Skip to main content Accessibility help

Young Women Subject to Statutory Orders and the Transition to Independence: Contradictions in policy and practice

  • Margaret Liddell (a1)


This paper examines the way the state welfare system deals with young women who are subject to statutory orders and their need for support as they move towards independence. Young women’s views of their needs are highlighted. Evidence is drawn from the author’s and other relevant Australian and overseas research. The issues are examined within the context of general community trends and policy and practice implications are studied using Community Services Victoria as a case example.

A variety of social and economic factors are leading to young people in the general community living with their parents for longer periods of time. In contrast, young people subject to statutory orders, especially young women, are often being discharged from these orders - and thus isolated from adult guidance - shortly after they pass their mid-teens.

Assumptions about these young women’s needs - that they no longer require nor wish for support and are ready for complete independence at this early age - are challenged. The legal, organisational and practice constraints which reinforce these assumptions are analysed. The apparent contradiction arising from young women refusing services which they also say they require, is also discussed.

The author demonstrates that there is a need for a reconceptualisation of the issue. A new kind of partnership between workers and young women on statutory orders is needed and a policy and administrative framework which facilitates this. The implications of the findings for practice and policy - and especially the important contribution ttiat young women’s views can make to the development of social policy - are presented.



Hide All
Aldgate, H; Maluccio, A; & Reeves, C. (1989) Adolescents in Foster Families, London: Batsford.
Alder, C & Sandor, D. (1989) Homeless Youth as Victims of Violence, Melb: University of Melbourne, Department of Criminology.
Attorney–General’s Department (Courts Management Division) (1990) Children’s Court Statistics, Victoria.
Bryson, L & Edwards, A. (1988) ‘Gender, Social Control and Community Services’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology, Vol 24, No 3, November.
Chesney-Lind, M. (1985) ‘Girls and Deinstitut ionalisation: Is Sexism and Juvenile Justice a Dead Issue’, Paper presented it Annual Meeting of the American Society of Criminology, San Diego.
Community Services Victoria, (1991) Client Information System, (unpublished) Melbourne.
Gamble, H. (1985) ‘Status Offenders’ in Borowski, A. & Murray, J. (eds) Juvenile Delinquency in Australia, Sydney: Methven.
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. (1989) Our Homeless Children, Canberra: AGPS.
Hancock, L. & Chesney-Lind, M. (1985) ‘Juvenile Justice: Legislation and Gender Discrimination’, in Borowski, A. & Murray, J. (eds) Juvenile Delinquency in Australia, Sydney: Methven.
Higgins, D. (1990) Who Cares Anyway: The Control, Protection and Punishment of Young Women in the Juvenile Justice System in Victoria, Melbourne: Girls Action Inc.
Hildebrand, S. & McDowell, M. (1990a) Policy and Planning for Appropriate Service Responses for Young Women, (unpubl.rept.) Melb.: CSV.
Hildebrand, S. & McDowell, M. (1990b) Study of Young Women admitted to Winlaton, (unpubl. rept.) Melb.: CSV.
Hildebrand, S. & McDowell, M. (1990c) Study of Short Stays in Winlaton, Turana and Baltara Institutions, (unpubl. rept.) Melb.: CSV.
Hirst, C. (1989) Forced Exit: Youth Homeless-ness Policy Development Project, Melbourne: Salvation Army.
Liddell, M. & Goddard, C. (1991) ‘State Wardship and Supervision and Youth Homelessness: Towards a Better Future’, National Social Policy Conference Proceedings, Sydney, Australia.
Liddell, M., Hynes, S. & McKenzie, K. (1989) Young Women Say… a survey of the accommodation and support needs of a sample of young women in the Western Port Region, Melbourne: CSV.
Murray, J. (1981) Innovations in Juvenile Justice in Victoria 1970–1980, a thesis submitted for a degree of master of Social Work, Latrobe University, Victoria.
Piper, K. & Smith, G. (1990) ‘Victims, Nuisances or Both? Changing Protective Services for Young People’, Children Australia, Vol. 15, No 3.
Sarri, R. (1983) ‘Gender Issues in Juvenile Justice’, Crime and Delinquency, Vol 29, No 3, July 1983.
Women’s Co-ordination Unit, Premiers Dept. (1986) Girls at Risk, Sydney: NSW Govt.
Youth Policy Development Council, Dept. of Labour (1988) Nothing Wrong with Me, Melbourne: Victorian Govt.

Related content

Powered by UNSILO

Young Women Subject to Statutory Orders and the Transition to Independence: Contradictions in policy and practice

  • Margaret Liddell (a1)


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed.