Skip to main content Accessibility help

Pasture-Based versus Conventional Milk Production: Where Is the Profit?

  • Jeffrey Gillespie (a1) and Richard Nehring (a2)


Costs and returns of pasture-based dairy production are compared with those of conventional production using matching samples. Both whole-farm and dairy enterprise-level estimates are made using the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Agricultural Resource Management Survey data. Conventional farms are matched to pasture-based farms on the basis of operation scale, scope, region, and farmer demographics and adoption of technology. Results show for pasture-based production lower net farm income on per-cow, per-hundredweight milk produced, and total bases. On an enterprise basis, results show for pasture-based production, higher net return over operating cost and lower net return over total cost per hundredweight milk produced.



Hide All
Abadie, A., Drakker, D., Herr, J.L., and Imbens, G.W.. “Implementing Matching Estimators for Average Treatment Effects in Stata.” The Stata Journal 4(2004):290311.
Benson, G.A.Pasture-Based and Confinement Dairy Farming in the United States: An Assessment.” Journal of International Farm Management 4,2(2008): 116.
Billewicz, W.Z.Matched Samples in Analytical Studies.” British Journal of Preventive & Social Medicine 18(1964): 167-73.
Boehlje, M.The Entry-Growth-Exit Processes in Agriculture.” Southern Journal of Agricultural Economics 5,1(1973):2336.
Boehlje, M.D., and Eidman, V.R.. Farm Management. John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1984.
Cochran, W.G.Matching in Analytical Studies.” American Journal of Public Health 43(1953): 684-91.
Darti, B.A., Lloyd, J.W., Radke, B.R., Black, J.R., and Kaneene, J.B.. “A Comparison of Profitability and Economic Efficiencies between Management-Intensive Grazing and Conventionally Managed Dairies in Michigan.” Journal of Dairy Science 82(1999):2412-20.
Elbehri, A., and Ford, S.A.. “Economic Analysis of Major Dairy Forage Systems in Pennsylvania: The Role of Intensive Grazing.” Journal of Production Agriculture 8,4(1995):501-07.
El-Osta, H.S., and Ahearn, M.C.. “Estimating the Opportunity Costs of Unpaid Farm Labor for U.S. Farm Operators.” Technical Bulletin 1848, USDA-Economic Research Service, Washington, DC, March 1996.
Foltz, J., and Lang, G.. “The Adoption and Impact of Management Intensive Grazing (MIRG) on Connecticut Dairy Farms.” Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems 20,4(2005):261-66.
Gillespie, J., and Nehring, R.. “Comparing Economic Performance of Organic and Conventional U.S. Beef Farms Using Matching Samples.” The Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 57(2013): 178-92.
Gillespie, J., Nehring, R., Hallahan, C., and Sandretto, C.. “Pasture-Based Dairy Systems: Who Are the Producers and Are Their Operations More Profitable than Conventional Dairies?Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 34,3(2009):412-27.
Gillespie, J.M., Wyatt, W., Venuto, B., Blouin, D., and Boucher, R.. “The Roles of Labor and Profitability in Choosing a Grazing Strategy for Beef Production in the U.S. Gulf Coast Region.” Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics 40(2008):301-13.
Hanson, G.D., Cunningham, L.C., Ford, S.A., Muller, L.D., and Parsons, R.L.. “Increasing Intensity of Pasture Use with Dairy Cattle: An Economic Analysis.” Journal of Production Agriculture 11,2(1998): 175-79.
Horner, J., Milhollin, R., and Prewitt, W.. “Economics of Pasture-Based Dairies.” Publication M192. Columbia, MO: University of Missouri Extension Service, 2012.
Huber, P.J. The Behavior of Maximum Likelihood Estimates under Nonstatistical Conditions. Proceedings of the Fifth Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability, University of California Press, Berkeley, CA, 1(1967):221-23.
Imbens, G.W.Nonparametric Estimation of Average Treatment Effects Under Exogeneity: A Review.” The Review of Economics and Statistics 86(2004):429.
Mayen, C.D., Balagtas, J.V., and Alexander, C.E.. “Technology Adoption and Technical Efficiency: Organic and Conventional Dairy Farms in the United States.” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 92,1(2010): 181-95.
McBride, W.D., and Greene, C.. “Costs of Organic Milk Production on U.S. Dairy Farms.” Review of Agricultural Economics 31(2009):793813.
Nehring, R., Gillespie, J., Sandretto, C., and Hallahan, C.. “Small U.S. Dairy Farms: Can They Compete?Agricultural Economics 40(2009): 817-25.
Neuman, W.New Pasture Rules Issued for Organic Dairy Producers.” New York Times, Business Section, February 13, 2010.
Parker, W.J., Muller, L.D., and Buckmaster, D.R.. “Management and Economic Implications of Intensive Grazing on Dairy Farms in the Northeastern States.” Journal of Dairy Science 75(1992):2587-97.
Peterson, G.A.Selection of Maximum Profit Combinations of Livestock Enterprises and Crop Rotations.” Journal of Farm Economics 37,3(1955):546-54.
Rubin, D.B.Using Multivariate Matched Sampling and Regression Adjustment to Control Bias in Observational Studies.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 74(1979): 318-28.
Rust, J.W., Shaeffer, C.C., Eidman, V.R., Moon, R.D., and Mathison, R.D.. “Intensive Rotational Grazing for Dairy Cattle Feeding.” American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 10,4(1995): 147-51.
Soder, K.J., and Rotz, C.A.. “Economic and Environmental Impact of Four Levels of Concentrate Supplementation in Grazing Dairy Herds.” Journal of Dairy Science 84,11(2001):2560-72.
Tauer, L.W.Estimation of Treatment Effects of Recombinant Bovine Somatotropin Using Matching Samples.” Review of Agricultural Economics 31 (2009):411-23.
Tauer, L.W., and Mishra, A.K.. “Can the Small Dairy Farm Remain Competitive in U.S. Agriculture?Food Policy 31,5(2006):458-68.
Taylor, J., and Foltz, J.. “Grazing in the Dairy State: Pasture Use in the Wisconsin Dairy Industry, 1993-2003.” Report provided by the Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Wisconsin, Madison, January 2006.
Tozer, P.R., Bargo, F., and Muller, L.D.. “Economic Analyses of Feeding Systems Combining Pasture and Total Mixed Ration.” Journal of Dairy Science 86,3(2003):808-18.
Tucker, W.B., Rude, B.J., and Wittayakun, S.. “Case Study: Performance and Economics of Dairy Cows Fed a Corn Silage-Based Total Mixed Ration or Grazing Annual Ryegrass during Mid to Late Lactation.” The Professional Animal Scientist 17,3(2001):195201.
Uematsu, H., and Mishra, A.. “Organic Farmers or Conventional Farmers: Where's the Money?Ecological Economics 78(2012):5562.
USDA-National Agricultural Statistics Service. “Prices Received for Corn by Month, United States.” Chart on Internet site: (Accessed April 16, 2013).
White, H.A Heteroskedasticity-Consistent Co-variance Matrix Estimator and a Direct Test for Heteroskedasticity.” Econometrica 48(1980): 817-30.
White, S.L., Benson, G.A., Washburn, S.P., and Green, J.T. Jr.Milk Production and Economic Measures in Confinement or Pasture Systems Using Seasonally Calved Holstein and Jersey Cows.” Journal of Dairy Science 85,1(2002):95104.


Pasture-Based versus Conventional Milk Production: Where Is the Profit?

  • Jeffrey Gillespie (a1) and Richard Nehring (a2)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed