Skip to main content Accessibility help
  • Get access
    Check if you have access via personal or institutional login
  • Cited by 1
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: November 2012

15 - Emerging legal issues in international migration



It is clear that there is no comprehensive universal legal framework governing the mobility of human beings. Nonetheless, it is generally agreed that there are numerous, albeit somewhat scattered, elements of a legal and normative framework, derived from binding global and regional instruments and accompanied by informal and non-binding understandings among States.

The exact nature and status of this assemblage is subject to debate, but the research literature leaves readers in no doubt that they are in the presence of work in progress. The body of dispersed, disparate, rather unevenly joined items has been characterised variously as an emergent regime or ‘substance without architecture’. Lillich’s early observation that the topic of the rights of aliens in international law was like a ‘giant unassembled jigsaw’ may appropriately be applied today to the more comprehensive framework now thought needed, or at least desirable, to ensure effective governance of human mobility in all of its manifestations. Construction sites abound. Some have a bilateral regulatory focus, as in the case of the management of labour migration flows; some have a rights-based orientation and dwell on the definition and protection of those rights; still others address mobility from the point of view of the necessity to balance facilitation of movement with entry control. Some boast robust and finished structures, such as the International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families (1990); others are best conceptualised simply as passageways to major adjoining policy areas, such as trade.

Cholewinski, RyszardPerruchoud, RichardMacdonald, EuanInternational Migration Law: Developing Paradigms and Key ChallengesTMC Asser Press 2007 xl
Global Commission on International MigrationMigration in an Interconnected World: New Directions for ActionGCIM 2005
Aleinikoff, AlexanderInternational Legal Norms on Migration: Substance without ArchitectureCholewinski, RyszardPerruchoud, RichardMacdonald, EuanInternational Migration LawTMC Asser Press 2007 467
Lillich, RichardThe Human Rights of Aliens in Contemporary International LawManchester University Press 1984 4
Robinson, CourtlandThe Comprehensive Plan of Action for Indochinese Refugees 1989–1997: Sharing the Burden and Passing the Buck 2004 17 Journal of Refugee Studies319
Phuong, CatherineThe International Protection of Internally Displaced PersonsCambridge University Press 2004
Cohen, RobertaDeng, FrancisMasses in Flight: The Global Crisis of Internal DisplacementBrookings Institution 1998
Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre 2011
Cohen, RobertaKey Policy Debates in the Internal Displacement Field 2008 32 Refugee Watch84
Bagshaw, SimonResponding to the Challenge of Internal Forced Migration: The Guiding Principles on Internal DisplacementCholewinski, RyszardPerruchoud, RichardMacdonald, EuanInternational Migration Law: Developing Paradigms and Key ChallengesTMC Asser Press 2007 189
Deng, Francis M.Kimaro, SadikielLyons, TerrenceRothchild, DonaldZartman, I. WilliamSovereignty as Responsibility: Conflict Management in AfricaBrookings Institution 1996
Inter-Agency Standing CommitteeIASC Framework on Durable Solutions for Internally Displaced PersonsBrookings Institution and University of Bern 2010
Cohen, RobertaThe Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement: An Innovation in International Standard Setting 2004 10 Global Governance459
Jonker, CorienProtecting IDPs in Europe 2008 Forced Migration Review15
International Conference on the Great Lakes Region 2006
Kamungi, PriscaBeyond Good Intentions: Implementing the Kampala Convention 2010 34 Forced Migration Review53
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate ChangeClimate Change: The IPCC Scientific AssessmentWorld Meteorological Organization 1990 5
Boncour, PhilippeBurson, BruceClimate Change and Migration in the South Pacific Region: Policy PerspectivesBurson, BruceClimate Change and Migration: South Pacific PerspectivesInstitute of Policy Studies 2010 5
International Organization for MigrationMigration, Climate Change and the EnvironmentIOM 2009
Biermann, FrankBoas, IngridProtecting Climate Refugees: The Case for a Global Protocol 2008 Environment 8
Hodgkinson, DavidBurton, TessAnderson, HeatherYoung, LucyThe Hour when the Ship Comes in: A Convention for Persons Displaced by Climate ChangeHodgkinson Group 2010
Docherty, BonnieGiannini, TylerConfronting a Rising Tide: A Proposal for a Convention on Climate Change Refugees 2009 33 Harvard Environmental Law Review349
Williams, AngelaTurning the Tide: Recognizing Climate Change Refugees in International Law 2008 30 Law & Policy502
Burson, BruceProtecting the Rights of People Displaced by Climate Change: Global Issues and Regional PerspectivesBurson, BruceClimate Change and Migration: South Pacific PerspectivesInstitute of Policy Studies 2010 159
Perruchoud, RichardRedpath-Cross, JillyanneGlossary on MigrationIOM 2011 33
Duong, TiffanyWhen Islands Drown: The Plight of “Climate Change Refugees” and Recourse to International Human Rights Law 2010 31 University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law1239
McAdam, JaneSwimming against the Tide: Why a Climate Change Displacement Treaty is Not the Answer 2011 23 International Journal of Refugee Law2
Grant, StefanieThe Legal Protection of Stranded MigrantsCholewinski, RyszardPerruchoud, RichardMacdonald, EuanInternational Migration LawTMC Asser Press 2007 29
Fargues, PhilippeWork, Refuge, Transit: An Emerging Pattern of Irregular Immigration South and East of the Mediterranean 2009 43 International Migration Review544
Collyer, MichaelStranded Migrants and the Fragmented Journey 2010 23 Journal of Refugee Studies273
Betts, AlexanderIntroduction: Global Migration GovernanceBetts, AlexanderGlobal Migration GovernanceOxford University Press 2011 1
Key references
African Union 2009
Betts, AlexanderTowards a “Soft Law” Framework for the Protection of Vulnerable Irregular Migrants 2010 22 International Journal of Refugee Law209
Black, RichardRefugees, Environment and DevelopmentLongman 1998
Brookings Institution 2008
Brookings Institution–University of Bern 2005
Commission on Human Rights 1992
Cooper, JessicaEnvironmental Refugees: Meeting the Requirements of the Refugee Definition 1998 6 New York University Environmental Law Journal480
De Haas, Hein 2007
Gemenne, François 2006
Guzmán, José MiguelMartine, GeorgeMcGranahan, GordonSchensul, DanielTacoli, CeciliaPopulation Dynamics and Climate ChangeUNFPA and IIED 2009
Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre 2008
Kälin, WalterGuiding Principles on Internal Displacement: AnnotationsStudies in Transnational Legal Policy No 38American Society of International Law and The Brookings Institution 2008
Keane, DavidEnvironmental Causes and Consequences of Migration: A Search for the Meaning of Environmental Refugees 2004 16 Georgetown International Law Review209
Kolmannskog, VikramMyrstad, FinnEnvironmental Displacement in European Asylum Law 2009 11 European Journal of Migration and Law313
McAdam, Jane 2011
McAdam, JaneClimate Change and Displacement: Multidisciplinary PerspectivesHart Publishing 2010
Myers, NormanKent, JenniferEnvironmental Exodus: An Emergent Crisis in the Global ArenaClimate Institute 1995
Weiss, ThomasKorn, DavidInternal Displacement: Conceptualization and its ConsequencesRoutledge 2006
White, JamesMarsella, AnthonyFear of Persecution: Global Human Rights, International Law, and Human Well-BeingLexington Books 2007