Skip to main content Accessibility help

Subsidy Incidence in Factor Markets: An Experimental Approach

  • Amy M. Nagler (a1), Dale J. Menkhaus (a1), Christopher T. Bastian (a1), Mariah D. Ehmke (a1) and Kalyn T. Coatney (a2)...


Laboratory market experiments are used to estimate the incidence of a stylized subsidy in factor market negotiations with university student and agricultural professional subjects. In separate sessions with both groups, prices converged approximately four and a half tokens higher when a 20-token per-unit subsidy was paid to buyers; this equates to 44% of the predicted 10-token split. A proportional market incentive treatment clarifies this subsidy effect. Discrepancies between predicted and observed incidence are similar to previous empirical estimates of subsidy incidence in agricultural land rental markets. A behavioral anomaly as well as buyer-buyer market competition may contribute to experimental results.



Hide All
Ashenfelter, O., Currie, J., Farber, H.S., and Spiegel, M.. “An Experimental Comparison of Dispute Rates in Alternative Arbitration Systems.Econometrica: Journal of the Econometric Society 60,6(1992):1407–33.
Bastian, CT., Menkhaus, D.J., Nagler, A.M., and Ballenger, N.S.. “Ex Ante Evaluation of Alternative Agricultural Policies in Laboratory Posted Bid Markets.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 90,5(2008):1208–15.
Bastian, CT., Nagler, A.M., Menkhaus, D.J., Ehmke, M.D., Whitaker, J.B., and Young, CE.. “Decoupled Programs, Payment Incidence, and Factor Markets: Evidence from Market Experiments.” Selected paper, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association Annual Meeting, Pittsburgh, PA, July 24-26, 2011.
Bhaskar, A., and Beghin, J.C. “How Coupled Are Decoupled Farm Payments? A Review of the Evidence.Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 34,1(2009):130–53.
Ciaassen, R., Cooper, J.C., and Carriazo, F.. “Crop Insurance, Disaster Payments, and Land Use Change: The Effect of Sodsaver on Incentives for Grassland Conversion.Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 43,2(2011):195211.
Davis, D.D., and Holt, CA.. Experimental Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1993.
Environmental Working Group. 2011 Farm Subsidy Database. Internet site: (Accessed August 17, 2012).
Fehr, E., and Schmidt, K.M.. “The Economics of Fairness, Reciprocity and Altruism-Experimental Evidence and New Theories.” Handbook of the Economics of Giving, Altruism and Reciprocity, Foundations Volume 1. Kolm, S-C and Ythier, J.M., eds. New York, NY: Elsevier, 2006.
Feichtinger, P., and Salhofer, K.. “The Valuation of Agricultural Land and the Influence of Government Payments.” Working paper, Factor Markets Coordination: Centre for European Policy Studies, Brussels, Belgium, December 2011.
Floyd, J.E.The Effects of Farm Price Supports on the Returns to Land and Labor in Agriculture.The Journal of Political Economy 73,2(1965):148–58.
Goodwin, B.K., Mishra, A.K., and Ortalo-Magn, F.N.é. “What's Wrong with Our Models of Agricultural Land Values?American Journal of Agricultural Economics 85,3(2003):744–52.
Grether, D.M., and Plott, CR.. “The Effects of Market Practices in Oligopolistic Markets: An Experimental Investigation of the Ethyl Case.Economic Inquiry 22,4(1984):479507.
Haydu, J.J., Myers, R.J., and Thompson, S.R.. “Why Do Farmers Forward Contract in Factor Markets?Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics 24,1(1992):145–52.
Herberich, D.H., and List, J.A.. “Digging into Background Risk: Experiments with Farmers and Students.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 94,2(2012):457–63.
Hong, J.T., and Plott, CR.. “Rate Filing Policies for Inland Water Transportation: An Experimental Approach.The Bell Journal of Economics 13,1(1982):119.
Kirwan, B., and Roberts, M.J.. “Who Really Benefits from Agricultural Subsidies? Evidence from Field-Level Data.” Selected Paper, Agricultural and Applied Economics Association Annual Meeting, Denver, July 25-27, 2010.
Kirwan, B.E.The Incidence of U.S. Agricultural Subsidies on Farmland Rental Rates.The Journal of Political Economy 117,1(2009):138–64.
Kostov, P., Patton, M., and McErlean, S.. “Non-parametric Analysis of the Influence of Buyers’ Characteristics and Personal Relationships on Agricultural Land Prices.Agribusiness 24,2(2008):161–76.
Luckstead, J., Devadoss, S., and Rodriguez, A.. “The Effects of North American Free Trade Agreement and United States Farm Policies on Illegal Immigration and Agricultural Trade.Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 44,1(2012):119.
Menkhaus, D.J., Bastian, C.T., Phillips, O.R., and O'Neill, P.D.. “Supply and Demand Risks in Laboratory Forward and Spot Markets: Implications for Agriculture.Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 32,1(2000):159–73.
Menkhaus, D.J., Phillips, O.R., and Bastian, CT.. “Impacts of Alternative Trading Institutions and Methods of Delivery on Laboratory Market Outcomes.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 85,5(2003):1323–29.
Menkhaus, D.J., Phillips, O.R., Bastian, CT., and Gittings, L.B.. “The Matching Problem (and Inventories) in Private Negotiation.American Journal of Agricultural Economics 89,4(2007):1073–84.
Mishra, A.K., and Perry, J.E.. “Forward Contracting of Inputs: A Farm-Level Analysis.Journal of Agribusiness 17,2(1999):7791.
Noussair, C.N., Plott, CR., and Riezman, R.G.. “An Experimental Investigation of the Patterns of International Trade.The American Economic Review 85,3(1995):462–91.
Parks, R.W.Efficient Estimation of a System of Regression Equations When Disturbances Are Both Serially and Contemporaneously Correlated.Journal of the American Statistical Association 62,318(1967):500–9.
Phillips, O.R., Menkhaus, D.J., and Krogmeier, J.L.. “Laboratory Behavior in Spot and Forward Auction Markets.Experimental Economics 4,3(2001):243–56.
Phillips, O.R., Nagler, A.M., Menkhaus, D.J., and Bastian, CT.. “Experimental Work on Subsidies, Moral Hazard, and Market Power in Agricultural Markets.Contemporary Economic Policy 28,4(2010):488501.
Plott, CR.Industrial Organization Theory and Experimental Economics.Journal of Economic Literature 20(1982):1485–527.
SAS. SAS/ETS User's Guide, Version 8. Cary, NC: SAS Institute, Inc., 1999.
Smith, V.L.Experimental Economics: Induced Value Theory.The American Economic Review 66,2(1976):274–79.
Sumner, D.A.Farm Subsidy Tradition and Modern Agricultural Realities.” Working Paper, American Enterprise Institute Policy Series: The 2007 Farm Bill and Beyond. Washington D.C: AEI Press, 2007.
Tweeten, L., and Zulauf, C.. “Farm Price and Income Policy: Lessons from History.Agribusiness 24,2(2008):145–60.
USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service. 2007 Census of Agriculture Demographics Fact Sheet. Internet site: (Accessed August 17, 2012).
Young, H.P., and Burke, M.A.. “Competition and Custom in Economic Contracts: A Case Study of Illinois Agriculture.The American Economic Review 91,3(2001):559–73.


Subsidy Incidence in Factor Markets: An Experimental Approach

  • Amy M. Nagler (a1), Dale J. Menkhaus (a1), Christopher T. Bastian (a1), Mariah D. Ehmke (a1) and Kalyn T. Coatney (a2)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed