Skip to main content Accessibility help

For Conscience and Kingdom Martyrs, Monarchs and the Spirit of Modernity in Early Modern England

  • Clayton Fordahl (a1)


This article compares the collective commemoration of martyrs to ascertain changes in cultural understandings of the relationship between the ultimate sacrifice offered by an individual and monarchal violence. This historical comparison is used to argue that changes in the nature of Christianity transformed the popular interpretation of sovereign violence from a desecrative to a redemptive force. While cultural individualism and political statism appear in secularized modernity as contradictory impulses, their birth in early modernity was induced by coherent and entirely consistent religious worldview.

Cet article compare différentes commémorations collectives de martyrs pour préciser la manière dont se transforme la compréhension culturelle de la relation entre le sacrifice ultime d’un individu et la violence monarchique. Cette comparaison historique permet d’affirmer que des changements dans la nature de la chrétienté ont contribué à transformer l’interprétation populaire de la violence souveraine comme force profanatrice en une force rédemptrice. Alors que l’individualisme culturel et l’étatisme politique apparaissent dans la modernité sécularisée comme des impulsions contradictoires, leur naissance au début de la modernité a été induite par une vision du monde religieuse entièrement cohérente.

Dieser Beitrag vergleicht verschiedene, für Märtyrer organisierte, kollektive Gedenkfeiern, um darzustellen, auf welche Art und Weise kulturelle Verständnisse die Beziehung zwischen individueller Opferbereitschaft und monarchischer Gewalt verändern. Dieser historische Vergleich verdeutlicht, wie eine sich verändernde Konzeption des Christentums bei der Öffentlichkeit zu einer Neuinterpretation der Gewaltausübung eines Herrschers führt – von einer ruchlosen zu einer erlösenden Gewalt. Obwohl der kulturelle Individualismus und der politische Etatismus in der säkularisierten Moderne als sich widersprechende Impulse verstanden werden, geht ihre Entstehung zu Beginn der Moderne auf eine ganz kohärente, religiöse Weltvorstellung zurück.



Hide All

Acknowledgement: I am grateful to Bryan S. Turner, Saïd Arjomand, Daniel Levy, and Ian Roxborough for their time and valuable feedback. A debt is owed also to Berglind H. Ragnarsdóttir for reading and commenting on this article’s earlier drafts.



Hide All
Anderson, Perry, 1974. Lineages of the Absolutist State (New York, Verso).
Armstrong, Karen, 2015. Fields of Blood: Religion and the History of Violence (New York, Anchor Books).
Barlow, Frank, 1990. Thomas Becket (Berkeley, CA, University of California Press).
Bendix, Reinhard, 1978. Kings or People: Power and the Mandate to Rule (Berkeley, CA, University of California Press).
Black, J. H., ed., 1846. The Life and Martyrdom of Thomas Beket, Archbishop of Canterbury, From the Series of Lives and Legends Now Proved to Have Been Composed By Robert of Gloucester in Early English Poetry and Ballads, and Popular Literature of the Middle Ages, Vol. XIX (London, Printed for the Percy Society by T. Richards).
Bodin, Jean, 1992. On Sovereignty (Cambridge Texts on Political Theory), edited by Franklin, Julian H. (New York, Cambridge University Press).
Cantor, Norman F., 1994. The Civilization of the Middle Ages: A Completely Revised and Expanded Edition of Medieval History (New York, Harper Perennial).
Cavanaugh, William T., 1995. “‘A Fire Strong Enough to Consume the House’: The Wars of Religion and the Rise of the State”, Modern Theology, 11 (4): 397-420.
Cheney, Mary G., 1941. “The Compromise of Avranches of 1172 and the Spread of Canon Law”, English Historical Review, 56 (222): 177-197.
Donne, John, 1610. Pseudo-martyr: Wherein, Out of Certaine Propositions and Gradations, This Conclusion Is Evicted, That Those Which Are of the Romane Religion in This Kingdome, may and ought to take The Oath Of Allegiance (London, W. Stansby for Walter Burre).
Elias, Norbert, 1982. Power and Civility: The Civilizing Process, Pt. II (New York, Pantheon).
Foucault, Michel, 1990. The History of Sexuality, Volume I (New York, Vintage).
Foxe, John, 1576. “The Unabridged Acts and Monuments Online or TAMO (1576 edition)”, HRI Online Publications, Sheffield, 2011. Retrieved September 20, 2017 (
Giddens, Anthony, 1990. The Consequences of Modernity (Palo Alto, Stanford University Press).
Giles, J. A., ed., 1846. The Life and Letters of Thomas à Becket, now first gathered from Contemporary Historians, Volume II (London, Whitacker & Co).
Gorski, Philip, 2003. The Disciplinary Revolution: Calvinism and the Rise of the State in Early Modern Europe (Chicago, University of Chicago Press).
Guy, John, 2012. Thomas Becket: Warrior, Priest, Rebel (New York, Random House).
Hobbes, Thomas, 1982. Leviathan (New York, Penguin Classics).
Internet Medieval Sourcebook. 1998. “Roger of Hovedon: The Chronicle: On the Disputes Between Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury and King Henry II of England.” The Bronx, NY: Fordham University. Retrieved September 19, 2017 (
Jones, Thomas M., ed., 1970. The Becket Controversy (New York, John Wiley and Sons).
Lilla, Mark, 2008. The Stillborn God: Religion, Politics, and the Modern West (New York, Vintage).
Magnusson, Eríkur, ed., 1883. Thómas Saga Erkibyskups: A Life of Archbishop Thomas Becket in Icelandic, Volume II (London, Longman & Co.).
Moore, Barrington Jr., 1987. Authority and Inequality under Capitalism and Socialism (Oxford, Clarendon Press).
Murray, Douglas, 2017. The Strange Death of Europe: Immigration, Identity, Islam (London, Bloomsbury Continuum).
Nederman, Cary J., ed., 1990. Policraticus: On the Frivolities of Courtiers and the Footprints of Philosophers (New York, Cambridge University Press).
Nederman, Cary J., 2015. “John of Salisbury’s Political Theory,” in Grellard, Christophe and Lachaud, Frederique, A Companion to John of Salisbury (Boston, Brill: 258-288).
Pinker, Steven, 2011. The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined (New York, Penguin).
Pollock, Frederick and Maitland, Frederic William., 1889. The History of English Law Before Edward I, Volume I (Cambridge, Little, Brown & Company).
Prudlo, Donald S., 2011. “Martyrs on the Move: the Spread of the Cults of Thomas of Canterbury and Peter of Verona”, Peregrinations: Journal of Medieval Art and Architecture, 3 (2): 32-62.
Reinhard, Wolfgang, 1989. “Reformation, Counter-Reformation, and the Early Modern State A Reassessment”, The Catholic Historical Review, 75 (3): 383-404.
Reynolds, E. E., ed., 1963. The Lives of Saint Thomas More by William Roper and Nicholas Harspfield (London, Everyman’s Library).
Robertston, William Craigie, ed., 1876. Materials for the History of Thomas Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury, Volume II (Benedict of Peterborough, John of Salisbury, Alan of Tewksbury, Edward Grim) (London, Longman & Co).
Schama, Simon, 2002. A History of Britain: At the Edge of the World? 3000 BC–1603 ad (London, BBC Books).
Shklar, Judith, 1989. “The Liberalism of Fear” in Liberalism and the Moral Life, edited by Rosenblum, Nancy L. (Cambridge, Harvard University Press: 21-38).
Smith, Lacey Baldwin, 1999. Fools, Martyrs, Traitors: The Story of Martyrdom in the Western World (Chicago, IL, Northwestern University Press).
Solt, Leo F., 1990. Church and State in Early Modern England, 1509-1640 (New York, Oxford University Press).
Spruyt, Hendrik, 1996. The Sovereign State and Its Competitors: An Analysis of Systems of Change (Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press).
Stevenson, Joseph, trans., 1856. William of Newburgh. The Church Historians of England, Vol. IV, Part II (London, Seeley’s).
Strayer, Joseph R., 1970. On the Medieval Origins of the Modern State (Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press).
Tilly, Charles, 1992. Coercion, Capital, and European States: AD 990-1992 (Cambridge, MA, Blackwell).
Turner, Bryan S., 2013. The Religious and the Political: A Comparative Sociology of Religion (New York, Cambridge University Press).
Wallerstein, Immanuel, 2011. The Modern World-System I: Capitalist Agriculture and the Origins of the European World-Economy in the Sixteenth Century (Berkeley, CA, University of California Press).
Weiler, Björn, 2009. “Kings and Sons: Princely Rebellions and the Structures of Revolt in Western Europe, c. 1170-1280”, Historical Research, 82 (215): 17-40.



Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed