Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-t5pn6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-20T01:00:38.397Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Biblical Authority and the Impact of Higher Criticism in Irish Presbyterianism, ca. 1850–19301

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 July 2009

Andrew R. Holmes
Andrew R. Holmes
Affiliation:
Research Fellow at the Institute of Irish Studies, Queen's University, Belfast.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

The decades between 1850 and 1930 saw traditional understandings of Christianity subjected to rigorous social, intellectual, and theological criticism across the transatlantic world. Unprecedented urban and industrial expansion drew attention to the shortcomings of established models of church organization while traditional Christian beliefs concerning human origins and the authority of Scripture were assailed by new approaches to science and biblical higher criticism. In contradistinction to lower or textual criticism, higher criticism dealt with the development of the biblical text in broad terms. According to James Strahan, professor of Hebrew at Magee College, Derry, from 1915 to 1926, textual criticism aimed “at ascertaining the genuine text and meaning of an author” while higher “or historical, criticism seeks to answer a series of questions affecting the composition, editing and collection of the Sacred Books.” During the nineteenth century, the controversy over the use of higher critical methods focused for the most part upon the Old Testament. In particular, critics dismissed the Mosaic authorship and unity of the Pentateuch, arguing that it was the compilation of a number of early documentary fragments brought together by priests after the Babylonian Exile in the sixth century B.C. This “documentary hypothesis” is most often associated with the German scholar, Julius Wellhausen. Indeed, higher criticism had been fostered in the extensive university system of the various German states, which encouraged original research and the emergence of a professional intellectual elite. It reflected the desire of liberal theologians to adapt the Christian faith to the needs and values of modern culture, particularly natural science and history.

Type
Articles
Information
Church History , Volume 75 , Issue 2 , June 2006 , pp. 343 - 373
Copyright
Copyright © American Society of Church History 2006

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

2. Strahan, James, “Criticism (Old Testament),” in Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics, 13 vols., ed. James, Hastings (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1908–1926), 4:314Google Scholar. My understanding of the rise and principles of higher criticism is indebted to Bray, Gerald, Biblical Interpretation: Past and Present (Leicester, U.K.: Apollos, 1996)Google Scholar; Parsons, Gerald, “Biblical Criticism in Victorian Britain: From Controversy to Acceptance?” in Religion in Victorian Britain, 5 vols, ed. Gerald, Parsons and John, Wolffe (Manchester, U.K.: Manchester University Press, 1988–1997), 2:238–57Google Scholar; Rogerson, John, Old Testament Criticism in the Nineteenth Century: England and Germany (London: SPCK, 1984).Google Scholar

3. Marsden, G. M., Understanding Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1991), 32–36Google Scholar; Reardon, B. M. G., Religious Thought in the Nineteenth Century (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1966)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Reardon, , Liberal Protestantism (London: Adam and Charles Black, 1968).Google Scholar

4. Anderson, R. D., Universities and Elites in Britain since 1800 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995)Google Scholar; Noll, Mark A., Between Faith and Criticism: Evangelicals, Scholarship and the Bible, 2nd ed. (Leicester, U.K.: Apollos, 1991), 32–36.Google Scholar

5. Johnson, Dale A., The Changing Shape of English Nonconformity, 1825–1925 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999).Google Scholar

6. Rogerson, John, “The Old Testament,” in The History of Christian Theology, 3 vols., ed. Paul, Avis (Basingstoke, U.K.: Marshall Pickering, 1986–1991), 2:127–28.Google Scholar

7. Moody, T. W., “The Irish University Question in the Nineteenth Century,” History 43 (1958): 90–109.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

8. Allen, Robert, The Presbyterian College Belfast 1853–1953 (Belfast: William Mullan and Sons, 1954)Google Scholar; Holmes, R. F. G., Magee 1865–1965: The Evolution of the Magee Colleges (Belfast: Belfast News-Letter, 1965).Google Scholar

9. Holmes, A., “The Experience and Understanding of Religious Revival in Ulster Presbyterianism, c. 1800 to 1930,” Irish Historical Studies 34 (2005): 361–85.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

10. Marsden, , Understanding Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism, 35Google Scholar; Gerrish, B. A., “Friedrich Schleiermacher,” in Nineteenth Century Religious Thought in the West, 3 vols., ed. Ninian, Smart, John, Clayton, Steven, Katz, and Patrick, Sherry (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985), 1: chap. 4Google Scholar; Reardon, , Religious Thought in the Nineteenth Century, 20, 39–42.Google Scholar

11. Cameron, Nigel M. de S., Biblical Higher Criticism and the Defense of Infallibilism in Nineteenth-century Britain (Lewiston, N.Y.: Edwin Mellen, 1987), 106–11.Google Scholar

12. The discussion of Scottish attitudes to biblical criticism given here is indebted to the following works: McLeod, James Lachlan, The Second Disruption: The Free Church in Victorian Scotland and the Origins of the Free Presbyterian Church (East Linton, U.K.: Tuckwell, 2000)Google Scholar; Noll, , Between Faith and Criticism, 67–72Google Scholar; Riesen, R. A., Criticism and Faith in Late Victorian Scotland: A. B. Davidson, William Robertson Smith and George Adam Smith (Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1985).Google Scholar

13. Rogerson, , Old Testament Criticism in the Nineteenth Century, 278.Google Scholar

14. See especially Riesen, Richard A., “‘Higher Criticism’ in the Free Church Fathers,” Records of the Scottish Church History Society 20 (1979): 119–42Google Scholar; Riesen, , Criticism and Faith in Late Victorian ScotlandGoogle Scholar; and Needham, N. R., The Doctrine of Holy Scripture in the Free Church Fathers (Edinburgh: Rutherford House Books, 1991).Google Scholar

15. The religious and cultural background may be traced from the following: Hempton, David and Hill, Myrtle, Evangelical Protestantism in Ulster Society 1740–1890 (London: Routledge, 1992)CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Holmes, R. F. G., “‘Ulster Will Fight and Ulster Will Be Right’: The Protestant Churches and Ulster's Resistance to Home Rule, 1912–14,” in The Church and War, ed. Sheils, W. J., Studies in Church History 20 (Oxford: Blackwell, 1983), 321–35Google Scholar; Holmes, , “United Irishmen and Unionists: Irish Presbyterians, 1791 and 1886,” in The Churches, Ireland, and the Irish, ed. Sheils, W. J. and Diana, Wood, Studies in Church History 25 (Oxford: Blackwell, 1989), 171–89Google Scholar; Livingstone, D. N. and Wells, R. A., Ulster-American Religion: Episodes in the History of a Cultural Connection (Notre Dame, Ind.: University of Notre Dame Press, 1999).Google Scholar

16. Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, 35–37.Google Scholar

17. The Confession of Faith: The Larger and Shorter Catechisms, with the Scripture Proofs at Large (Inverness, U.K.: Publications Committee of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland, 1976), 19–24.Google Scholar

18. Croskery, Thomas, “The Rev. Robert Wilson, D.D., Late Professor of Biblical Literature in the Belfast Presbyterian College,” in Irish Worthies: A Series of Original Biographical Sketches of Eminent Ministers and Members of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, ed. Thomas, Hamilton (Belfast: William Mullan, 1875), 80–87Google Scholar. For Davidson, see Rogerson, , Old Testament Criticism in the Nineteenth Century, chap.14.Google Scholar

19. For representative statements, see Killen, W. D., Academic Addresses, on Various Occasions (Belfast: William McComb, 1863)Google Scholar. See also the addresses delivered by other members of the Assembly's College staff as reported in the Banner of Ulster: Porter, J. L., 15 November 1860Google Scholar; Gibson, William, “Self Development,” 29 April 1865Google Scholar; Watts, Robert, “The Ministerial Curriculum,” 15 November 1866Google Scholar; Wallace, Henry, 25 April 1868.Google Scholar

20. Noll, Mark A., The Princeton Theology, 1812–1921: Scripture, Science, and Theological Method: From Archibald Alexander to Benjamin Breckenridge Warfield, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Academic, 2001), 40.Google Scholar

21. Carson, Alexander, Works, 6 vols. (Dublin: William Carson, 1847–1864)Google Scholar, vol. 3. The German works translated by Murphy included Keil, C. F., Commentary on the Book of Kings (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1854, 1857)Google Scholar; Zöckler, Otto, The Books of Chronicles Theologically and Homiletically Expounded (Edinburg: T and T Clark, 1868, 1876)Google Scholar; Hengstenberg, E. W., The Prophecies of the Prophet Ezekiel, trans. Murphy, A. C. and Murphy, J. G. (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1869).Google Scholar

22. See the following for significant statements of the Irish Presbyterian position: Given, J. J., The Truth of Scripture in Connection with Revelation, Inspiration and Canon (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1881)Google Scholar; Murphy, J. G., “The Bible the Word of God,” Evangelical Witness, 2 (1863): 141–43Google Scholar; Niblock, William, An Essay on the Plenary and Verbal Inspiration of the Scriptures (Belfast: William McComb, 1857)Google Scholar; Watts, Robert, The Rule of Faith and the Doctrine of Inspiration (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1885).Google Scholar

23. Klemme, Heiner F., “Scepticism and Common Sense,” in The Cambridge Companion to the Scottish Enlightenment, ed. Alexander, Broadie (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003), chap. 6.Google Scholar

24. Noll, Mark A., “Common Sense Traditions and American Evangelical Thought,” American Quarterly 37 (1985): 216–38, 220.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

25. For a stimulating indication of this, see Broadie, Alexander, “The Human Mind and Its Powers,” in Broadie, Cambridge Companion, chap. 3.Google Scholar

26. McCosh, James, The Scottish Philosophy, Biographical, Expository, Critical, from Hutcheson to Hamilton (London: Macmillan, 1875), 6.Google Scholar

27. McBride, I. R., “The School of Virtue': Francis Hutcheson, Irish Presbyterians and the Scottish Enlightenment,” in Political Thought in Ireland since the Seventeenth Century, ed. Boyce, D. G., Robert, Eccleshall, and Vincent, Geoghegan (London: Routledge, 1993), 73–99Google Scholar; Bishop, I. M., “The Education of Ulster Students at Glasgow University during the Eighteenth Eentury” (M.A. diss., Queen's University, Belfast [hereafter, QUB], 1987).Google Scholar

28. Graham, Gordon, “The Nineteenth-century Aftermath,” in Broadie, Cambridge Companion, 347–49.Google Scholar

29. Bebbington, D. W., Evangelicalism in Modern Britain: A History from the 1730s to the 1980s, rev. ed. (London: Routledge, 1995), 86–91Google Scholar; Harris, Harriet, Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism (Oxford: Clarendon, 1998), 122–26.Google Scholar

30. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 101, 179Google Scholar; Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, 7–8.Google Scholar

31. Needham, , The Doctrine of Holy Scripture in the Free Church Fathers, 34–45.Google Scholar

32. Noll, , Between Faith and Criticism, 136.Google Scholar

33. Davidson, Samuel, Lectures in Biblical Criticism, Exhibiting a Systematic View of That Science (Edinburgh: Thomas Clark, 1839), 2, 8Google Scholar; Given, J. J., The Inspiration of the Scriptures (Londonderry, U.K.: n.p., 1877), 4–5.Google Scholar

34. For example, Murphy, J. G., An Inaugural Lecture on the Hebrew Language (Dublin: Leckie, 1847)Google Scholar; Murphy, , The Elements of Hebrew Grammar (London: David Nutt, 1857)Google Scholar; Porter, J. S., Principles of Textual Criticism, with Their Application to the Old and New Testaments (London: Simms and Mclnytre, 1848).Google Scholar

35. Porter, J. L., Bishop Colenso on the Pentateuch Reviewed (Belfast: C. Aitchison, 1863), 20.Google ScholarMurphy, J. G., A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Genesis, with a New Translation (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1863), 13–16.Google Scholar

36. Davidson, Samuel, “Scripture and Reason,” Orthodox Presbyterian, n.s. 1 (1838): 45.Google Scholar

37. Murphy, J. C., “Common Sense,” Presbyterian Churchman (1890): 148Google Scholar. Murphy had previously published an extended discussion of mental philosophy: The Human Mind: A System of Mental Philosophy, for the General Reader (Belfast: William Mullan, 1873).Google Scholar

38. Given, , The Truth of Scripture, 132Google Scholar; Murphy, , “Common Sense,” 149.Google Scholar

39. For example, Porter, J. L., Illustrations of Bible Prophecy and History from Personal Travels in Palestine (Dublin: Hodges, Figgis, 1883).Google Scholar A list of his principal publications may be found in Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 309.Google Scholar

40. Martin, W. T., Our Church in Its Relation to Progressive Thought. A lecture … Delivered before the Newry Presbyterian Young Men's Society, in the Sandys-Street Church, November 3rd, 1863 (Newry, U.K.: n.p., 1863), 5–11Google Scholar; Murphy, J. G., The Nineteen Alleged Impossibilities of Part I & II of Colenso on the Pentateuch, Shown to Be Possible: With a Critique on Part II (Belfast: William McComb and C. Aitchison, 1863)Google Scholar; Porter, , Bishop Colenso on the PentateuchGoogle Scholar; Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, 25–26Google Scholar.

41. Livingstone, D. N., “Darwinism and Calvinism: the Belfast-Princeton Connection,” Isis 83 (1992): 408–28.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

42. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 183.Google Scholar

43. Leitch, Matthew, “Modern Criticism of the Pentateuch,” The Witness, 7 11 1890, 5.Google Scholar

44. Watts, Robert, The Newer Criticism and the Analogy of Faith: A Reply to Lectures by W. Robertson Smith, MA., on the Old Testament and the Jewish Church (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1881), chap. 1.Google Scholar

45. For example, Wilson, Samuel Law, “Will the Critics Leave Us a Working Theory of Inspiration?,” Witness, 1 04 1892, 3.Google Scholar

46. Cameron, , Biblical Higher Criticism, 117–20Google Scholar; Moore, James R., “Geologists and Interpreters of Genesis in the Nineteenth Century,” in God and Nature: Historical Essays in the Encounter between Christianity and Science, ed. Lindberg, D. C. and Numbers, R. L. (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1986), chap. 13.Google Scholar

47. Leitch, Matthew, “The Bible and the Age,” Witness, 14 11 1879, 5.Google Scholar

48. Dickey, R. H. F., “The Higher Criticism,” Witness, 6 11 1891, 2.Google Scholar

49. Dickey, R. H. F., “Inspiration,” Witness, 5 04 1895, 2.Google Scholar

50. Dickey, , “The Higher Criticism.”Google Scholar

51. Murphy, J. G., “The Book of Deuteronomy,” British and Foreign Evangelical Review, n.s. 27 (1878): 105–26Google Scholar; Bigger, J. L., “Priests and Levites,” Christian Church 1 (1881): 151–55Google Scholar; “The Revised Pentateuch,” Christian Church 1 (1881): 249–55Google Scholar; “The Encyclopaedia Britannica'—Wellhausen on Israel,” Christian Church 2 (1882): 1–5.Google Scholar

52. Watts, Robert, “The Post-exilic Period,” in Lex Mosaica or the Law of Moses and the Higher Criticism, ed. French, R. V. (London: Eyre and Spottiswoode, 1894), 562.Google Scholar

53. Leitch, Matthew, “Unscientific Criticism of the Bible,” Witness, 13 04 1906, 7.Google Scholar

54. For broader comments about this issue, see Harris, , Fundamentalism and Evangelicalism, chap. 5.Google Scholar

55. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 164.Google Scholar For other examples of Irish concern with trends in Scottish theology, see Croskery, Thomas, “Scotch Sermons,” British and Foreign Evangelical Review 29 (1880): 621–52Google Scholar, and the comments of Orr, J. H., reported in Alliance of the Reformed Churches Holding the Presbyterian System: Minutes and Proceedings of the Fourth General Council London, 1888, ed. Matthew, G. D. (London: Presbyterian Alliance Office, 1889), 294–99.Google Scholar

56. Watts, , The Newer Criticism and the Analogy of Faith, ix.Google Scholar

57. Leitch, Matthew, Deuteronomy; The Key to the Higher Criticism of the Old Testament (London: The Religious Tract Society, [1905]), 6–7.Google ScholarLeitch, Matthew, “Robertson Smith's lectures,” Presbyterian Churchman 5 (1881): 253–55.Google Scholar

58. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 162–63.Google Scholar

59. Ulster Unionist Convention: Held in Belfast, 17th June 1892: Report of the Great Meeting of 12,000 Delegates from All the Counties of Ulster, and of the Open-air Meeting in the Royal Botanic Gardens, Belfast (Belfast: Belfast News-Letter, 1892)Google Scholar; Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 232.Google Scholar

60. Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, 37.Google Scholar

61. Hempton, and Hill, , Evangelical Protestantism in Ulster society, chap. 8Google Scholar; Holmes, Janice, Religious Revivals in Britain and Ireland 1859–1905 (Dublin: Irish Academic Press, 2000)Google Scholar; Thompson, Joseph, “The Influence of D. L. Moody on Irish Presbyterianism,” in Ebb and Flow: Essays in Church History in Honour of R. Finlay G. Holmes, ed. Patton, W. D. (Belfast: Presbyterian Historical Society of Ireland, 2002), 119–40.Google Scholar

62. Bebbington, , Evangelicalism in Modern Britain, chap. 4Google Scholar; Bebbington, , Holiness in Nineteenth-century England (Carlisle, U.K.: Paternoster, 2000), chap. 4Google Scholar; Carson, J. T., The River of God Is Full: Portstewart Convention through Seventy Five Years 1914–1988 (Belfast: The Universities Press, 1989).Google Scholar

63. Graham, , “The Nineteenth-century Aftermath,” 349.Google Scholar

64. Johnson, , The Changing Shape of English Nonconformity, 161.Google Scholar

65. Moody, , “The Irish University Question,” 100–103.Google Scholar

66. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 190–91Google Scholar; Latimer, W. T., “The Assembly's Theological Committee,” letter to the Northern Whig, 28 04 1902Google Scholar; W. T. Latimer, “Cuttings 1900–1910,” Robert Allen material, box 2, Special Collections, QUB.

67. Latimer, W. T., “The New Code,” letter to The Witness, 11 November 1909Google Scholar; W. T. Latimer, “Cuttings–biographies etc. 1907–1910,” Robert Allen material, box 2, Special Collections, QUB.

68. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 142–43Google Scholar; Holmes, , Magee, 53.Google Scholar

69. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 199–208.Google Scholar

70. Witness, 9 November 1888, 5.Google Scholar

71. Walker, Thomas, “Importance of the Critical Study of the Old Testament,” Witness, 9 11 1888, 5.Google Scholar

72. Walker, Thomas, “An Educated Ministry,” Witness, 4 04 1890, 4.Google Scholar

73. Witness, 11 April 1890, 4Google Scholar; Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 201. The lecture was also debated in the Presbyterian Churchman (1890): 132–33, 167–68Google Scholar, and criticized by Dick, James, a Reformed Presbyterian minister: “Professor Walker's Closing Address,” The Covenanter, n.s. 22 (1890): 157–60.Google Scholar

74. His only known scholarly publication was the article, “Targum,” in A Dictionary of the Bible Dealing with Its Language, Literature and Contents including the Biblical Theology, 5 vols., ed. James, Hastings (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1898–1909), 4:678–83.Google Scholar

75. Walker, “Importance of the Critical Study of the Old Testament”; cf. “An Educated Ministry.”

76. Walker, Thomas, “William Robertson Smith,” Witness, 25 10 1912, 6.Google Scholar

77. Walker, Thomas, “Recent Critical Study of the Old Testament,” Witness, 11 04 1913, 5.Google Scholar

78. Walker, Thomas, “Recent Criticism of the Book of Psalms,” Witness, 2 11 1894, 3.Google Scholar

79. Walker, “William Robertson Smith.”

80. Riesen, R. A., “Scholarship and Piety: The Sermons of William Roberston Smith,” in William Robertson Smith: Essays in Reassessment, ed. William, Johnston (Sheffield, U.K.: Sheffield Academic Press, 1996), 86–94Google Scholar; Moorhead, Joseph, Problems of the Irish Presby terian Church (Banbridge, U.K.: Banbridge Chronicle, 1909), 16–17Google Scholar; Taylor, D. A., Via Media: Two Addresses to Theological Students (London: S. W. Partridge, 1900), 15, 22.Google Scholar

81. For the situation in Assembly's, see Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 224–26.Google Scholar

82. Latimer, W. T., “A History of Irish Presbyterians in Modern Times Vol. 1, 1888–91,” 45, Robert Allen material, box 3, Special Collections, QUB.Google Scholar

83. Walker, “Recent Critical Study of the Old Testament.”

84. For the criticism of Schweitzer, see “Recent Criticism and Interpretation of the New Testament in Relation to Jesus Christ,” Witness, 28 October 1910, 7Google Scholar. Other Examples by Leitch, include, “The Present Drift of the Higher Criticism of the Gospel,” Witness, 29 10 1897, 3Google Scholar, and “Principles of the Higher Criticism of the Old Testament in Their Application to the New Testament,” Witness, 8 April 1898, 3Google Scholar. See also Samuel, Law Wilson, “The Return to Christ,” Witness, 29 10 1909, 6.Google Scholar

85. Hamill, Thomas Macafee, “Christ's Redemptive Work,” Witness, 9 04 1909, 5Google Scholar; Smith, David, The Atonement in the Light of History and the Modern Spirit (London: Hodder and Stoughton, n.d.).Google Scholar

86. Leebody, J. R., “The Influence of Nineteenth-century Science on Religious Thought,” Witness, 6 04 1900, 5.Google Scholar

87. Smith, David, The Days of His Flesh: The Earthly Life of Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, 2nd ed. (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1905).Google Scholar

88. Smith, David, Christian Counsel (London: Hodder and Stoughton, n.d.), 135.Google Scholar

89. Smith, , Atonement, 123–35.Google Scholar

90. Strahan, James, Andrew Bruce Davidson (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1917)Google Scholar. Strahan was also Cunningham Lecturer at New College, Edinburgh, in 1914. His publications include, Hebrew Ideals from the Story of the Patriarchs: A Study of Old Testament Faith and Life (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, n.d.)Google Scholar; The Book of Job Interpreted (Edinburgh: T and T Clark, 1913)Google Scholar; God in History (London: James Clark, n.d.).Google Scholar

91. “Criticism (Old Testament),” in Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics, ed. Hastings, , 4:318.Google Scholar

92. “Inspiration (Protestant Doctrine),” in Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics, ed. Hastings, , 8:346–50.Google Scholar

93. Lewis, H. D., “The British Idealists,” in Nineteenth Century Religious Thought in the West, 2:297–98, 307–10.Google Scholar

94. For an overview of developments within English nonconformist theology, see Johnson, , The Changing Shape of English Nonconformity, chaps. 6 and 7Google Scholar. The standard biography is Fulton's, A. A. sympathetic J. Ernest Davey (Belfast: Presbyterian Church in Ireland, 1970)Google Scholar. For a critique of Davey's theology, see Thompson, John, “The Theology of J. E. Davey: An Evaluation,” Biblical Theology, 21 (1971): 20–24.Google Scholar

95. Davey, J. E., The Church and the Gospel: Two Lectures Delivered in the Chapel of the Assembly's College, Belfast (Belfast: n.p., [1918]).Google Scholar

96. Davey, J. E., The Changing Vesture of the Faith: Studies in the Origins and Development of Christian Forms of Belief, Institution and Observance (London: James Clark [1923]), 19.Google Scholar

97. Holmes, R. F. G., Our Irish Presbyterian Heritage (Belfast: Publications Committee of the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, 1985), 151–53.Google Scholar

98. Barnes, Stanley, All for Jesus: The Life of W. P. Nicholson (Belfast: Ambassador, 1996)Google Scholar; Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, chap. 5Google Scholar; Murray, S. W., W. P. Nicholson: Flame for God in Ulster (Belfast: The Presbyterian Fellowship, 1973)Google Scholar; Wells, R. A., “Transatlantic Revivalism and Ulster Identity: The Career of W. P. Nicholson,” in Atlantic Crossroads: Historical Connections between Scotland, Ulster and North America, ed. Patrick, Fitzgerald and Steve, Ickringill (Newtownards, U.K.: Colourpoint, 2001), chap. 7.Google Scholar

99. Nicholson, W. P., The Evangelist: His Ministry and Message (London: Marshall, Morgan, and Scott, n.d.), 30–31.Google Scholar

100. For broader comments, see Bebbington, Evangelicalism in Modern Britain, chap. 6; Bray, , Biblical Interpretation, 306–9Google Scholar; Noll, , Between Faith and Criticism, 48–51.Google Scholar

101. Witness, 23 November 1900, 5.Google Scholar

102. Latimer, W. T., “Irish Presbyterianism,” Witness, 2 06 1903; “Cuttings 1903,” Robert Allen material, box 3, Special Collections, QUB.Google Scholar

103. Articles of Constitution of Presbyterian Bible Standards League (Belfast: np., 1926).Google Scholar

104. Livingstone, and Wells, , Ulster-American Religion, 66.Google Scholar For Grier, see “In Memoriam: Rev W. J. Crier 1902–1983,” Evangelical Presbyterian (October 1983): 2–16.Google Scholar

105. Hart, D. G., Defending the Faith: J. Gresham Machen and the Crisis of Conservative Protestantism in Modern America (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker Books, 1995).Google Scholar

106. Witness, 8 June 1927, 2.Google Scholar

107. Record of the Trial of the Rev. Prof J. E. Davey by the Belfast Presbytery, and of the Hearing of Appeals by the General Assembly, 1927 (Belfast: printed at the “Witness” office, [1927]), 111–41.Google Scholar

108. Ibid., 123.

109. Ibid., 126.

110. Noll, , Between Faith and Criticism, 75–78; Bebbington, Evangelicalism in Modern Britain, chap. 6.Google Scholar

111. Allen, , The Presbyterian College Belfast, 259–61.Google Scholar

112. Pollock, John, A Cambridge Movement (London: John Murray, 1953)Google Scholar, illustration facing 182. I am grateful to Stephen Gregory for drawing my attention to this source.

113. Davey, J. E., A Memoir of the Reverend Charles Davey of Belfast D.D. (Belfast: McCaw, Stevenson, and Orr, 1921).Google Scholar

114. Record of the Trial of the Rev. Prof J. E. Davey, 190, cf. 140.Google Scholar

115. Ibid., 192.

116. Haire, James, “Christianity, the Final Religion,” Witness, 9 04 1920, 6.Google Scholar

117. Strahan, James, The Maréchale (London: James Clark, n.d.).Google Scholar

118. Strahan, James, “What Ireland Needs,” Irish Presbyterian, n.s. 27 (1921): 2Google Scholar; “Spiritual Revival,” Witness, 3 November 1922, 5Google Scholar; Smith, David, “Sacred Learning: Its Evangelical Necessity,” Witness, 27 10 1922, 4.Google Scholar

119. Carson, , The River of God Is Full, 5–8.Google Scholar

120. Bebbington, David, “Martyrs for the Truth: Fundamentalism in Britain,” in Martyrs and Martyrologies, Studies in Church History 30, ed. Diana, Wood (Oxford: Blackwell for the Ecclesiastical History Society, 1993), 417–51Google Scholar; Marsden, G. M., Fundamentalism and American Culture: The Shaping of Twentieth-century Evangelicalism 1870–1925 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1980).Google Scholar

121. Douglas, Jacobsen and Trollinger, W. V. Jr., ed., Re-forming the Center: American Protestantism, 1900 to the Present (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1998).Google Scholar

122. The American situation is covered by Longfield, Bradley in The Presbyterian Controversy: Fundamentalists, Modernists, and Moderates (New York: Oxford University Press, 1991)Google Scholar. For overviews of twentieth-century Irish Presbyterianism, see Mitchel, Patrick, Evangelicalism and National Identity in Ulster, 1921–1998 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), chap. 7CrossRefGoogle Scholar, and Holmes, Our Irish Presbyterian Heritage, chap. 5.

123. Bruce, Steve, God Save Ulster: The Religion and Politics of Paisleyism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1986).Google Scholar