Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Contributors
- Acknowledgments
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction
- Chapter 1 Homing in on Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 2 Fear and Trembling’s “Attunement” as midrash
- Chapter 3 Johannes de silentio’s dilemma
- Chapter 4 Can an admirer of silentio’s Abraham consistently believe that child sacrifice is forbidden?
- Chapter 5 Eschatological faith and repetition: Kierkegaard’s Abraham and Job
- Chapter 6 The existential dimension of faith
- Chapter 7 Learning to hope: the role of hope in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 8 On being moved and hearing voices: passion and religious experience in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 9 Birth, love, and hybridity: Fear and Trembling and the Symposium
- Chapter 10 Narrative unity and the moment of crisis in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 11 Particularity and ethical attunement: situating Problema III
- Chapter 12 ‘He speaks in tongues’: hearing the truth of Abraham’s words of faith
- Chapter 13 Why Moriah?: weaning and the trauma of transcendence in Kierkegaard’s Fear and Trembling
- Bibliography
- Index
Chapter 11 - Particularity and ethical attunement: situating Problema III
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 05 February 2015
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of Contributors
- Acknowledgments
- List of Abbreviations
- Introduction
- Chapter 1 Homing in on Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 2 Fear and Trembling’s “Attunement” as midrash
- Chapter 3 Johannes de silentio’s dilemma
- Chapter 4 Can an admirer of silentio’s Abraham consistently believe that child sacrifice is forbidden?
- Chapter 5 Eschatological faith and repetition: Kierkegaard’s Abraham and Job
- Chapter 6 The existential dimension of faith
- Chapter 7 Learning to hope: the role of hope in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 8 On being moved and hearing voices: passion and religious experience in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 9 Birth, love, and hybridity: Fear and Trembling and the Symposium
- Chapter 10 Narrative unity and the moment of crisis in Fear and Trembling
- Chapter 11 Particularity and ethical attunement: situating Problema III
- Chapter 12 ‘He speaks in tongues’: hearing the truth of Abraham’s words of faith
- Chapter 13 Why Moriah?: weaning and the trauma of transcendence in Kierkegaard’s Fear and Trembling
- Bibliography
- Index
Summary
Introduction
Shortly after launching Problema III, Johannes de silentio vows to adopt a more venturesome approach. Were he to continue to ply his present course, he surmises, he very soon would reach a familiar destination and a familiar impasse – namely, the paradox, wherein the “single individual” is elevated in his particularity above the ethical universal. In that event, Johannes realizes, he would have nothing new to say in response to the titular question of Problema III. Having identified the ethical universal as “the disclosed” (FT 82/SKS 4, 72), moreover, he now must be prepared to treat any act of secrecy or concealment as an ethical offense. In this light, Problema III appears to be headed for a conclusion similar to those delivered by Problemata I–II, which, he fears, would not advance our understanding of Abraham.
Johannes thus resolves to proceed “purely aesthetically,” which means, inter alia, that he will bypass the ethical universal, focusing instead on particular cases in which star-crossed lovers conceal their true aims and guiding aspirations from those whom they love. His aim in doing so, as we shall see, is to determine if some of these acts of concealment might be understood to serve identifiably ethical ends. In that event, presumably, these cases might qualify as exceptions to the general ethical rule, and the concealments they feature might be judged on that basis to be “ethically defensible.” The point of this extended digression, moreover, is to build a consensus in favor of treating one or more of Abraham’s acts of concealment as an exception to the general rule, such that we would be persuaded to respond in the affirmative to the titular question that stands at the head of Problema III. In that event, Johannes may proceed as planned with his campaign to understand Abraham on the model of the knight of faith.
- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- Kierkegaard's Fear and TremblingA Critical Guide, pp. 205 - 228Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2015
- 1
- Cited by