Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-zzh7m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-25T09:47:56.577Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Ensuring Elderly Well-Being During COVID-19 by Using the Internet of Things

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  22 October 2020

Prateek Pandey
Affiliation:
JAYPEE University of Engineering and Technology, Raghogarh, Guna, India
Ratnesh Litoriya*
Affiliation:
JAYPEE University of Engineering and Technology, Raghogarh, Guna, India
*
Correspondence and reprint requests to Ratnesh Litoriya, ATS-1-I-56, JUET Campus, Raghogarh, Guna (Madhya Pradesh), India (e-mail: litoriya.ratnesh@gmail.com).
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) cases continue to surge, and the world must learn from this disaster. Most of the world economies are shattered due to this pandemic. The development of infrastructure to counter such deadly viral attacks in the future is the wisest investment that can be made. The elderly population is the most vulnerable age group affected by the pandemic, and the threat to their lives becomes manifold if they are living alone. Thus, a well-formed elderly support framework is required to safeguard this vulnerable population from COVID-like disasters in the future. We report here on the research findings we conducted by laying out a mitigation system for elderly well-being during disastrous times. The proposed system demands a sound collaboration between software, hardware devices, the state, and social agencies.

Type
Concepts in Disaster Medicine
Creative Commons
Creative Common License - CCCreative Common License - BY
This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Copyright
Copyright © 2020 Society for Disaster Medicine and Public Health, Inc.

As per the World Health Organization (WHO), 1 coronavirus disease (COVID-19) cases continue to surge, and the world must learn from this disaster. Most of the world economies are shattered due to this pandemic. The development of infrastructure to counter such deadly viral attacks in the future is the wisest investment that can be made. Another report from the WHO 2 indicates that the elderly population is the most vulnerable age group affected by the pandemic, and the threat to their lives becomes manifold if they are living alone. Thus, a well-formed elderly support framework is required to safeguard this vulnerable population from COVID-like disasters in the future. We report here on the research findings we conducted by laying out a mitigation system for elderly well-being during disastrous times. The proposed system demands a sound collaboration between software, hardware devices, the state, and social agencies. Due to lockdown around the country and, therefore, the unavailability of the university’s resources, the presented outcomes are based on a pilot study conducted on only 1 elderly subject; however, the authors are determined to continue their research once life returns to “normal.”

We asked elderly subjects (69 years of age) to push a button on a custom-made mobile app when needing to buy important items from the market. The app was specially designed for keeping the cognitive limitations of older adults in mind. On pressing the button, an appropriate message would be sent to a cloud-based service, and the nearest lockdown volunteer was informed through the app and social-media services installed on his/her mobile. This simple but effective socio-technical system helped maintain social distancing norms and the well-being of the elderly subject in trying times. As a consequence of using technologies such as artificial intelligence (AI) and the Internet of things (IoT) in elderly care, the longevity of people can be increased. Reference Zelenkauskaite, Bessis, Sotiriadis and Asimakopoulou3-Reference Zelenkauskaite, Bessis, Sotiriadis and Asimakopoulou5

The IoT concept can be understood as an ecosystem of interconnected computing devices, machines, objects, or people equipped with unique identifiers. It has the data transmission ability over a network without entailing human-to-human or human-to-computer interaction. Reference Lee and Lee6

AI is a wide-ranging branch of computer science that refers to the simulation of human intelligence in machines that are programmed to think like humans and imitate their actions. Reference Lemaignan, Warnier and Sisbot7 AI is an interdisciplinary technology that incorporates multiple approaches for decision making. Reference Pandey and Litoriya8-Reference Prateek and Ratnesh10 When it comes to combining IoT and AI in different applications, including disaster prevention and elderly care, chances are together, and they will perk up operational efficiency in this field. Reference Marr11 Soe Ye Yint Tun et al. Reference Pandey, Litoriya and Pandey12 provide a wide-ranging overview of IoT and wearable technologies’ applications, including the data type collected and the types of devices for elderly health care. Elena et al. Reference Borelli, Paolini and Antoniazzi13 presented an IoT-based framework aiming at developing smart devices to support older adults living alone. Most of the similar solutions are reactive and require some kind of wearable gadgets to be worn by the elderly all the time or surveillance cameras to be installed around their personal space.

We used this technology a bit differently in that we installed 3 motion sensors in the subject’s house, which tracked the movement of the individual, using an android app installed on the subject’s mobile phone. As a result, the subject did not have to wear any gadgets on the wrist or around the neck, and also there was no need for video surveillance, which can be a violation of their privacy rights. As a backup plan, the IoT-based system sends an “OK” signal after a regular interval. If the system somehow fails or breaks, then the receiver system doesn’t receive the “OK” signal from the subject’s accommodation, and the volunteers are informed to contact the subject to assure its well-being and to fix the broken system.

Actions of the elderly around the day are recorded for further analysis. We defined “Wf,” the well-being factor, as a function of the movements an elderly individual performed in his house. A move is considered a signal of well-being, in general; however, if an activity is not found in the expected time frame, this doesn’t necessarily mean that the subject is in trouble. The subject’s health credentials and medication he is on play an essential role in decision making. Such health credentials were recorded on a locally made blockchain network for this research project. Reference Prateek and Ratnesh14

Blockchain technology facilitates distributed public ledgers that hold immutable data in an encrypted and secure way. 15 Here, the block is made up of digital pieces of information shared across a network of computers. Records are immutable, and once a record has been added to the chain, it is tough to change. Blockchains have been used to securely circulate virtual currencies like bitcoin, but many other possible use-cases are emerging. Reference Zhang, Schmidt, White and Lenz16-Reference Prateek and Ratnesh18

The information available on the blockchain has 2 fields of interest: disease and behavior. Thus, the well-being factor of an elderly is defined as W f  = f(Ø A , θ H ), where Ø A represents the statement of activeness relative to the general activity shown by the elderly in the past few days, θ H being the statement of the health of the elderly, which is acquired from the electronic health records available on a blockchain.

If the subject does not show activity in the expected time frame (say between 4:00 AM and 5:30 AM) but is currently on anti-depressant medication with “drowsiness,” an extended 30 minutes margin can safely be added on both sides of the time frame. In another case, if the subject doesn’t show any movement and is on a diuretic medication (indicated by frequent use of the washroom facility), this is considered an alarming situation, and the social volunteers are informed through various means. In such cases, the expected time frame must be contracted (say about 30 minutes) from both sides. For demonstration purposes, the 8 time frames of 3 hours each are created and presented in Table 1.

TABLE 1 Time Frame Activity Demonstration

**Activities include the aggregated data collected from all the 3 sensors with respect to a particular time frame.

***Motion sensors are installed near the washroom facility, TV room, and kitchen.

Table 1 demonstrates that the subject today is about 11.5% less active. Whether the decline in activity by 11.5% is a cause for worry or just a usual variation is determined according to the national health policies. The same can be recorded in a policy file (policy.json) in the proposed system. Other parameters to be included in a policy file are the min_act_dif_bel, which implies the minimum activity difference threshold below which, if the subject shows inactivity, the concerns will be addressed. Similarly, min_act_dif_abo is the threshold above which, if the subject shows activity, the concerns will be addressed. If the min_act_dif_bel property is set to 3, then on the 11th day, the volunteers will be called for the inactivity in the third time frame, but the same will not be called for the fourth time frame. While setting the limits to these properties, the age and the health status of the subject should also be considered.

Figure 1 shows the distribution of activities during the 8 time slots performed by the elderly subject in the first 10 days. The volunteers received an emergency alert during the ninth day from the subject’s device, which is also evident by looking at the 09-12 time slot in Figure 1, where most of the activity values lie above the mid-way mark, and only some (actually 1) falls. On inquiring about the subject, we were informed that the subject felt uneasy and tired, and nothing serious was there. Thus, this unusual activity performing pattern of the subject resulted in a true alarm being generated. We observed several false alarms in the first few days, but the system started demonstrating gradual improvement in performance after the early 10 days of learning was over.

FIGURE 1 Box Plot Activity Pattern After 10 Days of Monitoring.

Based on the intimation alarms generated in the first 60 days of the pilot study, as shown in Table 2, the authors observed that the number of false positives (ie, the report that the subject was sick when actually healthy and active) totaled 65, and the number of false negatives (ie, the subject was reported as healthy when actually sick) totaled 31. The number of true positives (ie, the subject was reported as sick when actually sick) was observed as 14. The number of true negatives (ie, the subject was reported as healthy when actually healthy) was recorded as 345. Thus, the accuracy of the system was found to be 78.89%.

TABLE 2 Observations for the First 60 Days

CONCLUSION

During the COVID-19 outbreak, older people who are living alone are often the most vulnerable. When the pan-region lockdown is in force, people are not even visiting their neighbors. In such conditions, taking care of the elderly is of utmost importance. This study reports on the efforts the authors made with ensuring the well-being of 1 elderly research subject. The proposed system provides a comprehensive solution for elder care during disastrous circumstances. The system not only offers the facility for home delivery of the necessary items on demand to the elderly, but also ensures that proper help reaches the individual during critical times. The proposed system provided 24/7 vigilance of the elderly subject without the need for any video surveillance; thus, the system respected the privacy of the elderly individual.

The reported system didn’t require the research subject to wear any gadget or band on his wrist, which some people find cumbersome. The major bottleneck in implementing the presented system lies in the unavailability of health care data as an electronic health record, which is still not on the agenda in many developing countries. As a future course of action, the presented study can be extended by considering multiple subjects with better conditions post-COVID-19.

Conflict of Interest Statement

The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

Author Contributions

Both PP and RL conceived the study and drafted the final version of the manuscript. PP carried out the statistical analysis.

Ethics Committee Approval

The study was based on an Informed Consent Form (ICF) representing an essential prerequisite to the respect of ethics while conducting research. No ethics committee approval was necessary.

References

REFERENCES

World Health Organization. Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) advice for the public: myth busters. 2020. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019/advice-for-public/myth-busters. Accessed May 10, 2020.Google Scholar
World Health Organization. Coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) situation report – 51. 2020. https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/situation-reports/20200311-sitrep-51-covid-19.pdf?sfvrsn=1ba62e57_10. Accessed May 10, 2020.Google Scholar
Zelenkauskaite, A, Bessis, N, Sotiriadis, S, Asimakopoulou, E. Interconnectedness of complex systems of Internet of things through social network analysis for disaster management. In: 2012 Fourth International Conference on Intelligent Networking and Collaborative Systems. 2012, 503-508.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pandey, P, Litoriya, R. Elderly care through unusual behavior detection: a disaster management approach using IoT and intelligence. IBM J Res Dev. 2019;64(1):1.Google Scholar
Zelenkauskaite, A, Bessis, N, Sotiriadis, S, Asimakopoulou, E. Disaster management and profile modelling of IoT objects: conceptual parameters for interlinked objects in relation to social network analysis. In: 2012 Fourth International Conference on Intelligent Networking and Collaborative Systems. 2012, 509-514.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lee, I, Lee, K. The Internet of things (IoT): applications, investments, and challenges for enterprises. Bus Horiz. 2015;58(4):431-440.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Lemaignan, S, Warnier, M, Sisbot, EA, et al. Artificial cognition for social human – robot interaction: an implementation. Artif Intell. 2017;247:45-69.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pandey, P, Litoriya, R. Software process selection system based on multicriteria decision making. J Softw Evol Proc. 2020;epub.Google Scholar
Pandey, P, Litoriya, R, Tiwari, A. A framework for fuzzy modelling in agricultural diagnostics. J Eur Syst Autom. 2018;51:203-223.Google Scholar
Prateek, P, Ratnesh, L. Fuzzy cognitive mapping analysis to recommend machine learning based effort estimation technique for web applications. Int J Fuzzy Log Intell Syst. 2020;22(4):1212-1223.Google Scholar
Marr, B.What is the artificial intelligence of things? When AI meets IoT.Forbes. 2019. https://www.forbes.com/sites/bernardmarr/2019/12/20/what-is-the-artificial-intelligence-of-things-when-ai-meets-iot/#55f126b4b1fd. Accessed April 25, 2020.Google Scholar
Pandey, M, Litoriya, R, Pandey, P. Empirical analysis of defects in handheld device applications. Adv Comput Data Sci. 2019;epub, 103-113.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Borelli, E, Paolini, G, Antoniazzi, F, et al. HABITAT: an IoT solution for independent elderly. Sensors. 2019;19(5):1258.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Prateek, P, Ratnesh, L. Securing and authenticating healthcare records through blockchain technology. Cryptol. 2020;epub, 1-16. doi: 10.1080/01611194.2019.1706060.Google Scholar
IBM.com. Hyperledger fabric: the flexible blockchain framework that’s changing the business world. IBM. (n.d.) https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/hyperledger. Accessed June 30, 2019.Google Scholar
Zhang, P, Schmidt, DC, White, J, Lenz, G. Chapter one: blockchain technology use cases in healthcare. In: Raj P, Deka GC, eds. Blockchain Technology: Platforms, Tools and Use Cases, vol. 111. Amsterdam: Elsevier; 2018:1-41.Google Scholar
Melanie, S. Blockchain: Blueprint for a New Economy. E-book. O’Reilly Media; 2015.Google Scholar
Prateek, P, Ratnesh, L. Promoting trustless computation through blockchain technology. Natl Acad Sci Lett. 2020;epub.Google Scholar
Figure 0

TABLE 1 Time Frame Activity Demonstration

Figure 1

FIGURE 1 Box Plot Activity Pattern After 10 Days of Monitoring.

Figure 2

TABLE 2 Observations for the First 60 Days