Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Print publication year: 2016
  • Online publication date: March 2016

Chapter 28 - Controversy: ablative surgery vs deep-brain stimulation in the management of Parkinson's disease

from Section IV - Clinical Trials in Parkinson's Diease: Lessons, Controversies and Challenges

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
1.Horsley, V. The Linacre Lecture on the function of the so-called motor area of the brain: delivered to the master and fellows of St. John's College, Cambridge, May 6th, 1909. Br Med J 1909; 2: 12132.
2.Spiegel, EA, Wycis, HT, Marks, M, Lee, AJ. Stereotaxic apparatus for operations on the human brain. Science 1947; 106: 34950.
3.Spiegel, EA, Wycis, HT, Baird, HW 3rd. Long-range effects of electropallidoansotomy in extrapyramidal and convulsive disorders. Neurology 1958; 8: 73440.
4.Meyers, R. Surgical experiments in the therapy of certain ‘extrapyramidal’ diseases: a current evaluation. Acta Psychiatr Neurol Suppl 1951; 67: 142.
5.Cooper, IS. Ligation of the anterior choroidal artery for involuntary movements; parkinsonism. Psychiatr Q 1953; 27: 31719.
6.Cooper, IS. Surgical alleviation of parkinsonism; effects of occlusion of the anterior choroidal artery. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1954; 2: 691718.
7.Guiot, G, Brion, S. Treatment of abnormal movement by pallidal coagulation. Rev Neurol (Paris) 1953; 89: 57880.
8.Narabayashi, H, Okuma, T. Procaine oil blocking of the globus pallidus for treatment of rigidity and tremor of parkinsonism: preliminary report. Proc Jpn Acad; 1953; 2 Procaine oil blocking 9: 134.
9.Hassler, R. The influence of stimulations and coagulations in the human thalamus on the tremor at rest and its physiopathologic mechanism. Proc Second Int Cong Neuropathol 1955; 2: 63742.
10.Laitinen, LV. Brain targets in surgery for Parkinson's disease. Results of a survey of neurosurgeons. J Neurosurg 1985; 62: 34951.
11.Svennilson, E, Torvik, A, Lowe, R, Leksell, L. Treatment of parkinsonism by stereotatic thermolesions in the pallidal region. A clinical evaluation of 81 cases. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1960; 35: 35877.
12.Yahr, MD. Clinical aspects of abnormal movements induced by L-dopa. In: Barbeau, A, McDowell, FH, eds. L-Dopa and Parkinsonism. Davis Company; 1970; 1018.
13.Barbeau, A. The clinical physiology of side effects in long-term l-DOPA therapy. Adv Neurol 1974; 5: 34765.
14.Laitinen, LV, Bergenheim, AT, Hariz, MI. Leksell's posteroventral pallidotomy in the treatment of Parkinson's disease. J Neurosurg 1992; 76: 5361.
15.Benabid, AL, Pollak, P, Louveau, A, Henry, S, de Rougemont, J. Combined (thalamotomy and stimulation) stereotactic surgery of the VIM thalamic nucleus for bilateral Parkinson disease. Appl Neurophysiol 1987; 50: 3446.
16.Albin, RL, Young, AB, Penney, JB. The functional anatomy of basal ganglia disorders. Trends Neurosci 1989; 12: 36675.
17.Bergman, H, Wichmann, T, DeLong, MR. Reversal of experimental parkinsonism by lesions of the subthalamic nucleus. Science 1990; 249: 14368.
18.Pollak, P, Benabid, AL, Gross, C, et al. Effects of the stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in Parkinson disease. Rev Neurol (Paris) 1993; 149: 1756.
19.Limousin, P, Krack, P, Pollak, P, et al. Electrical stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in advanced Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 1998; 339: 110511.
20.Siegfried, J, Lippitz, B. Bilateral chronic electrostimulation of ventroposterolateral pallidum: a new therapeutic approach for alleviating all parkinsonian symptoms. Neurosurgery 1994; 35: 11269; discussion 1129–30.
21.Vitek, JL, Bakay, RA, Hashimoto, T, et al. Microelectrode-guided pallidotomy: technical approach and its application in medically intractable Parkinson's disease. J Neurosurg 1998; 88: 102743.
22.Kaplitt, MG, Hutchison, WD, Lozano, AM. Target localization in movement disorders surgery. In: Tarsy, D, Vitek, JL, Lozano, AM, eds. Surgical Treatment of Parkinson's Disease. Humana Press; 2003; 8798.
23.Schuurman, PR, Bosch, DA, Merkus, MP, Speelman, JD. Long-term follow-up of thalamic stimulation versus thalamotomy for tremor suppression. Mov Disord 2008; 23: 114653.
24.Loher, TJ, Pohle, T, Krauss, JK. Functional stereotactic surgery for treatment of cervical dystonia: review of the experience from the lesional era. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2004; 82: 113.
25.Krayenbuhl, H, Wyss, OA, Yasargil, MG. Bilateral thalamotomy and pallidotomy as treatment for bilateral parkinsonism. J Neurosurg 1961; 18: 42944.
26.Moriyama, E, Beck, H, Miyamoto, T. Long-term results of ventrolateral thalamotomy for patients with Parkinson's disease. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) 1999; 39: 3506; discussion 356–7.
27.Jankovic, J, Cardoso, F, Grossman, RG, Hamilton, WJ. Outcome after stereotactic thalamotomy for parkinsonian, essential, and other types of tremor. Neurosurgery 1995; 37: 6806; discussion 686–7.
28.Wester, K, Hauglie-Hanssen, E. Stereotaxic thalamotomy – experiences from the levodopa era. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1990; 53: 42730.
29.Hallett, M, Litvan, I. Evaluation of surgery for Parkinson's disease: a report of the Therapeutics and Technology Assessment Subcommittee of the American Academy of Neurology. The Task Force on Surgery for Parkinson's Disease. Neurology 1999; 53: 191021.
30.Blomstedt, P, Hariz, GM, Hariz, MI. Pallidotomy versus pallidal stimulation. Parkinsonism Relat Disord 2006; 12: 296301. Bie, RM, de Haan, RJ, Nijssen, PC, et al. Unilateral pallidotomy in Parkinson's disease: a randomised, single-blind, multicentre trial. Lancet 1999; 354: 16659.
32.Vitek, JL, Bakay, RA, Freeman, A, et al. Randomized trial of pallidotomy versus medical therapy for Parkinson's disease. Ann Neurol 2003; 53: 55869.
33.Kondziolka, D, Bonaroti, E, Baser, S, et al. Outcomes after stereotactically guided pallidotomy for advanced Parkinson's disease. J Neurosurg 1999; 90: 197202.
34.Giller, CA, Dewey, RB, Ginsburg, MI, Mendelsohn, DB, Berk, AM. Stereotactic pallidotomy and thalamotomy using individual variations of anatomic landmarks for localization. Neurosurgery 1998; 42: 5662; discussion 62–5.
35.Shannon, KM, Penn, RD, Kroin, JS, et al. Stereotactic pallidotomy for the treatment of Parkinson's disease. Efficacy and adverse effects at 6 months in 26 patients. Neurology 1998; 50: 4348.
36.Kishore, A, Turnbull, IM, Snow, BJ, et al. Efficacy, stability and predictors of outcome of pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease. six-month follow-up with additional 1-year observations. Brain 1997; 120: 72937.
37.Krauss, JK, Desaloms, JM, Lai, EC, et al. Microelectrode-guided posteroventral pallidotomy for treatment of Parkinson's disease: postoperative magnetic resonance imaging analysis. J Neurosurg 1997; 87: 35867.
38.Lang, AE, Lozano, AM, Montgomery, E, et al. Posteroventral medial pallidotomy in advanced Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 1997; 337: 103642.
39.Kazumata, K, Antonini, A, Dhawan, V, et al. Preoperative indicators of clinical outcome following stereotaxic pallidotomy. Neurology 1997; 49: 108390.
40.Uitti, RJ, Wharen, RE Jr, Turk, MF, et al. Unilateral pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease: comparison of outcome in younger versus elderly patients. Neurology 1997; 49: 10727.
41.Trepanier, LL, Saint-Cyr, JA, Lozano, AM, Lang, AE. Neuropsychological consequences of posteroventral pallidotomy for the treatment of Parkinson's disease. Neurology 1998; 51: 20715.
42.Blomstedt, P, Hariz, MI. Are complications less common in deep brain stimulation than in ablative procedures for movement disorders? Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2006; 84: 7281.
43.Alkhani, A, Lozano, AM. Pallidotomy for Parkinson disease: a review of contemporary literature. J Neurosurg 2001; 94: 439.
44.Perrine, K, Dogali, M, Fazzini, E, et al. Cognitive functioning after pallidotomy for refractory Parkinson's disease. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 1998; 65: 1504.
45.Biousse, V, Newman, NJ, Carroll, C, et al. Visual fields in patients with posterior GPi pallidotomy. Neurology 1998; 50: 25865.
46.Hariz, MI, De Salles, AA. The side-effects and complications of posteroventral pallidotomy. Acta Neurochir Suppl 1997; 68: 428.
47.Zahodne, LB, Okun, MS, Foote, KD, et al. Greater improvement in quality of life following unilateral deep brain stimulation surgery in the globus pallidus as compared to the subthalamic nucleus. J Neurol 2009; 256: 13219.
48.Rodrigues, JP, Walters, SE, Watson, P, Stell, R, Mastaglia, FL. Globus pallidus stimulation improves both motor and nonmotor aspects of quality of life in advanced Parkinson's disease. Mov Disord 2007; 22: 186670.
49.Germano, IM, Gracies, JM, Weisz, DJ, et al. Unilateral stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in Parkinson disease: a double-blind 12-month evaluation study. J Neurosurg 2004; 101: 3642.
50.Mikos, A, Zahodne, L, Okun, MS, Foote, K, Bowers, D. Cognitive declines after unilateral deep brain stimulation surgery in Parkinson's disease: a controlled study using reliable change, part II. Clin Neuropsychol 2010; 24: 23545.
51.Okun, MS, Fernandez, HH, Wu, SS, et al. Cognition and mood in Parkinson's disease in subthalamic nucleus versus globus pallidus interna deep brain stimulation: the COMPARE trial. Ann Neurol 2009; 65: 58695.
52.Scott, R, Gregory, R, Hines, N, et al. Neuropsychological, neurological and functional outcome following pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease. A consecutive series of eight simultaneous bilateral and twelve unilateral procedures. Brain 1998; 121: 65975.
53.Intemann, PM, Masterman, D, Subramanian, I, et al. Staged bilateral pallidotomy for treatment of Parkinson disease. J Neurosurg 2001; 94: 43744.
54.Counihan, TJ, Shinobu, LA, Eskandar, EN, Cosgrove, GR, Penney, JB Jr. Outcomes following staged bilateral pallidotomy in advanced Parkinson's disease. Neurology 2001; 56: 799802.
55.Iacono, RP, Lonser, RR, Yamada, S. Contemporaneous bilateral postero-ventral pallidotomy for early onset “juvenile type” Parkinson's disease. Case report. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 1994; 131: 24752.
56.Iacono, RP, Shima, F, Lonser, RR, et al. The results, indications, and physiology of posteroventral pallidotomy for patients with Parkinson's disease. Neurosurgery 1995; 36: 111825; discussion 1125–7.
57.Vitek, JL, Bakay, RA, DeLong, MR. Microelectrode-guided pallidotomy for medically intractable Parkinson's disease. Adv Neurol 1997; 74: 18398.
58.Favre, J, Burchiel, KJ, Taha, JM, Hammerstad, J. Outcome of unilateral and bilateral pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease: patient assessment. Neurosurgery 2000; 46: 34453; discussion 353–5.
59.Siegel, KL, Metman, LV. Effects of bilateral posteroventral pallidotomy on gait of subjects with Parkinson disease. Arch Neurol 2000; 57: 198204. Bie, RM, Schuurman, PR, Esselink, RA, Bosch, DA, Speelman, JD. Bilateral pallidotomy in Parkinson's disease: a retrospective study. Mov Disord 2002; 17: 5338.
61.Hua, Z, Guodong, G, Qinchuan, L, et al. Analysis of complications of radiofrequency pallidotomy. Neurosurgery 2003; 52: 8999; discussion 99–101.
62.York, MK, Lai, EC, Jankovic, J, et al. Short and long-term motor and cognitive outcome of staged bilateral pallidotomy: a retrospective analysis. Acta Neurochir (Wien) 2007; 149: 85766; discussion 866.
63.Movement Disorder Society Task Force. Management of Parkinson's disease: an evidence-based review. Mov Disord 2002; 17 (Suppl. 4): S1166.
64.Merello, M, Starkstein, S, Nouzeilles, MI, Kuzis, G, Leiguarda, R. Bilateral pallidotomy for treatment of Parkinson's disease induced corticobulbar syndrome and psychic akinesia avoidable by globus pallidus lesion combined with contralateral stimulation. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2001; 71: 61114.
65.Parkin, SG, Gregory, RP, Scott, R, et al. Unilateral and bilateral pallidotomy for idiopathic Parkinson's disease: a case series of 115 patients. Mov Disord 2002; 17: 68292. Bie, RM, Schuurman, PR, Esselink, RA, Bosch, DA, Speelman, JD. Bilateral pallidotomy in Parkinson's disease: a retrospective study. Mov Disord 2002; 17: 5338. Bie, RM, de Haan, RJ, Schuurman, PR, et al. Morbidity and mortality following pallidotomy in Parkinson's disease: a systematic review. Neurology 2002; 58: 100812.
68.Deep-Brain Stimulation for Parkinson's Disease Study Group. Deep-brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus or the pars interna of the globus pallidus in Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 2001; 345: 95663.
69.Anderson, VC, Burchiel, KJ, Hogarth, P, Favre, J, Hammerstad, JP. Pallidal vs subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation in Parkinson disease. Arch Neurol 2005; 62: 55460.
70.Follett, KA, Weaver, FM, Stern, M, et al. Pallidal versus subthalamic deep-brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 2010; 362: 207791.
71.Odekerken, VJ, van Laar, T, Staal, MJ, et al. Subthalamic nucleus versus globus pallidus bilateral deep brain stimulation for advanced Parkinson's disease (NSTAPS study): a randomised controlled trial. Lancet Neurol 2013; 12: 3744.
72.Coban, A, Hanagasi, HA, Karamursel, S, Barlas, O. Comparison of unilateral pallidotomy and subthalamotomy findings in advanced idiopathic Parkinson's disease. Br J Neurosurg 2009; 23: 239.
73.Alvarez, L, Macias, R, Pavon, N, et al. Therapeutic efficacy of unilateral subthalamotomy in Parkinson's disease: results in 89 patients followed for up to 36 months. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2009; 80: 97985.
74.Slowinski, JL, Putzke, JD, Uitti, RJ, et al. Unilateral deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus for Parkinson disease. J Neurosurg 2007; 106: 62632.
75.Linazasoro, G, Van Blercom, N, Lasa, A. Unilateral subthalamic deep brain stimulation in advanced Parkinson's disease. Mov Disord 2003; 18: 71316.
76.Merello, M, Tenca, E, Perez Lloret, S, et al. Prospective randomized 1-year follow-up comparison of bilateral subthalamotomy versus bilateral subthalamic stimulation and the combination of both in Parkinson's disease patients: a pilot study. Br J Neurosurg 2008; 22: 41522.
77.Alvarez, L, Macias, R, Lopez, G, et al. Bilateral subthalamotomy in Parkinson's disease: initial and long-term response. Brain 2005; 128: 57083.
78.Deuschl, G, Schade-Brittinger, C, Krack, P, et al. A randomized trial of deep-brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 2006; 355: 896908.
79.Schupbach, WM, Maltete, D, Houeto, JL, et al. Neurosurgery at an earlier stage of Parkinson disease: a randomized, controlled trial. Neurology 2007; 68: 26771.
80.Williams, A, Gill, S, Varma, T, et al. Deep brain stimulation plus best medical therapy versus best medical therapy alone for advanced Parkinson's disease (PD SURG trial): a randomised, open-label trial. Lancet Neurol 2010; 9: 58191.
81.Krack, P, Batir, A, Van Blercom, N, et al. Five-year follow-up of bilateral stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus in advanced Parkinson's disease. N Engl J Med 2003; 349: 192534.
82.Weaver, FM, Follett, K, Stern, M, et al. Bilateral deep brain stimulation vs best medical therapy for patients with advanced Parkinson disease: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA 2009; 301: 6373.
83.Witt, K, Daniels, C, Reiff, J, et al. Neuropsychological and psychiatric changes after deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease: a randomised, multicentre study. Lancet Neurol 2008; 7: 60514.
84.Esselink, RA, de Bie, RM, de Haan, RJ, et al. Long-term superiority of subthalamic nucleus stimulation over pallidotomy in Parkinson disease. Neurology 2009; 73: 1513.
85.Drapier, D, Drapier, S, Sauleau, P, et al. Does subthalamic nucleus stimulation induce apathy in Parkinson's disease? J Neurol 2006; 253: 108391.
86.Lim, SY, O'sullivan, SS, Kotschet, K, et al. Dopamine dysregulation syndrome, impulse control disorders and punding after deep brain stimulation surgery for Parkinson's disease. J Clin Neurosci 2009; 16: 114852.
87.Voon, V, Krack, P, Lang, AE, et al. A multicentre study on suicide outcomes following subthalamic stimulation for Parkinson's disease. Brain 2008; 131: 27208.
88.Bakay, RA, DeLong, MR, Vitek, JL. Posteroventral pallidotomy for Parkinson's disease. J Neurosurg 1992; 77: 4878.
89.Van Buren, JM, Li, CL, Shapiro, DY, Henderson, WG, Sadowsky, DA. A qualitative and quantitative evaluation of parkinsonians three to six years following thalamotomy. Confin Neurol 1973; 35: 20235.
90.Fox, SH, Katzenschlager, R, Lim, SY, et al. The Movement Disorder Society Evidence-based Medicine Review Update: treatments for the motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease. Mov Disord 2011; 26 (Suppl. 3): S241.
91.Hooper, AK, Okun, MS, Foote, KD, et al. Clinical cases where lesion therapy was chosen over deep brain stimulation. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2008; 86: 14752.
92.Elias, WJ, Huss, D, Voss, T, et al. A pilot study of focused ultrasound thalamotomy for essential tremor. N Engl J Med 2013; 369: 6408.