Skip to main content Accessibility help

Two cultures in the times of interdisciplinary archaeology. A response to commentators

  • V. P. J. Arponen (a1), Walter Dörfler (a2), Ingo Feeser (a3), Sonja Grimm (a4), Daniel Groß (a5), Martin Hinz (a6), Daniel Knitter (a7), Nils Müller-Scheeßel (a8), Konrad Ott (a9) and Artur Ribeiro (a10)...


We would like to begin by thanking the journal and the commentators for their time and attention.


Corresponding author

*Corresponding author. Email:


Hide All
Arkush, E., 2011: The year in review. Explaining the past 2010, American anthropologist 113(2), 200–12.
Behringer, W., 2010: A cultural history of climate, Cambridge.
Bettinger, R.L., Garvey, R. and Tushingham, S., 2015: Hunter-gatherers. Archaeological and evolutionary theory, 2nd edn, New York (Interdisciplinary Contributions to Archaeology).
Bhaskar, R., 2008: A realist theory of science, London.
Bicho, N., and Cascalheira, J., 2018: Global perspectives on the impact of drastic environmental changes in hunter-gatherer technologies, Journal of Quaternary science 33(3), 255367.
Binford, M.W., Kolata, A.L., Brenner, M., Janusek, J.W., Seddon, M.T., Abbott, M. and Curtis, J.H., 1997: Climate variation and the rise and fall of an Andean civilization, Quaternary research 47(2), 235–48.
Bintliff, J., 2011: The death of archaeological theory?, in Bintliff, J. and Pearce, M. (eds), The death of archaeological theory?, Oxford, 722.
Boone, J.L., 2002: Subsistence strategies and early human population history. An evolutionary ecological perspective, World archaeology 34, 625.
Brewer, J., and Riede, F., 2018: Cultural heritage and climate adaptation. A cultural evolutionary perspective for the Anthropocene, World archaeology, 116.
Broome, J., 2012: Climate matters. Ethics in a warming world, New York.
Callaway, E., 2018: The battle for common ground, Nature 555, Feature News.
Carrithers, M., 2005: Anthropology as a moral science of possibilities, Current anthropology 46, 433–56.
Chakrabarty, D., 2009: The climate of history. Four theses, Critical inquiry 35, 197222.
Chapman, J., 2018 : Climatic and human impact on the environment? A question of scale, Quarternary international 496, 313.
Clarke, D.L., 1972: Models and paradigms in contemporary archaeology, in Clarke, D.L. (ed.), Models in archaeology, London, 160.
Contreras, D.A., 2016: Correlation is not enough, in Contreras, D.A. (ed.), The archaeology of human–environment interactions. Strategies for investigating anthropogenic landscapes, dynamic environments, and climate change in the human past, London, 322.
Coombes, P., and Barber, K., 2005: Environmental determinism in Holocene research. Causality or coincidence? Area 37(3), 303–11.
Cooper, J., and Sheets, P.D., 2012: Surviving sudden environmental change, Boulder, CO.
Currie, A., 2018: Consensus schmosensus. Dead dinosaurs, big rocks & simple stories (1 May 2018), at, accessed 8 January 2019.
Currie, A., 2018b: Rock, bone, and ruin. An optimist’s guide to the historical sciences, Cambridge, MA.
De Keyzer, M., 2016: All we are is dust in the wind. The social causes of a ‘subculture of coping’ in the late medieval covers and belt, Journal for the history of environment and society, 1, 135.
Dilthey, W., 2008 (1883): Introduction to the human sciences. An attempt to lay a foundation for the study of society and history, Detroit.
Dobres, M.A., and Robb, J. (eds), 2000: Agency in archaeology, London.
Elder-Vass, D., 2010: The causal power of social structures. Emergence, structure and agency, Cambridge.
Erickson, C.L., 1999: Neo-environmental determinism and agrarian ‘collapse’ in Andean prehistory, Antiquity 73(281), 634–42.
Faulseit, R.K. (ed.), 2015: Beyond collapse. Archaeological perspectives on resilience, revitalization, and transformation in complex societies, Carbondale, IL.
Franklin, J., Potts, A.J., Fisher, E.C., Cowling, R.M. and Marean, C.W., 2015: Paleodistribution modeling in archaeology and paleoanthropology, Quaternary science reviews 110, 114.
Frei, K.M., and Frei, R., 2011: The geographic distribution of strontium isotopes in Danish surface waters. A base for provenance studies in archaeology, hydrology and agriculture, Applied geochemistry 26, 326–40.
Gardiner, S.M., 2011: A perfect moral storm. The ethical tragedy of climate change, Oxford.
Geertz, C., 1973: The interpretation of cultures, New York.
Grattan, J., 2006: Aspects of Armageddon. An exploration of the role of volcanic eruptions in human history and civilization, Quaternary international 151(1), 1018.
Haraway, D., 1988: Situated knowledges. The science question in feminism and the privilege of partial perspective, Feminist studies 14, 575–99.
Harper, T.K., Diachenko, A., Rassamakin, Y.Y. and Kennett, D.J., 2019: Ecological dimensions of population dynamics and subsistence in Neo-Eneolithic Eastern Europe, Journal of anthropological archaeology 53, 92101.
Hodder, I., 1985: Postprocessual archaeology, Advances in archaeological method and theory 8, 126.
Hodder, I., and Hutson, S., 2003: Reading the past. Current approaches to interpretation in archaeology, 3rd edn, Cambridge.
Hoggarth, J.A., Restall, M., Wood, J.W. and Kennett, D.J., 2017: Drought and its demographic effects in the Maya lowlands, Current anthropology 58(1), 82113.
Hoggarth, J.A., Breitenbach, S.F.M., Culleton, B.J., Ebert, C.E., Masson, M.A. and Kennett, D.J., 2016: The political collapse of Chichén Itzá in climatic and cultural context, Global and planetary change 138, 2542.
Hulme, M., 2011: Reducing the future to climate. A story of climate determinism and reductionism, Osiris 26(1), 245–66.
Ion, A., 2017: How interdisciplinary is interdisciplinary? Revisiting the impact of aDNA research for the archaeology of human remains, Current Swedish archaeology 25, 177–98.
Johnson, M.H., 2006: On the nature of theoretical archaeology and archaeological theory. Archaeological dialogues 13(2), 117–32.
Jones, T.L., Brown, G.M., Raab, L.M., McVickar, J.L., Spaulding, W.G., Kennett, D.J., York, A. and Walker, P.L., 1999: Environmental imperatives reconsidered. Demographic crises in western North America during the medieval climatic anomaly, Current anthropology 40(2), 137–70.
Killick, D., 2015: The awkward adolescence of archaeological science, Journal of archaeological science 56, 242–47.
Kintigh, K.W., Altschul, J.H., Beaudry, M.C., Drennan, R.D., Kinzig, A.P., Kohler, T.A., Limp, W.F., Maschner, H.D.G., Michener, W.K., Pauketat, T.R., Peregrine, P. and Sabloff, J.A., 2014: Grand challenges for archaeology, American antiquity 79(1), 524.
Kolata, A.L. (ed.), 1993: The Tiwanaku, Oxford.
Kristiansen, K., 2014: Towards a new paradigm? The third science revolution and its possible consequences in archaeology, Current Swedish archaeology 22, 1134.
Kristiansen, K., 2017: From deconstruction to interpretation. Archaeological dialogues 24(1), 4144.
Kristiansen, K., 2017: The nature of archaeological knowledge and its ontological turns, Norwegian archaeological review, at
Kuhn, T.S., 1996: The structure of scientific revolutions, 3rd edn, Chicago.
Leach, E., 1961: Rethinking anthropology, New York.
Leach, E., 1967: An anthropologist’s reflection on a social survey, in Jongmans, G. and Gutkind, P.C.W. (eds), Anthropologists in the field, Assen, 7588.
Leroy, S.A.G., 2006: From natural hazard to environmental catastrophe. Past and present, Quaternary international 158(1), 412.
Lohse, S., 2017: Pragmatism, ontology, and philosophy of the social sciences in practice, Philosophy of the social sciences 47(1), 327.
Lorenz, D.F., 2013: The diversity of resilience. Contributions from a social science perspective, Natural hazards 67, 724.
Lucas, G., 2017: The paradigm concept in archaeology, World archaeology 49(2), 260–70.
Malkki, L.H., 2007: Tradition and improvisation in ethnographic field research, in Cerwonka, A. and Malkki, L.H. (eds), Improvising theory. Process and temporality in ethnographic fieldwork, Chicago, 162–88.
Martinon-Torres, M., 2018: Mobility, minds and metal. The end of archaeological science?, in Armada, X.-L., Mourillo-Barosso, M. and Charlton, M. (eds), Metal, minds and mobility. Integrating scientific data with archaeological theory, Oxford, 161–69.
Mauch, C., and Pfister, C. (eds), 2009: Natural disasters, cultural responses. Case studies toward a global environmental history, Lanham, MD.
Meggers, B.J., 1954: Environmental limitations on the development of culture, American anthropologist 56, 801–24.
Meggers, B.J., 2001: The continuing quest for El Dorado. Round two, Latin American antiquity 12, 304–25.
Mesoudi, A., Whiten, A. and Laland, K.N., 2006: Towards a unified science of cultural evolution, Behavioural and brain sciences 29, 329–83.
Middleton, G., 2017: Understanding collapse. Ancient history and modern myths, Cambridge.
Müller, J., 2016: From the Neolithic to the Iron Age. Demography and social agglomeration: the development of centralized control?, in Fernandez-Götz, D.K.M. (ed.), Individualization, urbanization and social differentiation. Eurasia at the dawn of history, Cambridge, 106–24.
Noble, G., 2017: Woodland in the Neolithic of Northern Europe. The forest as ancestor, Cambridge.
Oliver-Smith, A., 1996: Anthropological research on hazards and disasters, Annual review of anthropology 25, 303–28.
Oliver-Smith, A., 2012: Haiti’s 500-year earthquake, in Schuller, M. and Morales, P. (eds), Tectonic shifts. Haiti since the earthquake, Sterling, VA, 1822.
Otto, I.M., Reckien, D., Reyer, C.P.O., Marcus, R., Le Masson, V., Jones, L., Norton, A. and Serdeczny, O., 2017: Social vulnerability to climate change. A review of concepts and evidence, Regional environmental change 17, 1651–62.
Parker, G., 2014: Global crisis. War, climate change and catastrophe in the seventeenth century, New Haven.
Peterson, N., and Broad, K., 2016: Climate and weather discourse in anthropology. From determinism to uncertain futures, in Crate, S.A. and Nuttall, M. (eds), Anthropology and climate change: From encounters to actions, London.
Pleşu, A., 2018: Destinul ca țesătură, Dilema Veche 773, 13–19, available at, accessed 20 December 2018.
Radivojevic, M., Roberts, B.J., Pernicka, E., Stos-Gale, Z., Martinon-Torres, M., Rehren, T., Bray, P., Brandherm, D., Ling, J., Mai, J., Vandkilde, H., Kristiansen, K., Shennan, S.J. and Broodbank, C., 2018: The provenance, use and circulation of metals in the European Bronze Age. The state of the debate, Journal of archaeological research, at
Ribeiro, A., 2018: Death of the passive subject. Intentional action and narrative explanation in archaeological studies, History of the human sciences 31(3), 105–21.
Riede, F., 2014: Towards a science of past disasters, Natural hazards 71, 335–62.
Riede, F., 2017: Past-forwarding ancient calamities. Pathways for making archaeology relevant in disaster risk reduction research, Humanities 6, 79.
Riede, F., 2018: Deep pasts– deep futures. A palaeoenvironmental humanities perspective from the Stone Age to the Human Age, Current Swedish archaeology 26, 1330.
Riede, F., Andersen, P. and Price, N., 2016: Does environmental archaeology need an ethical promise?, World archaeology 48, 466–81.
Robinson, E., and Riede, F., 2018: Cultural and palaeoenvironmental changes in Late Glacial to Middle Holocene Europe. Gradual or sudden?, Quaternary international 465, 159–61.
Roberts, N., Fyfe, R.M., Woodbridge, J., Gaillard, M.-J., Davis, B.A.S., Kaplan, J.O., Marquer, L., Mazier, F., Nielsen, A.B., Sugita, S., Trondman, A.-K. and Leydet, M., 2018: Europe’s lost forests. A pollen-based synthesis for the last 11,000 years. Nature communications 8(716), DOI:10.1038/s41598-017-18646-7.
Roberts, P., Henshilwood, C.S., van Niekerk, K.L., Keene, P. and Gledhill, A., 2016: Climate, environment and early human innovation. Stable isotope and faunal proxy evidence from archaeological sites (98–59ka) in the Southern Cape, South Africa, PLOS ONE 11(7), e0157408.
Shennan, S. (ed.), 1994: Archaeological approaches to cultural identity, London.
Shennan, S., 2004: Analytical archaeology, in Bintliff, J.L. (ed.), A companion to archaeology, Oxford, 320.
Snow, C.P., 1998 (1959): The two cultures and the scientific revolution, Cambridge.
Sørensen, T.F., 2017: The two cultures and a world apart. Archaeology and science at a new crossroads, Norwegian archaeological review 50(2), 101–15.
Stanton, T.W., 2004: Concepts of determinism and free will in archaeology, Annales de antropología 38, 2983.
Stephens, S., 1994: Situated knowledges and accountable scientific visions, Ethnos 59, 7179.
United Nations, 2016: Climate change resilience. An opportunity for reducing inequalities, New York.
Von Wright, G.H., 1971: Explanation and understanding, London.
Weiss, H. (ed.), 2017: Megadrought and collapse. From early agriculture to Angkor, Oxford.
Wheatley, D., 1993: Going over old ground. GIS, archaeological theory and the act of perception, in Andresen, J., Madsen, T. and Scollar, I. (eds), Computing the past. Computer applications and quantitative methods in archaeology, Aarhus, 133–38.
Whewell, W., 1847: The philosophy of the inductive sciences. Founded upon their history. New edition, with corrections and additions, and an appendix, containing philosophical essays previously published, London.
Wylie, A., 2002: Thinking from things. Essays in the philosophy of archaeology, Berkeley, CA.
Wyrwoll, K.-H., 2012: How Aboriginal burning changed Australia’s climate (11 January 2012), at, accessed 11 January 2019.


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed