Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Is High-Flux Dialysis Cost-Effective?

  • John C. Hornberger (a1), Alan M. Garber (a1) and Michael E. Chernew (a1)

Abstract

High-flux dialysis is a new method for providing routine-maintenance hemodialysis to patients with endstage renal disease. It promises to shorten the duration of the dialysis session, but poses potential clinical risks to patients and financial risks to dialysis centers because of the high unit cost of purchasing new dialysis equipment. We retrospectively evaluated the cost-effectiveness of high-flux dialysis compared to conventional dialysis in a hospital-based center. The center provided only conventional dialysis until March 1989, when it initiated high-flux dialysis. The estimated annual costs of treatment were US $31,249 (high-flux) and $32,562 (conventional). The rate of hospital admissions was almost identical in both groups (conventional, 1.29 admissions per year; high-flux, 1.24 admissions per year; p = 0.23). Predicted prolongation of life expectancy with high-flux dialysis was significantly higher after statistical adjustment for observable patient characteristics (1.8 to 4.5 years; p <0.01). The cost-effectiveness ratio was $28,188 per life-year saved for high-flux compared to conventional dialysis. These findings suggest that the added capital expense of purchasing high-flux equipment can be justified from the perspective of its societal cost-effectiveness.

Copyright

References

Hide All
1.Acchiardo, S. R., Kraus, A. P., & Jennings, B. R.Beta2-microglobulin levels in patients with renal insufficiency. American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 1989, 13, 7074.
2.Acchiardo, S. R., Moore, L. W., & Burk, L.Does short dialysis affect morbidity and mortality? (Abstract) Kidney International, 1989, 37, 286.
3.Acchiardo, S. R., Moore, L. W., & Burk, L.High flux hemodialysis. One year experience. (Abstract) Artificial Organs, 1987, 11, 301.
4.Alter, M. J., Favero, M. S., Moyer, L. A., & Bland, L. A.National surveillance of dialysis-associated diseases in the United States. ASAIO Transactions, 1991, 37, 97109.
5.Amemiya, T., Advanced econometrics. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1985.
6.Bardin, T., Kuntz, D., Zingraff, J., et al. Synovial amyloidosis in patients undergoing longterm hemodialysis. Arthritis and Rheumatism, 1985, 28, 1052–58.
7.Baurmeister, U., Travers, M., Vienken, et al. , Dialysate contamination and back filtration may limit the use of high-flux dialysis membranes. ASAIO Transactions, 1989, 35, 519–22.
8.Beck, J. R., & Pauker, S. G.The Markov process in medical prognosis. Medical Decision Making, 1983, 3, 419–58.
9.Bland, L. A., Arduino, M. J., Aguero, S. M., & Favero, M. S.Recovery of bacteria from reprocessed high-flux dialyzers after bacterial contamination of header spaces and O-rings. ASAIO Transactions, 1989, 35, 314–16.
10.Bommer, J., Becker, K. P., Urbaschek, R., et al. No evidence for endotoxin transfer across high-flux polysulfone membranes. Clinical Nephrology, 1987, 27, 278–82.
11.Casey, T. T., Stone, W. G., DiRaimondo, C. R., et al. Tumoral amyloidosis of bone of beta2- microglobulin origin in association with long-term hemodialysis: A new type of amyloid disease. Human Pathology, 1986, 17, 731–38.
12.Chanard, J., Toupance, O., Lavaud, S., et al. Serum beta2-microglobin and extracellular fluid volume during haemodialysis. Nephrology, Dialysis, Transplantation, 1989, 4, 549–54.
13.Collins, A., Ilstrup, K., Hanson, G., et al. Rapid high-efficiency hemodialysis. Artificial Organs, 1986, 10, 185–88.
14.Collins, A. J.Clinical aspects of high-efficiency dialysis. ASAIO Transactions, 1988, 34, 56–8.
15.de Francisco, A., Gordillo, J., Cotorruelo, J. G., et al. Influence of dialysis membranes on the convective transport of middle molecules. International Journal of Artificial Organs, 1986, 9, 421–26.
16.di Raimondo, C. R., & Pollak, V. E.Beta2-microglobulin kinetics in maintenance hemodialysis: A comparison of conventional and high-flux dialyzers and the effects of dialyzer reuse. American Journal of Kidney Diseases, 1989, 13, 390–95.
17.Feldstein, P. J.Health care economics. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1988.
18.Floege, J., Granolleraus, C., Deschodt, G., et al. High-flux synthetic versus cellulosic membranes for beta2-microglobulin removal during hemodialysis, hemodiafiltration and hemofiltration. Nephrology, Dialysis, Transplantation, 1989, 4, 653–57.
19.Gejyo, F., Homma, N., Suzuki, Y., & Arakawa, M.Serum levels of beta2-microglobulin as a new form of amyloid protein in patients undergoing long-term hemodialysis. (Letter). New England Journal of Medicine, 1986, 314, 585–86.
20.Goldman, M., Lagmiche, M., Dhaene, M., et al. Adsorption of beta2-microglobulin on dialysis membranes: Comparison of different dialyzers and effects of reuse procedures. International Journal of Artificial Organs, 1989, 12, 373–78.
21.Gordon, S. M., Oetinger, C. W., Bland, C., et al. The incidence of pyrogenic reactions in patients receiving conventional or high-flux dialysis using bicarbonate dialysis. (Abstract) Kidney International, 1990, 37, 298.
22.Grekso, J. D., & Laos, J. B.Issues in reduced time therapy. Contemporary Dialysis and Nephrology Magazine, 1987, 8, 2022.
23.Held, P. J., & Pauly, M. V.Competition and efficiency in the end-stage renal disease program. Journal of Health Economics, 1983, 2, 95118.
24.Hornberger, J. C., Chernew, M., & Petersen, . High-flux dialysis improves survival. (Abstract) Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 1990, 1, 362.
25.Hornberger, J. C., Garber, A. M., & Chernew, M. A multivariate analysis of mortality and hospital admissions of high-flux dialysis. Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, in press.
26.Kalbfleisch, J. D., & Prentice, R. L.The statistical analysis of failure time data. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1980.
27.Keshaviah, P., & Collins, A.High-efficiency hemodialysis. Contributions to Nephrology, 1989, 69, 109–19.
28.Keshaviah, P., & Collins, A.Rapid high-efficiency bicarbonate hemodialysis. ASAIO Transactions, 1986, 32, 1723.
29.Klinke, B., Rockel, A., Abdelhamid, S., et al. Transmembranous transport and adsorption of beta2-microglobulin during hemodialysis using polysulfone, poluymeth. International Journal of Artificial Internal Organs, 1989, 12, 697702.
30.Levin, N. W., Dumler, F., Zasuwa, G., & Stalla, K.Mortality comparison between conventional and high-flux dialysis. (Abstract) Journal of the American Society of Nephrology, 1990, 1, 365.
31.Mayer, G., Thum, J., Woloszcuk, W., & Graf, H.Beta2-microglobulin in hemodialysis patients. Effects of different dialyzers and different dialysis procedures. American Journal of Nephrology, 1988, 8, 280–84.
32.Miller, J. G.Survival analysis. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1981.
33.Naitoh, A., Tatsugushi, T., Okada, M., et al. Removal of beta2-microglobulin by diffusion alone is feasible using highly permeable dialysis membranes. ASAIO Transactions, 1988, 34, 630–34.
34.Petersen, J., Hyver, S., & Yeh, I.High-flux and cellulosic membranes, biocompatibility and in vivo clearances. ASAIO Transactions, 1987, 33, 265–68.
35.Peterson, J., Moore, R. J., Kaczmarek, R. G., et al. The effects of reprocessing cuprophane and polysulfone dialyzers on beta2-microglobulin removal from hemodialysis patients. American Journal of Kidney Disease, 1991, 17, 174–78.
36.Rettig, R. A., & Levinsky, N. G.Kidney failure and the federal government. Washington, DC: National Academy Press, 1991.
37.Rockel, A., Hertel, J., Fielgel, P., et al. Permeability and secondary membrane formation of a high-flux polysulfone hemofilter. Kidney International, 1986, 30, 429–32.
38.Ronco, C., Brendolan, A., Bragantini, L., et al. Technical and clinical evaluation of different short, highly efficient dialysis techniques. Contributions to Nephrology, 1988, 61, 4668.
39.Ronco, C., Fabris, A., Brendolan, A., et al. High-flux haemodialysis with 1.5m2 modified cuprammonium rayon membrane: Technical and clinical evaluation. Nephrology, Dialysis, Transplantation, 1988, 3, 440–47.
40.Ronco, C., Fabris, A., Chiaramonte, S., et al. Comparison of four different short dialysis techniques. International Journal of Artificial Organs, 1988, 11, 169–74.
41.Ronguillo, R. M.Short time dialysis: A facility report. Contemporary Dialysis and Nephrology Magazine, 1987, 8, 1318.
42.Schmidt, D. F., Kurtz, S. B., & McCarthy, J. T.Inaccurate blood flow rate during efficient dialysis with high negative arterial pressure. (Abstract) Kidney International, 1989, 37, 319.
43.Schulman, K. A., Lynn, L. A., Glick, H. A., & Eisenberg, J. M.Cost-effectiveness of Lowdose zidovudine therapy for asymptomatic patients with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection. Annals of Internal Medicine, 1991, 114, 798802.
44.Spertini, F., Wauters, J. P., & Poulenas, I.Carpal tunnel syndrome: A frequent, invalidating long-term complication of chronic hemodialysis. Clinical Nephrology, 1984, 21, 98101.
45.Swartz, R. D.Dialysis associated amyloidosis (DAA). The Kidney, 1991, 23, 16.
46.Tannenbaum, J. S., Gibson, R. L., Pearson, J. G., et al. High-flux dialysis using a polysulfone membrane: 10 months clinical experience. (Abstract) Kidney International, 1988,33,239.
47.von Albertini, B.High-efficiency hemodialysis: An overview. Contributions to Nephrology, 1988, 61, 3745.
48.Wauters, J., Bercini-Pansiot, S., Guillard, N., & Stauffer, J.Short hemodialysis: Long-term mortality and morbidity. Artificial Organs, 1986, 10, 182–84.
49.Welch, H. G., & Larson, E. B.Cost-effectiveness of bone marrow transplantation in acute nonlymphocytic leukemia. New England Journal of Medicine, 1989, 321, 807–12.
50.Winsett, O. E., & Wolma, F. J.Complications of vascular access for hemodialysis. Southern Medical Journal, 1985, 78, 513–17.

Is High-Flux Dialysis Cost-Effective?

  • John C. Hornberger (a1), Alan M. Garber (a1) and Michael E. Chernew (a1)

Metrics

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed