Skip to main content Accessibility help

Anti-Theism and the Objective Meaningful Life Argument



Philosophers of religion have begun to explore the value question of whether God’s existence would add to, detract from, or have no impact on the value of our world. The Meaningful Life Argument is one of the most promising arguments in support of the view that God’s existence would make the world worse, at least for certain individuals. I offer an objectivized version of the Meaningful Life Argument and show why recent objections leveled against it by Myron A. Penner do not apply to this version.

Les philosophes de la religion ont récemment commencé à se demander si l’existence de Dieu ajouterait ou enlèverait de la valeur à notre monde, ou encore si elle n’aurait aucun impact sur sa valeur. De plus en plus populaire, l’argument du sens de la vie (Meaningful Life Argument) soutient que l’existence de Dieu rendrait le monde pire, du moins pour certains individus. Dans cet article, j’offre une adaptation objectivée de l’argument du sens de la vie et je démontre que les objections formulées par Myron A. Penner ne s’appliquent plus.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Baggini, Julian 2004 What’s It All About?: Philosophy and the Meaning of Life. London: Granta Books.
Baier, Kurt 1957 “The Meaning of Life.” Reprinted in The Meaning of Life. 2 nd Edition, edited by Klemke, E.D.. New York: Oxford University Press.
Ballantyne, Nathan 2014 “Counterfactual Philosophers.” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research LXXXVIII (2): 368387.
Davis, Stephen T. 2014 “On Preferring that God Not Exist (or that God Exist): A Dialogue.” Faith and Philosophy 31 (2): 143159.
Fried, Charles 1970 An Anatomy of Values: Problems of Personal and Social Choice. USA: Harvard University Press.
Hepburn, R.W. 1966 “Questions about the Meaning of Life.” Reprinted in The Meaning of Life. 2 nd Edition. Edited by Klemke, E.D., 261-276. New York: Oxford University Press.
Johnson, Jeffery L. 1989 “Privacy and Judgment of Others.” Journal of Value Inquiry 23 (2): 157168.
Johnson, Jeffery L. 1992 “A Theory of the Nature and Value of Privacy.” Public Affairs Quarterly 6 (3): 271288.
Joske, W.D. 1974 “Philosophy and the Meaning of Life.” Reprinted in The Meaning of Life. 2 nd Edition. Edited by Klemke, E.D., 283–294. New York: Oxford University Press. 283294.
Kahane, Guy 2011 “Should We Want God to Exist?” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 82 (3): 674696.
King, Nathan L. 2016 “Religious Skepticism and Higher-Order Evidence.” Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Religion. Volume 7. Edited by Kvanvig, Jonathan L., 126156. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kitcher, Philip 2014 “Chapter One: Doubt Delineated.” In Life After Faith, 125. USA: Yale University Press.
Kornblith, Hilary 2010 “Belief in the Face of Controversy.” In Disagreement. Edited by Feldman, Richard and Warfield, Ted A., 2952. New York: Oxford University Press.
Kraay, Klaas, and Dragos, Chris 2013 “On Preferring God’s Non-Existence.” Canadian Journal of Philosophy 43 (2): 157178.
Kurtz, Paul 1974 The fullness of Life. New York: Horizon Press.
Lackey, Douglas P. 1985 “Divine Omniscience and Human Privacy.” Philosophy Research Archives 10: 383391.
Mawson, Tim 2012 “On Determining How Important it is Whether or Not there is a God.” European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 4 (4): 95105.
Metz, Thaddaeus 2013 Meaning in Life. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mugg, Joshua 2016 “The Quietest Challenge to the Axiology of God: A Cognitive Approach to Counterpossibles.” Faith and Philosophy 33 (4): 441460.
Murphy, Jeffrie 1982 Evolution, Morality, and the Meaning of Life. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Littlefield.
Penner, Myron A. 2015 “Personal Anti-Theism and the Meaningful Life Argument.” Faith and Philosophy 32 (3): 325337.
Penner, Myron A., and Lougheed, Kirk 2015 “Pro-Theism and the Added Value of Morally Good Agents.” Philosophia Christi 7 (1): 5369.
Plantinga, Alvin 2001 God, Freedom, and Evil. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans Publishing Co.
Pruss, Alexander R. 2012 “A Counter-Example to Plantinga’s Free Will Defense.” Faith and Philosophy 29 (4): 400415.
Rachels, James 1975 “Why Privacy is Important.” Philosophy & Public Affairs 4 (4): 323333.
Rescher, Nicholas 1990 “On Faith and Belief.” In Human Interests: Reflections on Philosophical Anthropology. Edited by Rescher, Nicholas, 166178. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Schellenberg, John L. 2006 Divine Hiddenness and Human Reason. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Schellenber, John L. 2015 The Hiddenness Argument: Philosophy’s New Challenge to Belief in God. New York: Oxford University Press.
Singer, Irving 1996 Meaning of Life, Volume 1: The Creation of Value. Baltimore: John Hopkins University Press.



Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed