Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-wq2xx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-18T15:12:36.069Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Contours of Female Piety in Later Medieval Hagiography

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Michael Goodich
Michael Goodich
Affiliation:
senior lecturer in medieval history inUniversity of Haifa, Israel.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The thirteenth century represents a high point in the establishment of female orders, whose ministry was directed largely at an urban population prone to heresy and undergoing the disruptive transition from pastoral feudalism to nascent capitalism. During this period, more than a quarter of the contemporary saints were women; they identified with all of the new movements which animated the church. Some, continuing the already established tradition of princely veneration, were active in evangelization in the recently Christianized regions of Europe's periphery, like Spain and Poland, through the patronage of charitable institutions and religious houses. The canonization trials of Hedwig of Poland, Elizabeth of Thuringia and Margaret of Hungary all reflect a broadly based constituency including rural and urban, lay and clerical, male and female support Others appealed to a narrower social and geographical audience and ministered to the problems of the urban poor: Sperandea of Cingoli's miraculous cures were performed exclusively on married women of the city and of the adjacent countryside. But the largest number of female saints continued to be cloistered women whose chief accomplishment was the establishment or endowment of a new convent or the foundation of a new female order, usually in association with a male order; for while many such orders began independently, the church feared the consequences of independent female piety and sought to ensure orthodoxy by associating the female houses with a corresponding male order. Nevertheless, while contemporary hagiography continued to be patterned after the stereotypical saints of early Christianity, the character of female piety changed to reflect such dynamic changes within the church as the rise of mendicancy, the transition from rural to urban life, the cult of the Virgin, the rise of national states, the war against heresy, the new emphasis on the humanity of Christ and the political struggles of the papacy.

Type
Research Article
Information
Church History , Volume 50 , Issue 1 , March 1981 , pp. 20 - 32
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 1981

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

* This article is based on a paper delivered at the Fourth Berkshire Conference in Women's History, Mount Holyoke, Mass., summer 1978.

1. Franknoi, William, ed., Inquisitio super vita, conversatione et miraculis beatae Margarethae virginis, in Monumenta romana episcopatus Vesprimiensis, 6 vols. (Budapest, 1896–1950), 1: 163–384Google Scholar (hereafter cited as Franknoí, Inquisitio); Simon of Trebnitz, Vita sanctae Hedwigis, in Bielowski, August, ed., Monumenta Poloniae Historica, 6 vols. (Warsaw, 1960–1961), 4: 510–633;Google ScholarHuyskens, Albert, ed., Quellenstudien zur Geschichte der hl. Elisabeth (Marburg, 1908).Google Scholar See also Goodich, Michael, “The Politics of Canonization in the Thirteenth Century: Lay and Mendicant Saints,” Church History 44 (09 1975): 1–14.CrossRefGoogle Scholar The chief source for the saints' lives is Socii Bollandiani, Acta sanctorum Bollandistarum, rev. ed., 66 vols. to date (Paris, 1863-).Google Scholar This last source is cited hereafter as AS, followed by the saint's day, with volume number and pages in parentheses.

2. AS, 11 September (3: 901–906).

3. For a general survey of the women's movement in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, see Grundmann, Herbert, Religiöse Bewegungen im Mittelalter (Hildesheim, 1963), pp. 170–198, 319–354;Google ScholarBolton, Brenda, “Mulieres sanctae,” Studies in Church History 10 (1973): 77–95;CrossRefGoogle ScholarMcDonnell, Ernest W., The Beguines and Beghards in Medieval Culture (New Brunswick, N.J., 1954).Google Scholar

4. AS, 19 June (4: 766–793) includes a sixteenth-century life by Archangelo Giani.

5. AS, 25 September (7: 166).

6. Dunbar, Agnes, A Dictionary of Saintly Women, 2 vols. (London, 1904–1905), 2: 103–104; 1: 338.Google Scholar

7. AS, 11 September (2: 890–913); 21 March (3: 362–364).

8. AS, 22 May (5: 205–221); 26 August (5: 845–854).

9. Canivez, Joseph Marie, L'Ordre de Citeaux en Belgique (Forges-les-Chimay, 1926), pp. 172–186.Google Scholar For the continued foundation of Cistercian nunneries despite attempted restrictions, see Roisin, Simone, “L'efflorescence cistercienne et le courant féminin de piété au xiiie siècle,” Revue d'histoire ecclésiastique 39 (1943): 342–378.Google Scholar

10. Moreau, Edouard de, Histoire de l'Eglise en Belgique, 6 vols. (Brussels, 1946–1952),Google Scholar 3: passim; AS, 16 June (4: 189–209); 1 July (1: 5–6); 16 June (4: 201–202).

11. Reypens, Leonce, ed., Vita Beatricis … (Antwerp, 1964);Google ScholarBollandiani, Socii, Catalogus Codicum hagiographicorum Bibliothecae regiae Bruxellensis, 4 vols. (Brussels, 1886), 2: 222–226Google Scholar (hereafter cited as Catalogus Bruxellensis); AS, 29 October (13: 100–135); Canivez, , L'Ordre de Citeaux en Belgique, pp. 193–198, 202–204Google Scholar on houses founded by Beatrice's father at Florival, Ramey, Val-des-Vierges and Nazareth.

12. ,AS, 5 April (1: 435–475); 436–440 on Cornillon.

13. Preger, Wilhelm, Geschichte der deutschen Mystik im Mittelalter, 3 vols. (Leipzig, 1874–1893), vol. 1,Google Scholar and Underhill, Evelyn, Mysticism (New York, 1957),Google Scholar provide good accounts of the mystic tradition, which was widespread in the thirteenth century in Cistercian, Dominican, Franciscan and beguine circles.

14. AS, 12 August (2: 754–768); Analecta Franciscana 3 (Quaracchi, 1897): 173–182;Google ScholarAS, 20 February (3: 169); 11 March (1: 52); 17 September (5: 463); Fortini, Arnaldo, Nova vita di San Francesco, 4 vols. (Assisi, 1950), 2: 315–349, 360–364, 437;Google ScholarPotthast, August, Regesta Pontificum romanorum unde ab anno post Christum natum MCXCVIII, 2 vols. (Berlin, 1874–1875):Google Scholar 15086 (hereafter cited as RPR, followed by number of papal bull).

15. Gottschalk, Joseph, St. Hedwig Herzogin von Schlesien (Cologne, 1961)Google Scholar discusses Hedwig's family. See also the appropriate articles in Caraffa, Filippo et al. , eds., Bibliotheca sanctorum, 12 vols. (Rome, 1961–,1970)Google Scholar: 4: 400; 7: 858; 8: 796; 1: 374; 1: 1185; 4: 933; 3: 122; 4: 1110; 8: 312; 4: 277; 11: 589 (hereafter cited as Bibliotheca sanctorum).

16. Warlop, E., The Flemish Nobility, 2 vols. to date (Courtrai, 1975-), 1: 276–284,Google Scholar discusses the indebtedness of the Flemish nobility. For Thomas of Cantimpré's life of Lutgard see AS, 16 June (4: 189–209).

17. de Sérent, Antoine, “L'Ordre de Sainte Claire en France pendant sept siècles,” Etudes franciscaines, n.s. 11 (1953): 134–135.Google Scholar

18. RPR, 18680.

19. AS, 3 September (1: 786) on Theresa of Santarem; 1 February (1: 259–260) on Veridiana Attavanti; 1 January (1: 349) on Gertrude of Oosten; 19 March (3: 67–71) on Sibyllina Biscossi.

20. Anon., “Vita beatae Margaritae virginis de Civitate Castelli sororis tertii ordinis de penitentia sancti Dominici,” Analecta Bollandiana 19 (1900): 22–36;Google ScholarLaurent, Marie Hyacinthe, “La plus ancienne légende de la B. Marguerite de Città di Castello,” Archivum Fratrum Praedicatorum 10 (1940): 109–131;Google Scholar Fatinellus de Fatinellis, Vita Zitae, in AS, 27 04 (3: 499–527).Google Scholar

21. Caesarius of Heisterbach, Vita sancte Elyzabeth Lantgravie, in Hilka, Alfons, ed., Die Wundergeschichten des Caesarius von Heisterbach, 3 vols. (Bonn, 1937), 3: 363:Google Scholar “quosdam vassalos mariti sui adversus eius derelictam, beatam scilicet Elyzabeth, sine causa commovit in tantum, ut eam miserabiliter satis de castro et omnibus possessionibus dotalitii sui eiecerunt”.

22. Guy of Cortona, Vita Humilianae, in AS, 19 May (4: 387). For other examples of familial opposition to the turn to religion, see Goodich, Michael, “Childhood and Adolescence among the Thirteenth Century Saints,” History of Childhood Quarterly 1 (1973): 285–309.Google Scholar

23. AS, 1 April (1: 3); 8 August (2: 395–398); on this hagiographical theme, see Bullough, Vern, “Transvestites in the Middle Ages,” American Journal of Sociology 79 (1973): 1381–1394;CrossRefGoogle ScholarAnson, John, “The Female Transvestite in Early Monasticism: The Origin and Development of a Motif,” Viator 5 (1974): 1–32.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

24. AS, 5 April (1: 444).

25. AS, 4 May (1: 537–539); 24 July (5: 655, 657).

26. Bardy, Gustave, “Catherine d'Alexandrie,” Dictionnaire d'histoire et de géographie ecclésiastiques, Alfred Baudrillart et al., eds., 17 vols. to date (Paris, 1912-), 11: 1503–1505.Google Scholar For a popular thirteenth-century account of the legend, see James, of Voragine, , Legenda aurea, ed. Johann Georg Theodor Graesse (Dresden, 1846), pp. 789–797.Google Scholar

27. “Ad susceptionem autem quarundam feminarum nobilium, quas parentes earum ratione paupertatis erudiendas et nutriendes tradebent hereticis, earum miseratus, opprobrium servus Dei Didaseus quoddam instituit monasterium … Prulianum.” Jordan, of Saxony, , De initiis ordinis, ed. Berthier, Joachim Joseph (Fribourg, 1890), cap. 18).Google Scholar See Bernard Gui, Historia fundationis conventum ordins Praedicatorum tolosanae et provinciae provinciarum, in Martène, Edmond and Durand, Ursinus, eds., Veterum scriptorum et monumentorum amplissima collectio, 9 vols. (Paris, 1724–1733), 6: 437–456 on the first Dominican convent.Google Scholar

28. Guiraud, Jean, ed., Cartulaire de Notre-Dame de Prouille, 2 vols. (Paris, 1907), 1: no. 1:Google Scholar “mulieres conversae per praedicatores ad praedicandum contra haereticos et ad repellendam haeresim pestiferam delegatos.”

29. Gerard of Fracheto, Chronica ordinis, in Reichert, Benedict M., ed., Monumenta ordinis Praedicatorum historica, 25 vols. (Louvain, 1896), 1: 322;Google ScholarRPR, 11624.

30. Vastovius, Johannes, Vitis Aquilonia sive Vitae sanctorum Sveo-Gothici, (Upsala, 1706), pp. 75–76.Google Scholar Ingrid's canonization hearing was initiated in 1414 along with that of Nicholas of Linkoping. See the fragment in Schück, Henrik, “Tvā svenska biografier fran medeltiden,” Antiquarisk Tidskrift 5 (1895): 463–474.Google Scholar

31. The history of the convent of Saint Agnes of Bologna was probably written between 1264 and 1283 by Aegidia. See Chronique de Sainte-Agnèse, in Analecta sacri ordinis praedicatorum, 24 vols. (Rome, 1893–1916), 1: 181:Google Scholar “ceperunt praeterea multe nobiles domini et illustris matrone de civitate Bononie ipsius (Diana) exemplo cum fratribus praedicatoribus familiaritatem et colloquium habere de salute animi.” For the life of Diana see Walz, Angelo, ed., B. Jordani de Saxonia epistolae, in Monumenta ordinis Praedicatorum historica, 25 vols. (Rome, 1951), 23: 195;Google ScholarAS, 9 06 (2: 256–263);Google ScholarAlessandrini, Alessandro, “Diana d'Andalo,” Dizionario biografico degli italiani, ed. Ghisalberti, Alberto Maria et al. , 12 vols. to date (Rome, 1960–), 1: 348–350.Google Scholar

32. RPR, 6631.

33. James of Vitry, Vita Mariae Oigniacensis, in AS, 23 06 (5: 542–572).Google Scholar

34. AS, 18 January (1: 180); 2 September (1: 582); 18 June (5: 532).

35. Maracci, O. M., “Bentivenga da Gubbio,” Dizionario biografico degli italiani 8: 589–591.Google Scholar

36. Faloci-Pulignani, Michele, ed., “Vita di S. Chiara da Montefalco scritta da Berengario di S. Africano,” Archivio storico per le Marche e per l'Umbria 1 (1884): 205–208.Google Scholar The account of their conversation here is a close paraphrase of this source.

37. AS, 10 May (2: 597–602); see the Chronicon of a monk of Padua in Rerum Italicarum Scriptores, ed. Muratori, Ludovico, 28 vols. (Milan, 1726), 7: 720–721;Google ScholarSeton, Walter, ed., Some New Sources for the Life of the Bl. Agnes of Bohemia, in British Society for Franciscan Studies 7 (Aberdeen, 1915);Google ScholarAS, 31 August (6: 787–808).

38. Lazzeri, Zefferino, ed., “II processo di S. Chiara d'Assisi,” Archivum Franciscanum Historicum 13 (1920): 403–507;Google ScholarAS, 4 September (2: 414–479).

39. AS, 11 June (2: 475); 24 July (5: 655–656).

40. Evêque, Garin of Guy-l', Legenda Margaretae, in AS, 28 01 (1: 904).Google Scholar

41. Lazzeri, ed., “II processo di S. Chiara d'Assisi,” pp. 403–507; AS, 16 June (4: 205); 9 November (4: 374); Franknoí, , Inquisitio, 1: 202, 214, 220;Google ScholarAS, 17 October (8: 263); Bibliotheca sanctorum, 11: 589–590.

42. Juncta of Bevagna, Vita Margaretae, in AS, 22 February (3: 300–356).

43. AS, 11 September (3: 902).

44. AS, 22 February (3: 304); Bibliotheca sanctorum, 4: 1096–1099.

45. AS, 5 April (1: 455); Roisin, Simone, L'hagiographie cistercienne dans le diocèse de Liège au xiiie siècle (Louvain, 1947).Google Scholar

46. Thomas of Cantimpré, Vita Lutgardis, in AS, 16 June (4: 189–210). Lutgard's prayers also helped Jordan of Saxony and others.

47. Thomas, of Cantimpré, , Vita Christianae, in AS, 24 07 (4: 656).Google Scholar

48. Paul, of Savino, San, Vita Gerardescae, in AS, 29 05 (7: 165).Google Scholar

49. Catalogus Bruxellensis, 2: 262–278; Biot, Rene, The Enigma of the Stigmata, trans. John, PatrickHepburne-Scott, (New York, 1962).Google ScholarAmann, Emile, “Stigmatisation,” Dictionnaire de théologie catholique, 14.2: 2616–2624,Google Scholar notes that no truly reliable list of stigmatized persons exists. See AS, 23 June (5: 552) for a description of Mary of Oignies's wounds.

50. Fredegondo Callaey, “Documentazione eucharistica liegesi dal vescovo di Liège Roberto di Torote al Papa Urban IV (1240–1264),” Miscellanea Pio Paschini, 2 vols. (Rome, 1948), 1: 215–315;Google ScholarAS, 5 April (1: 435–475); Emile Friedberg and Lewis Richter, eds., Corpus iuris canonici, 2 vols. (Leipzig, 1879),Google Scholar 2: Clementines, 3. 16.1; Coquelines, Charles, ed., Bullarum romanorum pontificum, 28 vols. (Rome, 1739–1750), 3: 75.Google Scholar

51. Werner, Ernst and Erbstösser, Martin, Ideologische Probleme des mittelalterlichen Pleberjertums: Die freigeistige Häresie und ihr sozialen Wurzeln (Berlin, 1960).Google Scholar

52. James, of Vitry, , Vita Mariae Oigniacensis, in AS, 23 06 (5: 547).Google Scholar Two works have recently appeared which deal with late medieval piety and sainthood. Finucane, Ronald C., Miracles and Pilgrims: Popular Beliefs in Medieval England (London, 1977)Google Scholar deals with the pilgrimage shrines of nine major twelfth and thirteenth century saints and the populations they attracted. Geary, Patrick, Furta Sacra: Thefts of Relics in the Central Middle Ages (Princeton, 1978)Google Scholar discusses the benefits which saint's relics accorded a community, and the lengths to which the community would go to secure them.