Book contents
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of tables
- Preface
- 1 The misunderstood French welfare state
- 2 Corporatist welfare states: the residue of the past, or the wave of the future?
- 3 The “treason of the intellectuals”: globalization as the big excuse for France's economic and social problems
- 4 France's break with socialism
- 5 Persisting inequalities
- 6 The protected people
- 7 The excluded: immigrants, youth, women
- 8 The French exception
- Appendix: Some major pieces of social legislation, France 1893–2003
- Notes
- Index
2 - Corporatist welfare states: the residue of the past, or the wave of the future?
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 12 January 2010
- Frontmatter
- Contents
- List of tables
- Preface
- 1 The misunderstood French welfare state
- 2 Corporatist welfare states: the residue of the past, or the wave of the future?
- 3 The “treason of the intellectuals”: globalization as the big excuse for France's economic and social problems
- 4 France's break with socialism
- 5 Persisting inequalities
- 6 The protected people
- 7 The excluded: immigrants, youth, women
- 8 The French exception
- Appendix: Some major pieces of social legislation, France 1893–2003
- Notes
- Index
Summary
As the nation grew objectively richer, it felt subjectively poorer. Why? If government is “poor,” if it is unable to “afford” things, that is because of its inability to unlock resources from entrenched claimants and reallocate them for new needs. It is not poor; it is paralyzed. It is not malnourished; it is maladaptive. It is trapped in its own past, held there like Gulliver in Lilliput by a thousand ancient commitments and ten thousand committed clients … Not only are programs virtually impossible to kill, but once put in place they are also hard to change. Every wrinkle in the law, every grant formula and tax loophole, produces a winner who resists subsequent reform, unless “reform” happens to mean more money or benefits for the lobbies concerned.
Jonathan Rauch, commenting on the USA in his book Government's End (1994).Today, there are three Frances. First, there are those whose jobs are guaranteed for life and who don't do much of anything … let alone create any wealth for the nation. These are the functionaries, who have replaced the aristocracy of years gone by. Naturally, they are as frightened as the nobles must have been on the eve … of August 4 [1789, when the nobility's privileges were abolished]. Then, there are those who have a job, who work, who create wealth. Finally, there are all those who are “excluded” from everything, the unemployed, the illiterate, foreigners, those on welfare, those forgotten and despised.
Thierry Desjardins, La décomposition française (2002).- Type
- Chapter
- Information
- France in CrisisWelfare, Inequality, and Globalization since 1980, pp. 19 - 53Publisher: Cambridge University PressPrint publication year: 2004
- 1
- Cited by