing season under different soil conditions. Ecological Modelling 171, 223246.
Eitzinger, J., Thaler, S., Schmid, E., Strauss, F., Ferrise, R., Moriondo, M., Bindi, M., Palosuo, T., Rötter, R., Kersebaum, K. C., Olesen, J. E., Patil, R. H., Saylan, L., Çaldag, B. & Çaylak, O. (2013). Sensitivities of crop models to extreme weather conditions during flowering period demonstrated for maize and winter wheat in Austria. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 151, 813835.
Farkas, C., Ristolainen, A. & Alakukku, L. (2006). Spatial variation of soil properties affecting yield. Cereal Research Communications 34, 155158.
Finnish Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry (2007). The Rural Development Programme for Mainland Finland 2007–2013. Helsinki: Finnish Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry.
Franko, U., Puhlmann, M., Kuka, K., Böhme, F. & Merbach, I. (2007). Dynamics of water, carbon and nitrogen in an agricultural used Chernozem soil in Central Germany. In Modelling Water and Nutrient Dynamics in Soil-Crop Systems (Eds Kersebaum, K. C., Hecker, J.-M., Mirschel, W. & Wegehenkel, M.), pp. 245258. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Goudriaan, J. (1977). Crop Micrometeorology: A Simulation Study. Simulation Monographs. Wageningen, The Netherlands: Pudoc, Wageningen.
Guntinas, M. E., Leiros, M. C., Trasar-Cepeda, C. & Gil-Sotres, F. (2012). Effects of moisture and temperature on net soil nitrogen mineralization: a laboratory study. European Journal of Soil Biology 48, 7380.
Hakala, K., Jauhiainen, L., Himanen, S. J., Rötter, R., Salo, T. & Kahiluoto, H. (2012). Sensitivity of barley varieties to weather in Finland. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 150, 145160.
Hansen, S. (2000). DAISY, a Flexible Soil-Plant-Atmosphere System Model. Equation Section 1. Copenhagen: The Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University.
Hansen, S., Jensen, H. E., Nielsen, N. E. & Svendsen, H. (1990). DAISY: A Soil Plant System Model. Danish Simulation Model for Transformation and Transport of Energy and Matter in the Soil-Plant-Atmosphere System. Copenhagen: National Agency for Environmental Protection.
Hay, R. K. M. & Porter, J. R. (2006). The Physiology of Crop Yield, 2nd edn, Oxford: Blackwell publishing.
Hlavinka, P., Eitzinger, J., Smutný, V., Thaler, S., Žalud, Z., Rischbeck, P. & Kren, J. (2010). The performance of CERES-Barley and CERES-Wheat under various soil conditions and tillage practices in Central Europe. Die Bodenkultur 61, 517.
Hlavinka, P., Trnka, M., Kersebaum, K. C., ČermÁk, P., PohankovÁ, E., OrsÁg, M., PokornÝ, E., Fischer, M., BrtnickÝ, M. & Žalud, Z. (2014). Modelling of yields and soil nitrogen dynamics for crop rotations by HERMES under different climate and soil conditions in the Czech Republic. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 152, 188204.
Håkansson, I., Myrbeck, Å. & Etana, A. (2002). A review of research on seedbed preparation for small grains in Sweden. Soil and Tillage Research 64, 2340.
Hyytiäinen, K., Niemi, J. K., Koikkalainen, K., Palosuo, T. & Salo, T. (2011). Adaptive optimization of crop production and nitrogen leaching abatement under yield uncertainty. Agricultural Systems 104, 634644.
Janssen, B. H., Guiking, F. C. T., van der Eijk, D., Smaling, E. M. A., Wolf, J. & van Reuler, H. (1990). A system for quantitative evaluation of the fertility of tropical soils (QUEFTS). Geoderma 46, 299318.
Jansson, P-E. & Karlberg, L. (2012). Coupled Heat and Mass Transfer Model for Soil-Plant Atmosphere Systems. Stockholm: Royal Institute of Technology, Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering.
Jansson, P-E. & Thoms-Hjärpe, C. (1986). Simulated and measured soil water dynamics of unfertilized and fertilized barley. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica 36, 162172.
Keating, B. A., Carberry, P. S., Hammer, G. L., Probert, M. E., Robertson, M. J., Holzworth, D., Huth, N. I., Hargreaves, J. N. G., Meinke, H., Hochman, Z., McLean, G., Verburg, K., Snow, V., Dimes, J. P., Silburn, M., Wang, E., Brown, S., Bristow, K. L., Asseng, S., Chapman, S., McCown, R. L., Freebairn, D. M. & Smith, C. J. (2003). An overview of APSIM, a model designed for farming systems simulation. European Journal of Agronomy 18, 267288.
Kersebaum, K. C. (2007). Modelling nitrogen dynamics in soil–crop systems with HERMES. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 77, 3952.
Kersebaum, K. C., Lorenz, K., Reuter, H. I., Schwarz, J., Wegehenkel, M. & Wendroth, O. (2005). Operational use of agro-meteorological data and GIS to derive site specific nitrogen fertilizer recommendations based on the simulation of soil and crop growth processes. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth, Parts A/B/C 30, 5967.
Kersebaum, K. C., Hecker, J-M., Mirschel, W. & Wegehenkel, M. (2007). Modelling water and nutrient dynamics in soil–crop systems: A comparison of simulation models applied on common data sets. In Modelling Water and Nutrient Dynamics in Soil–Crop Systems (Eds Kersebaum, K. C., Hecker, J.-M., Mirschel, W. & Wegehenkel, M.), pp. 117. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Knutti, R. (2010). The end of model democracy? An editorial comment. Climatic Change 102, 395404.
Launay, M., Brisson, N., Satger, S., Hauggaard-Nielsen, H., Corre-Hellou, G., Kasynova, E., Ruske, R., Jensen, E. S. & Gooding, M. J. (2009). Exploring options for managing strategies for pea-barley intercropping using a modeling approach. European Journal of Agronomy 31, 8598.
Martre, P., Wallach, D., Asseng, S., Ewert, F., Jones, J. W., Rötter, R. P., Boote, K. J., Ruane, A. C., Thorburn, P. J., Cammarano, D., Hatfield, J. L., Rosenzweig, C., Aggarwal, P. K., Angulo, C., Basso, B., Bertuzzi, P., Biernath, C., Challinor, A. J., Doltra, J., Gayler, S., Goldberg, R., Grant, R., Heng, L., Hooker, J., Hunt, L. A., Ingwersen, J., Izaurralde, R. C., Kersebaum, K. C., Müller, C., Naresh Kumar, S., Nendel, C., O'Leary, G., Olesen, J. E., Osborne, T. M., Palosuo, T., Priesack, E., Ripoche, D., Semenov, M. A., Shcherbak, I., Steduto, P., Stöckle, C., Stratonovitch, P., Streck, T., Supit, I., Tao, F., Travasso, M., Waha, K., White, J. W. & Wolf, J. (2015). Multimodel ensembles of wheat growth: many models are better than one. Global Change Biology 21, 911925.
Monteith, J. L. (1981). Climatic variation and the growth of crops. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 107, 749774.
Mäkelä, P. & Muurinen, S. (2012). Uniculm and conventional tillering barley accessions under northern growing conditions. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 150, 335344.
Nendel, C., Berg, M., Kersebaum, K. C., Mirschel, W., Specka, X., Wegehenkel, M., Wenkel, K. O. & Wieland, R. (2011). The MONICA model: testing predictability for crop growth, soil moisture and nitrogen dynamics. Ecological Modelling 222, 16141625.
Nendel, C., Venezia, A., Piro, F., Ren, T., Lillywhite, R. D. & Rahn, C. R. (2013). The performance of the EU-Rotate_N model in predicting the growth and nitrogen uptake of rotations of field vegetable crops in a Mediterranean environment. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 151, 538555.
Novem Auyeung, D. S., Suseela, V. & Dukes, J. S. (2013). Warming and drought reduce temperature sensitivity of nitrogen transformations. Global Change Biology 19, 662676.
Nykänen, A., Salo, T. & Granstedt, A. (2009). Simulated cereal nitrogen uptake and soil mineral nitrogen after clover-grass leys. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 85, 115.
Palosuo, T., Kersebaum, K. C., Angulo, C., Hlavinka, P., Moriondo, M., Olesen, J. E., Patil, R. H., Ruget, F., Rumbaur, C., Takac, J., Trnka, M., Bindi, M., Caldag, B., Ewert, F., Ferrise, R., Mirschel, W., Saylan, L., Siska, B. & Rötter, R. (2011). Simulation of winter wheat yield and its variability in different climates of Europe: a comparison of eight crop growth models. European Journal of Agronomy 35, 103114.
Patil, R. H., Lægdsmand, M., Olesen, J. E. & Porter, J. R. (2012). Sensitivity of crop yield and N losses in winter wheat to changes in mean and variability of temperature and precipitation in Denmark using the FASSET model. Acta Agriculturae Scandinavica. Section B: Plant and Soil 62, 335351.
Peltonen-Sainio, P., Muurinen, S., Rajala, A. & Jauhiainen, L. (2008). Variation in harvest index of modern spring barley, oat and wheat cultivars adapted to northern growing conditions. Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge 146, 3547.
Peltonen-Sainio, P., Jauhiainen, L., Rajala, A. & Muurinen, S. (2009). Tiller traits of spring cereals under tiller-depressing long day conditions. Field Crops Research 113, 8289.
Petersen, S. O., Schjønning, P., Olesen, J. E., Christensen, S. & Christensen, B. T. (2013). Sources of nitrogen for winter wheat in organic cropping systems. Soil Science Society of America Journal 77, 155165.
Pietola, L. & Tanni, R. (2003). Response of seedbed physical properties, soil N and cereal growth to peat application during transition to conservation tillage. Soil and Tillage Research 74, 6579.
Pietola, L., Tanni, R. & Elonen, P. (1999). Responses of yield and N use of spring sown crops to N fertilization, with special reference to the use of plant growth regulators. Agricultural and Food Science in Finland 8, 423440.
Probert, M. E., Dimes, J. P., Keating, B. A., Dalal, R. C. & Strong, W. M. (1998). APSIM's water and nitrogen modules and simulation of the dynamics of water and nitrogen in fallow systems. Agricultural Systems 56, 128.
Rahn, C. R., Zhang, K., Lillywhite, R., Ramos, C., Doltra, J., de Paz, J. M., Riley, H., Fink, M., Nendel, C., Thorup-Kristensen, K., Pedersen, A., Piro, F., Venezia, A., Firth, C., Schmutz, U., Rayns, F. & Strohmeyer, K. (2010). EU-Rotate_N – a decision support system – to predict environmental and economic consequences of the management of nitrogen fertiliser in crop rotations. European Journal of Horticultural Science 75, 2032.
Richards, L. A. (1931). Capillary conduction of liquids through porous mediums. Physics: A Journal of General and Applied Physics, American Physical Society 1, 318333.
Ros, G. H., Hanegraaf, M. C., Hoffland, E. & van Riemsdijk, W. H. (2011). Predicting soil N mineralization: relevance of organic matter fractions and soil properties. Soil Biology and Biochemistry 43, 17141722.
Rötter, R. P., Carter, T. R., Olesen, J. E. & Porter, J. R. (2011 a). Crop-climate models need an overhaul. Nature Climate Change 1, 175177.
Rötter, R. P., Palosuo, T., Pirttioja, N. K., Dubrovsky, M., Salo, T., Fronzek, S., Aikasalo, R., Trnka, M., Ristolainen, A. & Carter, T. R. (2011 b). What would happen to barley production in Finland if global warming exceeded 4 °C? A model-based assessment. European Journal of Agronomy 35, 205214.
Rötter, R. P., Palosuo, T., Kersebaum, K. C., Angulo, C., Bindi, M., Ewert, F., Ferrise, R., Hlavinka, P., Moriondo, M., Nendel, C., Olesen, J. E., Patil, R. H., Ruget, F., Takac, J. & Trnka, M. (2012). Simulation of spring barley yield in different climatic zones of Northern and Central Europe: a comparison of nine crop models. Field Crops Research 133, 2336.
Rötter, R. P., Höhn, J., Trnka, M., Fonzek, S., Carter, T. R. & Kahiluoto, H. (2013). Modelling shifts in agroclimate and crop cultivar response under climate change. Ecology and Evolution 3, 41974214.
Sapkota, T. B., Askegaard, M., Laegdsmand, M. & Olesen, J. E. (2012). Effects of catch crop type and root depth on nitrogen leaching and yield of spring barley. Field Crops Research 125, 129138.
Schabenberger, O. & Pierce, F. J. (2002). Contemporary Statistical Models for the Plant and Soil Sciences. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Setiyono, T. D., Yang, H., Walters, D. T., Dobermann, A., Ferguson, R. B., Roberts, D. F., Lyon, D. J., Clay, D. E. & Cassman, K. G. (2011). Maize-N. A decision tool for nitrogen management in maize. Agronomy Journal 103, 12761283.
Shaffer, M. J. (2002). Nitrogen modeling for soil management. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 57, 417425.
Smith, P., Smith, J. U., Powlson, D. S., McGill, W. B., Arah, J. R. M., Chertov, O. G., Coleman, K., Franko, U., Frolking, S., Jenkinson, D. S., Jensen, L. S., Kelly, R. H., Klein-Gunnewiek, H., Komarov, A. S., Li, C., Molina, J. A. E., Mueller, T., Parton, W. J., Thornley, J. H. M. & Whitmore, A. P. (1997). A comparison of the performance of nine soil organic matter models using datasets from seven long-term experiments. Geoderma 81, 153225.
Stöckle, C. O., Donatelli, M. & Nelson, R. (2003). CropSyst, a cropping systems simulation model. European Journal of Agronomy 18, 289307.
Strauss, F., Schmid, E., Moltchanova, E., Formayer, H. & Wang, X. (2012). Modeling climate change and biophysical impacts of crop production in the Austrian Marchfeld Region. Climatic Change 111, 641664.
Stuart, M. E., Gooddy, D. C., Bloomfield, J. P. & Williams, A. T. (2011). A review of the impact of climate change on future nitrate concentrations in groundwater of the UK. Science of the Total Environment 409, 28592873.
Sutton, M. A., Erisman, J. W., Leip, A., van Grinsven, H. & Winiwarter, W. (2011). Too much of a good thing. Nature 472, 159161.
Trnka, M., Dubrovsky, M. & Zalud, Z. (2004). Climate change impacts and adaptation strategies in spring barley production in the Czech Republic. Climatic Change 64, 227255.
Valkama, E., Salo, T., Esala, M. & Turtola, E. (2013). Nitrogen balances and yields of spring cereals as affected by nitrogen fertilization in northern conditions: a meta-analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 164, 113.
Van Oort, P. A. J., Timmermans, B. G. H., Meinke, H. & van Ittersum, M. K. (2012). Key weather extremes affecting potato production in The Netherlands. European Journal of Agronomy 37, 1122.
Wheeler, T. & von Braun, J. (2013). Climate change impacts on global food security. Science 341, 508513.
Williams, J. R. (1995). The EPIC model, 1995. In Computer Models of Watershed Hydrology (Ed. Singh, V. P.), pp. 9091000. Highlands Ranch, CO: Water Resources Publications.
Willmott, C. J. (1981). On the validation of models. Physical Geography 2, 184194.
Wolf, J., Hack-ten Broeke, M. J. D. & Rötter, R. P. (2005). Simulation of nitrogen leaching in sandy soils in the Netherlands with the ANIMO model and the integrated modelling system STONE. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment 105, 523540.
Yli-Halla, M. & Mokma, D. L. (2001). Soils in an agricultural landscape of Jokioinen, south-western Finland. Agriculture and Food Science in Finland 10, 3343.

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed