Skip to main content Accessibility help

Stunning pigs with nitrogen and carbon dioxide mixtures: effects on animal welfare and meat quality

  • P. Llonch (a1) (a2), P. Rodríguez (a1), M. Gispert (a1), A. Dalmau (a1), X. Manteca (a2) and A. Velarde (a1)...


The aim of this study was to assess the effect of exposure to the gas mixtures of 70% nitrogen (N2) and 30% carbon dioxide (CO2; 70N30C), 80% N2 and 20% CO2 (80N20C) and 85% N2 and 15% CO2 (85N15C) on aversion, stunning effectiveness and carcass, as well as meat quality in pigs, and to compare them with the commercial stunning of 90% CO2 (90C). A total of 68 female pigs were divided into four groups and stunned with one of the gas mixtures. During the exposure to the gas, behavioural variables (retreat attempts, escape attempts, gasping, loss of balance, muscular excitation and vocalizations) were recorded, and at the end of the stunning, corneal reflex and rhythmic breathing were assessed. After slaughter, meat quality parameters such as pH at 45 min post mortem (pH45) and at 24 h post mortem (pHu), electrical conductivity, drip loss and colour, in the Longissimus thoracis (LT) and Semimembranosus (SM) muscles were measured, and the presence of ecchymosis on the hams was noted. The PROC MIXED and the PROC GENMOD of SAS® were used to analyse the parametric and binomial variables, respectively. The ‘gas mixture’ was always considered a fixed effect and the ‘live weight’ as a covariate. To assess the correlation between meat quality and behaviour measures, PROC CORR was used. Pigs exposed to 90C showed a higher percentage of escape attempts and gasping, a lower percentage of vocalization and shorter muscular excitation phase than pigs exposed to the other N2 and CO2 mixtures (P < 0.05). After stunning, no pig exposed to 90C showed corneal reflex or rhythmic breathing, whereas 85% and 92% of the animals exposed to N2 and CO2 mixtures showed corneal reflex and rhythmic breathing, respectively. Animals stunned with 80N20C and 85N15C had a lower pH45 (P < 0.01) than animals exposed to 90C. Electrical conductivity in the SM muscle was lower (P < 0.001) in 90C and 70N30C pigs than in 80N20C and 85N15C pigs, whereas in LT, it was lower (P < 0.05) in 90C pigs than in 85N15C. As the CO2 concentration of the gas mixture was decreased, the prevalence of exudative pork increased. Twenty-five percent of animals exposed to N2 and CO2 mixtures (n = 68) had ecchymosis in their carcasses, whereas no animal stunned with 90C had ecchymosis. In conclusion, although N2 and CO2 stunning exhibit fewer signs of aversion than 90C, their induction time to unconsciousness is longer, and this may negatively affect meat and carcass quality.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Bager, F, Braggins, TJ, Devine, CE, Graafhuis, AE, Mellor, DJ, Tavener, A, Upsdell, MP 1992. Onset of insensibility at slaughter in calves: effects of electroplectic seizure and exsanguination on spontaneous electrocortical activity and indices of cerebral metabolism. Research in Veterinary Science 52, 162173.
Cannon, JE, Morgan, JB, McKeith, FK, Smith, GC, Sonka, S, Heavner, J, Meeker, DL 1996. Pork chain quality audit survey: quantification of pork quality characteristics. Journal of Muscle Foods 7, 2944.
Commission Internationale de l’Éclairage (CIE) 1976. Colorimetry. Bureau Central de la CIE. Publication no. 15, Vienna, Austria.
Council Regulation (EC) No. 1099/2009 of 24 September 2009 on the protection of animals at the time of killing. European Community Official Journal L303, 1–30.
Dalmau, A, Llonch, P, Rodríguez, P, Ruíz-de-la-Torre, JL, Manteca, X, Velarde, A 2010a. Stunning pigs with different gas mixtures. Part 1: gas stability. Animal Welfare 19, 315323.
Dalmau, A, Rodríguez, P, Llonch, P, Velarde, A 2010b. Stunning pigs with different gas mixtures. Part 2: aversion in pigs. Animal Welfare 19, 324333.
Dell, P, Hugelin, A, Bonvallet, M 1961. Cerebral anoxia and the electroencephalogram. In Effects of hypoxia on the reticular and cortical difuse systems (ed. H Gustaut and JS Meyer), p. 46. Charles C Thomas Publishing, Springfield, IL, USA.
Dodman, NH 1977. Observations on the use of the Wernburg dip-lift carbon dioxide apparatus for pre-slaughter anaesthesia of pigs. British Veterinary Journal 133, 7180.
D'Souza, DN, Dunshea, FR, Warner, RD, Leury, BJ 1999. Comparison of different dietary magnesium supplements on pork quality. Meat Science 51, 221225.
European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) 2004. Welfare aspects of animal stunning and killing methods. Scientific report of the Scientific Panel for Animal Health and Welfare on a request from the Commission. Retrieved May 25, 2011, from
Ernsting, J 1965. The effect of anoxia on the central nervous system. In A text book of aviation physiology (ed. JA Gillies), pp. 271289. Pergamon Press, Oxford, UK.
Faucitano, L, Ielo, MC, Ster, C, Lo Fiego, DP, Methot, S, Saucier, L 2010. Shelf life of pork from five different quality classes. Meat Science 84, 466469.
Forslid, A 1987. Transient neocortical, hippocampal and amygdaloid EEG silence induced by one minute inhalation of high concentration CO2 in swine. Acta Physiologica Scandinava 130, 110.
Gregory, NG 2004. Respiratory system. In Physiology and behaviour of animal suffering UFAW Animal Welfare Series (ed. Blackwell Publishing), pp. 207222. Blackwell Publishing, Oxford, UK.
Gregory, NG, Raj, ABM, Audsley, ARS, Daly, CC 1990. Effects of carbon dioxide on man. Fleischwirtschaft 70, 11731174.
Holst, S 2001. Carbon dioxide stunning of pigs for slaughter – practical guidelines for good animal welfare. 47th International Congress of Meat Science and Technology, Krakow, Poland, vol. I, pp. 4854.
Holst, S 2002. Behaviour in pigs immersed into atmospheric air or different carbon dioxide concentrations. Internal Report Ref. no. 02.709 7295, Danish Meat Research Institute, unpublished data.
Honikel, KO 1996. Reference methods supported by OECD and their use in Mediterranean meat products. Food Chemistry 54, 573582.
Llonch, P, Dalmau, A, Rodríguez, P, Manteca, X, Velarde, A 2011. Aversion to nitrogen and carbon dioxide mixtures for stunning pigs. Animal Welfare (in press).
Machold, U, Troeger, K, Moje, M 2003. Gas stunning of pigs – a comparison of carbon dioxide, argon, a nitrogen–argon-mixture and argon/carbon dioxide, (2 steps-system) under animal welfare aspects. Fleischwirtschaft 83, 109114.
Monin, G 1988. Stress d'abattage et qualités de la viande. Recueil de Médecine Vétérinaire 164, 835842.
Nakai, H, Saito, F, Ikeda, T, Ando, S, Komatsu, A 1975. Standard models of pork colour. Bulletin of National Institution of Animal Industry 29, 6974.
Peppel, P, Anton, F 1993. Responses of rat medullary dorsal horn neurons following intranasal noxious chemical stimulation: effects of stimulus, intensity, duration, and interstimulus interval. Journal of Neurophysiology 70, 22602274.
Raj, ABM 1999. Behaviour of pigs exposed to mixtures of gases and the time required to stun and kill them: welfare implications. The Veterinary Record 144, 165168.
Raj, ABM, Gregory, NG 1995. Welfare implications of the gas stunning of pigs. 1. Determination of aversion to the initial inhalation of carbon dioxide or argon. Animal Welfare 4, 273280.
Raj, ABM, Gregory, NG 1996. Welfare implications of gas stunning of pigs. 2. Stress of induction of anaesthesia. Animal Welfare 5, 7178.
Raj, ABM, Johnson, SP, Wotton, SB, McKinstry, JL 1997. Welfare implications of gas stunning pigs. 3. The time to loss of somatosensory evoked potentials and spontaneous electroencephalogram of pigs during exposure to gases. Veterinary Journal 153, 329340.
Ring, C, Schlager, B 1988. Quality of the meat of CO2-stunned pigs. Fleischwirtschaft 68, 15321534.
Rodriguez, P, Dalmau, A, Ruiz-de-la-Torre, JL, Manteca, X, Jensen, EW, Rodriguez, B, Litvan, H, Velarde, A 2008. Assessment of unconsciousness during carbon dioxide stunning in pigs. Animal Welfare 17, 341349.
Rosen, AS, Morris, ME 1991. Depolarising effects of anoxia on pyramidal cells of rat neocortex. Neuroscience Letters 124, 169173.
Terlouw, C 2005. Stress reactions at slaughter and meat quality in pigs: genetic background and prior experience. A brief review of recent findings. Livestock Production Science 94, 125135.
Troeger, K, Woltersdorf, W 1991. Gas anaesthesia of slaughter pigs. Stunning experiments under laboratory conditions with fat pigs of known halothane reaction type: meat quality and animal protection. Fleischwirtschaft 71, 10631068.
Troeger, K, Machold, U, Moje, M, Behrschmidt, M 2005. Gas stunning of pigs. A comparison of carbon dioxide, argon, a nitrogen/argon mixture and argon/carbon dioxide under meat quality aspects. 3. Summary and discussion of results; conclusions. Fleischwirtschaft 5, 109111.
Velarde, A, Gispert, M, Faucitano, L, Manteca, X, Diestre, A 2000. The effect of stunning method on the incidence of PSE meat and haemorrhages in pork carcasses. Meat Science 55, 309314.
Velarde, A, Gispert, M, Faucitano, L, Alonso, P, Manteca, X, Diestre, A 2001. Effects of the stunning procedure and the halothane genotype on meat quality and incidence of haemorrhages in pigs. Meat Science 58, 313319.
Velarde, A, Cruz, J, Gispert, M, Carrión, D, Ruiz-de-la-Torre, JL, Diestre, A, Manteca, X 2007. Aversion to carbon dioxide stunning in pigs: effect of the carbon dioxide concentration and the halothane genotype. Animal Welfare 16, 513522.
Van der Wal, PG 1997. Causes for variation in pork quality. Meat Science 46, 319327.
Wadsworth, RM 1994. Vasoconstrictor and vasodilator effects of hypoxia. Trends in Pharmacological Sciences 15, 4753.
Warris, PD, Brown, SN 1987. The relationship between initial pH, reflectance and exudation in pig muscle. Meat Science 20, 6574.


Stunning pigs with nitrogen and carbon dioxide mixtures: effects on animal welfare and meat quality

  • P. Llonch (a1) (a2), P. Rodríguez (a1), M. Gispert (a1), A. Dalmau (a1), X. Manteca (a2) and A. Velarde (a1)...


Altmetric attention score

Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed