Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: December 2014

6 - The Nation That Wasn't There?

Summary

Unlike in Britain, Yugoslavia, India, or America, “Soviet” was never considered an ethnic or a national identity.

The internal passport system acted as a powerful instrument of social control but undermined the development of a common Soviet identity.

Soviet citizens have had internal passports that recorded their ethnicity since 1932. Dozens of ethnic groups benefitted from affirmative action policies and acquired autonomous territories on the basis of their ethnicity. Unfortunately, the deportation of all ethnic Germans, Chechens, Crimean Tatars, and other ethnic groups, resulting in the decimation of their populations, was also made possible by “passport ethnicity,” which was also used to discriminate against Jews in politics and employment. Despite the push for the creation of a supraethnic Soviet identity, attempts to remove ethnicity from the passport failed from the 1950s until after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Why?

I challenge the hegemonic view in the study of Soviet politics that “Soviet was never considered…a national identity.” In the course of this chapter, I demonstrate that there was an effort akin to “nation building” at the all-Soviet level, expressed by the increasingly ubiquitous notion of Sovetskii narod. The term is often translated as the “Soviet people,” but it can also be expressed in the English language as the “Soviet nation.” While demonstrating that there has been a concerted effort to promote a Soviet national identity, which intensified in the post-Stalinist period, I ask why Soviet authorities were unable to eliminate the ethnicity category in the internal passport, which I see as a parallel endeavor in the same direction that failed. This is a key question because “passport ethnicity” constituted the microfoundation of institutionalized multiethnicity in the Soviet Union and served as a major obstacle that prevented the much-anticipated “merger” (sliianie) of ethnicities into the supraethnic collectivity that the concept of Sovetskii narod encapsulates. Failure to remove ethnicity from the internal passport denotes a failure to change the ethnicity regime in the USSR. It is also this failure to overcome institutionalized ethnic divisions at the substate level that allowed some scholars to allege that “Soviet was never considered…a national identity.” Explaining the failure to abolish passport ethnicity in the post-Stalinist period while following the political trajectory and relevance of the Sovetskii narod idea provides a political history of an all-Soviet nation-building project. Its ultimate failure does not imply that “Soviet was never considered…a national identity.”

Suny, Ronald Grigor and Martin, Terry, eds., A State of Nations: Empire and Nation-Making in the Age of Lenin and Stalin (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001), 9
Rogachev, P. and Sverdlin, M., “Sovetskii narod – novaia istoricheskaia obshchnost’ liudei,” Kommunist no. 9 (June 1963): 11–20
Affirmative Action Empire, 5: “Already in 1916
Kommunist, no. 5 (March 1983): 56–64
Dimanshtein, S., “Slozhnost’ raboty novogo Narkomnatsa,” Zhizn natsional'nostei 17, no. 74 (June 9, 1920): 1
Weiner, Amir, Making Sense of War: The Second World War and the Fate of the Bolshevik Revolution (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 2001)
Platt, Kevin M. F. and Brandenberger, David, eds., Epic Revisionism: Russian History and Literature as Stalinist Propaganda (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2006)
Slezkine, Yuri, “N. Ia. Marr and the National Origins of Soviet Ethnogenetics,” Slavic Review 55, no. 4 (Winter 1996): 826–62
Suny, Ronald Grigor, Revenge of the Past: Nationalism, Revolution, and the Collapse of the Soviet Union (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press, 1993)
Bilinsky, Yaroslav, “The Soviet Education Laws of 1958–9 and Soviet Nationality Policy,” Soviet Studies 14, no. 2 (October 1962): 139
Sadomskaya, Natalia, “New Soviet Rituals and National Integration,” in Soviet Nationality Policies: Ruling Ethnic Groups in the USSR, ed. Henry R. Huttenbach (New York: Mansell, 1990)
Miller, John H., “Cadres Policy in Nationality Areas: Recruitment of CPSU First and Second Secretaries in Non-Russian Republics of the USSR,” Soviet Studies 29, no. 1 (January 1977): 20
Tompson, William J., “The Fall of Nikita Khrushchev,” Soviet Studies 43, no. 6 (1991): 1101–21
Party Bifurcation and Elite Interests,” Soviet Studies 17, no. 4 (1966): 417–30
Cutler, Robert M., “Soviet Dissent Under Khrushchev: An Analytical Study,” Comparative Politics 13, no. 1 (October 1980): 15–35
Khazanov, Anatoly M., “The Ethnic Problems of Contemporary Kazakhstan,” Central Asian Survey 14, no. 2 (1995): 243–64
Hale, Henry, “Cause without a Rebel: Kazakhstan's Unionist Nationalism in the USSR and CIS,” Nationalities Papers 37, no. 1 (January 2009): 5
Barghoorn, Frederick C., Soviet Russian Nationalism (New York: Oxford University Press, 1956)
Kommunist in 1953
Bol'shevik no. 11–12 (June 1941): 8–11
Vasetskii, G., “Nesokrushimoe edinstvo velikogo sovetskogo naroda,” Bol'shevik no. 14 (July 1941): 35–41
Velichestvennaia pobeda sovetskogo naroda,” Bol'shevik no. 8 (April 1951): 1–8
Sovetskii narod v avangarde bor'by za mir,” Bol'shevik no. 17 (September 1951): 1–8
Sovetskii narod was in popular circulation by the late 1930s is corroborated by my interviews. Interview with Victor Shnirelman, IEA, Moscow, May 24, 2007
Sovetskii narod in the course of his opening speech. Vneocherednoi XXI s’’ezd KPSS. Stenogramma pervogo zasedaniia, January 27, 1959
There are many examples of articles published in Kommunist to illustrate the point that narod is used as the equivalent of nation in English. Among others, see, Palmiro Tol'yatti, “Vozhd’ Ital'yanskogo naroda” (The leader of the Italian nation), Kommunist, no. 5 (March 1953) 66–81
Bagramov, E., and Lavrent'ev, B.Rasistskie izmyshleniia o iaponskom narode” (Racist fabrications about the Japanese nation), Kommunist, no. 9 (June 1956): 113–20
Pozniak, V., “Vydaiushchaiasia pobeda sovetskogo naroda” (Outstanding Victory of the Soviet Nation), Kommunist no. 17 (November 1956): 29–40
Mukhitdinov, N., “O vyrashchivanii i vospitanii kadrov sovetskoi intelligentsii v natsional'nykh respublikakh” (On the Cultivation and Upbringing of Cadres of Soviet Intelligentsia in the National Republics), Kommunist no. 17 (November 1956): 58
Akman, Ayhan, “Modernist Nationalism: Statism and National Identity in Turkey,” Nationalities Papers 32, no. 1 (2004): 23–52
Kunaev, Dinmukhammed, a regular contributor for the next thirty years, and the first secretary of the Kazakh CP between 1960–2 and 1964–86. “Sovetskii Kazakhstan – sotsialisticheskaia industrial'no-kolkhoznaia respublika (Soviet Kazakhstan – socialist industrial-agricultural republic),” Kommunist no. 4 (March 1957): 59–72
Kunaev, D., “V edinoi sem'e k velikoi tseli (In one family toward a great goal),” Kommunist no. 12 (August 1970): 24–34
Kunaev, D., “V blagotvornoi atmosfere leninskoi druzhby narodov (On beneficent atmosphere in the Leninist friendship of peoples),” Kommunist no. 12 (August 1980): 8–23
Ignat'ev, S., “V edinoi bratskoi sem'e sovetskikh narodov,” Kommunist no. 9 (June 1957): 78–87
Berbekov, Kh., “400 let vmeste s narodami Rossii,” Kommunist no. 10 (July 1957): 64–72
Mitiushkin, V., “325 let velikoi bratskoi druzhby,” Kommunist no. 14 (October 1957): 52–60
Razzakov, I., “Leninskaia natsional'naia politika i druzhba narodov” (Leninist nationalities policy and the friendship of peoples), Kommunist no. 13 (September 1958): 37–48
Babaev, S., “Leninskaia natsional'naia politika v deistvii (Leninist nationalities policy at present),” Kommunist no. 9 (June 1957): 65–77
des Innern, Bundesministerium [Federal Ministry of the Interior], Nationale Minderheiten in Deutschland (Berlin: BMI, 2006)
Leninizm-znamia sovetskogo naroda v bor'be za pobedu kommunizma (Leninism – Flag of the Soviet Nation in its Struggle for the Victory of Communism),” Kommunist no. 5 (April 1958): 3–14
Gulamov, R., “Pod leninskim znamenem druzhby narodov,” Kommunist no. 15 (October 1958): 47–55
Zimianin, M., “Nerushimaia bratskaia druzhba velikikh narodov (Unbreakable brotherly friendship of great nations),” Kommunist no. 3 (February 1960): 63–71
Kommunist no. 10 (July 1960): 72–81
Weber, Max, “The Origins of Ethnic Groups,” in Ethnicity, ed. John Hutchinson and Anthony Smith (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996)
Pavlov, G., “Rastsvet i sblizhenie sotsialisticheskikh natsii (Flourishing and drawing together of socialist ethnicities),” Kommunist, no. 18 (December 1962): 40
Rogachev, P. and Sverdlin, M., “Sovetskii narod – novaia istoricheskaia obshchnost’ liudei,” Kommunist no. 9 (June 1963): 11–20
Hechter, Michael, Internal Colonialism: The Celtic Fringe in British National Development (New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, 1999)
Ponomarev, B., “Stroitel'stvo kommunizma v SSSR – velikaia internatsional'naia zadacha sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist no. 11 (July 1964): 36–61
Federalism was thus a ‘transitional step’ to ‘democratic centralism.’” Grey Hodnett, “The Debate over Soviet Federalism,” Soviet Studies 18, no. 4 (April 1967): 471
Taubman, William, Khrushchev: The Man and His Era (New York: W. W. Norton, 2003)
Khrushchev, 's autobiographical Memoirs of Nikita Khrushchev (Sergei Khrushchev ed.) (University Park: Pennsylvania State University Press, 2007)
Skilling, Gordon, “Groups in Soviet Politics: Some Hypotheses,” in Interest Groups in Soviet Politics, ed. Gordon Skilling and Franklyn Griffiths (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1971), 35
Strauss, Leo, Persecution and the Art of Writing (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988)
Vsemirno-istoricheskaia pobeda sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 7 (May 1965)
Patriotizm i internatsionalizm sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 9 (June 1966)
O merakh po dal'neishemu povysheniiu blagosostoianiia sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 14 (September 1967)
Sokolov, S., “Bessmertnyi podvig sovetskogo naroda i ego armii,” Kommunist, no. 7 (May 1970): 80–90
Igitkhanian, M., “Sovetskii narod – doblestnyi stroitel’ kommunizma,” Kommunist, no. 6 (April 1971)
Sovetskii narod – novaia istoricheskaia obshchnost’ liudei,” Kommunist, no. 12 (August 1972): 3–14
Iovchuk, M., “Internatsionalistskaia kul'tura mnogonatsional'nogo sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 3 (February 1973): 49–62
Zimanas, G., “Politika partii i internatsionalisticheskoe soznanie sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 5 (March 1974): 45–53
Tvorcheskii genii sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 10 (July 1975): 3–11
Internatsionalizm sovetskogo naroda,” Kommunist, no. 13 (September 1976): 13–20
The New Constitution (Basic Law) of the USSR, Kommunist, no. 15 (October 1977): 24–52
Sovetskie liudi – patrioty, internatsionalisty,” Kommunist, no. 1 (January 1969): 3–12
Bilinsky, Yaroslav, “The Concept of the Soviet People and Its Implications for Soviet Nationality Policy,” Annals of the Ukrainian Academy of Arts and Sciences in the United States 14 (1978–80): 87–133
Breslauer, George W., Khrushchev and Brezhnev as Leaders: Building Authority in Soviet Politics (Boston: George Allen and Unwin, 1982), 205
Bialer, Seweryn, Stalin's Successors: Leadership, Stability, and Change in the Soviet Union (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1982), 208
Dzhandil'din, N., Kommunizm i razvitie natsional'nykh otnoshenii (Moscow: Mysl’, 1964)
Agadzhanian, G. S., K voprosu o prirode i perspektivakh razvitiia sotsialisticheskikh natsii v SSSR (Erevan: Aiastan, 1972)
Glezerman, G. E., Klassy i natsii (Moscow: Gospolitizdat, 1977)
Martynov, I., “Muzyka sblizhaet narody,” Kommunist no. 5 (March 1965): 75–84
Gabdulin, M. and Morozov, M., “Formirovanie novoi kul'tury bytaKommunist no. 6 (April 1965): 61–9
Zimanas, G., “Internatsional'noe i natsional'noe v zhizni narodov,” Kommunist no. 6 (April 1965): 52
Baller, E. and Zlobin, N., “Obshchenarodnaia, obshchechelovecheskaia kommunisticheskaia kul'tura,” Kommunist no. 11 (July 1967): 27–37
“Sovetskii narod.” Interview with Sergei Khrushchev, December 10, 2009
Kunaev, D., “V edinoi sem'e k velikoi tseli,” Kommunist no. 12 (August 1970): 24–34
Mzhavanadze, V., “V sem'e edinoi druzhnoi,” Kommunist no. 7 (May 1971): 10–19
Igitkhanian, M., “Sovetskii narod – doblestnyi stroitel’ kommunizma,” Kommunist no. 6 (April 1971): 87–99
Sovetskii narod – novaia istoricheskaia obshchnost’ liudei,” Kommunist no. 12 (August 1972): 3–14
Kulichenko, Mikhail I., Bagramov, E. A., Kaltakhchian, S. T., and Khanazarov, K. Kh., Razvitie Sovetskogo Naroda: Novoy istoricheskoy obshchnosti (The Rise of the Soviet Nation/People: A New Historic Community) (Moscow: Politizdat, 1980)
Kulichenko, M. I., Nations and Social Progress (Moscow: Progress, 1984)
Gorovskii, F. Ia., Sovetskii Narod – Kak internatsional'naia obshchnost’ (Kiev: Vishcha Shkola, 1982)
Shevelev, A. G. et al., Velikii sovetskii narod (Kiev: Naukova Dumka, 1976)
Gorodnik, N. V., ed., Sovetskii narod – Novaia internatsional'naia obshchnost’ liudei (Kishinev: Shtiintsa, 1987)
Platkovskii, V., My-Sovetskii narod. Novaia istoricheskaia obshchnost’ liudei (Moscow: Molodaia gvardiia, 1973)
Sherstobitov, V. P., Sovetskii narod-Monolitnaia obshchnost’ stroitelei kommunizma (Moscow: Mysl’, 1976)
Kulichenko, M., “Voploshchenie leninskogo plana stroitel'stva Soiuza SSR,” Kommunist no. 12 (August 1972): 60–71
Bagramov, E.,“Razvitie KPSS marksistsko-leninskogo ucheniia o natsional'nykh otnosehniiakh,” Kommunist no. 4 (March 1973): 34
Kommunist no. 5 (March 1973)
Zavada, Marina and Kulikov, Yuri, “Arkadii Vol'skii on Brezhnev, Andropov, Chernenko, and Gorbachev,” Kommersant, September 12, 2006
Fartyshev, Vasilii, Iurii Andropov i Vladimir Putin na puti k vozrozhdeniiu (Moscow: Olma-Press, 2001)
Mlechin, Leonid, Andropov (Moscow: Prospekt, 2006), 5
Minutko, Igor, Andropov lost his mother at the age of five and his father at the age of fifteen. Iurii Andropov: Real'nost’ i Mif (Moscow: Ast-Press, 2004), 38
Medvedev, Roi, Iurii Andropov: Neizvestnoe ob izvestnom (Moscow: Vremia, 2004), 22
Semanov, Sergei, Iurii Andropov (Moscow: Algoritm-Eksmo, 2003)
Ebon, Martin, The Andropov File (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1983), 14
Klepikova, Elena, Yuri Andropov: A Secret Passage into the Kremlin (New York: Macmillan, 1983), 1–25
Brown, Archie, The Gorbachev Phenomenon (New York: Oxford University Press, 1996), 4
Roy, Sergei, Collapse of the Colossus: “On November 22, 1982
Arendt, Hannah, The Origins of Totalitarianism (New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1951)
Kommersant, September 12, 2006
Tishkov, Valery, Ethnicity, Nationalism and Conflict in and after the Soviet Union: The Mind Aflame (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, 1997), 23
Bromlei, , “Etnicheskie protsessy v SSSR,” Kommunist no. 5 (March 1983): 56–64
Kulichenko (chief editor), M. I., Bagramov, E. A., Kaltakhchian, S. T., Khanazarov, K. Kh., eds., Razvitie sovetskogo naroda – novoi istoricheskoi obshchnosti (Moscow: Institut Marksizma-Leninizma pri TsK KPSS/Politizdat, 1980)
Kulichenko, M. I., Rastsvet i sblizhenie natsii v SSSR (Moscow: Mysl’, 1981)
Kommunist by I. P. Sharapov, dated December 31, 1966
Kommunist, dated March 30, 1980
Inkeles, Alex and Bauer, Raymond A., The Soviet Citizen: Daily Life in a Totalitarian Society (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1961), 351
Kotkin, Stephen, “Mongol Commonwealth? Exchange and Governance across the Post-Mongol Space,” Kritika 8, no. 2 (Summer 2007): 520
Sasse, Gwendolyn, The Crimea Question: Identity, Transition, and Conflict (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2007)