Hostname: page-component-cd9895bd7-hc48f Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-12-26T19:23:35.951Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

BLACKBALLING BUCKLER: THE LETTERS OF JOHN BUCKLER (1770–1851), THE CARTER SCHOOL AND THE FOUNDATIONS OF AN ANTIQUARIAN DYNASTY

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  29 June 2022

Joshua Mardell
Joshua Mardell*
Affiliation:
School of Architecture, Royal College of Art, Kensington Gore, South Kensington, London SW7 2EU, UK. Email: joshua.mardell@rca.ac.uk
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

This paper examines the story, hitherto neglected by scholarship, of the antiquarian artist and architect John Buckler (1770–1851) through a remarkable cache of his letters at the Bodleian Library. Most of the letters relate to Buckler’s attempts to be elected a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries. Having twice been blackballed in 1808 and 1809, he canvassed Britain’s leading antiquarian figures for support. With the blackballing of the architect James Wyatt in 1797 frequently alluded to, Buckler’s blackballing was the result of a cabal against him led by Sir Joseph Banks and Samuel Lysons, which had to do with both factionalism – ie his closeness to the preservationist faction led by Richard Gough and John Carter, termed the Carter school – and the Society’s onslaught against professionals. His eventual success in 1810 institutionalised his practice, allowed him entry into polite society and brought him closer to aristocratic patronage. The remainder of the Bodleian letters relate to Buckler’s topographical work recording medieval buildings across the UK, showing how he took on the revisionist medievalist project promoted by the Carter school. The article will explain Buckler’s role in the developing discourses of antiquarianism and the Gothic Revival, and how his association with the Carter school laid the foundations for the work of the Buckler dynasty. Over three generations, in line with the family name (meaning ‘to protect’), they sought to embody the idea of the architect-antiquary as a protector.

Keywords

Society of Antiquaries of LondontopographyGothic Revivalprofessionalismarchitecture
Type
Research paper
Information
The Antiquaries Journal , Volume 102 , September 2022 , pp. 418 - 446
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Society of Antiquaries of London

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Primary sources

Bodleian, ms Buckler, mss Eng. lett. a. 1, fols 1–220Google Scholar
Bodleian, ms Don. d. 89, nos 49 and 100Google Scholar
Bodleian, ms Top. Gen. c 103 6rGoogle Scholar
BL, Add. ms 27963 (original of Magdalen College Archive, P371/MS1/1; Add mss 36356–443; Add mss 36979–80; Add mss 37120–46Google Scholar
Corpus Christi College, Cambridge, Archive, ms 603, 79–82Google Scholar
Lewis Walpole Library, Farmington, Babb-Beckford no. 85+Google Scholar
Magdalen College, Oxford, Archive, ms Buckler, fol 30Google Scholar
Magdalen College, Oxford, Archive, P371/MS1/1Google Scholar
SAL, Antiquaries Correspondence, ms 31.383Google Scholar
SAL, Antiquaries Papers: 1777 statuteGoogle Scholar
Surrey History Centre, Woking, Nichols Archive, PC2/2/f187 NAD1954Google Scholar
Wiltshire Museum, Devizes, ms 725, Box 63Google Scholar
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven, B1991.40.91Google Scholar

Secondary sources

Anon 1806. ‘Monthly retrospect of the fine arts’, Monthly Mag and British Register, 21 (1), 543–6Google Scholar
Anon 1813. ‘Letters’, Gentleman’s Mag, 83 (May), 430 Google Scholar
Anon 1816. ‘Dr Whitaker’s history of Yorkshire’, Edinburgh Rev: or Critical J, 27 (50), npGoogle Scholar
Anon 1852a. ‘Mr John Buckler FSA’, Gentleman’s Mag, 191 (1), 103–4Google Scholar
Anon 1852b. ‘The late Mr Buckler, architect’, Builder, 10 (3), 7 Google Scholar
Anon 1865. ‘Oxford Architectural and Historical Society’, Gentleman’s Mag, 218 (1), 321–4Google Scholar
Anon 1894. ‘The late John Chessell Buckler’, Architect Contract Rep, 51, 44 Google Scholar
Antony, C M 1927. Father Reginald Buckler, O.P., Sheed & Ward, London Google Scholar
Arnold, D and Bending, S 2003. ‘Introduction’, in Arnold, D and Bending, S (eds), Tracing Architecture: the aesthetics of antiquarianism, 1–10, Blackwell, Oxford Google Scholar
Banham, R 1999. ‘Pevsner’s progress’, in Banham, M (ed), A Critic Writes: essays by Reyner Banham, 216–22, University of California Press, Berkeley Google Scholar
Bloxam, M H 1836. The Principles of Gothic Architecture: elucidated by question and answer, C Tilt and J Weale, London Google Scholar
Bodleian 1951. Drawings of Oxford by J C Buckler 1811–27: Bodleian picture book no. 3, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Bradley, S 2000. ‘The roots of ecclesiology: late Hanoverian attitudes to medieval churches’, in Webster, C and Elliott, J (eds), ‘A Church As It Should Be’: the Cambridge Camden Society and its influence, 22–44, Shaun Tyas, Stamford Google Scholar
Buchanan, A 1999. ‘Science and sensibility: architectural antiquarianism in the early nineteenth century’, in Myrone, M and Peltz, L (eds), Producing the Past: aspects of antiquarian culture and practice, 1770–1850, 169–86, Ashgate, Aldershot Google Scholar
Buckler, C A 1880. Bucleriana: or, notices of the family of Buckler, Mitchell and Hughes, London Google Scholar
Buckler, G 1856. Twenty-Two of the Churches of Essex: architecturally described and illustrated, Bell and Daldy, London Google Scholar
Buckler, J 1842. ‘Remarks upon some remains of ancient architecture, disclosed in taking down a portion of the church of St. Mary Overy, Southwark’, Archaeologia, 29, 241–2Google Scholar
Buckler, J and Buckler, J C 1826. Views of Eaton Hall in Cheshire, the seat of the Right Honourable Earl Grosvenor, William Clark, London Google Scholar
Buckler, J C 1817. ‘Memoir of the late Mr John Carter, F A S’, Gentleman’s Mag, 87 (2), 363–6Google Scholar
Buckler, J C 1823. Observations on the Original Architecture of Saint Mary Magdalen College, Oxford, John Nichols and Son, London Google Scholar
Buckler, J C 1832. An Examination of Some Observations Upon the Inaccuracy of Architectural Draughtsmen in a Letter Published in No. X of the British Magazine addressed to William Twopenny, Esq, privately printed, LondonGoogle Scholar
Butler, L A S 1976. ‘Documentary evidence and the church fabric’, in Addyman, P and Morris, R (eds), The Archaeological Study of Churches, CBA Res Rep 13, 18–20, Council for British Archaeology, London Google Scholar
Carlos, E J 1830. ‘Royal Academy: architectural designs and models’, Gentleman’s Mag, 100 (1), 540–2Google Scholar
Carlos, E J 1835. ‘Crypt at St Saviour’s, Southwark’, Gentleman’s Mag, 158 (1), 602–6Google Scholar
Clark, D 2014. ‘Beware of Buckler: attention to detail’, unpublished lecture, Vernacular Architecture Group conferenceGoogle Scholar
Clark, P 2000. British Clubs and Societies 1580–1800: the origins of an associational world, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Colvin, H 1983. Unbuilt Oxford, Yale University Press, London Google Scholar
Crook, J M 1995. John Carter and the Mind of the Gothic Revival, W S Maney and Son, London Google Scholar
Crook, J M 2004. ‘Carter, John (1748–1817)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edn, <https://doi.org/10.1093/ref:odnb/4791>(accessed 22 March 2022)CrossRef(accessed+22+March+2022)>Google Scholar
Doyle, A I 1955–6. ‘Martin Joseph Routh and his books in Durham University Library’, Durham Uni J, 48, 100–7Google Scholar
Evans, D M 2009. ‘“Banks is the villain”!? Sir Joseph Banks and the governance of the Society of Antiquaries’, Antiq J, 89, 337–63CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Evans, J 1956. A History of the Society of Antiquaries, Oxford University Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Farington, J 1923. The Farington Diary, Volume 1 (ed Greig, J), Hutchinson & Co, London Google Scholar
Farington, J 1926. The Farington Diary, Volume 6 (ed Greig, J), George H Doran Co, New York Google Scholar
Frew, J 1979. ‘Richard Gough, James Wyatt, and late 18th-century preservation’, J Soc Arch Hist, 38, 366–74Google Scholar
Gascoigne, J 1994. Joseph Banks and the English Enlightenment: useful knowledge and polite culture, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar
Gerrard, C 2005. Medieval Archaeology: understanding traditions and contemporary approaches, Routledge, London Google Scholar
Goodwin, G 2004. ‘Lysons, Samuel (bap. 1763, d. 1819)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edn, <https://doi.org/10.1093/ref:odnb/17298>(22 March 2022)(22+March+2022)>Google Scholar
Gorman, W G 1910. Converts to Rome: a biographical list of the more notable converts to the Catholic Church in the United Kingdom during the last sixty years, Sands & Co, London Google Scholar
Gough, R 1786. Sepulchral Monuments, J Nichols, London Google Scholar
Gough, R 1814. A Catalogue of the Books, Relating to British Topography and Saxon and Northern Literature, Clarendon Press, Oxford Google Scholar
Graves, A 1905. The Royal Academy of Arts: a complete dictionary of contributors and their work from its foundation in 1769 to 1904, vol 1, H Graves & Co, London Google Scholar
Heringman, N 2013. Sciences of Antiquity: romantic antiquarianism, natural history and knowledge work, Oxford University Press, Oxford CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Hill, R 2008. God’s Architect, Penguin, London Google Scholar
Hill, R 2016. ‘“Proceeding like Guy Faux”: the antiquarian investigation of St Stephen’s Chapel Westminster, 1790–1837’, Architectural Hist, 59, 253–79Google Scholar
Hill, R 2021. Time’s Witness: history in the age of Romanticism, Penguin Books, London Google Scholar
Howard, M T 2012. John Latham: surgeon, ornithologist and antiquary, Romsey’s first historian, Matador, Leicester Google Scholar
, J C 1810. ‘Remains of Bermondsey Abbey Southwark’, Gentleman’s Mag, 80 (Dec), 513. https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=osu.32435054260641&view=1up&seq=545&q1=buckler Google Scholar
King, J 2014. George Hadfield: architect of the federal city, Ashgate, Abingdon Google Scholar
Lewis, J E (1996) The English Fable: Aesop and literary culture, 1615–1740, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Google Scholar
Lysons, D and Lysons, S 1792–6. Environs of London: being an historical account of the towns, villages, and hamlets, within twelve miles of that capital interspersed with biographical anecdotes, 4 vols, printed by A Strahan for T Cadell, LondonGoogle Scholar
Lysons, D and Lysons, S 1806–22. Magna Britannia: being a concise topographical account of the several counties of Great Britain, 6 vols, printed for T Cadell and W Davies, LondonGoogle Scholar
Mardell, J 2018. ‘“Fidelis ad Mortem”: J C Buckler, an Oxford College architect’, Oxoniensia, 83, 73–92 Google Scholar
Mardell, J 2020. ‘Getting into a scrape: the Buckler dynasty, Lincoln Cathedral and mid-Victorian architectural politics’, Architectural Hist, 63, 191–218 CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Maty, P H 1784. An History of the Instances of Exclusion from the Royal Society, 2nd edn, J Debrett, London Google Scholar
Milner, J 1798a. A Dissertation on the Modern Style of Altering Antient Cathedrals, J Nichols, London Google Scholar
Milner, J 1798b. ‘Mr Milner on the institution of the Society of Antiquaries’, Gentleman’s Mag, 83 (1), 476–8Google Scholar
Munby, J 1978. ‘J C Buckler, Tackley’s Inn and three medieval houses in Oxford’, Oxoniensia, 43, 123–69Google Scholar
Musgrave, T 2020. The Multifarious Mr Banks: from Botany Bay to Kew, the natural historian who shaped the world, Yale University Press, New Haven Google Scholar
Nairn, I and Pevsner, N 1965. The Buildings of England: Sussex, Penguin, Harmondsworth Google Scholar
Nichols, J B 1855. ‘Some notices on the library at Stourhead’, Wiltshire Archaeol and Nat Hist Mag, 2, 119–25Google Scholar
Nurse, B 2000. ‘George Cruikshank’s The Antiquarian Society, 1812, and Sir Henry Charles Englefield’, Antiq J, 80, 316–20CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Nurse, B 2011. ‘John Carter, FSA: the ingenious and very accurate draughtsman’, Antiq J, 91, 211–5CrossRefGoogle Scholar
Owen, H and Blakeway, J B 1825. A History of Shrewsbury, 2 vols, Harding, Lepard and Co, London Google Scholar
Philo-Junius 1816. ‘Buckler’s “cathedrals”’, Gentleman’s Mag, 86 (2), 37 Google Scholar
Porter, R 2000. ‘The need for buddies’, London Rev Books, 22 (12), 30–1Google Scholar
Rodwell, W 1989. The Archaeology of Religious Places: churches and cemeteries in Britain, University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia Google Scholar
Rogister, J 2015. ‘Societies of conversation’, Times Literary Suppl, <https://www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/societies-of-conversation/> (22 March 2022)+(22+March+2022)>Google Scholar
Royal Commission on the Ancient and Historical Monuments of Wales 1986. An Inventory of the Ancient Monuments in Brecknock (Brycheiniog): later prehistoric monuments and unenclosed settlements to 1000 AD, Her Majesty’s Stationery Office, London Google Scholar
SAL 1853. Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of London, 2 (32), 236Google Scholar
Scott, G G 1866. ‘Mr Scott’s reply to Mr Buckler’, Ecclesiologist, 176 (October), 290–308 Google Scholar
Scott, S 2013. ‘Samuel Lysons and his circle: art, science and the remains of Roman Britain’, Bull Hist of Archaeol, 23, 1–22 Google Scholar
Scott, W 1995. The Antiquary (ed Hewitt, D), Edinburgh University Press and Columbia University Press, Edinburgh and New York Google Scholar
Skelton, J. 1843. Oxonia Antiqua restaurata, John Nichols and Son, London Google Scholar
Smith, G 2002. The Emergence of the Professional Watercolourist: contentions and alliances in the artistic domain, 1760–1824, Ashgate, Aldershot Google Scholar
Sweet, R 2004. Antiquaries: the discovery of the past in eighteenth century Britain, Hambledon, London Google Scholar
Sweet, R 2007. ‘The incorporated society and its public role’, in Pearce, S (ed), Visions of Antiquity: the Society of Antiquaries of London, 1707–2007, 74–97, SAL, London Google Scholar
Tyack, G 2004. ‘Buckler, John (1770–1851), artist and architect’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography online edn, <http://www.oxforddnb.com/view/article/3863> (22 March 2022)+(22+March+2022)>Google Scholar
Weber, W 1998. ‘Dynastiesicherung und Staatsbildung: Die Entfaltung des frühmodernen Fürstenstaates’, in Weber, W (ed), Der Fürst: Ideen und Wirklichkeiten in der europäischen Geschichte, 91–136, Cologne, Weimar and Vienna, Buchbeschreibung BöhlauCrossRefGoogle Scholar
Whitaker, T D 1823. An History of Richmondshire, Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme and Browne, London Google Scholar