INTRODUCTION
Verotoxigenic Escherichia coli (VTEC) is a major zoonotic pathogen worldwide, with the serotype O157:H7 the most frequently isolated from outbreaks and severe human disease [Reference Karch, Tarr and Bielaszewska1]. The first cases of infection by VTEC in humans in Sweden were reported in the mid-1990s and infection with VTEC O157:H7 has been a notifiable disease since 1996. In 2004, all serotypes of VTEC were included in the official notification system and the number of reported cases of human VTEC infection during 2004–2009 has varied between 196 and 385 cases per year (www.smittskyddsinstitutet.se). Of these cases, about half have been reported as serotype O157:H7. In 50–80% of cases, infection is contracted within Sweden, with the highest number occurring during the summer months. Geographically the number of reported cases varies significantly, with the majority of cases reported from the west coast and particularly from the county of Halland (www.smittskyddsinstitutet.se).
Ruminants, and especially cattle, are asymptomatic carriers of VTEC O157:H7 (reviewed by Gyles [Reference Gyles2]), and there is evidence of association between cattle and farm density and human infection in a region [Reference Kistemann3]. Studies in Sweden have shown that 3·4% of cattle carry VTEC O157:H7 in faeces at slaughter [Reference Boqvist, Aspán and Eriksson4]. Of these, most are younger animals [Reference Boqvist, Aspán and Eriksson4, Reference Albihn5]. It has also been shown that about 12% of cattle presented for slaughter carry VTEC O157:H7 on the hide [Reference Boqvist, Aspán and Eriksson4]. In a prevalence study performed on dairy cattle farms between 1998 and 2002, VTEC O157:H7 was detected in 8·9% of all sampled herds. The bacterium was more commonly found in cattle sampled in the south and central Sweden, but there were no findings from the north of Sweden. The highest prevalence was found in the county of Halland, where 23% of the dairy herds were positive [Reference Eriksson6].
Sources of human infection include direct contact with animals, contaminated food, e.g. unpasteurized milk and meat, contaminated water, and person-to-person contact [Reference Karch, Tarr and Bielaszewska1]. The infectious dose for VTEC O157:H7 is very low and it may suffice to ingest <100 bacteria for disease to develop (reviewed by Karch et al. [Reference Karch, Tarr and Bielaszewska1]). Clinical manifestations vary from no symptoms at all to mild watery diarrhoea that may develop to severe bloody diarrhoea [Reference Mead and Griffin7]. The diarrhoea may be followed by complications such as haemolytic uraemic syndrome (HUS) and thrombotic thrombocytopaenic purpura (TTP) [Reference Mead and Griffin7]. Serious illness is more frequent in children [Reference Tarr, Gordon and Chandler8].
The pathogenicity of VTEC O157:H7 derives from virulence-associated genes acquired by the bacteria through horizontal gene transfer [Reference Kelly, Vespermann and Bolton9]. A principal virulence factor of VTEC O157:H7 is the ability to produce verotoxins (VTs) [Reference Yoon and Hovde10]. Several other virulence factors are known, including genes conferring the ability to cause attaching-effacing lesions, other factors encoded in the locus of enterocyte effacement (LEE) and genes on the large virulence plasmid pO157 [Reference Yoon and Hovde10]. To date there is no comprehensive definition of which virulence determinants are necessary for VTEC to cause disease in humans [11].
Retrospective typing studies performed on Swedish cattle strains of VTEC O157:H7 (n=200) isolated during 1996–2002 have revealed that the strains, isolated from randomly sampled cattle in prevalence studies, demonstrated great diversity regarding phage types, verotoxin subtypes and pulsed field electrophoresis (PFGE) patterns [Reference Aspán and Eriksson12]. Conversely, strains that were isolated from cattle farms that had been linked to human cases of illness during 1996–2002 presented a more homogenous pattern. Among these strains a specific predominating group of strains was identified, which were of phage type (PT)4, carried two verotoxin genes (vtx 2 and vtx 2c) and had similar PFGE profiles. This group of strains, hereafter called VTEC O157:H7 (PT4;vtx 2,vtx 2c), was isolated on 16/18 farms linked to human cases of VTEC O157 infection [Reference Aspán and Eriksson12]. Moreover, VTEC O157:H7 (PT4;vtx 2;vtx 2c) strains isolated during 2001–2008 accounted for more than two thirds of human VTEC O157 cases in Sweden [S. Löfdahl, Swedish Institute of Infectious Disease Control (SMI), personal communication].
In the present study we investigated the repertoire of virulence factors in a subset of isolates from the above-mentioned retrospective studies performed by Aspán & Eriksson [Reference Aspán and Eriksson12], to investigate the distribution of known and suspected virulence determinants in Swedish VTEC O157:H7 cattle strains. Of particular interest was whether the virulence gene profile of the isolates from the prevalence studies would differ from the virulence profile of the more homogenous group of VTEC O157:H7 strains isolated from farms associated with human VTEC cases, which were assayed using the same methods. Most of these isolates were VTEC O157:H7 (PT4;vtx 2;vtx 2c). Such information is of great importance to characterize the findings of VTEC O157:H7 in primary production systems and in food products, specifically in order to predict whether a strain that has been isolated is likely to cause serious human illness.
DNA microarray technology enables the simultaneous detection of a large number of target sequences. For pathogenic E. coli as well as many other bacteria, different low-density arrays with comparatively few but relevant target genes have been successfully used to profile the presence of virulence factors and other genetic markers [Reference Bruant13–Reference Afset17]. This type of assay requires comparatively simple equipment and data analysis, and is thereby well suited for high throughput use and routine diagnostics. In the studies described here we employed a commercially available microtube array system containing 124 E. coli gene probes in duplicate, including controls, designed to detect virulence genes in E. coli of various pathotypes.
METHODS
Bacterial strains and DNA extraction
Bacterial strains were stored in glycerol stocks at −70°C at the National Veterinary Institute (Uppsala, Sweden) since isolation. Thirty-two isolates were included from a Swedish dairy cattle prevalence study of VTEC O15:H7 performed during 1998–2000 [Reference Eriksson6], with one strain representing each farm on which VTEC O157:H7 was detected in the study, excluding one farm for which the representing isolate was lost in storage. Thirteen isolates were available from the seven different farms in Sweden where human VTEC infection had been confirmed, arising either from direct or indirect contact with livestock on those farms during the same time period (1998–2000), and where human and livestock strains had been linked by comparison of verotoxin gene profiles and PFGE [Reference Aspán and Eriksson12]. The geographical origin of the isolates is presented in Figures 1 and 2. Finally, five different well characterized E. coli strains with different virulence gene profiles were analysed. These included two strains of VTEC O157, CCUG (Culture Collection, University of Gothenburg) 42744 (E. coli O157 vtx 1+, vtx 2+, eaeA +, EHEC-hlyA +, fliC +) and CCUG 42901 (E. coli O157 vtx 1−, vtx 2−, eaeA −, EHEC-hlyA −, and fliC −), and three ETEC strains; one O101 carrying genes for STa, F41 and F5/K99, one O141 carrying genes for STa, STb, VT2e and F18, and one O149 carrying genes for EAST1, STa, STb, LT, F6/987P, and F4/K88, as determined by conventional PCR analysis. DNA extraction was performed by boiling colonies in PCR grade water and using the lysates for BioRobot EZ1 DNA extraction (Qiagen, Austria).
Fig. 1. Map of the southern part of Sweden detailing the geographic origin of isolates. The VTEC O157:H7 isolates analysed were from the counties of Gävleborg (X), Uppsala (C), Södermanland (D), Värmland (S), Gotland (I), Kalmar (H), Skåne (M), Kronoberg (G), Jönköping (F), Halland (N) and what is currently Västra Götaland county, with the historical subregions of Bohuslän (O), Skaraborg (R) and Älvsborg (P). The location of the seven farms (F1–F7) where livestock VTEC O157:H7 caused cases of disease in humans during the same period are indicated by black dots (•).
Fig. 2. PFGE patterns, phage types, virulence (vir.) types and geographic origin of studied isolates. UPGMA dendrogram based on XbaI restriction patterns using the Dice algorithm. RDNC=Reacts, but does not conform. Farm of origin is presented for isolates associated with human cases of illness.
Characterization of strains
Virulence typing was performed by PCR to identify genes encoding VT1 and VT2 (vtx 1 and vtx 2), intimin (eaeA) and EHEC-haemolysin (EHEC-hlyA) according to Paton & Paton [Reference Paton and Paton18] and H7 (fliC) according to Gannon et al. [Reference Gannon19]. VT2-positive isolates were further investigated by PCR–RFLP to determine the VT2 gene subtype, as described by Pierard et al. [Reference Pierard20].
Seven E. coli virulence determinants were analysed by PCR according to harmonized protocols developed in Work Package (WP)26 – ‘virulotyping of Salmonella and E. coli’ of the MedVetNet project (www.medvetnet.org), with primers developed in WP26 or adopted from the literature: efa-1 5′-region, efa-1 3′-region [Reference Morabito21], icf, sodC, tccP [Reference Garmendia22], ureA [Reference Friedrich23] and terB [Reference Taylor24]. The primer sequences are presented in Table 1. Each PCR reaction consisted of 0·5 U of AmpliTaq Gold polymerase, 1× GeneAmpPCR buffer II, 0·1 m of each dNTP, 2·25 mm MgCl2, (all from Applied Biosystems, USA), each primer at 0·27 μm, 5 μl DNA template, and PCR grade water up to a final volume of 25 μl. The PCR programmes were for efa-1 5′, sodC and terB: 94°C for 5 min, 30 cycles at 94°C for 30 s, 55°C for 30 s (annealing) and 72°C for 1 min, and finally 72°C for 7 min. For efa-1 3′ and tccP the same programme was used but with 58°C annealing temperature, icf annealing temperature 56°C, ureA annealing temperature 63°C. The presence and size of PCR products were analysed by submarine electrophoresis on 1·5% agarose gels supplemented with ethidium bromide.
Table 1. Primer sequences
* Variable.
Phage-typing using published methods [Reference Ahmed25, Reference Khakhria, Duck and Lior26] was performed at the Laboratory of Enteric Pathogens (Central Public Health Laboratory, London, England). PFGE was performed as described previously [Reference Albihn5].
Microarrays (Identibac Ec v. 3) containing 124 E. coli virulence gene probes including controls were purchased from Identibac (New Haw, UK) and used according to the manufacturer's instructions. Array images were processed in IconoClust 3.0 (Clondiag, Germany), and signals were analysed using the gapA-positive control gene for normalization and with cut-offs as recommended by the manufacturer (>0·4=present, 0·4 to 0·3=ambiguous, <0·3=absent, relative to the gapA signal). Probes which produced ambiguous signals, mostly representing duplicates targeting known variants of the same gene, were excluded from further analysis, excluded probes are indicated in the Supplementary Appendix (available online). Genes were considered present in the isolate if at least one well-performing probe gave a positive signal.
Statistical association between belonging to a given virulence gene type and belonging to the group of isolates with known links to human disease was tested using two-sided Fisher's exact test implemented in R 2.7.1 (r-project.org). Association between possession of a virulence gene and belonging to a given phage type/virulence gene type was tested as above. For statistical testing, identical duplicate isolates from the same farm were treated as single. A P value of ⩽0·05 was considered significant.
RESULTS
PCR detection of virulence genes
For a summary of results, see Figures 2 and 3. All cattle isolates (n=32) were positive for fliC (H7), vtx 2, eaeA, hlyA, sodC, terB, ureA, and the 5′-region of efa-1. All cattle isolates were also positive for tccP, with PCR product sizes exceeding the expected 1154 bp for the isolates Bd7146/00, Bd7151/00 and PN188/98, and PCR products of <1154 bp for PN643/99, PN1095/99, PN1217/00, PN1376/00, PN431/98 and PN746/99. All isolates were negative for the 3′-region of efa-1. icf was present in the majority of the cattle isolates, while absent in PN1599/00, PN500/99, PN559/99, PN715/99 and PN905/99. vtx 1 was present in 21 of the cattle isolates. PCR results for control strains are presented in Table 2.
Fig. 3. Virulence genes in Swedish VTEC O157:H7. Definition of virulence types based on present genes/gene variants (•) as determined by (A) PCR–RFLP according to Pierard et al. [Reference Pierard20]. (B) Multiplex PCR according to Paton & Paton [Reference Paton and Paton18]. (C) PCR according to the MedVetNet WP26 PCR protocol. (D) Identibac Ec v. 3 microarray assay. Only genes positive for at least one VTEC O157:H7 strain are shown. Percentage of isolates carrying each gene was calculated based on the prevalence study isolates (n=32).
Table 2. Virulence genes in control strains
Microarray analysis
For two genes, astA (EAST1) and espA, no well-performing probe was found, and these genes were therefore excluded from further analysis. All VTEC O157:H7 isolates tested positive for vtx 2AB, eaeA, hlyA, tccP, tir, katP, etpD, espF, espJ, toxB, iha, nleA, nleB and nleC, while vtx 1A, cdtB, espP, iss and cba were variably absent or present. For detailed results, see Figures 2 and 3. Full probe-level results are available in the Supplementary Appendix. Genes known from previous characterization to be present in positive control strains and which were represented on the array (eaeA, hlyA, vtx 1, vtx 2, sta, stb, fanA, fim41a, lthA, fasA, fedA, fedF, K88) were successfully detected, while not detected in control strains known not to carry the genes. All E. coli isolates were positive for the control genes gad and ihfA. Microarray results for the control strains are presented in Table 2.
Virulence types
Based on the absence or presence of virulence genes and gene variants, the cattle isolates were assigned to eight different virulence types coded by roman numerals (see Fig. 3 for details). All pairs of isolates from the same farm had the same virulence type. Virulence type I was highly significantly associated with the group of isolates linked to human disease cases compared to all other virulence types grouped (P=0·012). Virulence type I/PT4 was significantly associated with the presence of two vtx gene variants (vtx 2 and vtx 2c) compared to all other types (P<0·001). Apart from the previously noted association between the county of Halland and the (PT4;vtx 2,vtx 2c) variant [Reference Aspán and Eriksson12] shown here to belong to virulence type I, no obvious connection between geographic origin and virulence type was observed. As evident in Figure 2, all isolates of PT2 and PT4 and most isolates of PT14 had identical virulence gene types and similar PFGE patterns within each group, while PT8 isolates and isolates not corresponding to known phage types (RDNC, ‘reacts but does not conform’) were more variable. The association between virulence type III, with the majority of the PT14 isolates included in the study, and cdtB was statistically significant (P<0·001), as was the association between PT2/virulence type II and iss (P=0·004). However, in the latter case this was based on only two independent observations.
DISCUSSION
A highly topical question concerning VTEC O157:H7 is highlighted in this study, namely: which virulence factors are found in human pathogenic strains of VTEC O157:H7, and to what extent are these factors found in the average strain found in the cattle reservoir? Improved knowledge in this area can, at an early stage such as in primary production or later in the food chain, predict whether strains of VTEC O157:H7 are more or less likely to cause disease in humans. In this way, targeted intervention measures can be deployed at an early stage and thereby reduce the risk of spread of highly pathogenic VTEC O157:H7.
Using combined data from PCR and microarray analysis we have found a well-conserved core set of virulence genes in all VTEC O157:H7 isolates investigated. Apart from the verotoxins, all isolates carried the LEE-associated genes for intimin, the translocated intimin receptor (tir) and the effector protein gene espF. From the large virulence plasmid pO157, in addition to haemolysin (hlyA) the genes for catalase/peroxidase P (katP), the type II secretion pathway related protein gene etpD, and toxin B (toxB) were detected in all isolates. One further pO157 virulence gene, the serine protease gene espP, was indicated by microarray analysis to be present in all isolates except three, all of which were PT8 and none of which were associated with human disease cases. This suggests that these isolates do carry the large virulence plasmid, but with sequence divergence or a deletion. Brunder et al. [Reference Brunder27] found espP in all of 63 non-sorbitol-fermenting human VTEC O157:H7/H− isolates by colony blot hybridization, two of which were PCR negative due to a partially deleted espP gene in the first and an insertion sequence in the second, showing that substantial alterations to the espP gene does not render the bacteria incapable of causing human infections.
All isolates tested positive for the genes tccP, by both microarray and PCR, as well as espJ by microarray only, both of which are described as located on the prophage CP-933U. This is in agreement with the results of Garmendia and co-workers [Reference Garmendia22], who investigated 365 O157:H7 isolates from several countries on different continents and found all to be tccP +/espJ +. Furthermore, we noted variant tccP gene sizes for nine isolates, all PT8 and two of which (Bd7146/00 and Bd7151/00) have been implicated in causing human illness. Again this is in agreement with the findings of others that strains with gene size variations due to different numbers of proline-rich repeat elements encoded in this gene can infect humans [Reference Garmendia22]. Similarly co-located on O157:H7 genomic islands are the tellurite resistance gene terB, the urease ureA and the adhesin iha [Reference Taylor24], all of which were consistently positive in the assayed cattle isolates. Interestingly, these three genes were either all present or all absent in the non-O157 control strains.
The efa-1 gene appears to generally be truncated in non-sorbitol-fermenting O157:H7 strains [Reference Toth28], and in the present study PCR analysis could not detect the 3′-region of the gene in any isolate, while the 5′-region was present in all O157:H7 cattle strains. The efa-1 gene is also represented on the microarray, targeting a part of the 3′-region absent in EDL933. As expected, this probe also produced negative results for all isolates. The adhesion factor lpfA was found in the control strain CCUG 42901, but not in the O157:H7 cattle isolates. This was not surprising as the lpfA probe of this microarray system is designed against AY057066 which corresponds to LpfAO113, while O157:H7 isolates generally carry LpfAO157/OI-141 and LpfAO157/OI-154 [Reference Toma29].
A few additional genes were variably absent or present: the icf (paa) gene, known to participate in O157:H7 cell adhesion in model systems [Reference Ho30], was absent in four isolates, all of PT8 and none related to human cases of disease. Additionally, in a few strains that were tested using the arrays we detected genes not traditionally associated with VTEC O157:H7 pathogenicity. Cytolethal distending toxin has been described as highly prevalent in sorbitol-fermenting VTEC O157:NM strains [Reference Friedrich31], and has been found in atypical eae-negative O157 [Reference Toth28]. In O157:H7, cdt has previously been described as most common in phage types 34 and 14, while rare in phage types 4, 8 and 2, and was shown to be significantly more common in clinical isolates from patients with diarrhoea than in patients with HUS or asymptomatic carriers [Reference Friedrich31]. In the present study, six PT14 isolates out of seven, all from different, geographically dispersed farms, but with similar PFGE patterns, tested positive for cdtB. We found the gene coding for increased serum survival (iss) in a single PT8 isolate and all three PT2 isolates assayed, two of which were linked to human illness. Increased serum survival exists in several plasmid-encoded and chromosomal variants, and mediates complement resistance. It has been implicated as a key virulence determinant for avian extraintestinal E. coli infection and neonatal meningitis-associated E. coli [Reference Johnson, Wannemuehler and Nolan32], but has to our knowledge no known association with enteric disease. The plasmid-carried colicin B (cba) was present in a few otherwise unrelated strains, one PT8 and one RDNC, as well as in the control strains CCUG 42744, 853/67 and 60/84.
The majority of the isolates related to human cases of disease investigated in this study were of the (PT4,vtx 2+,vtx 2c+) variant which is known to frequently cause severe illness in Sweden. All these isolates had identical virulence gene profiles, and the same were present in all PT4 isolates assayed. This further strengthens previous conclusions based on PFGE that these hyper-virulent strains form a distinct genetic group. However, although the isolates belonging to the (PT4,vtx 2+,vtx 2c+) group shared a unique virulence type, these isolates did not carry any distinguishing genes to explain the high virulence of this variant. Neither could we identify any distinguishing feature separating all isolates with connection to human cases of illness from the prevalence study isolates. The particular virulence of certain VTEC O157:H7 might well depend on some key virulence trait not covered by the comparatively limited set of genes investigated in this study, there is also evidence that certain groups of VTEC O157:H7 strains have higher gene expression of key virulence factors and that these differences are correlated to different prevalence in human and cattle hosts [Reference Vanaja33, Reference Zhang34]. Screening the cattle population for strains with potentially higher virulence might thereby have to rely on detection of regulatory elements or clonal markers identifying known high-virulence genogroups rather than detection of the presence of the virulence genes themselves.
The opportunity to compare data with PCR systems for a number of key VTEC virulence determinants also allowed us to evaluate the employed microarray system for routine characterization of VTEC isolates. Where comparison was possible the microarray performed well, with full and consistent agreement between PCR and the microarray for vtx 1, vtx 2, hlyA, eaeA and tccP. We additionally detected a substantial number of expected virulence genes in non-O157 control strains.
In conclusion, we have investigated the virulence gene profile of 32 VTEC O157:H7 cattle isolates from a prevalence study and 13 cattle isolates with strong epidemiological links to cases of human disease using DNA microarray analysis complemented by PCR assays. We have found a remarkably well-conserved core set of 18 virulence factors in all assayed isolates, while only a small number of genes were variably absent or present. This suggests that a majority of VTEC O157:H7 bacteria found in Swedish cattle carry a broad virulence gene repertoire and should be considered a potential threat to human health. Most isolates associated with known human disease cases had identical virulence gene profiles, but we found no particular genetic trait to explain the increased virulence of this genotype. The identification of such markers will be the objective of further study.
NOTE
Supplementary material accompanies this paper on the Journal's website (http://journals.cambridge.org/hyg).
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This study was financially supported by the Ivar and Elsa Sandberg Foundation. The authors thank Eva Saarinen, Lisa Lindberg and Griselda Loreto-Palma for excellent technical assistance.
DECLARATION OF INTEREST
None.
