Skip to main content Accessibility help

Hope in Dirt: Report of the Fort Apache Workshop on Forensic Sedimentology Applications to Cultural Property Crime, 15—19 October 2018

  • John R. Welch (a1), Mark T. Altaha (a2), Garry J. Cantley (a3), William H. Doelle (a4), Sarah A. Herr (a5), Morag M. Kersel (a6), Brandi L. MacDonald (a7), Francis P. McManamon (a8), Barbara Mills (a9), Fred Nials (a10), Mary Ownby (a11), Michael Richards (a12), Ramon Riley (a13), Stacy L. Ryan (a14), Duston Whiting (a15) and Donna Yates (a16)...


A 2018 workshop on the White Mountain Apache Tribe lands in Arizona examined ways to enhance investigations into cultural property crime (CPC) through applications of rapidly evolving methods from archaeological science. CPC (also looting, graverobbing) refers to unauthorized damage, removal, or trafficking in materials possessing blends of communal, aesthetic, and scientific values. The Fort Apache workshop integrated four generally partitioned domains of CPC expertise: (1) theories of perpetrators’ motivations and methods; (2) recommended practice in sustaining public and community opposition to CPC; (3) tactics and strategies for documenting, investigating, and prosecuting CPC; and (4) forensic sedimentology—uses of biophysical sciences to link sediments from implicated persons and objects to crime scenes. Forensic sedimentology served as the touchstone for dialogues among experts in criminology, archaeological sciences, law enforcement, and heritage stewardship. Field visits to CPC crime scenes and workshop deliberations identified pathways toward integrating CPC theory and practice with forensic sedimentology’s potent battery of analytic methods.



Hide All
Adovasio, J. M. 2012. “An ‘Outsider’ Look at Forensic Anthropology.” In A Companion to Forensic Anthropology, edited by Dirkmaat, Dennis C., 683–89. Somerset, UK: Wiley Blackwell.
Adovasio, J. M. 2017. “Forensic Geoarchaeology.” In Encyclopedia of Geoarchaeology, edited by Gilbert, Allan S., 276–85. New York: Springer.
Borgstede, Greg. 2014. “Cultural Property, the Palermo Convention, and Transnational Organized Crime.” International Journal of Cultural Property 21: 281–90.
Brodie, Neil, and Renfrew, Colin. 2005. “Looting and the World’s Archaeological Heritage: The Inadequate Response.” Annual Review of Anthropology 34: 343–61.
Campbell, Peter B. 2013. “The Illicit Antiquities Trade as a Transnational Criminal Network: Characterizing and Anticipating Trafficking of Cultural Heritage.” International Journal of Cultural Property 20: 113–53.
Gilbert, Allan S., ed. 2017. Encyclopedia of Geoarchaeology. New York: Springer
Hart, Siobhan M., and Chilton, Elizabeth S.. 2015. “Digging and Destruction: Artifact Collecting as Meaningful Social Practice.” International Journal of Heritage Studies 21: 318–35.
Kersel, Morag M. 2007. “Transcending Borders: Objects on the Move.” Archaeologies: Journal of the World Archaeological Congress 3, no. 2 :8198.
Kersel, Morag M. 2017. “Myths and Facts about Looting.” In The Book of Plunder, edited by Baror, Michal, 196–98. Tel Aviv: Center for Contemporary Art.
Mackenzie, Simon, and Yates, Donna. 2016. “Trafficking Cultural Objects and Human Rights.” In The Routledge Handbook of Criminology and Human Rights, edited by Weber, L., Fishwick, E., and Marmo, M., 220–29. London: Routledge.
Mackenzie, Simon, and Yates, Donna. 2017. “What Is Grey about the ‘Grey Market’ in Antiquities?” In The Architecture of Illegal Markets towards an Economic Sociology of Illegality in the Economy, edited by Beckert, Jens and Dewey, Matias, 7086. London: Oxford University Press.
McAllister, Martin E., and McManamon, Francis P.. 2007. Technical Brief 20: Archeological Resource Damage Assessment. Washington, DC: Archeology Program, National Park Service.
McManamon, Francis P. 1991. “The Federal Government’s Response to Archaeological Looting.” In Protecting the Past, edited by Smith, George S. and Ehrenhard, John E., 261269. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
Miksa, Elizabeth J., and Heidke, James M.. 2001. “It All Comes Out in the Wash: Actualistic Petrofacies Modeling of Temper Provenance, Tonto Basin, Arizona, USA.” Geoarchaeology 16: 177–222.
Pirrie, D., Ruffell, A., and Dawson, L. A., eds. 2013. Environmental and Criminal Geoforensics Geological Society Special Publications. London: Environmental and Criminal Geoforensics Geological Society.
Proulx, Blythe Bowman. 2013. “Archaeological Site Looting in ‘Glocal’ Perspective: Nature, Scope, and Frequency.” American Journal of Archaeology 117, no. 1: 111–25.
Ryan, Stacy L. 2018. “White Mountain Heritage: Understanding Your Place.” Outdoor Adventure December: 1617.
Silverman, Helaine, ed. 2002. “Touring Ancient Times: The Present and Presented Past in Contemporary Peru.” American Anthropologist 104, no. 3: 881902.
Silverman, Helaine, ed. 2006. Archaeological Site Museums in Latin America. Gainsville: University Press of Florida.
Snead, James E. 2018. Relic Hunters: Archaeology and the Public in 19th Century America . New York: Oxford University Press.
Skoy Woodfill, Brent K. 2013. “Community Development and Collaboration at Salinas de Los Nueve Cerros, Guatemala: Accomplishments, Failures, and Lessons Learned Conducting Publically-Engaged Archaeology.” Advances in Archaeological Practice 1: 105–20.
Swain, Todd. 2007. “How Do You Manage Your Resources If They Are Being Stolen and Sold at the Swap Meet?” Proceedings of the George Wright Society. Hancock, MI: George Wright Society.
US Government Accountability Office. 1987. Cultural Resources: Problems Protecting and Preserving Federal Archeological Resources, Doc. GAO/RCED-88-3. Washington, DC: Government Accountability Office.
Waldvaver, Richard C. 1991. “Archaeological Resources Protection Training.” In Protecting the Past, edited by Smith, George S. and Ehrenhard, John E., 201205. Boca Raton: CRC Press.
Welch, John R., Altaha, Mark, Hoerig, Karl, and Riley, Ramon. 2009. “Best Cultural Heritage Stewardship Practices by and for the White Mountain Apache Tribe.” Conservation and Management of Archaeological Sites 11, no. 2: 48160.
Welch, John R., and Ferguson, T. J.. 2007. “Putting Patria into Repatriation: Cultural Affiliations of White Mountain Apache Tribe Lands.” Journal of Social Archaeology 7: 171–98.
Yates, Donna. 2014. “Displacement, Deforestation, and Drugs: Antiquities Trafficking and the Narcotics Support Economies of Guatemala.” In Cultural Property Crime, edited by Kila, Joris D. and Balcells, Marc, 2336. Leiden: Brill.
Yates, Donna, and Mackenzie, Simon. 2018. “Heritage, Crisis, and Community Crime Prevention in Nepal.” International Journal of Cultural Property 25: 203–21.


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed