Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-c4f8m Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-24T00:36:42.587Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Vygotskian critique of self-instructional training

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  04 March 2009

Rafael M. Diaz  and
Laura E. Berk
Rafael M. Diaz*
Affiliation:
Stanford University
Laura E. Berk
Affiliation:
Illinois State University
*
Rafael M. Diaz, School of Education, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Self-instructional training, a widely used intervention for treating the learning and behavioral difficulties of impulsive, attention deficit-hyperactivity disordered, and learning disabled children, has repeatedly failed to promote self-control or improve academic performance. In light of this failure, we critically examine four assumptions underlying self-instructional training: (a) children with learning and behavior problems show a lack and/or deficient use of self-regulatory private speech; (b) modeling of self-verbalizations will increase children's spontaneous production of private speech; (c) speech and action are intrinsically coordinated; and (d) internalization refers to subvocalization of private speech. We argue that self-instructional training interventions need to be thoroughly grounded in Soviet developmental theory of verbal self-regulation and in systematic research on the social origins and development of children's private speech. A new research agenda is suggested.

Type
Articles
Information
Development and Psychopathology , Volume 7 , Issue 2 , Spring 1995 , pp. 369 - 392
Copyright
Copyright © Cambridge University Press 1995

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abikoff, H. (1985). Efficacy of cognitive training interventions in hyperactive children: A critical review. Clinical Psychology Review, 5, 479–512.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Abikoff, H. (1991). Cognitive training in ADHD children: Less to it than meets the eye. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 24, 205–209.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Abikoff, H., Ganeles, D., Reiter, G., Blum, C., Foley, C., & Klein, R. G. (1988). Cognitive training in academically deficient ADHD boys receiving stimulant medication. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 16, 411–432.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Azmitia, M. (1992). Expertise, private speech, and the development of self-regulation. In Diaz, R. M. & Berk, L. E. (Eds.), Private speech: From social interaction to self-regulation (pp. 101–122). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Balamore, U., & Wozniak, R. H. (1984). Speechaction coordination in young children. Developmental Psychology, 20, 850–858.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Barkley, R. A. (1985). The social behavior of hyperactive children: Developmental changes, drug effects, and situational variation. In McMahon, R. & Peters, R. (Eds.), Childhood disorders: Behavioral-developmental approaches (pp. 218–243). New York: Brunner/Mazel.Google Scholar
Barkley, R. A. (1988). The effects of methylphenidate on the interactions of preschool ADHD children with their mothers. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 27, 336–341.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Barkley, R. A., Fischer, M., Edelbrock, C. S., & Smallish, L. (1991). The adolescent outcome of hyperactive children diagnosed by research criteria—III: Mother-child interactions, family conflicts and maternal psychopathology. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 32, 233–255.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Beaudichon, J. (1973). Nature and instrumental function of private speech in problem solving situations. Merril-Palmer Quarterly, 19, 117–135.Google Scholar
Befera, M. S., & Barkley, R. A. (1985). Hyperactive and normal girls and boys: Mother-child interaction, parent psychiatric status and child psychopathology. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 26, 439–452.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Behrend, D. A., Rosengren, K. S., & Perlmutter, M. (1989). A new look at children's private speech: The effects of age, task difficulty, and parental presence. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 12, 305–320.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Behrend, D. A., Rosengren, K. S., & Perlmutter, M. (1992). The relation between private speech and parental interactive style. In Diaz, R. M. & Berk, L. E. (Eds.), Private speech: From social interaction to self-regulation (pp. 85–100) Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Berk, L. E. (1986). Relationship of elementary school children's private speech to behavioral accompaniment to task, attention, and task performance. Developmental Psychology, 22, 671–680.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berk, L. E. (1992). Private speech: An overview of theory and the status of research. In Diaz, R. M. & Berk, L. E. (Eds.), Private speech: From social interaction to self-regulation (pp. 17–53). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Berk, L. E., & Garvin, R. A. (1984). Development of private speech among low-income Appalachian children. Developmental Psychology, 20, 271–286.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berk, L. E., & Landau, S. (1993). Private speech of learning disabled and normally achieving children during classroom academic and laboratory tasks. Child Development, 64, 556–571.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Berk, L. E., & Potts, M. (1991). Development and functional significance of private speech among attention-deficit hyperactivity disordered and normal boys. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 19, 357–377.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Berk, L. E., & Spuhl, S. T. (1994, April). Maternal teaching strategies, microgenetic change in preschoolers' private speech, and task performance. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New Orleans LA.Google Scholar
Bivens, J. A., & Berk, L. E. (1990). A longitudinal study of the development of elementary school children's private speech. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 36, 443–463.Google Scholar
Cameron, M. I., & Robinson, V. M. J. (1980). Effects of cognitive training on academic and on-task behavior of hyperactive children. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 8, 405–419.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Camp, B. W., & Bash, M. A. S. (1981). Think Aloud: Increasing social and cognitive skills—A problemsolving program for children. Champaign, IL: Research Press.Google Scholar
Camp, B. W., Blom, G., Hebert, F., & van Doorninck, W. (1977). “Think Aloud”: A program for developing self-control in young aggressive boys. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 5, 157–168.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Cole, P. M., & Kazdin, A. E. (1980). Critical issues in self-instruction training with children. Child Behavior Therapy, 2, 1–21.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Copeland, A. P. (1979). Types of private speech produced by hyperactive and nonhyperactive boys. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 7, 169–177.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Danforth, J. S., Barkley, R. A., & Stokes, T. F. (1991). Observations of parent-child interactions with hyperactive children: Research and clinical implications. Clinical Psychology Review, 11, 703–727.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Deutsch, F., & Stein, A. H. (1972). The effects of personal responsibility and task interruption on the private speech of preschoolers. Human Development, 15, 310–324.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diaz, R. M. (1986). The union of thought and language in children's private speech. Quarterly Newsletter of the Laboratory of Comparative Human Cognition, 8, 90–97.Google Scholar
Diaz, R. M. (1992). Methodological concerns in the study of private speech. In Diaz, R. M. & Berk, L. E. (Eds.), Private speech: From social interaction to self-regulation (pp. 55–81). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Diaz, R. M., & Berk, L. E. (Eds.) (1992). Private speech: From social interaction to self-regulation. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Diaz, R. M., & Lowe, J. P. (1987). The private speech of young children at risk: A test of three deficit hypotheses. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 2, 181–194.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diaz, R. M., Neal, C. J., & Amaya-Williams, M. (1990). The social origins of self-regulation. In Moll, L. C. (Ed.), Vygotsky and education: Instructional implications and applications of sociohistorical psychology (pp. 127–154). New York: Cambridge University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Diaz, R. M., Padilla, K. A., & Weathersby, E. K. (1991). The impact of bilingualism on the selfregulatory private speech of Mexican American preschoolers. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 6, 377–393.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Douglas, V. I., Parry, P., Marton, P., & Garson, C. (1976). Assessment of a cognitive training program for hyperactive children. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 4, 389–410.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Dush, D. M., Hirt, M. L., & Schroeder, H. E. (1989). Self-statement modification in the treatment of child behavior disorders: A meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 106, 97–106.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Erikson, K. A., & Simon, H. A. (1993). Protocol analysis: Verbal reports as data (rev. ed.). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fischer, M. (1990). Parenting stress and the child with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 19, 337–346.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Flavell, J. H., Beach, D. R., & Chinsky, J. M. (1966). Spontaneous verbal rehearsal in a memory task as a function of age. Child Development, 37, 283–299.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Frauenglass, M. H., & Diaz, R. M. (1985). Selfregulatory functions of children's private speech: A critical analysis of recent challenges to Vygotsky's theory. Developmental Psychology, 21, 357–364.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Fuson, K. C. (1979). The development of selfregulating aspects of speech: A review. In Zivin, G. (Ed.), The development of self-regulation through private speech (pp. 135–217). New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Gaskill, M. N., & Diaz, R. M. (1991). The relation between private speech and cognitive performance. Infancia y Aprendisaje, 53, 45–58.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geary, D. C., & Burlingham-Dubree, M. (1989). External validation of the strategy choice model for addition. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 47, 175–192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Geary, D. C., Widaman, K. F., Little, T. D., & Cormier, P. (1987). Cognitive addition: Comparison of learning disabled and academically normal elementary school children. Cognitive Development, 2, 249–269.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Goodman, S. (1981). The integration of verbal and motor behavior in preschool children. Child Development, 52, 280–289.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Harris, K. R. (1985). Conceptual, methodological, and clinical issues in cognitive-behavioral assessment. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 13, 373–390.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Harris, K. R. (1986). The effects of cognitive-behavior modification on private speech and past performance during problem solving among learningdisabled and normally achieving children. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 14, 63–76.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hinshaw, S. P., & Erhardt, D. (1991). Attentiondeficit hyperactivity disorder. In Kendall, P. C. (Ed.), Child and adolescent therapy: Cognitivebehavioral procedures (pp. 98–128). New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Hobbs, S. A., Moguin, L. E., Tyroler, M., & Lahey, B. B. (1980). Cognitive behavior therapy with children: Has clinical utility been demonstrated? Psychological Bulletin, 87, 147–165.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kendall, P. C. (1977). On the efficacious use of verbal self-instructional procedures with children. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 1, 331–341.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kendall, P. C., & Braswell, L. (1985). Cognitivebehavioral therapy for impulsive children. New York: Guilford Press.Google Scholar
Kendall, P. C., & Finch, A. J. Jr. (1979). Changes in verbal behavior following a cognitive-behavioral treatment for impulsivity. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 7, 455–463.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Kohlberg, L., Yaeger, J., & Hjertholm, E. (1968). Private speech: Four studies and a review of theories. Child Development, 39, 691–736.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Kuhl, J., & Beckman, J. (Eds.). (1985). Action control: From cognition to behavior. West Berlin: Springer-Verlag.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Landau, S., & McAninch, C. (1993, May). Young children with attention deficits. Young Children, 48 (4), 49–58.Google Scholar
Luria, A. (1961). The role of speech in the regulation of normal and abnormal behaviors. New York: Liveright.Google Scholar
Luria, A. R. (1982). Language and cognition. New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Lysynchuk, L. M., Pressley, M., & Vye, N. J. (1990). Reciprocal teaching improves standardized reading-comprehension performance in poor comprehenders. Elementary School Journal, 90, 469–484.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
McGee, R., & Share, D. L. (1988). Attention deficit disorder-hyperactivity and academic failure: Which comes first and what should be treated? Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 27, 318–325.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Meador, A. E., & Ollendick, T. H. (1984). Cognitive behavior therapy with children: An evaluation of its efficacy and clinical utility. Child and Family Behavior Therapy, 6, 25–44.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Mee, L. (1988). Mother-child interaction and the private speech of 2- and 3-year-old children. Unpublished master's thesis, Illinois State University.Google Scholar
Meichenbaum, D. (1971, April). The nature and modification of impulsive children: Training impulsive children to talk to themselves. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Minneapolis, MN. (ERIC Document ED 073 834).Google Scholar
Meichenbaum, D. (1975). Self-instructional methods. In Kanfer, F. & Goldstein, A. (Eds.), Helping people change. New York: Pergamon Press.Google Scholar
Meichenbaum, D. (1977). Cognitive-behavior modification: An integrative approach. New York: Plenum Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Meichenbaum, D. H., & Burland, S. (1979). Cognitive behavior modification with children. School Psychology Digest, 8, 426–433.Google Scholar
Meichenbaum, D., & Goodman, J. (1971). Training impulsive children to talk to themselves: A means of developing self-control. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 77, 115–126.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Milich, R., & Kramer, J. (1984). Reflections on impulsivity: An empirical investigation of impulsivity as a construct. In Gadow, K. (Ed.), Advances in learning and behavioral disabilities (Vol. 3, pp. 57–94). Greenwich, CT: JAI.Google Scholar
Montero, I., & Diaz, R. (1992, September). The coordination between private speech and action: Exploring a new method of analysis. Paper presented at the Conference for Socio-cultural research, Madrid, Spain.Google Scholar
Murray, J. D. (1979). Spontaneous private speech and performance on a delayed match-to-sample task. Journal of Experiemental Child Psychology, 27, 286–302.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Neilans, T. H., & Israel, A. C. (1981). Toward maintenance and generalization of behavior change: Teaching children self-regulation and self-instructional skills. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 5, 189–196.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Newson, J., & Newson, E. (1975). Intersubjectivity and the transmission of culture: On the social origins of symbolic functioning. Bulletin of the British Psychological Society, 28, 437–446.Google Scholar
Olson, S. L. (1989). Assessment of impulsivity in preschoolers: Cross-measure convergences, longitudinal stability, and relevance to social competence. Journal of Clinical Child Psychology, 18, 176–183.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Padilla, K. A., & Diaz, R. M. (1986, April). The training of self-regulatory prviate speech. Paper presented at the conference of the Minority Biomedical Research Program, New Orleans, LA.Google Scholar
Palincsar, A. S. (1992, April). Beyond reciprocal teaching: A retrospective and prospective view. Raymond B. Cattell Early Career Award Address at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, CA.Google Scholar
Palincsar, A. S., & Brown, A. L. (1984). Reciprocal teaching of comprehension fostering and comprehension monitoring. Cognition and Instruction, 1, 117–175.Google Scholar
Palincsar, A. S., & Klenk, L. (1992). Fostering literacy learning in supportive contexts. Journal of Learning Disabilities, 25, 211–225.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Palkes, H., Stewart, M., & Kahana, B. (1968). Porteus maze performance of hyperactive boys after training in self-directed verbal commands. Child Development, 39, 817–826.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Pellegrini, A. D. (1981). The development of preschoolers' private speech. Journal of Pragmatics, 5, 445–458.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pelham, W. E. (1986). The effects of stimulant drugs on learning and achievement in hyperactive and learning disabled children. In Torgesen, J. K. & Wong, B. (Eds.), Psychological and educational perspectives on learning disabilities (pp. 259–295). Orando, FL: Academic.Google Scholar
Pratt, M. W., Green, D., MacVicar, J., & Bountrogianni, M. (1992). The mathematical parent: Parental scaffolding, parenting style, and learning outcomes in long-division mathematics homework. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 13, 17–34.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pratt, M., Kerig, P. K., Cowan, P. A., & Cowan, C. P. (1988). Mothers and fathers teaching 3-year-olds: Authoritative parenting and adult scaffolding of young children's learning. Developmental Psychology, 24, 832–839.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Pressley, M. (1979). Increasing children's self-control through cognitive interventions. Review of Educational Research, 49, 319–370.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Reed, M. A., Pien, D. L., & Rothbart, M. K. (1984). Inhibitory self-control in preschool children. Merrill-Palmer Quarterly, 30, 131–147.Google Scholar
Roberts, R. N. (1979). Private speech in academic problem-solving: A naturalistic perspective. In Zivin, G. (Ed.), The development of self-regulation through private speech (pp. 295–323). New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Rogoff, B. (1990). Apprenticeship in thinking. New York: Oxford University Press.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Rubin, K. H. (1979). Impact of the natural setting on private speech. In Zivin, G. (Ed.), The development of self-regulation through private speech (pp. 265–294). New York: Wiley.Google Scholar
Sartoris, C., & Berk, L. E. (1994). Private speech and math strategy use of children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder and normal controls during mathematics problem solving. Research in progress.Google Scholar
Saxe, G., Guberman, S., & Gearhart, M. (1987). Social processes in early number development. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development, 52 (2, Serial No. 216).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Schooler, J. (1990). Verbal overshadowing of visual memories: Some things are better left unsaid. Cognitive Psychology, 22, 36–71.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Schooler, J. (1993). Thoughts beyond words: When language overshadows insight. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 122, 166–188.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Siegler, R. S. (1986). Unities in strategy choices across domains. In Perlmutter, M. (Ed.), Minnesota Symposia on Child Psychology (Vol. 19, pp. 1–48). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Siegler, R. S., & Crowley, K. (1991). The microgenetic method: A direct means for studying cognitive development. American Psychologist, 46, 606–620.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Smolucha, F. (1992). Social origins of private speech in pretend play. In Diaz, R. M. & Berk, L. E. (Eds.), Private speech: From social interaction to selfregulation (pp. 123–141). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.Google Scholar
Strommen, E. A. (1973). Verbal self-regulation in a children's game: Impulsive errors on Simon Says. Child Development, 44, 849–853.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Tallmadge, J., & Barkley, R. A. (1983). The interactions of hyperactive and normal boys with their fathers and mothers. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 11, 565–580.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Tharp, R. G., & Gallimore, R. (1988). Rousing minds to life. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Vygotsky, L. S. (1962). Thought and language (Hanfmann, E. & Vakar, G., Eds. & Trans.). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. (Original work published 1934).CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society: The development of higher mental processes (Cole, M., John-Steiner, V., Scribner, S., & Souberman, E., Eds.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. (Original work published 1930, 1933, 1935).Google Scholar
Vygotsky, L. S. (1981). The genesis of higher mental functions. In Wertsch, J. W. (Ed. & Trans.), The concept of activity in Soviet psychology (pp. 144–188). New York: M. E. Sharpe. (Reprinted from Razvitie vysshikh psikhicheskikh funktsii, 1960, 182–223).Google Scholar
Watson, J. B. (1924). Behaviorism. New York: Norton.Google Scholar
Wertsch, J. V., & Hickmann, M. (1987). Problem solving in social interaction: A microgenetic analysis. In Hickmann, M. (Ed.), Social and functional approaches to language and thought (pp. 251–266). San Diego, CA: Academic Press.Google Scholar
Wertsch, J. V., & Stone, C. A. (1985). The concept of internalization in Vygotsky's account of the genesis of higher mental functions. In Wertsch, J. V. (Ed.), Culture, communication, and cognition (pp. 162–182). New York: Cambridge University Press.Google Scholar
Whalen, C. K., Henker, B., & Hinshaw, S. P. (1985). Cognitive-behavioral therapies for hyperactive children: Premises, problems, and prospects. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 13, 391–410.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Winsler, A. (1994). The social origins and self-regulatory quality of private speech in hyperactive and normal children. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Stanford University.Google Scholar
Winsler, A., Atencio, D., & Diaz, R. M. (1991, April). Training self-regulation in impulsive children. Paper presented at the biennial meeting of the Society for Research in Child Development, Seattle WA.Google Scholar
Wong, B. Y. L. (1985). Issues in cognitive-behavioral interventions in academic skill areas. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 13, 425–441.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed
Wood, D. J., & Middleton, D. (1975). A study of assisted problem-solving. British Journal of Psychology, 66, 181–191.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Wozniak, R. H. (1972). Verbal regulation of motor behavior—Soviet research and non-Soviet replications. Human Development, 15, 13–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Zivin, G. (1972). Functions of private speech during problem-solving in preschool children. Dissertation Abstracts International, 33 (2-B), 1834. (University Microfilms No. 72–26, 224)Google Scholar
Zivin, G. (Ed.). (1979). The development of selfregulation through private speech (pp. 13–49). New York: Wiley.Google Scholar