Skip to main content Accessibility help

Women with a low-satiety phenotype show impaired appetite control and greater resistance to weight loss

  • Nicola J. Buckland (a1), Diana Camidge (a2), Fiona Croden (a2), Anna Myers (a3), Jacquelynne H. Lavin (a4), R. James Stubbs (a2), John E. Blundell (a2) and Graham Finlayson (a2)...


This trial compared weight loss outcomes over 14 weeks in women showing low- or high-satiety responsiveness (low- or high-satiety phenotype (LSP, HSP)) measured by a standardised protocol. Food preferences and energy intake (EI) after low and high energy-density (LED, HED) meals were also assessed. Ninety-six women (n 52 analysed; 41·24 (SD 12·54) years; 34·02 (sd 3·58) kg/m2) engaged in one of two weight loss programmes underwent LED and HED laboratory test days during weeks 3 and 12. Preferences for LED and HED food (Leeds Food Preference Questionnaire) and ad libitum evening meal and snack EI were assessed in response to equienergetic LED and HED breakfasts and lunches. Weekly questionnaires assessed control over eating and ease of adherence to the programme. Satiety quotients based on subjective fullness ratings post LED and HED breakfasts determined LSP (n 26) and HSP (n 26) by tertile splits. Results showed that the LSP lost less weight and had smaller reductions in waist circumference compared with HSP. The LSP showed greater preferences for HED foods, and under HED conditions, consumed more snacks (kJ) compared with HSP. Snack EI did not differ under LED conditions. LSP reported less control over eating and reported more difficulty with programme adherence. In conclusion, low-satiety responsiveness is detrimental for weight loss. LED meals can improve self-regulation of EI in the LSP, which may be beneficial for longer-term weight control.


Corresponding author

*Corresponding author: Dr N. J. Buckland, email


Hide All
1.Public Health England (2017) Health matters: obesity and the food environment 2017. (accessed June 2017).
2.Wardle, J & Johnson, F (2002) Weight and dieting: examining levels of weight concern in British adults. Int J Obes 26, 11441149.
3.Teixeira, PJ, Going, SB, Sardinha, LB, et al. (2005) A review of psychosocial pre-treatment predictors of weight control. Obes Rev 6, 4365.
4.Crawford, D, Jeffery, RW & French, SA (2000) Can anyone successfully control their weight? Findings of a three year community-based study of men and women. Int J Obes 24, 11071110.
5.Wing, RR & Hill, JO (2001) Successful weight loss maintenance. Annu Rev Nutr 21, 323341.
6.Mann, T, Tomiyama, AJ, Westling, E, et al. (2007) Medicare’s search for effective obesity treatments: diets are not the answer. Am Psychol 62, 220233.
7.Stubbs, J, Brogelli, D, Pallister, C, et al. (2012) Behavioural and motivational factors associated with weight loss and maintenance in a commercial weight management programme. Open Obes J 4, 3543.
8.Womble, LG, Williamson, DA, Greenway, FL, et al. (2001) Psychological and behavioral predictors of weight loss during drug treatment for obesity. Int J Obes 25, 340345.
9.Drapeau, V, Hetherington, M & Tremblay, A (2011) Impact of eating and lifestyle behaviors on body weight: beyond energy value. In Handbook of Behavior, Food and Nutrition, pp. 693706 [Preedy, VR, Watson, RR and Martin, CR, editors]. New York: Springer.
10.Barkeling, B, King, NA, Naslund, E, et al. (2007) Characterization of obese individuals who claim to detect no relationship between their eating pattern and sensations of hunger or fullness. Int J Obes 31, 435439.
11.Dalton, M, Hollingworth, S, Blundell, J, et al. (2015) Weak satiety responsiveness is a reliable trait associated with hedonic risk factors for overeating among women. Nutrients 7, 74217436.
12.Drapeau, V, Blundell, J, Therrien, F, et al. (2005) Appetite sensations as a marker of overall intake. Br J Nutr 93, 273280.
13.Drapeau, V, King, N, Hetherington, M, et al. (2007) Appetite sensations and satiety quotient: predictors of energy intake and weight loss. Appetite 48, 159166.
14.Drapeau, V, Blundell, J, Gallant, AR, et al. (2013) Behavioural and metabolic characterisation of the low satiety phenotype. Appetite 70, 6772.
15.Arguin, H, Tremblay, A, Blundell, JE, et al. (2017) Impact of a non-restrictive satiating diet on anthropometrics, satiety responsiveness and eating behaviour traits in obese men displaying a high or a low satiety phenotype. Br J Nutr 118, 750760.
16.Finlayson, G, King, N & Blundell, J (2008) The role of implicit wanting in relation to explicit liking and wanting for food: implications for appetite control. Appetite 50, 120127.
17.Stubbs, J, Ferres, S & Horgan, G (2000) Energy density of foods: effects on energy intake. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 40, 481515.
18.Bell, EA & Rolls, BJ (2001) Energy density of foods affects energy intake across multiple levels of fat content in lean and obese women. Am J Clin Nutr 73, 10101018.
19.Buckland, NJ, Camidge, D, Croden, F, et al. (2018) A low energy-dense diet in the context of a weight-management program affects appetite control in overweight and obese women. J Nutr 148, 798806.
20.Epstein, LH, Truesdale, R, Wojcik, A, et al. (2003) Effects of deprivation on hedonics and reinforcing value of food. Physiol Behav 78, 221227.
21.Goldstone, AP, de Hernandez, CGP, Beaver, JD, et al. (2009) Fasting biases brain reward systems towards high-calorie foods. Eur J Neurosci 30, 16251635.
22.Drapeau, V, Jacob, R, Panahi, S, et al. (2019) Effect of energy restriction on eating behavior traits and psychobehavioral factors in the low satiety phenotype. Nutrients 11, 245.
23.Faul, F, Erdfelder, E, Lang, A-G, et al. (2007) G*Power 3: a flexible statistical power analysis program for the social, behavioral, and biomedical sciences. Behav Res Methods 39, 175191.
24.Stubbs, RJ, Morris, L, Pallister, C, et al. (2015) Weight outcomes audit in 1.3 million adults during their first 3 months’ attendance in a commercial weight management programme. BMC Public Health 15, 882.
25.NHS-Choices (2015) Start the NHS weight loss plan. (accessed January 2014).
26.Stunkard, AJ & Messick, S (1985) The three-factor eating questionnaire to measure dietary restraint, disinhibition and hunger. J Psychosom Res 29, 7183.
27.Blundell, J, de Graaf, C, Hulshof, T, et al. (2010) Appetite control: methodological aspects of the evaluation of foods. Obes Rev 11, 251270.
28.Myers, A, Gibbons, C, Finlayson, G, et al. (2017) Associations among sedentary and active behaviours, body fat and appetite dysregulation: investigating the myth of physical inactivity and obesity. Br J Sports Med 51, 15401544.
29.Finglas, PM, Roe, MA, Pinchen, HM, et al. (2015) McCance and Widdowson’s The Composition of Foods, 7th summary ed. Cambridge: Royal Society of Chemistry.
30.Elobeid, MA, Padilla, MA, McVie, T, et al. (2009) Missing data in randomized clinical trials for weight loss: scope of the problem, state of the field, and performance of statistical methods. PLoS ONE 4, e6624.
31.Field, A (2005) Discovering Statistics using SPSS (Introducing Statistical Methods series), 2nd ed. London: Sage Publications Ltd.
32.Butryn, ML, Thomas, JG & Lowe, MR (2009) Reductions in internal disinhibition during weight loss predict better weight loss maintenance. Obesity 17, 11011103.
33.Poppitt, SD, Swann, D, Black, AE, et al. (1998) Assessment of selective under-reporting of food intake by both obese and non-obese women in a metabolic facility. Int J Obes 22, 303311.
34.Heitmann, BL & Lissner, L (1995) Dietary underreporting by obese individuals-is it specific or non-specific? Br Med J 311, 986989.
35.Wadden, TA, Brownell, KD & Foster, GD (2002) Obesity: responding to the global epidemic. J Consult Clin Psychol 70, 510525.
36.National Health Service (2016) High blood pressure (hypertension). (accessed June 2017).
37.McNeil, J, Drapeau, V, Gallant, AR, et al. (2013) Short sleep duration is associated with a lower mean satiety quotient in overweight and obese men. Eur J Clin Nutr 67, 13281330.
38.Geiker, NRW, Ritz, C, Pedersen, SD, et al. (2016) A weight-loss program adapted to the menstrual cycle increases weight loss in healthy, overweight, premenopausal women: a 6-mo randomized controlled trial. Am J Clin Nutr 104, 1520.
39.Brennan, IM, Feltrin, KL, Nair, NS, et al. (2009) Effects of the phases of the menstrual cycle on gastric emptying, glycemia, plasma GLP-1 and insulin, and energy intake in healthy lean women. Am J Physiol Gastrointest Liver Physiol 297, G602G610.


Type Description Title
Supplementary materials

Buckland et al. supplementary material
Buckland et al. supplementary material

 Word (134 KB)
134 KB

Women with a low-satiety phenotype show impaired appetite control and greater resistance to weight loss

  • Nicola J. Buckland (a1), Diana Camidge (a2), Fiona Croden (a2), Anna Myers (a3), Jacquelynne H. Lavin (a4), R. James Stubbs (a2), John E. Blundell (a2) and Graham Finlayson (a2)...


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed