Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-wq2xx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-16T19:55:35.769Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

Leadership and Uncertainty in Fiscal Restructuring: Ralph Klein and Roy Romanow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 July 2005

Cristine de Clercy
Cristine de Clercy
Affiliation:
University of Saskatchewan
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Abstract. In the literature on leadership, the Certainty Axiom holds that leaders exercise leadership through reassuring uncertain citizens. It is thought that policy entrepreneurs particularly must supply much certainty to lead people to adopt new policies. A new theory—the Strategic Manipulation of Uncertainty (SMU) model—challenges this axiom. Its propositions hold that political leaders may strategically address public uncertainty to secure specific objectives. Risk-averse, traditional (“transactional”) leaders communicate more certainty, and less uncertainty, than their transformational counterparts. Risk-acceptant, entrepreneurial (“transformational”) leaders supply less certainty, and more uncertainty, than their transactional counterparts. Testing these hypotheses through analyzing the public speeches of Saskatchewan Premier Roy Romanow and Alberta Premier Ralph Klein supports the SMU model. As a transactional leader, Premier Romanow communicated more certainty, and less uncertainty, than Premier Klein. Premier Klein communicated less certainty, and more uncertainty, than Premier Romanow. The results challenge the utility of the Certainty Axiom and suggest that leaders address citizens' uncertainty strategically, increasing it or reducing it, in pursuit of particular policy objectives.

Résumé. Dans la littérature sur le leadership, l'axiome de la certitude stipule que les dirigeants exercent leur leadership en réassurant les citoyens incertains. On considère que les initiateurs de politiques publiques en particulier doivent transmettre beaucoup de certitude pour convaincre le public d'adopter de nouvelles politiques. Une nouvelle théorie—le modèle de la Manipulation stratégique de l'incertitude—remet en question cet axiome. Ce modèle propose que les dirigeants politiques puissent s'adresser stratégiquement à l'incertitude du public afin d'atteindre des objectifs spécifiques. Les dirigeants traditionnels, prenant peu de risques (“ transactionnels ”), communiquent plus de certitude, et moins d'incertitude, tandis que les dirigeants prenant des risques, entreprenant (“ transformationnels ”), offrent moins de certitude et plus d'incertitude. Ces hypothèses sont testées en analysant les discours publics du Premier Ministre de la Saskatchewan, Roy Romanow et du Premier Ministre de l'Alberta, Ralph Klein. Ceci confirme le modèle. En tant que dirigeant “ transactionnel ”, Roy Romanow était plus rassurant que son homologue, Ralph Klein, en ce qui concerne la restructuration fiscale. Les résultats contestent l'utilité de l'axiome de la certitude et suggèrent que les dirigeants entreprenants peuvent bénéficier de l'incertitude des citoyens.

Type
Research Article
Information
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique , Volume 38 , Issue 1 , March 2005 , pp. 175 - 202
Copyright
© 2005 Cambridge University Press

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

“Balancing Act.” 1996. The London Free Press, May 8: A3.
Blondel, Jean. 1987. Political Leadership: Towards a General Analysis. London: SAGE Publications.
Bruce, Christopher, Ronald Kneebone and Kenneth McKenzie, eds. 1997. A Government Reinvented: A Study of Alberta's Deficit Elimination Program. Toronto: Oxford University Press.
Brummett, Barry. 1980. “Towards a Theory of Silence as a Political Strategy.” The Quarterly Journal of Speech, 66: 289–303.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Burns, James MacGregor. 1978. Leadership. New York, NY: Harper & Row.
Carter, Jimmy. 1980. “Energy and National Goals: Address to the Nation, July 15, 1979.” In Public Papers of the Presidents of the United States: Jimmy Carter, Volume II. Washington, DC: United States Government Printing Office, 1235–1241.
Cohen, Andrew. 1996. “Prairie Sun.” Report on Business Magazine, 97–105.
Cooper, Barry. 1996. The Klein Achievement. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Cooper, Barry and Mebs Kanji. 2000. Governing in Post-deficit Times: Alberta in the Klein Years. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Corelli, Rae. 1995. “Saskatchewan's New Idea.” Maclean's, July 31, 16.
Cushman, David O. and Robert F. Lucas. 2001. “Western Deficits: Common Causes.” In Deficit Reduction in the Far West: The Great Experiment, eds. Paul Boothe and Bradford Reid. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
Dabbs, Frank. 1995. Ralph Klein: A Maverick Life. Vancouver: Greystone Books.
de Clercy, Cristine. 2000. “Leadership and the Strategic Manipulation of Uncertainty.” Doctoral dissertation. Department of Political Science, The University of Western Ontario. London, Ontario.
de Clercy, Cristine. 2001. “Policy Innovation and Deficit Reduction: Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia.” In Deficit Reduction in the Far West: The Great Experiment, eds. Paul Boothe and Bradford Reid. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
Denis, Claude. 1995. “The New Normal: Capitalist Discipline in Alberta in the 1990s.” In The Trojan Horse: Alberta and the Future of Canada, eds. Trevor Harrison and Gordon Laxer. Montreal: Black Rose.
Douglas, Roger. 1993. Unfinished Business. Auckland: Random House.
Downs, Anthony. 1957. An Economic Theory of Democracy. New York, NY.: Harper & Row.
Frendreis, John P. 1983. “Explanation of Variation and the Detection of Covariation: The Purpose and Logic of Comparative Analysis.” Comparative Political Studies (July): 255–272.Google Scholar
Friedman, Milton and Rose Friedman. 1984. Tyranny of the Status Quo. San Francisco,CA: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Gibbins, Roger. 2001. “Staying the Course? Historical Determinants of Debt Management Strategies in Western Canada.” In Deficit Reduction in the Far West: The Great Experiment, eds. Paul Boothe and Bradford Reid. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
Government of Alberta. Alberta Financial Review Commission. 1993. Report to Albertans. Edmonton: Government of Alberta.
Government of Alberta. Premier's Office. 1994a. “Notes for an Address by Premier Ralph Klein to the C.D. Howe Institute.” March 2.
Government of Alberta. Premier's Office. 1994b. “Notes for Premier Klein's Financial Review Speech.” February 13.
Government of Alberta. Premier's Office. 1995. “Notes for an Address by Premier Ralph Klein to the ‘Changing Fortunes’ Roundtable.” July 7.
Government of Alberta. Premier's Office. 2004. “Alberta to be first debt-free province in Canada.” News release, July 15, available at http://www.gov.ab.ca/home/index.cfm?page=852., site last Accessed July 17, 2004.
Government of Saskatchewan. Department of Finance. 1992. Budget Address. Regina: Queen's Printer.
Government of Saskatchewan. 1992b. Saskatchewan Financial Review Commission: Summary and Highlights. Regina: Queen's Printer.
Government of Saskatchewan. 1992c. Transcript of the “Premier's Broadcast.” STN Network, May 3.
Government of Saskatchewan. Department of Finance. 1993. Budget Address. Regina: Queen's Printer.
Government of Saskatchewan. Executive Council Office. 1994. “Notes for Remarks—Premier Roy Romanow, Association of Kin Clubs—District 3—Regina.” March 21.
Government of Saskatchewan. Media Services. 1996. News Release. March 1.
Ha, Tu Thanh. 1996. “Bouchard hit with own tactics.” The Globe and Mail, November 25, A4.
Helmer, Joanne. 1995. “Redefining Normal: Life in the New Alberta.” In The Trojan Horse: Alberta and the Future of Canada, eds. Trevor Harrison and Gordon Laxer. Montreal: Black Rose.
Kellerman, Barbara. 1984. “Leadership as a Political Act.” In Leadership: Multidisciplinary Perspectives, ed. Barbara Kellerman. Englewood Cliffs, NJ.: Prentice-Hall.
Kwon, O. Yul. 1991. “Saskatchewan: Provincial Public Finances.” In Provincial Public Finances: Provincial Surveys, volume 1, ed. Melville MacMillan. Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation.
Laghi, Brian. 1996. “Alberta to limit propping up of business.” The Globe and Mail, February 14, A3.
Lewis, Eugene. 1984. “The Political Leader as Entrepreneur.” In Leadership: Multidisciplinary Perspectives, ed. Barbara Kellerman. Englewood Cliffs, NJ.: Prentice-Hall.
Lisac, Mark. 1995. The Klein Revolution. Edmonton: NeWest.
MacKinnon, Janice. 2003. Minding the Public Purse: The Fiscal Crisis, Political Trade-Offs and Canada's Future. Montreal & Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press.
Mandryk, Murray. 1995. “Tax relief remains 1996 ‘objective’ for Romanow.” The StarPhoenix. December 27, A2.
Mandryk, Murray. 1996. “Seven Examples of NDP's Style.” The StarPhoenix, June 26, A7.
Mandryk, Murray. 1999. “Premier Wise to Avoid Farm Rally.” The StarPhoenix, August 19, A12.
Martin, Don. 2002. King Ralph: The Political Life and Successes of Ralph Klein. Toronto: Key Porter.
Martin, Don. 2003. King Ralph: First Guts then Glory. Toronto: Key Porter.
Mitchell, Alanna. 1996. “West struggles to define itself.” The Globe and Mail, January 2, A1; A4.
Mollenhoff, Clark R. 1980. The President Who Failed: Carter Out of Control. New York, NY: Macmillan.
Neustadt, Richard E. 1990. Presidential Power and the Modern Presidents: The Politics of Leadership from Roosevelt to Reagan. New York, NY: The Free Press.
Nisbet, Robert A. 1950. “Leadership and Social Crisis.” In Studies in Leadership: Leadership and Democratic Action, ed. Alvin Ward Gouldner. New York, NY: Harper & Brothers.
Osborne, David and Ted Gaebler. 1992. Reinventing Government. Don Mills: Addison-Wesley.
Paige, Glenn D. 1977. The Scientific Study of Political Leadership. New York, NY.: The Free Press.
Pitsula, James M. and Ken Rasmussen. 1990. Privatizing a Province: The New Right in Saskatchewan. Vancouver: New Star Books.
Roberts, David. 1995. “‘Hack and Slash’ methods rejected, Romanow says.” The Globe and Mail, June 23, A7.
Romanow, Roy, John Whyte and Howard Leeson. 1984. Canada … Notwithstanding: The Making of theConstitution, 1976–1982. Toronto: Carswell/Methuen.
Saskatchewan New Democratic Party. 1995. The Saskatchewan Way: It's Working: 1995 Election Platform. Regina: The Saskatchewan New Democratic Party.
Séguin, Rhéal. 1996. “PQ caves in to save Bouchard. The Globe and Mail, November 25, A1; A5.
Schumpeter, Joseph A. 1983. The Theory of Economic Development: An Inquiry into Profits, Capital, Credit, Interest and the Business Cycle. New Brunswick, N.J.: Transaction Books, originally published in 1934.
Serres, Christopher. 1995. “Alberta's billion-dollar question.” Alberta Report, July 10, 6–9.
Sheppard, Robert. 1995. “What happened to all the anger?” The Globe and Mail, June 17, A27.
Simpson, Jeffrey. 2004. “Klein is ready for a fight on health care.” The Globe and Mail, March 16, A17.
Smircich, L. and G. Morgan. 1989. “Leadership: The Management of Meaning.” Journal of Applied Behavioural Science, 18: 257–273.CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Statistics Canada. Cansim. 2004. Interprovincial Migrants, by Province or Territory of Origin and Destination, 1971–2002. Table 051-0019.
Tucker, Robert C. 1981. Politics as Leadership. Columbia, MO: University of Missouri Press.