Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2014
  • Online publication date: June 2014

6 - Turnout, Abstention, and Democratic Legitimacy

Summary

Introduction

Before embarking on a specific defense of the requirement to vote, it is important to discuss the problem to which compulsory voting is a purported solution: low voter turnout. As Ben Saunders has pointed out, “If high turnout is not necessarily democratically better than low levels of turnout, then compulsory voting cannot be justified on the grounds that it is necessary to realize democracy.”

Despite the assumed importance of elections and voting, some commentators have argued that it is not necessary – or even desirable – for everyone to vote and that low turnout therefore presents no problems for democracy or democratic legitimacy. Is there actually anything wrong with low turnout? Can democracy really do without voters? And can we, as individuals, do without voting?

Before starting, it may be worth clarifying what this chapter is not about: it is not about whether aggregative democracy is superior or inferior to other forms of democracy (such as deliberative democracy) as a means for preference gathering and self-government; further, it is not about which voting system best serves democratic values. Neither does it challenge the idea that voting is self-defeating because of the ambiguities and instabilities that can plague voting methods (as per William Riker and Kenneth Arrow). Rather, it takes the following as facts of political life that must be taken into account rather than wished away: namely, that voting – with all its distortions and problems – remains the primary mechanism for establishing legitimate governments in advanced representative democracies and, further, that things are likely to stay this way for the foreseeable future. Given this reality, does low turnout matter?

Related content

Powered by UNSILO
Saunders, Ben, “The Democratic Turnout ‘Problem,” Political Studies 60 (2012): 306–20
Blais, Andre, Gidengil, E., Nevitte, N., and Nadeau, R., “Where Does Turnout Decline Come From?European Journal of Political Research 43 (2004): 221–36
Blais, Andre, “Political Participation,” in LeDuc, L., Niemi, R. G., and Norris, P. (eds.), Comparing Democracies 3: Elections and Voting in the 21st Century (London: Sage, 2010): 165–83
Blais, A. and Rubenson, D., “The Source of Turnout Decline,” Comparative Political Studies 46 (1) (2013): 95–117
Katz, R. S., Democracy and Elections (New York: Oxford University Press, 1997): chap. 7
Salisbury, R. H., “Research on Political Participation,” American Journal of Political Science 19 (1975): 326–7
Gans, C. B., “The Empty Ballot Box: Reflections on Non-voters in America,” Public Opinion 1 (1978): 54–7
Keany, E. and Rogers, B., A Citizen’s Duty: Voter Inequality and the Case for Compulsory Turnout [London: Institute for Public Policy Research, 2006])
Brady, H. E., Verba, S., and Schlozman, K., “Beyond SES: A Resource Model of Political Participation,” American Political Science Review 89 (2) (1995): 271–94
Hooghe, M. and Pelleriaux, K., “Compulsory Voting in Belgium: An Application of the Lijphart Thesis,” Electoral Studies 17 (1998): 419–24
Beramendi, P. and Anderson, C. J., “Income Inequality and Democratic Representation,” in Beramendi, P. and Anderson, C. J. (eds.), Democracy, Inequality and Representation (New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 2008): 3–25
Fowler, A., “Electoral and Policy Consequences of Voter Turnout: Evidence from Compulsory Voting in Australia,” Quarterly Journal of Political Science 8 (2013):159–82
Kelsen, H., “Foundations of Democracy,” Ethics 66 [2006]: 1–101, 3
Dahl, R., “Procedural Democracy,” in Laslett, P. and Fishkin, J. [eds.], Philosophy, Politics and Society, 5th Series [New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1979]: 101–31)
Sidgwick, H., The Elements of Politics [London: Macmillan, 1891]: 587)
Thompson, D. F., The Democratic Citizen [Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1970]: 13–19
Weale, A., Democracy [New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1999]: 54–5)
Lomasky, L. and Brennan, G., “Is There a Duty to Vote?Social Philosophy and Policy 17 (1) (2000): 62–86
Wolfinger, R. E. and Rosenstone, S. J., Who Votes? (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1980)
Studlar, D. T. and Welch, S., “The Policy Opinions of British Non-Voters: A Research Note,” European Journal of Political Research 14 (1986): 139–48
Texeira, R. A., The Disappearing American Voter (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1992)
Rubenson, D., Blais, A., Gidengil, E., Nevit, N., and Fournier, P., “Does Turnout Matter?Electoral Studies 26 (2007): 589–97
Wattenberg, M. P., “Why Don’t More Americans Vote?Boston Globe [September 21, 2003])
Ciccone, A., “The Constitutional Right to Vote Is Not a Duty,” Hamline Journal of Public Law and Policy 23 (2001–2): 325–57
Nagel, J. and McNulty, J. E., “Partisan Effects of Voter Turnout in Senatorial and Gubernatorial Elections,” American Political Science Review 90 (1996): 780–93
Petrocik, J., “Voter Turnout and Electoral Preferences: The Anomalous Reagan Elections,” in Schlozman, K. (ed.), Elections in America (New York: Allen and Unwin, 1987)
Pettersen, P. A., “Comparing Non-Voters in the USA and Norway,” European Journal of Political Research 17 (1999): 351–9
Pacek, A. and Radcliff, B., “Turnout and the Vote for Left-of-Centre Parties: A Cross-National Analysis,” British Journal of Political Science 25 (1995): 137–43
Citrin, J., Schickler, E., and Sides, J., “What if Everyone Voted? Simulating the Impact of Increased Turnout in Senate Elections,” American Journal of Political Science 47 (2013): 75–90
Hansford, T. G. and Gomez, B. T., “Estimating the Electoral Effects of Voter Turnout,” American Political Science Review 104 (2010): 268–88
Brunell, T. L. and Nardo, J. D., “A Propensity Score Reweighting Approach to Estimating the Partisan Effects of Full Turnout in American Presidential Elections,” Political Analysis 12 (2004): 28–45
Sides, J., Schickler, E., and Citrin, J., “If Everyone Had Voted, Would Bubba and Dubya Have Won?Presidential Studies Quarterly 38 (2008): 521–39
Wattenberg, M. P., Is Voting for Young People? (New York: Pearson, 2008): 150–1
Martin, P. S., “Voting’s Rewards: Voter Turnout, Attentive Publics and Congressional Allocation of Federal Money,” American Journal of Political Science 47 (2003): 110–27
Burnham, W. D., “The Turnout Problem,” in Richly, J. (ed.), Elections American Style (Washington, DC: Brookings Institution, 1987): 99
Verba, S., Schlozman, S. L., Brady, H., and Nie, N. H., “Citizen Activity: Who Participates? What Do They Say?American Political Science Review 77 (1993): 303–18
Verba, S., “Would the Dream of Political Equality Turn Out to Be a Nightmare?Perspectives on Politics 1 (2003): 663–79
Gallego, A., “Understanding Unequal Turnout: Education and Voting in Comparative Perspective,” Electoral Studies 29 (2010): 239–48
Verba, S. and Nie, N., Participation in America: Political Democracy and Social Equality (New York: Harper and Row, 1972): 338
Martin, P. S., “Voting’s Rewards: Voter Turnout, Attentive Publics and Congressional Allocation of Federal Money,” American Journal of Political Science 47 (1) (2003): 110–27
Griffin, J. D. and Newman, B., “Are Voters Better Represented?The Journal of Politics 67 (2005): 1206–27
Keech, W., The Impact of Negro Voting: The Role of the Vote in the Quest for Equality (Chicago: Rand McNally, 1968)
Button, J. W., Blacks and Social Change: Impact of the Civil Rights Movement in Southern Communities (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1998)
Bullock, C. S. III, “Congressional Voting and the Mobilization of a Black Electorate in the South,” Journal of Politics 43 (1981): 662–82
Hill, K. Q. and Leighley, J. E., “The Policy Consequences of Class Bias in State Electorates,” American Journal of Political Science 36 (1992): 351–65
O’Toole, F. and Strobl, E., “Compulsory Voting and Government Spending,” Economics and Politics, 7 [3] [1995]: 271–80)
Mahler, V. A., “Electoral Turnout and Income Redistribution by the State: A Cross-National Analysis of the Developed Democracies,” European Journal of Political Research 47 (2008): 161–83
Bennett, S. E. and Resnick, D., “The Implications of Nonvoting for Democracy in the United States,” American Journal of Political Science 34 (1990): 771–802
Hicks, A. M. and Swank, D. H., “Politics, Institutions, and Welfare Spending in Industrialized Countries, 1960–82,” American Political Science Review 86 (1992): 658–74
Hill, K. Q., Leighley, J. E., and Hinton-Anderson, A., “Lower-Class Mobilization and Policy Linkage in the U.S. States,” American Journal of Political Science 39 (1995): 75–86
Mueller, D. C. and Stratmann, T., “The Economic Effects of Democratic Participation,” Journal of Public Economics 87 (2003): 2129–55
Kenworthy, L. and Pontusson, J., “Rising Inequality and the Politics of Redistribution in Affluent Countries,” Perspectives on Politics 3 (3) (2005): 449–71
Arnold, D. R., The Logic of Congressional Action [New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1990]: 64–5)
Swenson, K. M., “Sticks, Carrots, Donkey Votes and True Choice: A Rationale for Abolishing Compulsory Voting in Australia,” Minnesota Journal of International Law 16 (2007): 525–52
Brennan, Jason, “Polluting the Polls: When Citizens Should Not Vote,” Australasian Journal of Philosophy 87 (2009): 535–49
Jones, W. H. M., “In Defence of Apathy: Some Doubts on the Duty to Vote,” Political Studies 2 (1954): 25–37
Mayo, H. B., “A Note on the Alleged Duty to Vote,” Journal of Politics 21 [1959]: 319–23)
Abraham, J. H., Compulsory Voting (Washington, DC: Public Affairs Press, 1955)
Rosema, M., “Low Turnout: Threat to Democracy or Blessing in Disguise? Consequences of Citizens’ Varying Tendencies to Vote,” Electoral Studies 26 (2007): 612–23
Hasen, R. L., “Voting without Law,” Pennsylvania Law Review 144 [1996]: 2135–79)
Hill, Lisa, “Compulsory Voting, Political Shyness and Welfare Outcomes,” Journal of Sociology 36 (1) (2000): 30–49
Southwell, P. L., “The Effect of Political Alienation on Voter Turnout, 1964–2000,” Journal of Political and Military Sociology 36 (2008): 131–45
Brody, R. and Page, B., “Indifference, Alienation and Rational Decisions,” Public Choice 15 (1973): 1–17
Nownes, A. J., “Primaries, General Elections, and Voter Turnout: A Multinomial Logit Model of the Decision to Vote,” American Politics Quarterly 20 (1992): 205–26
Ragsdale, L. and Rusk, J. G., “Who Are Nonvoters? Profiles from the 1990 Senate Elections,” American Journal of Political Science 37 (1993): 721–46
Henn, M., Weinstein, M., and Wring, D., “A Generation Apart? Youth and Political Participation in Britain,” British Journal of Politics and International Relations 4 (2002): 167–92
Henn, M., Weinstein, M., and Forrest, S., “Uninterested Youth? Young People’s Attitudes towards Party Politics in Britain,” Political Studies 53 (2005): 556–78
Dermody, J., Hammer-Lloyd, S., and Scullion, R., “Young People and Voting Behaviour: Alienated Youth and(or) an Interested and Critical Citizenry?European Journal of Marketing 44 (2010): 421–35
Pammet, J. H. and LeDuc, L., Explaining the Turnout Decline in Canadian Federal Elections: A New Survey of Non-Voters (Ottawa: Elections Canada, 2003): 6
Grönlund, K. and Setälä, M., “Political Trust, Satisfaction and Voter Turnout,” Comparative European Politics 5 (4) (2007):400–22
Lundell, K., “Compulsory Voting, Civic Participation and Political Trust,” Representation 48 (2) (2012): 221–34
Bannon, Declan B., “Electoral Participation and Non-Voter Segmentation,” Journal of Nonprofit and Public Sector Marketing 14 (2010): 109–27
Dowding, Keith, Goodin, Robert E., and Pateman, Carole, “Introduction,” in Dowding, K., Goodin, R. E., and Pateman, C. (eds.), Justice and Democracy: Essays for Brian Barry (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2004): 9
Wielhouwer, P. W., “Releasing the Fetters: Parties and Mobilization of the African-American Electorate,” Journal of Politics 62 (2000): 206–22
Wielhouwer, P. W., “Strategic Canvassing by the Political Parties,” American Review of Politics 16 (1995): 213–38
Gershtenson, J., “Mobilization Strategies of the Democrats and Republicans, 1956–2000,” Political Research Quarterly 56 (2003): 293–308
Wattenberg, Martin, Where Have All the Voters Gone? (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2002): 99
Lomasky, Loren, “The Booth and Consequences: Do Voters Get What They Want?Reason 24 [6] [1992]: 30–4)
Gomez, B. T., Hansford, T. G., and Krause, G. A., “The Republicans Should Pray for Rain: Weather, Turnout and Voting in U.S. Presidential Elections,” Journal of Politics 69 (2007): 649–63