Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home

Altered Standards of Care During an Influenza Pandemic: Identifying Ethical, Legal, and Practical Principles to Guide Decision Making

  • Donna Levin, Rebecca Orfaly Cadigan, Paul D. Biddinger, Suzanne Condon, Howard K. Koh and Joint Massachusetts Department of Public Health-Harvard Altered Standards of Care Working Group...

Abstract

Although widespread support favors prospective planning for altered standards of care during mass casualty events, the literature includes few, if any, accounts of groups that have formally addressed the overarching policy considerations at the state level. We describe the planning process undertaken by public health officials in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, along with community and academic partners, to explore the issues surrounding altered standards of care in the event of pandemic influenza. Throughout 2006, the Massachusetts Department of Public Health and the Harvard School of Public Health Center for Public Health Preparedness jointly convened a working group comprising ethicists, lawyers, clinicians, and local and state public health officials to consider issues such as allocation of antiviral medications, prioritization of critical care, and state seizure of private assets. Community stakeholders were also engaged in the process through facilitated discussion of case scenarios focused on these and other issues. The objective of this initiative was to establish a framework and some fundamental principles that would subsequently guide the process of establishing specific altered standards of care protocols. The group collectively identified 4 goals and 7 principles to guide the equitable allocation of limited resources and establishment of altered standards of care protocols. Reviewing and analyzing this process to date may serve as a resource for other states. (Disaster Med Public Health Preparedness. 2009;3(Suppl 2):S132–S140)

Copyright

Corresponding author

Address correspondence and reprint requests to Rebecca Orfaly Cadigan, c/o Kirkpatrick Tans, Division of Public Health Practice, Harvard School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Ave, Landmark Center, 3rd Floor E, Boston, MA 02115(e-mail: rcadigan@fas.harvard.edu).

References

Hide All
1.Trust for America’s Health. A Killer Flu. June 2005. http://healthyamericans.org/reports/flu/Flu2005.pdf. Accessed July 14, 2008.
2.Mehta, S.Disaster and mass casualty management in a hospital: how well are we prepared? J Postgrad Med. 2006;52:8990.
3.Gostin, LO, Powers, M.What does social justice require for the public’s health? Public health ethics and policy imperatives. Health Affairs. 2006;25:10531060.
4.Huber, SJ, Wynia, MK.When pestilence prevails Physician responsibilities in epidemics. Am J Bioethics. 2004;4:W5W11.
5.Reid, L.Diminishing returns? Risk and the duty to care in the SARS epidemic. Bioethics. 2005;19:348361.
6.Ruderman, C, Tracy, CS, Bensimon, CM, et alOn pandemics and the duty to care: whose duty? Who cares? BMC Medical Ethics. 2006;7:5.
7.Singer, PA, Benatar, SR, Bernstein, M, et alEthics and SARS: lessons from Toronto. BMJ. 2003;327:13421344.
8.Sokol, DK.Virulent epidemics and scope of healthcare workers’ duty of care. Emerg Infect Dis. 2006;12:12381241.
9.University of Toronto Joint Center for Bioethics (Working Group). Ethics and SARS: Learning Lessons from the Toronto Experience. http://www.yorku.ca/igreene/sars.html. Accessed August 21, 2007.
10.Nossiter A. Grand Jury Won’t Indict Doctor in Hurricane Deaths. New York Times. July 25, 2007. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/25/us/25doctor.html?scp=1&sq=Grand%20Jury%20Won%92t%20Indict%20Doctor%20in%20Hurricane%20Deaths&st=cse. Accessed May 4, 2009.
11.Okie, S.Dr. Pou and the hurricane—implications for patient care during disasters. New Engl J Med. 2008;358:15.
12.US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. FluSurge. http://www.cdc.gov/flu/flusurge.htm. Accessed November 27, 2006.
13.Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The General Laws of Massachusetts. http://www.mass.gov/legis/laws/mgl/index.htm. Accessed October 3, 2008.
14.Challen, K, Bentley, A, Bright, J, et alClinical review: mass casualty triage—pandemic influenza and critical care. Crit Care. 2007;11:212.
15.US Department of Health and Human Services, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. 2005. Altered Standards of Care in Mass Casualty Events. http://www.ahrq.gov/research/altstand. Accessed May 2, 2009.
16.Hick, JL, Rubinson, L, O’Laughlin, DT, et alClinical review: allocating ventilators during large-scale disasters—problems, planning, and process. Crit Care. 2007;11:217.
17.Daniels, N.Accountability for reasonableness. BMJ. 2000;321:13001301.
18.Larkin, GL, Arnold, J.Ethical considerations in emergency planning, preparedness, and response to acts of terrorism. Prehosp Disast Med. 2003;18:170178.
19.Koenig, KL, Cone, DC, Burstein, JL, et alSurging to the right standard of care. Acad Emerg Med. 2006;13:195198.
20.Kinlaw K, Levine R. Ethical Guidelines in Pandemic Influenza—Recommendations of the Ethics Subcommittee of the Advisory Committee to the Director, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 2007. http://www.pandemicflu.utah.gov/docs/20070515-PanFluEthicGuides.pdf. Accessed May 2, 2009.
21.Bernstein, M, Hawryluck, L.Challenging beliefs and ethical concepts: the collateral damage of SARS. Crit Care. 2003;7:269271.
22.Thompson, AK, Faith, K, Gibson, JL, et alPandemic influenza preparedness: an ethical framework to guide decision-making. BMC Med Ethics. 2006;7:12.
23.Pesik, N, Keim, ME, Iserson, KV.Terrorism and the ethics of emergency medical care. Ann Emerg Med. 2001;37:642646.
24.Schoch-Spana, M, Chamberlain, A, Franco, C, et alDisease, disaster, and democracy: the public’s stake in health emergency planning. Biosecur Bioterror. 2006;4:313319.
25.Hawryluck, L.Ethics review: position papers and policies—are they really helpful to front-line ICU teams? Crit Care. 2006;10:242.
26.The Proceedings of the Public’s Health and the Law in the 21st Century: Fifth Annual Partnership Conference.J Law Med Ethics. 2007;35 (Suppl 4):11137.
27.White, DB, Katz, MH, Luce, JM, et alWho should receive life support during a public health emergency? Using ethical principles to improve allocation decisions. Ann Intern Med. 2009;150:132138.
28.Hodge, JG, Gostin, LO, Vernick, JS.The Pandemic and All-Hazards Act: improving public health emergency response. JAMA. 2007;297:17081711.
29.World Health Organization. WHO Global Influenza Preparedness Plan. 2005. http://www.who.int/csr/resources/publications/influenza/GIP_2005_5Eweb.pdf. Accessed December 20, 2007.
30.US Department of Health and Human Services, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Mass Medical Care with Scarce Resources. 2007. http://www.ahrq.gov/research/mce. Accessed May 2, 2009.
31.Devereaux, A, Christian, MD, Dichter, JR, et alSummary of suggestions from the Task Force for Mass Critical Care Summit, January 26–27, 2007. Chest. 2008;133:1S7S.
32.Rubinson, L, Nuzzo, JB, Talmor, DS, et alAugmentation of hospital critical care capacity after bioterrorist attacks or epidemics: recommendations of the Working Group on Emergency Mass Critical Care. Crit Care. 2005;33:E1E13.
33.Hick, JL, O’Laughlin, DT.Concept of operations for triage of mechanical ventilation in an epidemic. Acad Emerg Med. 2006;13:223229.
34.US Government Accountability Office. States Are Planning for Medical Surge, but Could Benefit from Shared Guidance for Allocating Scarce Medical Resources. GAO-08-668. June 13, 2008. http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d08668.pdf. Accessed March 1, 2009.
35.Daniels, N.Just Health: Meeting Health Needs Fairly. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 2008.
36.Tai, DYH.SARS plague: duty to care or medical heroism? Ann Acad Med Singapore. 2006;35:374378.
37.Nick, GA, Savoia, E, Elqura, L, et alEmergency preparedness for vulnerable populations: people with special health-care needs. Public Health Rep. 2009;124:338343.

Keywords

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Altered Standards of Care During an Influenza Pandemic: Identifying Ethical, Legal, and Practical Principles to Guide Decision Making

  • Donna Levin, Rebecca Orfaly Cadigan, Paul D. Biddinger, Suzanne Condon, Howard K. Koh and Joint Massachusetts Department of Public Health-Harvard Altered Standards of Care Working Group...

Metrics

Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.