Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2011
  • Online publication date: June 2014

5 - Villages and villagers, land and landowners

Summary

Introduction: interpreting Carolingian society

Afraid of meeting ‘dog-headed men’ on his travels in Scandinavia, the missionary Rimbert, some time in the middle of the ninth century, was moved to enquire of Abbot Ratramnus of Corbie whether such monstrous perversions of humanity had souls that could be saved. Ratramnus – a theological authority whose monastery had long-standing links with the Frankish mission in the north – replied that all the available information on contemporary Scandinavian societies pointed to familiar patterns of agrarian life: did not the Danes and Swedes follow laws, live in villages, farm the land, domesticate animals and indeed wear clothes similar to the Franks’? They therefore had souls; Rimbert's job was to save them for the true, Christian, God. Ratramnus's exchange with Rimbert belongs in a long tradition of Roman and Frankish ethnographic fantasies about their northern neighbours which were intended to assert the normality of home society by vividly defining distant and not-so-distant neighbours as ‘others’. But rather than identifying, as was customary, monstrous peoples as agents of God's wrath or actors in Biblical prophecies, here Ratramnus described the familiarity of the way of life of rural Scandinavia, regardless of the shape of its inhabitants’ heads. These rural communities resembled those whose labours sustained Ratramnus and his monks in Francia, and so were ripe for conversion under the aegis of a Christian empire.

As so often, in imagining others distant from home Ratramnus and Rimbert reveal social assumptions that would have been much harder to voice in a discussion of their own society. Indeed, direct commentary on the structure of Frankish society by the spokespeople of the ruling elites of Church and court is rare. When such commentary did occur, it was theological in nature and ecclesiological in aim, designed to explicate the proper harmonious relationship between the different orders that made up Christian society. The first decades of the ninth century saw a series of attempts to apply to Carolingian society the theory of ‘three orders of man’ developed by Augustine and elaborated by other late antique churchmen. At Aachen in 802, for example, the three orders of clergy, laity and monks were each encouraged to meditate on their roles, as reflected in authoritative texts from canon law, secular law and the monastic rule. A few decades later the monastic scholar Heiric of Auxerre, influenced by classical texts, inaugurated what was to become the dominant social theory of the Middle Ages by classifying society as made up of those who fight, those who pray and those who work. Fascinating though it is, such theorising is primarily a part of intellectual history: early medieval social theories do not aim at the kind of understanding sought by modern historians.

Ratramnus of Corbie, Perels, E.MGH EppBerlin 1925
Wood, I.Christians and pagans in ninth-century ScandinaviaSawyer, B.Sawyer, P. H.Wood, I. N.The Christianization of ScandinaviaAlingsås 1987 36
Oexle, O. G.Tria genera hominum. Zur Geschichte eines Deutungsschemas der sozialen Wirklichkeit in Antike und MittelalterFenske, L.Institutionen, Gesellschaft und Kultur im Mittelalter. Festschrift Josef FleckensteinSigmaringen 1984 483
Iogna-Prat, D.Le “Baptême” du schéma des trois ordres fonctionnels: l'apport de l’école d’Auxerre dans la seconde moitié du e siècleAnnales ESC 41 1986 101
Duby, G.The Three Orders: Feudal Society ImaginedChicago 1982
Wickham, C.The other transition: from the ancient world to feudalismP&P 113 1984 3
Sarris, P.Banaji, J.
Devroey, J.-P.Économie rurale et société dans l’Europe franque ( siècles)Paris 2003
Devroey, Puissants et misérables: Système social et monde paysan dans l’Europe des Francs ( siècles)Brussels 2006
Depreux, P.Les Sociétés occidentales du milieu du e à la fin du e siècleRennes 2002
Innes, Economies and societiesThe Inheritance of Rome: A History of Europe, 400–1000London 2009
Heinzelman, M.Villa d'après l'oeuvre de Grégoire de ToursAux sources de la gestion publique : Enquête lexicographique sur fundus, villa, domus, mansusLille 1993 45
Halsall, G.Settlement and Social Organisation: the Merovingian Region of MetzCambridge 1995
Murray, A. C.From Roman to Frankish Gaul: and in the administration of the Merovingian kingdomTraditio 44 1988 59
Innes, 94
Innes, M.247
Bougard, F. 1996 291
Innes, M.Framing the Carolingian economyJournal of Agrarian Change 9 2009 42
Erhart, P.Kleindienst, J.Urkundenlandschaft RätiensVienna 2004 83
Herlihy, D.The Carolingian mansusEHR 13 1960 69
Perrin, C.-E.Observations sur la manse dans la region parisienne au début du e siècleAnnales 8 1945 39
Schlesinger, W.Vorstudien zu einer Untersuchungen über die HufeAusgewählte Aufsätze von W. Schlesinger 1965–1979Sigmaringen 1987 458
Banaji, J.Aristocracies, peasantries and the framing of the early middle agesJournal of Agrarian Change 9 2009 59
Weidinger, U.Untersuchungen zur Wirtschaftsstruktur des Kloster Fulda in der KarolingerzeitStuttgart 1991 23
Ripoll, G.Arce, J.The transformation and end of Roman in the west (fourth–seventh centuries): problems and perspectivesTowns and their Territories from Late Antiquity to the Early Middle AgesLeiden 2000 63
Lewit, T.“Vanishing villas”: what happened to elite rural habitation in the west in the fifth–sixth centuries?Journal of Roman Archaeology 16 2003 26
Wickham,
Wickham, C.European forests in the early middle ages: landscape and land clearanceSettimane di Studio del Centro italiano di studi sull'alto medioevoSpoleto 1989 479
Ward-Perkins, B.The Fall of Rome and the End of CivilisationOxford 2005 145
Hamerow, 146
Davies, W.Small Worlds: The Village Community in Early Medieval BrittanyLondon 1988
Wickham, C.431
Wickham, 388
Kosto, A.Laymen, clerics and documentary practices in the early middle ages: the example of CataloniaSpeculum 80 2005 44
Gasparri, S.La Rocca, C.Carte di famiglia. Strategie, rappresentazione e memoria del gruppo familiare di Totone di Campione, 721–877Rome 2005
Feller, L.Gramain, A.Weber, F.La Fortune de Karol. Marché de la terre et liens personnels dans les Abruzzes au haut moyen âgeRome 2005
Pertz, G. H.158
Paxton, F. S.Anchoress and Abbess in Ninth-Century Saxony: the Lives of Liutbirga of Wendhausen and Hathumoda of GandersheimWashington, DC 2009
Burrow, J.The “village community” and the uses of history in late nineteenth-century EnglandHistorical Perspectives: Studies in English Thought and Society in Honour of Sir J H PlumbCambridge 1974 255
Smith, R.Modernisation and the corporate village community: some sceptical reflectionsExplorations in Historical GeographyCambridge 1984 140
Reynolds, S.Kingdoms and Communities in Western Europe, 900–1300Oxford 1997
Staab, F.A reconsideration of the ancestry of modern political liberty: the problem of the so-called King's Freemen ()Viator 11 1980 51
Verhulst, A.The Carolingian EconomyCambridge 2002
Verhulst, A.Rural and Urban Aspects of Early Medieval Northwest EuropeAldershot 1992
Devroey, J.-P.Études sur le grand domaine carolingienAldershot 1993
Morimoto, Y.Études sur l’économie rurale du haut moyen âge: historiographie, régime domanial, polyptyques carolingiensParis 2008
Loyn, Percival, 65
Metz, W.Das Karolingische ReichsgutBerlin 1960
McKitterick, 149
Goetz, H.-W.Serfdom and the beginnings of a “seigneurial system” in Carolingian EuropeEME 2 1993 29
Davies, W.On servile status in the early Middle AgesSerfdom and SlaveryLondon 1996 225
Bonnassie, P.From Slavery to Feudalism in Southwest EuropeCambridge 1991
Freedman, P.The Origins of Peasant Servitude in Medieval CataloniaCambridge 1991
Kuchenbuch, L.Bäuerliche Gesellschaft und Klosterherrschaft im 9. Jht. Studien zur Sozialstruktur der Familia der Abtei PrümWiesbaden 1978
Gockel, M.Karolingische Königshöfe am MittelrheinGöttingen 1970
Devroey, J.-P.Les Services de transport à l'abbaye de Prüm au e siècleRevue du Nord 61 1979 543
Devroey, Un monastère dans l’économie d’échanges: les services de transport à l'abbaye de St-Germain-des-Prés au e siècleAnnales ESC 39 1984 570
Müller-Mertens, E.Karl der Große, Ludwig der Fromme und die Freien. Wer waren die der karolingischen Kapitularien (742/3–832)? Ein Beitrag zur Sozialgeschichte und Sozialpolitik des FrankenreichesBerlin 1963
Ullman, W.Public welfare and social legislation in the early medieval councilsStudies in Church History 7 1971 1
Humfress, C.Poverty and Roman lawPoverty in the Roman WorldCambridge 2006 183
Thiébaux, M.Dhuoda: Handbook for her Warrior SonCambridge 1998
Neel, C.Handbook for William: a Carolingian Woman's Counsel for her SonLondon, NE 1991
Nelson, Polyptyque de l’Abbé IrminonParis 1844
Tessier, G.Recueil des actes de Charles II le ChauveParis 1943 228