Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2011
  • Online publication date: June 2014

7 - Exchange and trade: the Carolingian economy

Summary

Introduction: interpreting the carolingian economy

Around 890, a team of scholars at the court of the Anglo-Saxon king Alfred the Great undertook the translation of the fifth-century Latin world history of Orosius into the written version of their vernacular Old English language. Orosius's work, with its story of barbarian invasions and Christian triumph, had an obvious message for readers in Viking-age England, and Alfred's team translated freely: as a result, when they came across Orosius's lengthy geographical descriptions of Europe, they updated his very classical picture of northern and eastern Europe to reflect contemporary realities. The detailed account of the different peoples and groupings of the Baltic and southern Scandinavia led into a series of digressions, recounting the tales told to King Alfred by two travellers in the north, Ohthere and Wulfstan. Ohthere claimed to Alfred that ‘he lived the furthest north of all Northmen’, and gave an account of his exploration around the modern Norwegian coast as far as Lapland and the White Sea. Ohthere's accounts of various groupings of Beormas, Cwenas, Finnas and Norðmanna distinguish them not in terms of ethnic origin but in terms of their land and their economy. The lands of the Finnas, for example, were described as ‘waste’, that is lacking agriculture, animal husbandry or permanent settlement: they were seasonal hunters, in contrast to the Beormas, whose territory was ‘fully settled’.

But the scribe recording Ohthere's tale-telling was not solely interested in ethnographic and geographical detail: he focussed also on wealth and its exchange. Hence the almost palpable interest of the audience as they heard an account of riches rooted not in property rights over land and labour, but in control of livestock, some tame but most wild, and the collection of tribute: Ohthere told how he was ‘a very rich man in those objects which their riches consist of, that is wild deer…he was among the first men of his land, but he had not more than twenty cattle, twenty sheep and twenty pigs, and little that he ploughed with horses’. The wealth of Ohthere's people, we are told, lay ‘mostly in the tribute (gafol) that the Finnas pay them’, which was carefully graded, with each different rank among the Finnas making specific gifts of animal skins, bird feathers and whale bones. These were destined to be exchanged, for Ohthere's account of his wealth and his relations with the neighbouring peoples naturally flowed into an account of a voyage down the Norwegian coast to the trading town (port) of Kaupang, and thence to Hedeby at the base of the Jutland peninsula, the nodal point of the trading routes of southern Scandinavia. From Ohthere's account of the trip to Hedeby, the scribe moved seamlessly on to an analogous account of the voyage of Wulfstan east from Hedeby to Truso, a major centre for exchange in the Baltic. Wulfstan's observation of the coastline and islands of the Baltic is enlivened by discussion of the customs of the peoples he encountered: the drinking habits, funeral rites and magical abilities of the Este.

Bately, J. M.The Old English OrosiusOxford 1980
Lund, N.Two Voyagers at the Court of King AlfredYork 1984
Bately, Englert, A.Ohthere's VoyagesRoskilde 2007
Townend, M.Language and History in Viking Age England: Linguistic Relations between Speakers of Old English and Old NorseTurnhout 2002 79
Michelet, F. L.Creation, Migration and Conquest. Imaginary Geography and the Sense of Space in Old English LiteratureOxford 2006 115
Gilles, S.Territorial interpolations in the Old English OrosiusText and Territory: Geographical Imagination in the Middle AgesPhiladelphia, PA 1998 79
Godden, M.The Anglo-Saxons and the Goths: rewriting the sack of RomeAnglo-Saxon England 31 2002 47
Nelson, J. L.Charlemagne and the paradoxes of powerReuter LectureUniversity of Southampton 2006
Grierson, P.Commerce in the dark ages: a critique of the evidenceTRHS 9 1959 123
Bostock, Knight44
Hardt, M.Royal treasures and representation in the early Middle AgesStrategies of Distinction. The Construction of Ethnic Communities, 300–800Leiden 1998 255
Schwind, F.Zu karolingerzeitlichen Klöstern als Wirtschaftsorganismen und Stätten handwerklicher ProduktionInstitutionen, Kultur und Gesellschaft im Mittelalter: Festschrift für Josef Fleckenstein zu seinem 65. GeburtstagSigmaringen 1984 101
Hodges, R.San Vincenzo al Volturno 1. The Excavations 1980–1986, part 1London 1993
Coupland, S.Carolingian arms and armour in the ninth centuryViator 29 1990 29
Hodges, Anglo-Saxon Trading Centres: Beyond the EmporiaGlasgow 1999
Hill, D.Cowie, R.Wics: The Early Medieval Trading Centres of Northern EuropeSheffield 2001
Scull, C.Urban centres in pre-Viking England?The Anglo-Saxons from the Migration Period to the Eighth CenturyWoodbridge 1997 269
Clarke, H.Ambrosiani, B.Towns in the Viking AgeLondon 1995
Hodges, R.Towns and Trade in the Age of CharlemagneLondon 2000
Verhulst, A.The Rise of Cities in North-West EuropeCambridge 1999
Lohier, F.Laporte, J. 1936 20
Kelly, S.Trading privileges from eighth-century EnglandEME 1 1992 3
van Es, W.Verwers, W.Excavations at Dorestad I. The Harbour, Hoogstraat IAmersfoort 1980
Verwers, W.Dorestad: a Carolingian town?The Rebirth of Towns in the West, 700–1050London 1988 52
Hill, D.Quentovic definedAntiquity 61 1990 51
Lebecq, S.121
Nelson, J. L.England and the continent in the ninth century: , Vikings and othersTRHS 13 2003 1
Heather, P.State formation in Europe in the first millennium Scotland in Dark Age EuropeSt Andrews 1994 47
Maund, K. L.“A turmoil of warring princes”: political leadership in ninth-century DenmarkHaskins Society Journal 6 1994 29
Garipzanov, I.Frontier identities: Carolingian frontier and Franks, Northmen, and Slavs: Identities and State Formation in Early Medieval EuropeTurnhout 2008 113
Liutprand, Zur Wirtschaftsgeschichte Italiens im frühen MittelalterGotha 1904
McCormick, 117
Gelichi, S.The rise of an early medieval emporium and the economy of Italy in the late Longobard ageAnnales. Series Historia et Sociologia 18/2 2008 319
Gasparri, S.157
Rovelli, A.195
Rovelli, A.Emissione e uso della moneta: le testimonianze scritte e archaeologicheSettimane di Studio del Centro italiano di studi sull'alto medioevoSpoleto 2001 821
Rovelli, A.Coins and trade in early medieval ItalyEME 17 2009 45
Wickham, C.345
Whitehouse, D.“Things that travelled”: the surprising case of raw glassEME 12 2003 301
McCormick, M.Complexity, chronology and context in the early medieval economyEME 12 2003 307
McCormick, 766
The Vita of Constantine and the of MethodiusKantor, M.Ann Arbor, MI 1976
Khurradadhbih, IbnBibliotheca geographorum arabicorumLeiden 1889
Lopez, R. S.Raymond, I. W.Medieval Trade in the Mediterranean World: Illustrative DocumentsLondon and New York 1955 30
Kennedy, H.Military pay and the economy of the early Islamic stateHistorical Research 188 2002 155
Kennedy, H.From to : urban change in late antique and early Islamic SyriaP&P 106 1985 3
Carver, M.Transitions to IslamTowns in Transition. Urban Evolution in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle AgesAldershot 1996 184
Bolin, S.Mohammed, Charlemagne and RuricScandinavian Economic History Review 1 1953 5
Hodges, Whitehouse, 6
Callmer, J.Numismatics and archaeologyFornvännen 75 1980 203
Coupland, S. 1985 11