Hostname: page-component-8448b6f56d-jr42d Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-19T12:18:11.401Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

A Century of Continuity and (Little) Change in the Undergraduate Political Science Curriculum

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  28 November 2006

JOHN ISHIYAMA ,
MARIJKE BREUNING  and
LINDA LOPEZ
JOHN ISHIYAMA
Affiliation:
Truman State University
MARIJKE BREUNING
Affiliation:
Truman State University
LINDA LOPEZ
Affiliation:
National Science Foundation
Any opinions, findings and conclusions or recommendations expressed in this material are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Science Foundation.
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

Although in recent years there has emerged a renewed interest in teaching and learning issues in the APSA, relatively little attention has been paid to the structure of the undergraduate political science curriculum. In this article we conduct a broad survey of articles that appeared in the APSR from 1906 to 1990 and find that (1) in the past the association paid much attention to the undergraduate political science curriculum; (2) over time attention shifted from a conception of the major as promoting substantive knowledge to a conception that emphasized skills; and (3) current concerns regarding skills, sequencing, and capstone experiences were all discussed several decades before the appearance of the “Wahlke Report” in 1991. We offer an explanation for the ebb and flow of the attention curricular issues received historically in the APSA, and suggest what the future may hold for current efforts to reexamine the structure of the undergraduate political science curriculum.

Type
“THE EVOLUTION OF POLITICAL SCIENCE” ESSAYS
Information
American Political Science Review , Volume 100 , Issue 4 , November 2006 , pp. 659 - 665
Copyright
© 2006 by the American Political Science Association

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

Abbott Andrew. 1981. “Status and Status Strain in the Professions.” American Journal of Sociology 86 (January): 819– 35.Google Scholar
Association of American Colleges. 1990. Reports from the Fields: Liberal Learning and the Arts and Sciences Major. Volume 2. Washington: Association of American Colleges.
American Association of Colleges. 1991. “Political Science.” Reports from the Fields: Project on Liberal Learning, Study-in-Depth, and the Arts and Sciences Major, vol. 2. Washington: AAC.
American Association of Colleges and Universities. 2006. Liberal Education Outcomes: A Preliminary Report on Student Achievement in College. Washington: AACU.
Bates Frank G. 1927. “Instruction in Political Science Along Functional Rather than Descriptive Lines.” American Political Science Review 21 (May): 402– 405.Google Scholar
Bennett Douglas C. 1991. “Political Science within the Liberal Arts: Towards Renewal of Our Commitment.” PS: Political Science & Politics 24 (June): 201– 204.Google Scholar
Bennett Stephen Earl. 1999. “The Past Need Not Be Prologue: Why Pessimism about Civic Education in Premature.” PS: Political Science & Politics 32 (December): 755– 57.Google Scholar
Bobic Michael, 2005. “Do You Want Fries With That? A Review of the BA in Political Science” Politics and Policy 33 (September): 334– 39.Google Scholar
Breuning Marijke, Paul Parker, and John Ishiyama. 2001. “The Last Laugh: Skill Building through a Liberal Arts Political Science Curriculum” PS: Political Science & Politics 34 (December): 657– 61.Google Scholar
Committee of Five of the American Political Science Association. 1908. “Report of the Committee of Five of the American Political Science Association on Instruction in American Government in Secondary Schools.” Proceedings of the American Political Science Association. 5: 219– 57.
Committee on Instruction in Political Science of the American Political Science Association. 1922. “The Study of Civics.” American Political Science Review 16 (February): 116– 25.
Committee of the American Political Science Association on War-Time Changes in the Political Science Curriculum. 1942. “Instruction and Research: The Political Science Curriculum in War-Time: Report of the Committee of the American Political Science Association in War-Time.” American Political Science Review 36 (December): 1142– 46.
Committee on Standards of Instruction of the American Political Science Association. 1962. “Political Science as a Discipline” American Political Science Review 56 (June): 417– 21.
Corwin Edwin. 1929. “Democratic Dogma and the Future of Political Science.” American Political Science Review 23 (August): 569– 92.Google Scholar
Dahl Robert A. 1961. “The Behavioral Approach in Political Science: An Epitaph to a Successful Protest Movement.” American Political Science Review 55 (December): 763– 72.Google Scholar
Dimock Marshall E., Clinton Rossiter, John P. Roche, John C. Donovan. 1952. “Goals for Political Science: A Discussion” American Political Science Review 46 (June): 504– 11.Google Scholar
Fesler James, Louis Hartz, John H. Hallowell, Victor G. Rosenblum, Walter H.C. Laves, W.A. Robson, and Lindsay Rogers. 1951. “Goals for Political Science: A Discussion” American Political Science Review 45 (December): 996– 1024.Google Scholar
Haines Charles G. 1915. “Report of Committee of Seven on Instruction in Colleges and Universities” American Political Science Review 9 (May): 353– 74.Google Scholar
Hall Arnold Bennett. 1922. “The Teaching of Constitutional Law.” American Political Science Review 16 (August): 486– 96.Google Scholar
Ishiyama John and Stephen Hartlaub. 2003. “Sequential or Flexible? The Impact of Differently Structured Political Science Majors on the Development of Student Reasoning” PS: Political Science & Politics 36 (January): 83– 86.Google Scholar
Ishiyama John. 2005a. “The Structure of an Undergraduate Major and Student Learning: A Cross-Institutional Study of Political Science Programs at Thirty-two Colleges and Universities” Social Science Journal 42: 359– 6.Google Scholar
Ishiyama John. 2005b. “Examining the Impact of the Wahlke Report: Surveying the Structure of the Political Science Curricula at Liberal Arts and Sciences Colleges and Universities in the Midwest” PS: Political Science & Politics 38 (January): 71– 75.Google Scholar
Laves Walter H.C. 1940. “The Next Decade in Political Science Teaching” American Political Science Review 34 (October): 983– 86.Google Scholar
Leonard Stephen T. 1999. “‘Pure Futility and Waste’: Academic Political Science and Civic Education.” PS: Political Science & Politics 32 (December): 749– 54.Google Scholar
Mansfield Harvey C. 1947. “The Major in Political Science” American Political Science Review 41 (June): 500– 507.Google Scholar
Munro William Bennett. 1928. “Physics and Politics—An Old Analogy Revisited.” American Political Science Review 22 (February): 1– 11.Google Scholar
Reed Thomas, 1930. “Training for the Public Service.” American Political Science Review 24 (February): 173– 79.Google Scholar
Rockwell Landon G. 1947. “Instruction and Research: Toward a More Integrated Political Science Curriculum” American Political Science Review 41 (April): 314– 20.Google Scholar
Rossiter Clinton L. 1948. “Political Science 1 and Political Indoctrination” American Political Science Review 42 (May): 542– 4.Google Scholar
Schachter Hindy Lauer. 1998. “Civic Education: Three Early American Political Science Committees and Their Relevance for Our Times.” PS 31 (September): 631– 35.Google Scholar
Stahl O. Glen. 1937. “Public Service Training in the Universities.” American Political Science Review 31 (October): 870– 78.Google Scholar
Story Russell. 1926. “The Content of the Introductory Course in Political Science.” American Political Science Review 20 (May): 419– 28.Google Scholar
Wahlke John C. 1991. “Liberal Learning and the Political Science Major: A Report to the Profession.” PS 24 (March): 48– 60.Google Scholar
Walker Robert A. 1948. “Citizenship Education and the Colleges” American Political Science Review 42 (February): 74– 84.Google Scholar
Wilcox Francis O. 1941. “Teaching Political Science in a World at War” American Political Science Review 35 (April): 325– 33.Google Scholar
Wilcox Francis O. 1947. “The Introductory Course in Government” American Political Science Review 41 (June): 489– 500.Google Scholar