Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-zzh7m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T08:30:12.243Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Seen, Said, or Deduced? Travel Accounts, Historical Criticism, and Discourse Theory: Towards an “Archeology” of Dialogue in Seventeenth-Century Guinea*

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  13 May 2014

Gérard Chouin*
Affiliation:
Syracuse University, chouin/glchouin@maxwell.syr.edu

Extract

      Puisqu'il n'existe pas de mots qui ne soient à personne
      (Bakhtin 1979 in Todorov 1981: 83)
      Le discours, c'est-à-dire le langage dans sa totalité concrète et vivante.
      (Bakhtin 1963 in Todorov 1981: 44)

European travel accounts are widely used as sources to write the history of societies that did not themselves produce a large amount of textual documentation. On the Coast of Guinea, and more particularly on the area formerly known as Gold Coast (approximately the littoral of modern Ghana), many of the written documents providing historians with information on coastal societies prior to nineteenth century were produced by Europeans travelers. Most of these individuals were merchants, craftsmen, pastors or soldiers who had settled several years in the numerous forts and trading posts erected along the seashore to protect and enhance the trade of chartered companies. Others were seamen and merchants who only spent a few weeks at a stretch plying the African Coast aboard men-of-war or trading ships, exchanging manufactured goods for gold, slaves, and ivory. Professional writers, who had not traveled to Africa, but had obtained data from various written sources or from travelers, also composed some of the accounts. Therefore, these documents show an extraordinary diversity in form and content, which historians and archeologists need to investigate before using them as primary sources for reconstructing the past.

In the first part of the present paper, which focuses on a specific genre, the seventeenth-century travel accounts, I recall the historiography of the recent critique of these sources. I also point out that despite decisive methodological breakthroughs, some heuristic dimensions or attributes of these texts are yet to be recognized and assessed. I then re-examine these sources from the dual perspective of historic and linguistic anthropological methods and introduce an exploratory approach centered on the Bakhtinian approach to discourse.

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © African Studies Association 2001

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

Footnotes

*

A French version of this paper is forthcoming in a volume prepared by the Centre de Recherche Africaine (CRA), Université de Paris-I in honor to Claude-Hélène Perrot. Jean-Pierre Chrétien and Hélène d'Almeida-Topor, the editors, kindly allowed me to submit an English version of it to History in Africa. I am grateful to Chaise LaDousa for introducing me to Bakhtin's thought. Adam Jones provided useful information and advised on the title, while Christopher DeCorse and Thomas Montfort carefully commented on the first draft of this paper. All translations herein are my own.

References

Bakhtin, M.Problemy poétiki Dostoevskogo (Problems of Dostoievski's Poetics). Moscow 1963 (translated quotations in Todorov 1981)Google Scholar
Bakhtin, M.Estetika slovesnogo tvorchestva (Esthetic of Verbal Creation). Edited by Bucharov, S. G.Moscow, 1979. (translated quotations in Todorov 1981)Google Scholar
Bakhtin, M. M.Discourse in the Novel” in The Dialogic Imagination: Four Essays. Austin, 1981, 258422.Google Scholar
Becker, C.Réflexions sur les sources de l'histoire de la Sénégambie” in Heintze, /Jones, , European Sources, 147–65.Google Scholar
Chouin, G. Eguafo, un royaume africain au “coeur françois,” 1637-1687. Mutations socio-économiques et politique européenne d'un état de la Côte de l'Or (Ghana) au XVIIe siècle. Paris, 1998.Google Scholar
Chouin, G.Review of Voyages en Afrique Noire d'Alvise Ca' da Mosto (1455 & 1456), translated and presented by F. Verrier, Paris, 1994, Journal of African History 37 (1996), 517–18.Google Scholar
Chouin, G.Looking Through the Forest: Sacred Groves as Historical Markers and Archaeological Clues in Southern Ghana: an Approach” paper presented at the 14th biennial Conference of the Society of Africanist Archaeologists, 1998.Google Scholar
Delaunay, K.Voyages à la Côte de l'Or (1500-1750). Etude historiographique des relations de voyage sur le littoral ivoirien et ghanéen. Paris, 1994.Google Scholar
De Marees, P.Description and Historical Account of the Gold Kingdom of Guinea (1602). Translated from the Dutch and edited by Van Dantzig, Albert and Jones, Adam. Oxford, 1987Google Scholar
Fabian, J.Language and Colonial Power. The Appropriation of Swahili in the Former Belgian Congo (1880-1938). Berkeley, 1986.Google Scholar
Fage, J. D.A Guide to Original Sources for Precolonial Western Africa Published in European Languages. Madison, 1987.Google Scholar
Fage, J. D.A Supplement to a Guide to Original Sources for Precolonial Western Africa: Corrigenda et Addenda.” History in Africa 19(1992), 201–36.Google Scholar
Fage, J. D.A Guide to Original Sources for Precolonial Western Africa Published in European Languages, for the Most Part in Book Form. Madison, 1994.Google Scholar
Galloway, P.The Unexamined Habitus. Direct Historic Analogy and the Archaeology of the Text” in Gardin, J.C. and Peebles, C.S., eds. Representations in Archaeology. Bloomington, 1992, 178–95.Google Scholar
Goody, Jack. The Domestication of the Savage Mind. Cambridge, 1977.Google Scholar
Goody, Jack. The Interface Between the Written and the Oral. Cambridge, 1987.Google Scholar
Hair, P. E. H.The Use of African Languages in Afro-European Contact in Guinea (1440-1560).” Sierra Leone Language Review 5 (1966), 526.Google Scholar
Heintze, Beatrix and Jones, Adam, eds. European Sources for Sub-Saharan Africa Before 1900: Use and Abuse. Stuttgart, 1987 (=Paideuma 33)Google Scholar
Hymes, D.Models of the Interaction of Language and Social Life” in Gumperz, J.J. and Hymes, D., eds. Directions in Sociolinguistics. The Ethnography of Communication. New York, 1972.Google Scholar
Jenkins, R. G.A. B. Ellis, a Participant in the Scramble of Gold Coast Africana, 1874-1894” in Heintze, /Jones, , European Sources, 313–35.Google Scholar
Johnson, M.Some Non-narrative Sources for Pre-Colonial African History” in Hentze, /Jones, , European Sources, 8193.Google Scholar
Jones, A.German Sources for West African History 1559-1669. Stuttgart, 1983.Google Scholar
Jones, A.Brandenburg Sources for West African History 1680-1700. Stuttgart, 1985.Google Scholar
Jones, A.Raw, Medium, Well Done: A Critical Review of Editorial and Quasi-Editorial Work on 1885 European Sources for Sub-Saharan Africa, 1960-1986. Madison, 1987.Google Scholar
Jones, A.Zur Quellenproblematik der Geschichte Westafrikas 1450-1900. Stuttgart, 1990.Google Scholar
Jones, A.Drink Deep, or Taste Not: Thoughts on the Use of Early European Records in the Study of African Material Culture.” History in Africa. 21 (1994), 349–70.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, A.West Africa in the Mid-Seventeenth Century. An Anonymous Dutch Manuscript. Atlanta, 1995.Google Scholar
Medvedev, P. N.Fromal'nyi metod v literaturovedenii (the Formal Method in the Literary Studies). Leningrad, 1928. (Translated quotations in Todorov 1981)Google Scholar
Nardin, J.-C.Que savons-nous du chevalier Des Marchais” in Daget, S., ed. De la traite à l'esclavage: Actes du colloque international sur la traite des Noirs, Nantes, 1985, 325–45.Google Scholar
Perrot, Cl.-H. and Van Dantzig, A., eds. Marie-Joseph Bonnat et les Ashanti. Journal (1869–1874). Paris, 1994.Google Scholar
Ratelband, K. ed. Vijf dagregisters van het Kasteel São Jorge da Mina (Elmina) aan de Goudkust (1645-1647). ‘s Gravenhage, 1953.Google Scholar
Todorov, T.Mikhaïl Bakhtine, le principe dialogique. Ecrits du Cercle de Bakhtine. Paris, 1981.Google Scholar
Villault de Bellefond, Nicolas. Relation des costes d'Afrique appellées Guinée. Paris, 1669.Google Scholar
Voloshinov, V. N.Frejdizm (Freudism). Moscow, 1927. (translated quotations in Todorov 1981)Google Scholar
Voloshinov, V. N.Marksizm i filosofija jazyka (Marxism and the Philosophy of Language). Leningrad, 1929. (translated quotations in Todorov 1981)Google Scholar