Skip to main content Accessibility help

Regulation as the art of intuitive judgment: a critique of the economic approach to environmental regulation

  • Oren Perez (a1)


This article develops a general critique of the economic approach to environmental regulation, drawing on the insights of systems theory. It highlights, first, the problematic of subjugating the regulatory system to a single purpose – which in the context of environmental economics is interpreted as the utilitarian maximization of collective welfare. Second, it questions the teleological pretence of the regulatory project as it is configured in the economic literature. It highlights in this context the problem of trans-systemic incompatibilities, which impede the incorporation of economic ideas into the systems of law and politics. Environmental economics in both its normative and sociopolitical strands, fails to provide a convincing response to this dilemma. The article discusses two examples of the reconstruction of economic ideas within the legal and political domains, drawing on the EU and US regulatory experience. This twofold critique of the economic approach can be extended, it is argued, to every regulatory project with far-reaching teleological ambitions. The article applies this critique to some alternative regulatory visions, such as self-regulation, reflexive law and responsive regulation, noting in this context the limitations of systems theory itself. It concludes with a discussion of the role of intuition in regulatory decision-making.



Hide All
Asimov, Isaac (1951) Foundation. New York: Gnome Press.
Ayres, I. and Braithwaite, J. (1992) Responsive Regulation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Baldwin, Robert and Black, Julia (2008) ‘Really Responsive Regulation’, Modern Law Review 71: 5994.
Barthes, Roland (1980/1993) Camera Lucida: Reflections on Photography, trans Howard, R.. London: Vintage.
Bator, Francis M. (1958) ‘The Anatomy of Market Failure’, The Quarterly Journal of Economics 72(3): 351–79.
Becker, Gary S. (1968) ‘Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach’, Journal of Political Economy 76: 169217.
Black, Julia (1996) ‘Constitutionalising Self-Regulation’, Modern Law Review 59(1): 24–55.
Brans, Marleen and Rossbach, Stefan (1997) ‘The Autopoiesis of Administrative Systems: Niklas Luhmann on Public Administration and Public Policy’, Public Administration 75: 417–39.
Capros, P. and Mantzos, L. (2000) The Economic Effects of EU-wide Industry-Level Emission Trading to Reduce Greenhouse Gases – Results from PRIMES model. Athens: Institute of Communication and Computer Systems, National Technical University of Athens.
Christodoulidis, Emilios (1991) ‘A Case for Reflexive Politics: Challenging Luhmann’s Account of the Political System’, Economy and Society 20(4): 380401.
Coglianese, Cary (2008) ‘Reflections on Executive Order 13,422: The Rhetoric and Reality of Regulatory Reform’, Yale Journal on Regulation 25: 10–12.
Cohen, M. A. (1999) ‘Monitoring and Enforcement of Environmental Policy’ in Tietenberg, T. and Folmer, H. (eds) International Yearbook of Environmental and Resource Economics, Volume III. Northampton: Edward Elgar, 44–106.
Collins, Hugh (2002) ‘Law as Politics: Progressive American Perspectives’ in Penner, J., Schiff, D. and Nobles, R. (eds) Jurisprudence and Legal Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 279333.
Dahlstrom, KristinaHowes, ChrisLeinster, Paul and Skea, Jim (2003) ‘Environmental Management Systems and Company Performance: Assessing the Case for Extending Risk-Based Regulation’, European Environment 13: 187203.
Dana, David A. (2001) ‘Rethinking the Puzzle of Escalating Penalties for Repeat Offenders’, Yale Law Journal 110(5): 733–83.
Darnall, Nicole and Sides, Stephen (2008) ‘Assessing the Performance of Voluntary Environmental Programs: Does Certification Matter?’, Policy Studies Journal 36(1): 95117.
Dyson, Stephen Benedict (2006) ‘Personality and Foreign Policy: Tony Blair’s Iraq Decisions’, Foreign Policy Analysis 2: 289306.
Ecofys (2004) Analysis of the National Allocation Plans for the EU Emissions Trading Scheme. London: Ecofys UK.
Eea (2005) ‘Market-based Instruments for Environmental Policy in Europe’, EEA Technical report No 8/2005. Copenhagen: European Environment Agency.
Entreprises Pour L’environnement, (2006) EU-ETS Review. Available at:
Epa (2000) Guidelines for Preparing Economic Analyses. Washington, DC: US Environmental Protection Agency.
Epa (2001) The United States Experience with Economic Incentives for Protecting the Environment. Washington, DC: US Environmental Protection Agency.
Epa (2005) Position Statement on Environmental Management Systems (EMS). Washington, DC: US Environmental Protection Agency.
Epa science advisory board (2005) Identifying and Calculating Economic Benefit that Goes Beyond Avoided and/or Delayed Costs: An SAB Advisory. Washington, DC: United States Environmental Protection Agency.
Estache, Antonio and Martimort, David (1999) ‘Politics, Transaction Costs, and the Design of Regulatory Institutions. World Bank Working Paper 2073.
Eu commission (2000) Green Paper on Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading within the European Union. Brussels: European Commission.
Frey, Bruno S. and Stutzer, Alois (2006) ‘Environmental Morale and Motivation’, IERE Working Paper No. 288.
Ghoshal, Sumantra (2005) ‘Bad Management Theories are Destroying Good Management Practices’, Academy of Management Learning & Education 4(1): 7591.
Goulder, Lawrence H. and Parry, Ian W. H. (2008) ‘Instrument Choice in Environmental Policy’, Review of Environmental Economics and Policy 2(2): 152–74.
Gowdy, John and Erickson, Jon D. (2005) ‘The Approach of Ecological Economics’, Cambridge Journal of Economics 29(2): 207222.
Grand, Julian le (1991) ‘The Theory of Government Failure’, British Journal of Political Science 21: 423–42.
Grubb, Michael and Neuhoff, Karsten (2006) ‘Allocation and Competitiveness in the EU Emissions Trading Scheme: Policy Overview’, Climate Policy 6: 730.
Gunningham, Neil and Rees, Joseph (1997) ‘Industry Self-Regulation: An Institutional Perspective’, Law & Policy 19(4): 363414.
Hahn, Robert W. (2000) ‘The Impact of Economics on Environmental Policy’, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 39(3): 375–99.
Hepburn, Cameron (2006) ‘Regulation by Prices, Quantities, or Both: A Review of Instrument Choice’, Oxford Review of Economic Policy 22: 226–47.
Heylighen, F. (2002) ‘Complexity and Information Overload in Society: Why Increasing Efficiency Leads to Decreasing Control’, Unpublished manuscript,
Heylighen, F. (2007) ‘Knowledge Selection Criteria’, Principia Cybernetica Web, [last visited 19 October 2008].
House of commons environmental audit select committee (2007) ‘The EU Emissions Trading Scheme: Lessons for the Future’, HC 70.
Keohane, N. O.Revesz, R. L. and Stavins, R. N. (1998) ‘The Choice of Regulatory Instruments in Environmental Policy’, Harvard Environmental Law Review 22(2): 313–68.
King, Andrew A. and Lenox, Michael J. (2000) ‘Industry Self-Regulation Without Sanctions: The Chemical Industry’s Responsible Care Program’, Academy of Management Journal 43(4): 698717.
King, Michael (2006) ‘What’s the Use of Luhmann’s Theory?’ in King, M. and Thornhill, C. (eds) Luhmann on Law and Politics: Critical Appraisals and Applications. Oxford: Hart, 37–52.
Kirchgässner, Gebhard and Schneider, Friedrich (2003) ‘On the Political Economy of Environmental Policy’, Public Choice 115(3): 369–96.
Laffont, Jean-Jacques and Martimort, David (1999) ‘Separation of Regulators Against Collusive Behavior’, Rand Journal of Economics 30(2): 232–62.
Leamer, E. E. (2007) ‘A Flat World, a Level Playing Field, a Small World After All, or None of the Above? A Review of Thomas L. Friedman’s The World is Flat’, Journal of Economic Literature 45: 83126.
Letelier, Juan Carlos, Marin, Gonzalo and Mpodozis, Jorge (2003) ‘Autopoietic and (M,R) Systems’, Journal of Theoretical Biology 222(2): 261–72.
Lovelock, James E. (1991) Gaia: the Practical Science of Planetary Medicine. London: Gaia Books.
Luhmann, Niklas (1989) Ecological Communication, trans Bednarz, J.Oxford: Polity Press.
Luhmann, Niklas (1992) ‘Operational Closure and Structural Coupling: The Differentiation of the Legal System’, Cardozo Law Review 13: 1419–41.
Luhmann, Niklas (1995) Social Systems. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Luhmann, Niklas (1998) Observations on Modernity, trans Whobrey, W.. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Luhmann, Niklas (2004) Law As a Social System, trans Ziegert, K. A.. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lutter, Randall (2001) Improving Regulatory Analysis at the Environmental Protection Agency, Testimony Before the House Committee on Small Business, Subcommittee on Regulatory Reform and Oversight (Testimony 01-5). Washington, DC: AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies.
Markussen, Peter and Svendsen, Gert Tinggaard (2005) ‘Industry Lobbying and the Political Economy of GHG Trade in the European Union’, Energy Policy 33(2): 245–55.
Martimort, David (1999) ‘The Life Cycle of Regulatory Agencies: Dynamic Capture and Transaction Costs’, The Review of Economic Studies 66(4): 929–47.
Maturana, H. R. (1988) ‘Reality: The Search for Objectivity or the Quest for a Compelling Argument’, The Irish Journal of Psychology 9(1):2581.
Maturana, H. R. and Mpodozis, Jorge (2000) ‘The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Drift’, Revista chilena de historia natural 73(2): 261310.
Mondak, Jeffery J. and Halperin, Karen D. (2008) ‘A Framework for the Study of Personality and Political Behaviour’, British Journal of Political Science 38: 335–62.
Moreau, Francois (2004) ‘The Role of the State in Evolutionary Economics. Cambridge Journal of Economics 28(6): 847–74.
Oates, Wallace E., Portney, Paul R. (2003) ‘The Political Economy of Environmental Policy’ in Mäler, Karl-Göran and Vincent, Jeffrey R. (eds) Handbook of Environmental Economics. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 325–54.
Ogus, Anthony (2006) A. Ogus, Costs and Cautionary Tales: Economic Insights for the Law. Hart Publishing.
Paterson, J. and Teubner, G. (1998) ‘Changing Maps: Empirical Legal Autopoiesis’, Social & Legal Studies 7(4): 451–86.
Pearce, David (2006) ‘The Political Economy of an Energy Tax: The United Kingdom’s Climate Change Levy. Energy Economics 28(2): 149–58.
Peltzman, SamLevine, Michael E. and Noll, Roger G. (1989) ‘The Economic Theory of Regulation after a Decade of Deregulation’, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity. Microeconomics, 159.
Perez, Oren (2003) ‘Normative Creativity and Global Legal Pluralism: Reflections on the Democratic Critique of Transnational Law’, Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 10(2): 2564.
Perez, Oren (2006) ‘Law in the Air: A Prologue to the World of Legal Paradoxes’, in Perez, O. and Teubner, G. (eds) Paradoxes and Inconsistencies in Law. Oxford: Hart Publishing, 338.
Petitmengin-peugeot, Claire (1999) ‘The Intuitive Experience’, in Varela, F. J. and Shear, J. (eds) The View from Within: First-person Approaches to the Study of Consciousness. Exeter: Imprint Academic, 4377.
Pinch, Trevor J. and Bijker, Wiebe E. (1984) ‘The Social Construction of Facts and Artefacts: Or How the Sociology of Science and the Sociology of Technology might Benefit Each Other’, Social Studies of Science 14(3): 399441.
Polinsky, Mitchell A. and Shavell, Steven (1994) ‘Should Liability be Based on the Harm to the Victim or the Gain to the Injurer?’, Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization 10: 427–37.
Prakash, Aseem and Potoski, Matthew (2006) The Voluntary Environmentalists: Green Clubs, ISO 14001, and Voluntary Environmental Regulations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Schafer, M. (2000) ‘Issues in Assessing Psychological Characteristics at a Distance: An Introduction to the Symposium’, Political Psychology 21: 511–27.
Siegel, Neil S. (1999) ‘Sen and the Hart of Jurisprudence: A Critique of the Economic Analysis of Judicial behavior’, California Law Review 87(6): 1581–608.
Sijm, J., Neuhoff, K. and Chen, Y. (2006) ‘CO2 Cost Pass-through and Windfall Profits in the Power Sector’, Climate Policy 6: 49–72.
Simons, Kenneth W. (2001) ‘The Hand Formula in the Draft Restatement Third of Torts: Encompassing Fairness As Well As Efficiency Values’, Vanderbilt Law Review 54: 901–40.
Stavins, Robert N. (2001) Experience with Market-Based Environmental Policy Instruments. John F. Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, Research Working Papers Series, October 2001, RWP00-004.
Steinberger, Peter J. (1993) The Concept of Political Judgment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Stigler, George J. (1971) ‘The Theory of Economic Regulation’, The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science 2(1): 321.
Sunder, Madhavi (2001) ‘Cultural Dissent’, Stanford Law Review 54: 495567.
Teubner, G. (1983) ‘Substantive and Reflexive Elements in Modern Law’, Law & Society Review 17: 239–85.
Teubner, G. (1990) ‘How the Law Thinks: Toward a Constructivist Epistemology of Law as an Autopoietic System. Law and Society Review 23: 727–57.
Teubner, G. (1993) Law as an Autopoietic System. Oxford: Blackwell.
Teubner, G. (2001) ‘Economics of Gift – Positivity of Justice: The Mutual Paranoia of Jacques Derrida and Niklas Luhmann’, Theory, Culture & Society 18(1): 2947.
Tietenberg, Tom (2003) Environmental and Natural Resource Economics, 6th edn. Boston: Addison Wesley.
Waldron, Jeremy (2003) ‘Locating Distribution’, The Journal of Legal Studies 32: 277302.
Warford, Jeremy J.Munasinghe, Mohan and Cruz, Wilfrido (1997) The Greening of Economic Policy Reform. Washington, DC: The World Bank.
Winter, David G. (2005) ‘Things I’ve Learned about Personality from Studying Political Leaders at a Distance’, Journal of Personality 73(3): 557–84.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Regulation as the art of intuitive judgment: a critique of the economic approach to environmental regulation

  • Oren Perez (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.