Hostname: page-component-78c5997874-v9fdk Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-11-17T16:17:19.151Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Bread or Circuses? Repoliticization in the Italian Populist Government Experience

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 April 2020

Gianfranco Baldini Open the ORCID record for Gianfranco Baldini [Opens in a new window]  and
Matteo F.N. Giglioli Open the ORCID record for Matteo F.N. Giglioli [Opens in a new window]
Gianfranco Baldini*
Affiliation:
Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
Matteo F.N. Giglioli
Affiliation:
Department of Political and Social Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy
*
*Corresponding author. Email: gianfranco.baldini2@unibo.it
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The majority view within political science is that populism is best understood as a (thin) ideology. We problematize the ideational approach by broadening the scope of analysis, linking populism to the rise of long-term generalized anti-political sentiments, against interpretations that tend to tie the populist wave to conjunctural factors related to recent crises. We argue that the essence of populism lies at the intersection of the ‘material constitution’ of advanced industrial democracies (that is, how macroeconomic governance relates to democratic decision-making) and the feelings of societal alienation that are at the heart of anti-political sentiments. We show the peculiar coexistence of economic turbulence, heralded by the crisis of the cartel party and of the neoliberal economic consensus, and an appeal to a post-democratic ‘virtual politics’ of performed but ineffectual popular sovereignty. The policies of the populist coalition governing Italy in 2018–19 provide a key case to test the relevance of our arguments.

Keywords

anti-politicsdepoliticization/repoliticizationvirtual politicsdemocracy
Type
Article
Information
Government and Opposition , Volume 56 , Issue 3 , July 2021 , pp. 505 - 524
Copyright
Copyright © The Author(s) 2020. Published by Government and Opposition Limited and Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Afonso, A (2015) Choosing Whom to Betray: Populist Right-Wing Parties, Welfare State Reforms and the Trade-Off between Office and Votes. European Political Science Review 7(2), 271–292.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Albertazzi, D, Giovannini, A and Seddone, A (2018) ‘No Regionalism Please, We Are Leghisti!’ The Transformation of the Italian Lega Nord under the Leadership of Matteo Salvini. Regional and Federal Studies 28(5), 645–671.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Arditi, B (2004) Populism as a Spectre of Democracy: A Response to Canovan. Political Studies 52(1), 135–143.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bailo, F (2019) Il successo della Lega, i media e le crisi migratorie. You Trend, www.youtrend.it/2019/11/06/il-successo-della-lega-i-media-e-le-crisi-migratorie.Google Scholar
Baldini, G and Giglioli, MFN (2019) Italy 2018: The Perfect Populist Storm? Parliamentary Affairs, published early online, January, https://doi.org/10.1093/pa/gsy052.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Baldini, M and Gori, C (2019) Il reddito di cittadinanza. il Mulino 2, 269–277.Google Scholar
Banca d'Italia (2020) Bollettino Economico, 1 January, https://www.bancaditalia.it/pubblicazioni/bollettino-economico/2020-1/index.html.Google Scholar
Blühdorn, I and Butzlaff, F (2019) Rethinking Populism: Peak Democracy, Liquid Identity and the Performance of Sovereignty. European Journal of Social Theory 22(2), 191–211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Bordignon, F, Ceccarini, L and Diamanti, I (2018) Le divergenze parallele. Bari: Laterza.Google Scholar
Branco, R, Cardoso, D, Guillén, A, Sacchi, S and Balbona, DL (2019) Here to Stay? Reversals of Structural Reforms in Southern Europe as the Crisis Wanes. South European Society and Politics 24(2), 205–232.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brubaker, R (2017) Why Populism? Theory and Society 46, 357–385.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Brunazzo, M and Gilbert, M (2017) Insurgents against Brussels: Euroscepticism and the Right-Wing Populist Turn of the Lega Nord since 2013. Journal of Modern Italian Studies 22(5), 624–641.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Canovan, M (2004) Populism for Political Theorists? Journal of Political Ideologies 9, 241–252.