Skip to main content Accessibility help

Tools for evaluating and regulating nitrogen impacts in livestock farming systems

  • C. Bockstaller (a1), F. Vertès (a2), J.-L. Fiorelli (a3), P. Rochette (a4) and H. F. M. Aarts (a5)...


This article describes several indicators and methods for estimating nitrogen flows and balance sheets. It reviews their strengths and weaknesses according to user types and their objectives. The nitrogen balance sheets, based on the difference between inputs and outputs are by far the most-often used estimator of nitrogen management on livestock farms. Among those, the soil surface balance helps in guiding the fertilisation and the farmgate balance is logically higher. The indicators of practices are easy to use but are poor predictors of nitrogen losses, whereas the indicators of emissions allow for estimating nitrogen losses using either direct measurements or models thereby providing a dynamic assessment of these flows. The coupling of balance sheets and indicators of emissions offers a certain potential for improvement of diagnosis and support of decision making. Finally, the indicators of impacts, including the life cycle analyses are currently the most popular for qualifying the impacts of animal production.


Corresponding author


Hide All
Bockstaller, C, Guichard, L, Makowski, D, Aveline, A, Girardin, P and Plantureux, S 2008. Agri-environmental indicators to assess cropping and farming systems. A review. Agronomy for Sustainaible Development 28, 139149.
Bockstaller, C and Girardin, P 2006. Evaluation agri-environnementale des systèmes de culture: la méthode INDIGO®. Oléoscope 85, 46.
Bockstaller, C, Guichard, L, Keichinger, O, Girardin, P, Galan, MB and Gaillard, G 2009. Comparison of methods to assess the sustainability of agricultural systems. A review. Agronomy for Sustainable Development 29, 223235.
Bockstaller, C, Gaillard, G, Baumgartner, D, Freiermuth Knuchel, R, Reinsch, M, Brauner, R and Unterseher, E 2006. Méthodes d’évaluation agri-environnementale des exploitations agricoles: Ccomparaison des méthodes INDIGO, KUL/USL, REPRO et SALCA. ITADA, Colmar. 112pp.
Bockstaller, C, Lassere-Joulin, F, Slezack-Deschaumes, S, Piutti, S, Villerd, J, Amiaud, B and Plantureux, S 2011. Assessing biodiversity in arable farmland by means of indicators: an overview. Oléagineux Corps Gras Lipides 18, 137144.
Cannavo, P, Recous, S, Parnaudeau, V and Reau, R 2008. Modeling N dynamics to assess environmental impacts of cropped soils. Advances in Agronomy 97, 131174.
Corpen 2006. Des indicateurs AZOTE pour gérer des actions de maîtrise des pollutionsà l'échelle de la parcelle, de l'exploitation et du territoire, Paris, Ministère de l'Ecologie et du Développement Durable. Retrieved March 2011 from, 113p.
De Vries, W, Leip, A, Reinds, GJ, Kros, J, Lesschen, JP, Bouwman, AF, Grizzetti, B, Bouraoui, F, Butterbach-Bahl, K, Bergamaschi, P and Winiwarter, W 2011. Geographical variation in terrestrial nitrogen budgets across Europe. In The European Nitrogen Assessment. Sources, effects and policy perspectives (ed. MA, Sutton, CM, Howard, JW, Erisman et al.), pp. 317344. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Durand, P 2004. Simulating nitrogen budgets in complex farming systems using INCA: calibration and scenario analyses for the Kervidy catchment (W. France). Hydrology and Earth System Sciences 8, 793802.
EEA 2005. Agriculture and environment in EU-15; the IRENA indicator report. Copenhagen: European Environmental Agency (EEA), 128p.
Girardin, P, Bockstaller, C and Van der Werf, HMG 1999. Indicators: tools to evaluate the environmental impacts of farming systems. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture 13, 521.
Gudmundsson, H 2003. The policy use of environmental indicators – learning from evaluation research. The Journal of Transdisciplinary Environmental Studies 2, 111.
Langeveld, JWA, Verhagen, A, Neeteson, JJ, Keulen, HV, Conijn, JG, Schils, RLM and Oenema, J 2007. Evaluating farm performance using agri-environmental indicators: recent experiences for nitrogen management in The Netherlands. Journal of Environmental Management 82, 363376.
Leip, A, Britz, W and De Vries, V 2011. Farm, land, and soil nitrogen budgets for agriculture in Europe calculated with CAPRI. Environmental Pollution 159, 32433253.
Niemeijer, D and de Groot, RS 2008. A conceptual framework for selecting environmental indicator sets. Ecological Indicators 8, 1425.
Oenema, O, Kros, H and De Vries, V 2003. Approaches and uncertainties in nutrient budgets: implications for nutrient management and environmental policies. European Journal of Agronomy 20, 316.
Riley, J 2001. The indicator explosion: local needs and international challenges. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 87, 119120.
Schröder, JJ, Aarts, HFM, ten Berge, HFM, van Keulen, HV and Neeteson, JJ 2003. An evaluation of whole-farm nitrogen balances and related indices for efficient nitrogen use. European Journal of Agronomy 20, 3344.
Simon, JC, Grignani, C, Jacquet, A, Lecorre, L and Pages, J 2000. Typology of nitrogen balances on a farm scale: research of operating indicators. Agronomie 20, 175195.
Smeets, E and Weterings, R 1999. Environmental indicators: Typology and overview. Copenhagen: EEA (Technical report No 25), 19p.
Topp, CFE, Stockdale, EA, Watson, CA and Rees, RM 2007. Estimating resource use efficiencies in organic agriculture: a review of budgeting approaches used. Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture 87, 27822790.
Van der Werf, HMG, Kanyarushoki, C and Corson, MS 2011. L’Analyse de Cycle de Vie: un nouveau regard sur les systèmes de production agricole. Innovations Agronomiques 12, 121133.
van der Werf, HGM and Petit, J 2002. Evaluation of environmental impact of agriculture at the farm level: A comparison and analysis of 12 indicator-based methods. Ecosystems & Environment 93, 131145.
Vertès, F, Bockstaller, C, Espagnol, S, Guichard, L, Petit, J and Raison, C 2010. Stratégies de choix des méthodes et outils d’évaluation environnementale en systèmes d’élevage. In Elevages et Environnement (ed S, Espagnol and P, Leterme), pp. 1564. Editions Quae-Editions Educagri, Versailles.
Watson, CA and Atkinson, D 1999. Using nitrogen budgets to indicate nitrogen use efficiency and losses from whole farm systems: a comparison of three methodological approaches. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 53, 259267.


Tools for evaluating and regulating nitrogen impacts in livestock farming systems

  • C. Bockstaller (a1), F. Vertès (a2), J.-L. Fiorelli (a3), P. Rochette (a4) and H. F. M. Aarts (a5)...


Full text views

Total number of HTML views: 0
Total number of PDF views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

Abstract views

Total abstract views: 0 *
Loading metrics...

* Views captured on Cambridge Core between <date>. This data will be updated every 24 hours.

Usage data cannot currently be displayed