'This will be a crucial addition to the practitioner’s library shelves. Both in international tax planning, and in controversy work, being able to bring to bear the decisions of foreign courts on tax treaty issues is often a powerful technique. Even from an early review of the proofs, I found relevant materials for current ‘live’ work in the areas of permanent establishments, beneficial ownership and treaty override. The global case law taxonomy and 'golden bridge' indexing assist with navigation and will provide an interesting evolution of treaty dispute patterns in future editions.'
Murray Clayson - Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer LLP and President of the International Fiscal Association, The Netherlands
'Eduardo Baistrocchi’s outstanding new book on tax treaty disputes is the result of an intense five-year global collaborative project among international tax scholars, practitioners and administrators. The book provides an unprecedented set of information and offers the first global qualitative and quantitative analysis on one of the most important debates over international tax scholarship across the last decades, that is, whether an international tax regime exists and is binding upon states as a matter of customary international law.'
Reuven Avi Yonah
Source: Tax Notes International
'This two-volume book deserves to be mentioned because of its exceptionally rich content and its original approach. … At a time of harmonization of international tax law at a global level, this treatise is particularly welcome.'
Source: Translated from Revue de Droit Fiscal
'The volume charts a new course and should be explored by professionals interested in international taxation and, in particular, by those working on dispute resolution pertaining to tax treaties.'
Source: Business Standard
'This is an important addition to the international tax disputes literature containing interesting statistics, a useful categorisation of cases from different countries on a particular topic, and a wide range of country chapters.'
John Avery Jones
Source: British Tax Review
‘Based on the country-by-country analysis of the leading tax treaty disputes in 27 jurisdictions, this book drew four significant conclusions on the cutting edge issues of contemporary international tax law, ranging from global taxonomy of the patterns of tax treaty disputes, global evolutionary path of tax treaty dispute resolution, implications of triple non-taxation and BEPS, and to global quantitative analysis of tax treaty disputes.’
Source: Beijing Law Review
'The main interest of the treatise lies in its comprehensiveness as well as in its critical approach to the subject. It is a very ambitious work containing the largest compilation to date in one single book of cases dealing with controversies related to double taxation treaties. Roughly 1,600 cases are cited related to the application of treaties listed both country-by-country and thematically. The cases are listed in the treatise’s first volume, which offers a classification based on various criteria, i.e., the country where the controversy takes place and, also, in the so-called 'Golden Bridge', an analytical listing of cases sorted out according to the precepts of the OECD Model Convention. This listing, along with the chart on page 1443, offers a unique picture of the type of controversies that have been resolved within the 1923 to 2015 timeframe covered by the treatise.'
Violeta Ruiz Almendral
Source: Crónica Tributaria
'Baistrocchi’s collection is a must-have for readers interested in tax treaties. It might aptly be referred to as 'the definitive encyclopedia on tax treaty case law'. Work by 42 authors spans 27 countries and provides an analysis of over 580 tax treaty cases. … This review does not do justice to the rich resource that this double volume provides for tax practitioners, policy makers, and scholars with an interest in tax treaty disputes. It is a stand-out contribution in the area.'
Source: Revue fiscale canadienne
‘Both Eduardo Baistrocchi and his publisher Cambridge University Press are to be congratulated for having the courage, energy and discipline to produce this excellent publication. A book, even in two volumes, with the title A Global Analysis of Tax Treaty Disputes might ordinarily seem to be an over-ambitious project but this publication is a triumph. There are both scope and scale in this book which makes it unique in tax academic literature. The publication will also be immensely valuable in taxation practice, administration and jurisprudence for reasons discussed below. In short, the book is a remarkable reflection of legal analysis and likely to be of huge assistance in international tax disputes, but more generally in tax legal scholarship.’
Source: Australian Tax Review
‘A Global Analysis of Tax Treaties Disputes helps in identifying both promises and risks, and is an invaluable resource for policymakers in designing their next move as well as for the future assessment of new policies.’
Source: Modern Law Review
‘… the book contributes … [to] a better understanding of the metalanguage that has been developed in … International Tax Law. It also arrives at a good time because it marks the end of a period (the pre-BEPS period), offering a safe base that serves as a starting point for the analysis of the international scenario that will arise from now on.'
Luís Eduardo Schoueri
Source: Translated from Revista Direito Tributário Internacional Atual
'… after leafing through the two heavy volumes and reading … some chapters - and in particular the whole of Part V of the second volume, I was completely captivated by what I can only describe as one of the seven wonders of the international tax world. … Eduardo Baistrocchi, professor at Torcuato di Tella University in Buenos Aires and the London School of Economics, along with his team of colleagues and assistants, have created an original academic monument of colossal proportions.'
‘The country-by-country analysis covers around twenty countries, including member countries from the OECD and the BRICS. Each author begins by very briefly recalling the fiscal context of the country, then describes and summarizes the CPDI policy, the legal instruments in place and the judgments he considers important. The study covers a large number of countries and is therefore not exhaustive. The analysis nevertheless gives a good overview of the situation in each country.’
Source: Revue de droit international et de droit comparé