Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-dnltx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-20T00:27:22.152Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Fissures in Late-Nineteenth-Century English Nonconformity: A Case Study in One Congregation

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Dale A. Johnson
Dale A. Johnson
Affiliation:
Mr. Johnson is professor of church history in The Divinity School, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

Recent study of English Nonconformity in the nineteenth century has focused upon issues in the integration of a small culture of Dissent into the larger Anglican-dominated culture, issues such as politics, education, and advancement in the general society. Little attention, by contrast, has been given to theological questions or developments. As a result, the impact of some major shifts in theological thinking within denominational traditions has not been carefully pursued; more seriously, such changes have been frequently characterized as illustrations of theological decline. Greater perspective, however, would be gained by locating instances of theological contention and setting them in the larger framework of cultural and religious change. The following exploration of a theological dispute in one Nonconformist congregation is such an attempt.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 66 , Issue 4 , December 1997 , pp. 735 - 749
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1997

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. Recent broad denominational studies have provided some attention to theology. Examples include Davies, Rupert et al. , eds., A History of the Methodist Church in Great Britain, 4 vols. (London, 1965–1988); andGoogle ScholarBriggs, J. H.Y., The English Baptists of the Nineteenth Century (Didcot, U.K., 1994).Google Scholar

2. For this latter judgment, see Sellers, Ian, Nineteenth-Century Nonconformity (London, 1977), pp. 25, 27.Google Scholar

3. Who's Who of British Members of Parliament, ed. Stenton, Michael and Lees, Stephen (Sussex, U.K., 1978), 2:85.Google ScholarSee the several references to the Crossley family in Binfield, Clyde, So Down to Prayers (London, 1977), such as the following: “Halifax is a restless Renaissance city, with the Crossleys of Square Chapel as its Medici” (p. 147).Google Scholar

4. For Simon's own impact on theological education in his denomination, see Powicke, Frederick J., David Worthington Simon (London, 1912); andGoogle ScholarJohnson, Dale A., “The End of the ‘Evidences’: A Study in Nonconformist Theological Transition,”Journal of the United Reformed Church History Society 2:3 (April 1979): 62–72.Google Scholar

5. See the short biography of Lawrence in The Evangelical Magazine (August 1892): 445–447.

6. Congregational Year Book (1910), p. 178.

7. The bulk of these details are provided in Wadsworth, G. P., The History of Square Road Congregational Church, Halifax (Halifax, U.K., 1889), pp. 6, 22, 27–28.Google Scholar

8. The Crossleys are described in Girouard, Mark, The Victorian Country House, rev. ed. (New Haven, Conn., 1979), pp. 205–212; a photograph of the church building is on p. 206.Google Scholar

9. Wadsworth, pp. 26–27.

10. The following narrative is drawn from this pamphlet; the Calderdale District Archives Service, Halifax, provided a photocopy of this document.

11. Lawrence, Eric A., To the Members of Square Church, pp. 6, 10.Google Scholar

12. Lawrence, Eric A., To the Members of Square Church, p. 16.Google Scholar

13. Lawrence, Eric A., To the Members of Square Church, pp. 6–7, 12–13.Google Scholar

14. Christ, the Bearer of our Sins (Halifax, U.K., n.d.), pp. 3, 13, 14.Google Scholar

15. “What is the Atonement?” a tract by , E. C. (Ryde, U.K., 1892), pp. 3–7.Google Scholar

16. Crossley, Edward, “Whois the Man of Sin?” (Ryde, U. K. 1892), pp. 11, 15, 25.Google Scholar

17. To the Members of Square Church, pp. 7, 9, 11.

18. Lawrence, , Jesus our Saviour (Halifax, U.K., 1892), pp. 13–14.Google Scholar

19. Rogers, J. G., The Christian Standard Bearer (1881), cited in Wadsworth, pp. 24–25.Google Scholar

20. The Rev. Mellor, E., The Atonement, Its Relation to Pardon; An Argument and a Defence, 2d ed. (London, 1860). See also his Priesthood in the Light of the New Testament (1876).Google Scholar

21. The Rev. Mellor, E., The Atonement, Its Relation to Pardon; An Argument and a Defence, 2d ed. (London, 1860), pp. 5, 11, 23–24.Google Scholar

22. The Rev. Mellor, E., The Atonement, Its Relation to Pardon; An Argument and a Defence, 2d ed. (London, 1860), p. 2.Google Scholar

23. The Rev. Mellor, E., The Atonement, Its Relation to Pardon; An Argument and a Defence, 2d ed. (London, 1860), pp. 14–20.Google Scholar

24. Faith and Criticism (London, 1893), pp. v–vi.Google Scholar

25. Barrett, George S., in Lancashire Independent College. Jubilee, 1893 (Manchester, U.K., 1893), pp. 57–58.Google Scholar

26. Barrett, George S., in Lancashire Independent College. Jubilee, 1893 (Manchester, U.K., 1893), p. 58.Google Scholar

27. “The Expiatory Theory of the Atonement,” British Quarterly Review 46 (October 1867): 463.

28. Campbell, John McLeod, The Nature of the Atonement, 3d ed. (London, 1869), pp. 76–77Google Scholar

29. Gilbert, Joseph, The Christian Atonement (London, 1836), p. 73.Google Scholar

30. See Hunter, John, “Alexander John Scott,” Expositor, 8th ser. 21 (1921): 386–400, 450–462.Google Scholar

31. The Victorian Transformation of Theology (London, 1934), pp. 53, 22.Google ScholarSee also Mackennal, Alexander, a close peer of Eric Lawrence: “when it can be appraised, it will be seen that his abiding influence has been, not on English Churchmen, but on English Congregationalists” (Sketches in the Evolution of English Congregationalism [London, 1901], pp. 195–206).Google Scholar

32. See Brown, J. Baldwin, The Doctrine of the Divine Fatherhood in Relation to the Atonement (London, 1860);Google ScholarHinton, J. H., “Strictures on Some Passages in the Rev. J. B. Brown's Divine Life in Man,” Baptist Magazine 52 (1860);Google ScholarCandlish, Robert S., The Fatherhood of God, 5th ed. (Edinburgh, 1870); andGoogle ScholarCrawford, Thomas J., The Fatherhood of God Considered in its General and Special Aspects, and Particularly in Relation to the Atonement (London, 1866).Google Scholar

33. Dale, R.W., Christian Doctrine: A Series of Discourses (London, 1894), p. 261.Google Scholar

34. Dale, , The Atonement, pp. 372–373, 404; andGoogle ScholarDale, , Christian Doctrine, pp. 241–242.Google Scholar

35. In a revealing footnote, Simon commented: “In order to make clear this somewhat enigmatical statement, I should have to expound a view of the atonement which is at present not clear enough to myself to fit me for presenting it to others”; The Redemption of Man (Edinburgh, 1889), p. 191 n. 1.Google Scholar

36. In a revealing footnote, Simon commented: “In order to make clear this somewhat enigmatical statement, I should have to expound a view of the atonement which is at present not clear enough to myself to fit me for presenting it to others”; The Redemption of Man (Edinburgh, 1889), pp. 337–338.Google Scholar

37. Reconciliation by Incarnation (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 293, 48, 128.Google Scholar

38. Reconciliation by Incarnation (Edinburgh, 1898), pp. 370, 378–381.Google Scholar

39. “Christ and the Christian,” pp. 153, 180–181.

40. Sharp, Fred, “Dr. Mellor,” cutting from The Guardian, 24 April 1915, Mansfield College Library, Oxford.Google Scholar

41. “An Appreciation”—[By One Who Knew Him] (1909), Mansfield College Library.

42. “Catalogue of the Remainder of the Library of the late Rev. Eric A. Lawrence of St. Anne's-on-the-Sea,” Mansfield College Library.Google Scholar

43. Fairbairn, A. M., The Place of Christ in Modern Theology (London, 1893), pp. 3–4.Google Scholar

44. See Binfield, Clyde, “Chapels in Crisis: Men and Issues in Victorian Eastern England,” Transactions of the Congregational Historical Society 20:8 (1968): 237–254.Google Scholar