Skip to main content Accessibility help
×
Home
  • Print publication year: 2012
  • Online publication date: June 2012

1 - Israel

Summary

In early June 1967, Israel won the swiftest and the most spectacular military victory of its entire war-filled history. Defence Minister Moshe Dayan quickly branded it the “Six-Day War” in a conscious allusion to the six days of the Creation in the book of Genesis. With a few exceptions, Israelis regard this war as a defensive war, a morally justified war, and a war of no-choice, a war imposed on them by their predatory Arab foes. In the Arab world, this war is viewed as a wilful act of aggression with a secret agenda of territorial expansion. The widely held view is that during the summer of 1967 Israel was ready for war, well prepared, and only waiting for an opportunity to launch it. Many Egyptians go further and claim that Israel laid a trap for Gamal Abdel Nasser and that Nasser fell into it. Jordanians believe that there was a trap and consider it part of an Israeli strategy to draw the neighbouring Arab states into a war for which they were not prepared. The notion that Israel was constantly planning and plotting to capture the West Bank is central to the Jordanian understanding of the origins of the war. In a speech on 25 January 1967, King Hussein declared that “the enemy's present objective is the West Bank; after that it will be the East Bank and after that they will expand throughout the Arab homeland to achieve their aims and ambitions.” This view of Israel's conduct in 1967 is entirely consistent with the predominant Arab perception of themselves as the innocent victims and of Israel as an inherently aggressive and expansionist state, an outpost of Western imperialism. The reality is more complex on both sides of the equation.

The purpose of this chapter is to reexamine the Arab claims of a premeditated war plot in the light of the evidence that is now available. Why did Israel launch a surprise attack on 5 June 1967? What were its war aims? Did they include territorial expansion at the expense of its neighbours? Was this a defensive or an offensive war? Was it a war of choice or a war of no-choice? These are some of the main questions to be explored here. Fortunately, the primary sources available regarding Israel's conduct in 1967 are extraordinarily rich. Israel emulated Britain's thirty-year rule for the review and declassification of official documents and applied it in an admirably liberal fashion. The primary sources regarding the June War that have been declassified include the verbatim records of Cabinet meetings; the papers of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the verbatim records of the meetings of the Israel Defence Force (IDF) General Staff, the papers of the Chief of Staff, and the minutes of countless consultative meetings involving military and civilian officials. Whatever one might think of Israel's policy towards the Arabs, it is very much to its credit that it allows researchers such remarkably free access to its internal records.

Parker, Richard B.The Six-Day War: A RetrospectiveGainesvilleUniversity of Florida 1996 61
Mutawi, Samir A.Jordan in the 1967 WarCambridgeCambridge University Press 1987 69
Harkabi, Y.Arab Attitudes to IsraelJerusalemIsrael Universities Press 1974
Brecher, MichaelDecisions in Israel's Foreign PolicyLondonOxford University Press 1974
Brecher, MichaelGeist, BenjaminDecisions in Crisis: Israel, 1967 and 1973BerkeleyUniversity of California Press 1980
Shlaim, AviThe Iron Wall: Israel and the Arab WorldNew YorkW. W. Norton 2000 219
Segev, Tom1967: Israel, the War and the Year that Transformed the Middle EastLondonLittle, Brown 2007
Gluska, AmiEshkol, Give an Order! The IDF and the Political Leadership on the Road to the Six-Day War, 1963–1967Tel AvivMa'arachot 2004 36
Rabin, YitzhakAn Interview with Yitzhak Rabin, 22 August 1982Iyunim Bitkumat Israel 8 1998 665
Rosenthal, YemimaYitzhak Rabin: Prime Minister of Israel, 1974–1977, 1992–1995: Selected Documents, Volume 1, Early Years and Military Career, 1922–1967JerusalemIsrael State Archives 2005 445
Shlaim, AviLion of Jordan: King Hussein's Life in War and PeaceLondonAllen Lane 2007 235
el-Sadat, AnwarIn Search of Identity: An AutobiographyNew YorkHarper and Row 1978 172
Howard, MichaelHunter, RobertIsrael and the Arab World: The Crisis of 1967LondonInternational Institute for Strategic Studies 1967 24
Rabin, YitzhakThe Rabin MemoirsLondonWeidenfeld and Nicolson 1979 58
Haber, EitanToday War Will Break Out: The Reminiscences of Brigadier-General Israel Lior, Aide-de-Camp to Prime Ministers Levi Eshkol and Golda MeirTel AvivEdanim 1987 163
Eban, Abba 1969
Department of StateForeign Relations of the United States, 1964–1968, vol. XIX, Arab-Israeli Crisis and War, 1967Washington, DCU.S. Government Printing House 2004 62
Rosenthal, YemimaLevi Eshkol – The Third Prime Minister: Selected Documents, 1895–1969JerusalemIsrael State Archives 2002 532
Heikal, Mohamed1967: The ExplosionCairoAl-Ahram 1990 371
Oren, MichaelSix Days of War: June 1967 and the Making of the Modern Middle EastOxfordOxford University Press 2002 120
Shemesh, MosheArab Politics, Palestinian Nationalism and the Six Day War: The Crystallization of Arab Strategy and Nasir's Descent to War 1957–1967Brighton, UKSussex Academic Press 2008 197
Stephens, RobertNasser: A Political BiographyLondonPenguin Books 1971 479
Hod, Major General MottiOperation ‘Moked’ − Why It Is Not a Gamble?The Six-Day WarTel Avivthe Israeli Society for Military History 1996 91
Shlaim, AviCollusion across the Jordan: King Abdullah, the Zionist Movement, and the Partition of PalestineOxfordClarendon Press 1988 303
Eban, AbbaPersonal Witness: Israel through My EyesNew YorkPutnam 1992 386
Amit, MeirThe Road to the Six Days: The Six Day War in RetrospectMa'arachot 325 1992
Quandt, William B.Peace Process: American Diplomacy and the Arab-Israeli Conflict since 1967BerkeleyUniversity of California Press 1993
Amit, Major General Meir
Dayan, MosheMilestones: An AutobiographyJerusalemYediot Aharonot 1976 436
Lanir, ZviPolitical Aims and Military Objectives in Israel's WarsWar by Choice: A Collection of ArticlesTel AvivHakibbutz Hameuchad Publishing House 1985 129
Brown, AriePersonal Imprint: Moshe Dayan in the Six-Day War and AfterTel AvivMa'arachot 1997 35
Gilboa, Moshe A.Six Years – Six Days: Origins and History of the Six Day WarTel AvivAm Oved 1969 207
Eban, AbbaAn AutobiographyLondonWeidenfeld and Nicolson 1977 408
Narkis, UziSoldier of JerusalemTel AvivMinistry of Defence 1991 327
Benvenisti, MeronJerusalem: The Torn CityJerusalemIsratypeset 1976 84
Rabinovich, Abraham 1992
Seale, PatrickAsad: The Struggle for the Middle EastLondonI. B. Tauris 1988 137
Bartov, HanochDado – 48 Years and 20 More DaysTel AvivMa'ariv 1978 125
Nakdimon, Shlomo 1997
Tal, Rami 1997
Schmemann, Serge 1997
Rusk, DeanAs I Saw It: A Secretary of State's MemoirsLondonI. B. Tauris 1991 332
Medzini, MeronIsrael's Foreign Relations: Selected Documents, 1982–1984JerusalemMinistry of Foreign Affairs 1990 134