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Caramani, D (2017) Will vs. Reason: The Populist and Technocratic Forms of Political Representation and Their Critique to Party Government. American Political Science Review 111, 54–67.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cento Bull, A (2009) Lega Nord: A Case of Simulative Politics? South European Society and Politics 14(2), 129–146.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Clarke, N, Jennings, W and Moss, J (2018) The Good Politician: Political Interaction and the Rise of Anti-Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Codogno, L and Merler, S (2019) The Willing Suspension of Disbelief: The Contract for Government and the Budget. Contemporary Italian Politics 11(3), 294–309.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Corbetta, P, Colloca, P, Cavazza, N and Roccato, M (2018) Lega and Five-Star Movement Voters: Exploring the Role of Cultural, Economic and Political Bewilderment. Contemporary Italian Politics 10(3), 279–293.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Corso, L (2019) When Anti-Politics Becomes Political: What Can the Italian Five Star Movement Tell us about the Relationship Between Populism and Legalism. European Constitutional Law Review 15(3), 462–487.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Cotta, M (2019) Due governi e un pugile alle corde, personal blog, 8 August, http://mauriziocotta.it/blog/23/due-governi-e-un-pugile-alle-corde-maurizio-cotta-8-agosto-2019.Google Scholar
Culpepper, PD (2014) The Political Economy of Unmediated Democracy: Italian Austerity under Mario Monti. West European Politics 37(6), 1264–1281.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Emanuele, V and De Sio, L (2018) Il sondaggio CISE: priorità dei cittadini e strategie dei partiti verso Il voto. CISE, 14 February, https://cise.luiss.it/cise/2018/02/14/temi-del-dibattito-e-opportunita-elettorali-in-italiaGoogle Scholar
Fabbrini, S and Zgaga, T (2019) Italy and the European Union: The Discontinuity of the Conte Government. Contemporary Italian Politics 11(3), 280–293.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Ferrera, M and Jessoula, M (2015) The Welfare State: Pensions and Health Care. In Jones, E and Pasquino, G (eds), Oxford Handbook of Italian Politics. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 504–516.Google Scholar
Gallo, G and Sacchi, S (2019) Beneficiari e spesa del reddito di cittadinanza: una stima della misura finale. Inapp, Policy Brief 11, 1–5.Google Scholar
Geddes, A and Pettrachin, A (2020) Italian Migration Policy and Politics: Exacerbating Paradoxes. Contemporary Italian Politics, forthcoming.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Giugliano, F (2019) The Populist Revolution and the Fight Against Inequality: The Conte Government Between ‘Quota Cento’ and the ‘Citizens’ Income’. Contemporary Italian Politics 11(3), 324–335.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goldoni, M and Wilkinson, MA (2018) The Material Constitution. Modern Law Review 81(4), 567–597.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Grande, E, Schwarzbözl, T and Fatke, M (2019) Politicizing Immigration in Western Europe. Journal of European Public Policy 26(10), 1444–1463.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hall, B (2019) With Salvini on the Rise, Europe's Refugee Policy is Ever More Adrift. Financial Times, 25 August, www.ft.com/content/1af54e9a-c4fc-11e9-a8e9-296ca66511c9.Google Scholar
Hopkin, J and Blyth, M (2019) The Global Economics of European Populism: Growth Regimes and Party System Change in Europe. Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics 54(2), 193–225.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Horowitz, J (2018) Italy's Populist Parties Win Approval to Form Government. New York Times, 31 May, www.nytimes.com/2018/05/31/world/europe/italy-government-populists.html.Google Scholar
Jones, E (2019) Why European Democracies Are Struggling. Current History 118(806), 83–89.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Jones, E and Matthijs, M (2017) Democracy Without Solidarity: Political Dysfunction in Hard Times. Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics 52(2), 185–210.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Magnani, A (2019) Salvini contro la Ue sui migranti ma Macron ribadisce: ‘Approdo nel porto più vicino’. Il Sole 24 Ore, 22 July, www.ilsole24ore.com/art/migranti-parigi-vertice-la-distribuzione-ma-salvini-non-va-ACRj2Ka.Google Scholar
Mair, P (2014) Ruling the Void: The Hollowing-Out of Western Democracy, 2nd edn. London: Verso Books.Google Scholar
Marangoni, F and Verzichelli, L (2019) Goat-Stag, Chimera or Chameleon? The Formation and First Semester of the Conte Government. Contemporary Italian Politics 11(3), 263–279.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Massariolo, A (2019) I numeri ufficiali: nel 2019 sono stati rimpatriati 6.298 migranti. Il Bo Live, University of Padua, 5 December, https://ilbolive.unipd.it/it/migranti-rimpatriati-italia-2019.Google Scholar
McDonnell, D and Valbruzzi, M (2014) Defining and Classifying Technocrat-led and Technocratic Governments. European Journal of Political Research 53, 654–671.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mény, Y and Surel, Y (2000) Par le peuple, pour le peuple: le populisme et les démocraties. Paris: Fayard.Google Scholar
Mete, V (2010) Four Types of Anti-Politics: Insights from the Italian Case. Modern Italy 15, 37–61.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Morlino, L and Tarchi, M (1996) The Dissatisfied Society: The Roots of Political Change in Italy. European Journal of Political Research 30, 41–63.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mortati, C (1998 [1940]) La costituzione in senso materiale, Ristampa inalterata. (Ed. or 1940) Per la storia del pensiero giuridico moderno. Milan: Giuffrè.Google Scholar
Mosca, L and Tronconi, F (2019) Beyond Left and Right: The Eclectic Populism of the Five Star Movement. West European Politics 42(6), 1258–1283.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mudde, C (2004) The Populist Zeitgeist. Government and Opposition: An International Journal of Comparative Politics 39(4), 541–563.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nichols, T (2017) The Death of Expertise: The Campaign Against Established Knowledge and Why it Matters. New York: Oxford University Press.Google Scholar
Orsina, G (2018) La democrazia del narcisismo. Breve storia dell'antipolitica. Venice: Marsilio.Google Scholar
Ranci Ortigosa, E (2019) Il Reddito di Cittadinanza, Combinare più politiche, connettere più interventi. Fifth Welforum Seminar, 14 May.Google Scholar
Reichlin, P (2019) Economic Stagnation and Recession: The Difficult Italian Transition to the Monetary Union. Journal of Modern Italian Studies 24(3), 402–414.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rooduijn, M (2019) State of the Field: How to Study Populism and Adjacent Topics? A Plea for Both More and Less Focus. European Journal of Political Research 58, 362–372.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rovira Kaltwasser, C and Taggart, P (2016) Dealing with Populists in Government: A Framework for Analysis. Democratization 23, 201–220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Santana Pereira, J and Moury, C (2018) Planning the ‘Government of Change’: The 2018 Italian Coalition Agreement in Comparative Perspective. Italian Political Science 13(2), 92–103.Google Scholar
Sartori, G (1976) Parties and Party Systems: A Framework for Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Schlamp, H-J (2019) Das perfekte Feindbild, Spiegel, 1 July, www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/matteo-salvini-und-carola-rackete-showdown-in-italien-a-1275275.html.Google Scholar
Stanley, B (2017) Populism in Central and Eastern Europe. In Kaltwasser, CR, Taggart, P, Ochoa Espejo, P and Ostiguy, P (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Populism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 140–160.Google Scholar
Taggart, P (2017) Populism in Western Europe. In Kaltwasser, CR, Taggart, P, Ochoa Espejo, P and Ostiguy, P (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Populism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 248–263.Google Scholar
Tarchi, M (2013) Populism and Political Science: How to Get Rid of the ‘Cinderella Complex’. In Ghergina, S et al. (eds), Contemporary Populism. Cambridge: Cambridge Scholar, pp. 114–139.Google Scholar
Tarchi, M (2015) Italy: The Promised Land of Populism? Contemporary Italian Politics 7, 273–285.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Valbruzzi, M (2018) When Populists Meet Technocrats: The Italian Innovation in Government Formation. Journal of Modern Italian Studies 23(4), 460–480.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vines, E and Marsh, D (2017) Anti-Politics: Beyond Supply-Side Versus Demand-Side Explanations. British Politics 13(4), 433–453.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wood, M and Flinders, M (2014) Rethinking Depoliticisation: Beyond the Governmental. Policy and Politics 42, 151–170.Google Scholar
Zürn, M (2019) Politicization Compared: At National, European, and Global Levels. Journal of European Public Policy 26(7), 977–995.CrossRefGoogle Scholar